- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DA-WAM, a decision-aligned world action model for autonomous driving. It predicts a distinct compact future representation for each candidate trajectory and combines it with the current scene context to assess trajectory safety and driving utility, ultimately selecting a driving trajectory. Its main innovation is a compact candidate representation that supports both future prediction and trajectory scoring. Joint optimization with dense future-feature supervision and planning objectives during training encourages the representations to capture scene dynamics relevant to decision-making. The model further incorporates hard-negative trajectories that are geometrically similar but have different safety outcomes to sharpen safety boundaries. Evaluated on NAVSIM-v1, NAVSIM-v2, and Bench2Drive, DA-WAM achieves 93.7 PDMS, 89.2 EPDMS (with temporal-consistency reranking), and a Driving Score of 59.04, respectively.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a concrete and efficient way to connect future prediction with trajectory scoring. DA-WAM scores each candidate trajectory using its own compact representation and applies future-feature supervision to the expert-matched candidate during joint training. At inference, the dense decoder is removed while the candidate-conditioned prediction branch remains active. This is a reasonable design that integrates predictive supervision into planning without reconstructing a complete future scene for every candidate, offering practical value.
- The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, covering NAVSIM-v1, NAVSIM-v2, and Bench2Drive to assess both planning metrics and closed-loop driving performance. The targeted safety refinement also yields measurable improvements.
Critical weaknesses
- The contribution beyond WoTE is insufficiently established. WoTE already predicts candidate-specific future BEV states for reward evaluation, so the claimed limitations of shared futures or weak candidate–future coupling need clarification. Controlled comparisons are needed to isolate the benefits of DA-WAM’s representation, supervision, and safety refinement.
- The role of future representations in decision-making is insufficiently validated. The experiments do not clearly distinguish whether the gains arise from modeling future consequences or from stronger scene–trajectory feature interactions. Equal-capacity controls and trajectory–future representation shuffling experiments would help validate the proposed mechanism.
Questions for authors
- WoTE already predicts candidate-specific future states for trajectory evaluation. What specific limitation in WoTE’s candidate–future coupling does DA-WAM address, and how does its architecture overcome it?
- Do the “No Future Prediction” and “Action-Conditioned Future” variants in Table 4 have comparable model capacity, scoring architectures, and training settings? What existing evidence distinguishes gains from future-prediction supervision from those due to additional scene–trajectory feature processing?
2 comments
Additional Response to Reviewer iQyG (Text Revision Instructions)
Dear Reviewer,
We found your comments especially insightful. They helped us substantially improve the manuscript’s readability and explain our contribution more clearly. We made the following revisions.
Q1. We revised Figure 1 and clarified in the Introduction and Related Work sections how DA-WAM and WoTE differ in the way they link candidate trajectories to predicted futures.
Q2. We clarified the comparison of model capacity at line 377 and reported the results of the trajectory–latent alignment test in Table 9. Figure 6 and Appendix Figures 12–13 show how different candidate actions yield different predicted futures from the same observation.
We would be very pleased if these revisions address your concerns. Please feel free to let us know if any questions or concerns remain. We would be happy to provide further clarification.
Best regards,
The Authors of Submission 16157
Response to Reviewer iQyG
We thank the reviewer for identifying two questions that helped us clarify our contribution: how DA-WAM differs from WoTE, and what evidence shows that future prediction contributes to trajectory selection. Our responses to each point are provided below.
W1 / Q1: Contribution beyond WoTE
We acknowledge that WoTE already performs candidate-specific future BEV prediction and reward evaluation.
Our contribution concerns how each candidate’s future representation is learned. WoTE supervises future BEV states with predefined semantic maps. Similar to image or occupancy reconstruction, the target specifies the scene details that the model should retain, including those that have a relatively small impact on the decision. In DA-WAM, observed future features supervise the representation of the expert-matched candidate, while candidate-level planning objectives train the model to evaluate all candidates. During training, gradients from trajectory evaluation also update the future predictor. This is what makes the representation decision-aligned: the planning objectives help determine which distinctions about safety and progress the representation retains.
We have improved Figure 1 to make this distinction explicit. Figure 1(a) illustrates predefined prediction targets, including the semantic maps used by WoTE, and Figure 1(c) shows how predictive and planning supervision jointly shape DA-WAM’s representations. The corresponding revisions in the Introduction and Related Work are highlighted in blue.
In order to better highlight our advantages, we conducted a comparison on navsim:
W2 / Q2: Equal-Capacity Control and Future-Supervision Effects
(1) Equal-capacity comparison under identical Stage 2 refinement.
We apologize for the ambiguity in our original description. The statement around Line 394, “Δ=0 predicts the current latent state,” refers to our architecture-matched control. Specifically, Current-Latent Conditioning (Δ=0) and Action-Conditioned Future (Δ=0.5) share the same architecture and parameter capacity, including the predictor, candidate-conditioned feature processing, and scorer. Only the prediction target differs: the former predicts the current latent representation, whereas the latter predicts the future latent representation. Current-Latent Conditioning therefore serves as the equal-capacity baseline for Action-Conditioned Future. In contrast, the No-Future variant removes the prediction module and consequently has a different architecture.
To distinguish the benefit of future supervision from that of safety refinement, we evaluate both variants before and after the same Stage 2 procedure:
Future supervision improves PDMS by 0.21 before Stage 2 and 0.17 after Stage 2, demonstrating a benefit under both settings with model capacity held constant. Stage 2 also improves both variants, by 0.26 for Current-Latent Conditioning and 0.22 for Action-Conditioned Future. These comparisons distinguish the contribution of the future prediction target from the additional benefit of safety refinement.
(2) Trajectory–latent alignment test.
To assess whether the trained scorer relies on the correspondence between each candidate trajectory and its predicted latent, we perform the requested shuffling test without retraining:
Jointly permuting trajectories and latents preserves their correspondence and leaves PDMS unchanged. In contrast, breaking this correspondence reduces PDMS by 2.66–5.15 points, with the largest decrease occurring when latents are swapped between dissimilar trajectories. This pattern indicates that the scorer uses candidate-specific trajectory–latent alignment rather than treating predicted latents as interchangeable context. The equal-capacity comparison in (1) further shows the benefit of using future targets to learn these representations.