- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses roadside 4D occupancy forecasting, which predicts future semantic occupancy in the coordinate frame of a fixed roadside sensor. Based on the statistic that 97.55% of occupied voxels in InfraOcc are static and only 1.19% belong to moving agents, the authors argue that the global scene state and local motion should be handled separately. InfraWorld rolls out a dense BEV latent from a VQ tokenizer autoregressively while carrying 20 persistent queries. It consists of three modules: DQI, which places queries using a moving-mask head; LST (long-short temporal fusion), which combines short-term ConvGRU fusion with a long-term trend summarized from history residuals; and MAQI, which writes confidence-weighted query information back into the BEV.
Critical strengths
- The idea of separating and handling features of dynamic objects, which are the main focus in 4D occupancy forecasting, is sound, and the ablation study supports it.
- The analysis of the voxel distribution is a useful addition.
Critical weaknesses
-
Separating static and dynamic elements has been proposed for 3D occupancy prediction in StreamOcc (ECCV 2026), and the long-short-term temporal fusion is similar to the design proposed in SOLOFusion (ICLR 2023). I am not convinced that the proposed components make a distinct contribution beyond these works, and a comparison or discussion would help.
-
Since the setting is fixed-view and the goal is to separate static from moving objects, one could detect changed regions by directly comparing BEV representation values over time, without a moving-mask loss to filter moving regions. A comparison with such a simpler alternative would be helpful.
-
Occ3D-nuScenes assumes a moving ego vehicle, which differs from the fixed-view setting. I would like to know the exact experimental setup used on this dataset.
-
A comparison of accuracy and cost with methods based on sparse representations, such as GaussianWorld (CVPR 2025), would strengthen the paper.
Questions for authors
Please see the questions raised in the Weaknesses. Answers to Weaknesses 1 and 3 (clarification) would most likely change my assessment; Weaknesses 2 and 4 are suggestions that would strengthen the paper but are not required for the rebuttal.