- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
For autonomous driving, predicting how the surrounding environment will evolve is crucial. This paper treats a frozen world-model prediction as an explicit reference and learns to apply selective, evidence-grounded revisions. The effectiveness of the proposed method is validated on real-world autonomous driving datasets.
Critical strengths
Unlike existing paradigms that rely on redundant predictions, this approach introduces a reference-based editing strategy, which improves both the efficiency and performance of occupancy prediction. The method incorporates "evidence-guided boundary editing" and "executable semantic editing" to refine the initial reference prediction from multiple perspectives. It specifically addresses the core challenges of learning how to edit a reference prediction and when to retain its original content, with its efficacy demonstrated through extensive experimentation.
Critical weaknesses
- In the EGBE component, while provenance information helps refine boundaries, identifying the specific "contributing refine points" is non-trivial. The validity of the identified "direct contributors" and "class-consistent supporting points" requires further verification.
- Regarding semantic editing, the authors utilize an ontology to extract information concerning existence, kinematics, interaction, and visibility. The rationale for selecting these four ontology-defined states should be clarified, and it should be explained whether there is a specific supervisory strategy for extracting these states.
- Relying solely on SparseWorld as a forecasting anchor is insufficient to demonstrate the method's generalizability or model-agnostic applicability; the approach should be evaluated by integrating it with a broader range of model architectures.
- In the planning performance evaluation, the proposed method exhibits a significantly higher collision rate at the 1-second horizon compared to models like UniAD. This raises concerns regarding whether the method is suitable for short-term occupancy prediction tasks.
Questions for authors
Refer to Critical Weaknesses.
2 comments
Response to Reviewer skck (Part 2/2)
W4: Short-Horizon Planning Safety
A: We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. We acknowledge that ForecastEdit's 1s collision rate (0.14%) is higher than UniAD's (0.05%), indicating room for improvement in short-horizon planning safety. However, this does not imply that ForecastEdit is unsuitable for short-horizon Occupancy Prediction. At 1s, ForecastEdit improves mIoU from 14.93 to 16.70 and occupied IoU from 22.96 to 23.89, demonstrating improved short-horizon forecasting quality. Importantly, Occupancy accuracy and downstream planning safety are not equivalent optimization objectives.
UniAD is a separate planning-oriented model trained with auxiliary supervision from Maps, Boxes, and Occupancy. In contrast, ForecastEdit retains the frozen SparseWorld Planner and improves planning solely through refined scene representations, without explicitly optimizing for collision risk. Thus, collision rates depend not only on Occupancy quality but also on the Planner's decision policy and its response to different prediction errors.
One possible explanation is the trade-off between Occupancy accuracy and planning safety. ForecastEdit primarily improves predictions by retracting unsupported occupancy, which may also introduce some recall loss. In Occupancy-conditioned Planning, false-positive occupancy may induce conservative behavior. Therefore, better Occupancy predictions do not necessarily translate into lower collision rates at every horizon.
Although ForecastEdit improves average collision rates and longer-horizon planning performance, we acknowledge that short-horizon safety remains an area for improvement. We will explicitly discuss this distinction between Occupancy forecasting quality and short-horizon planning safety in the revised Limitations section.
Response to Reviewer skck (Part 1/2)
W1: EGBE Contributor Identification and Validity
A: We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. We clarify that EGBE contributors are automatically constructed from Point-to-Voxel Provenance retained by the frozen Renderer, rather than manually selected. Direct Contributors participate in Occupancy rendering, while Class-consistent Supporting Points are identified through the Renderer's same-class spatial support.
Instead of manually annotated point-level weights, Candidate-conditioned Attention learns each contributor's relative importance, while the Utility-aware Retraction Objective optimizes preserve/retract decisions. Thus, contributor identification is grounded in Renderer provenance, with its effectiveness learned through the editing objective.
To validate both contributor types, we conduct additional ablations comparing Direct-only, Direct + Random Local Points, and Full Provenance, achieving mIoU scores of 13.91, 13.86, and 14.17, respectively. The full approach improves mIoU by 0.26 and 0.31 points, while adding random local points provides no gain. These results suggest that class-consistent supporting points provide meaningful evidence beyond direct provenance and generic local aggregation, supporting the validity of our provenance construction.
W2: Ontology Design and Supervision
A: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We select Existence, Kinematics, Interaction, and Visibility to capture four complementary aspects of object dynamics: existence continuity, motion evolution, interaction constraints, and observation uncertainty.
Specifically, Existence distinguishes object persistence, temporary disappearance, and scene exit. Kinematics describes motion states such as stationary, accelerating, decelerating, and turning. Interaction captures relationships such as following, overtaking, and cutting in, providing constraints for multi-agent forecasting. Visibility distinguishes actual existence changes from observation loss due to occlusion, as temporary invisibility does not imply scene exit.
Regarding supervision, Existence, Kinematics, and Interaction labels are deterministically derived from matched ground-truth trajectories, motion changes, and pairwise trajectory relationships, respectively. Visibility labels use historical observation ratios and detection confidence. Unreliably matched objects are excluded to avoid noisy supervision. The four states are trained with cross-entropy and Brier calibration losses, while pairwise relations use multi-label BCE and Brier losses, together with soft logical consistency constraints.
Importantly, these states are not merely auxiliary predictions. Their predicted probabilities are projected back into object representations to directly condition multimodal future dynamics decoding, influencing future motion, existence, and local Occupancy. Thus, they provide complementary structured semantics while contributing directly to future scene modeling.
W3: Cross-Backbone Generalization
A: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We agree that evaluation solely on SparseWorld is insufficient to fully establish ForecastEdit's applicability across different architectures.
We therefore extend ForecastEdit to SparseWorld-TC[1] and COME[2], two occupancy forecasting models with different architectures, while preserving their original forecasting settings. As shown in the table below, ForecastEdit consistently improves both backbones.
These results suggest that ForecastEdit's effectiveness is not limited to SparseWorld-specific properties but complements different forecasting mechanisms. Together with our original SparseWorld results, these experiments provide further evidence of cross-backbone generalization. We will include the results and analyses in the revised manuscript.
[1] SparseWorld-TC: Trajectory-Conditioned Sparse Occupancy World Model, Du et al., CVPR 2026
[2] COME: Adding Scene-Centric Forecasting Control to Occupancy World Model, Shi et al., NeurIPS 2025