acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Context-Aware LLM Agents as World-to-Game Bridges for Solving Open Games

Abstract

Game theory underpins many high-stakes applications—security, defense, resource allocation, auctions, and negotiation—yet practical deployment is blocked by a fundamental tension: models faithful enough to capture reality are typically intractable, while models simple enough to solve discard the information that actually matters. In real deployments the game is also dynamic and open: its parameters change over time, and the decisive information arrives as unstructured, semantic, and drifting context (traffic reports, road closures, observed trajectories, market signals). Existing solvers—equilibrium algorithms, deep RL, or pure LLM-generated policies—cannot consume such context, because they assume a fully specified, fixed, numeric game. We introduce the Context-Aware Game-Theoretic Agent (CAGTA), a general framework that resolves this tension. An LLM acts solely as a world-to-game bridge: it interprets the unstructured context stream and maps it into the numeric parameters of a game that a solver can handle, thereby deciding what to be robust against, while the solver decides how to be optimal. Experiments on urban network security games demonstrate substantial gains in scalability and generalization over strong context-blind baselines.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM Agents, LLM Application, Game Theory, Open Games

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_o39wOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the challenge of real-world games characterized by unknown, time-varying environmental parameters and critical information presented in unstructured formats, proposing the Context-Aware Game-Theoretic Agent (CAGTA). The framework leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to convert contextual inputs—such as announcements and reports—into environmental parameters and their associated uncertainty ranges; it subsequently updates the model and replans whenever new information falls outside the scope of the current strategy. Theoretically, the authors analyze how effectively narrowing the uncertainty range enhances robust returns and derive a global error bound for multi-stage replanning under relevant assumptions. Experiments conducted on the GraphChase urban pursuit-evasion task—using LLMs to simultaneously handle interpretation and planning without additional training—evaluate performance across scenarios involving road closure information, time budgets, dynamic road weights, large-scale maps, and real-world urban announcements, demonstrating superior capture rates compared to selected baselines.

Critical strengths

The research addresses a problem of practical significance and employs a clear division of tasks within its framework. Focusing on how dynamic semantic information from real-world game scenarios is integrated into decision-making models, the paper proposes a workflow wherein an LLM interprets the context and updates environmental parameters, subsequently triggering a re-planning process. This design bridges language understanding and game planning, offering a clear pathway for adapting existing solution methods to environmental changes encountered during real-world deployment—a key aspect of the paper's practical value.

The paper provides a clear conditional analysis regarding the value of context. It demonstrates that effectively narrowing the scope of environmental uncertainty can improve worst-case payoff guarantees and further discusses the conditions under which performance in the actual environment is guaranteed to be no worse than that of the original strategy. This distinction avoids the simplistic assumption that "more information" automatically equates to "better actual performance"; it helps clarify the relationship between the accuracy of contextual interpretation and planning payoffs, thereby enhancing the method's interpretability.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The comparison is not sufficiently fair to determine whether the performance gains stem from the proposed method itself or from the additional information provided. CAGTA not only received notifications of road closures but also had access to pre-calculated travel times and exit analyses; some prompts even explicitly instructed the model on which police officer to dispatch to which exit. In contrast, the Vanilla LLM lacked such assistance, and the large-map experiments primarily compared the method against baselines involving random movement or remaining stationary. Consequently, the current results fail to answer whether CAGTA would still outperform other planning methods if they were granted access to the same information, making it difficult for the paper to substantiate the independent contribution of its approach.

  2. The testing scenarios are overly limited; a high capture rate is insufficient to demonstrate the method's reliability. The "100 paths" in the synthetic road-closure experiments actually consisted of a single path repeated 100 times, and the "20 paths" on real-world maps involved the same path played back repeatedly. Furthermore, the paper did not adequately test scenarios where the fugitive alters their route in response to police deployment or where the environment undergoes multiple consecutive changes. Thus, while the 100% capture rate confirms the system's success in a few fixed cases, it does not sufficiently support the claim that the system can handle diverse adversaries and continuously changing environments.

Questions for authors

CAGTA received pre-calculated travel times and deployment recommendations; did other methods also have access to this information? Has a comparative study been conducted where both parties were provided with the same information? If so, what further performance gains could CAGTA achieve?

Both road-blocking scenarios involved repeated testing on the same escape route. Beyond this, have existing experiments tested different escape routes, scenarios where the fugitive changes routes based on police deployment, or situations involving continuously changing road conditions? If so, please provide the corresponding results.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to Reviewer o39w

Thank you very much for your constructive comments.

W1 — the gain may be additional information, not the method. In Section 5.2 the six auction arms share the same numeric state and differ only in interpretation and solver (Table 4; Appendix E). We report the result as nuanced. After the rule change the bridge beats blindness (0.044 against 0.022 in first price with two bidders). CAGTA+Shade, given Theta, is stronger than the LLM. On these clean notices a Vanilla-LLM with the same text is competitive, so this table alone does not show that the interpreter is necessary. The bridge is visible where the prose has to be turned into parameters: on the Toronto bulletin, Vanilla LLM captures nothing in every arm, while CAGTA+LLM goes from 0 to 1 once the closure is read (Table 3).

W2 — limited scenarios. The revision adds the distinct-path IGRS values (25 / 95 / 193 paths; 0.5 vs 1.0; Table 2), adaptive competitors (Table 9), a four-regime day with three consecutive changes (Tables 10 and 11), and the second domain (Section 5.2). The paper states the route counts and the earlier repetition explicitly.

Q1 — fair information. Same comparison as in our reply to reviewer eaSX, Q1. With the same state in every arm (Section 5.2, Table 4): Vanilla-LLM scores 0.111 / 0.039 / 0.014 against CAGTA-LLM’s 0.121 / 0.044 / 0.012, inside the per-seed ranges (Table 8). On clean notices the bridge is not distinguishable from giving the text to the same LLM. The learner, which sees no notice, beats CAGTA-LLM before the changes (0.140 against 0.121) and falls below it afterwards (0.025 against 0.044; 0.009 against 0.012). CAGTA+Shade leads every regime (0.148 / 0.063 / 0.046). After the change, the ordering is solver-given-Theta > informed ~ vanilla-with-state > blind.

Q2 — diverse settings.

  • Different escape routes — yes, for the exact solver. CAGTA+IGRS is re-run on every distinct simple path within the horizon: 25 / 95 / 193 paths at T=5/6/7, value 0.5 blind and 1.0 informed (Table 2). On the real district the count is 210 pure paths from node 105, value 2/3 blind and 1 informed (Table 3).
  • A fugitive that changes routes in response to deployment. IGRS solves the maximin problem, so its value is the guarantee against a best-responding adversary; it is not a log of one fleeing path. Adaptive adversaries are also tested on the auction: five learning rivals (σ=0.05, update every 20 impressions, seeds 0–4, unpaired; Table 9). CAGTA+Shade scores 0.147 / 0.072 / 0.049, informed 0.132 / 0.017 / 0.014, and blind 0.122 / 0.007 / -0.001. The mean ordering is unchanged, and the per-seed ranges overlap.
  • Continuously changing conditions — measured in the second domain. GraphChase has a single closure, announced at t=0 or mid-episode (the t=1 column of Table 1). The auction has four regimes over 400 impressions — second price with two bidders, first price with two, first price with three, and second price with three, 100 impressions each — with the three notices (effective at impressions 101, 201, and 301) pre-announced at impression 1. The informed LLM’s per-participation gap to CAGTA+Shade does not grow with the number of prior changes: 0.001, 0.067, 0.043, 0.001 (Table 10); the largest gap is after the first change. In day totals the gap is 4.90 utility units, or 0.027 per participation, against 7.29 (0.041) for the blind arm (Table 11). The blind arm’s per-regime gaps are 0.025, 0.074, 0.056, 0.014 (Table 10). Per-regime totals sum to the day total by construction, so this is evidence against compounding, not a numerical check of the theorem’s constant. The sum of the four per-participation gaps (0.112 informed, 0.169 blind) is not itself the day’s per-participation gap; that quantity is the participation-weighted figure in Table 11.
Reviewer_o39wOpenReview ↗

Response

Thank you for the substantial revisions. The distinct-path evaluations and auction experiments address much of my concern about limited testing. However, the method’s added benefit remains unclear: CAGTA-LLM performs similarly to Vanilla-LLM under matched information in auctions, and the instruction-bearing vanilla baseline matches it in Toronto. These results do not sufficiently resolve my concern about gains beyond additional information and preprocessing, so I maintain my rating of 2 (weak rejection).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to the new comments (reviewer o39w)

We thank the reviewer for stating the concern plainly. We answer it in steps, and we keep Table 3 unchanged.

1. The LLM planner is not the contribution

The paper's claim is the framework: an interpreter produces a game object, a solver plays it. Using LLM as the Role 2 is a heuristic instantiation; the exact solver is CAGTA+IGRS (and, in the auction, CAGTA+Shade).

2. The vanilla LLM is the control for the game model

The vanilla consumes the bulletin as text but does not map it into game parameters, as we mention in Section 5.1. The vanilla is therefore the control for the significance of the game model, not a competing planner.

3. Table 3, unchanged

  • Blind: CAGTA+IGRS is 0.67; every vanilla row is 0. When the information is insufficient, the game model is what makes the decision.
  • Informed: CAGTA+LLM, CAGTA+IGRS and the instruction-bearing vanilla all reach 1. When the instruction is enough, the game model is not necessary on this easy instance.

4. Control: when informed, the game model can still be necessary

To show that the game model can still be necessary in the informed case, we do a control experiments. That is, on a harder Toronto placement — outside officer near the gate, inside officer near E1, the true exit inside, a false exit outside, the same city bulletin — we run CAGTA+LLM and the two vanilla variants. No IGRS row; no late column.

armblindinformed
CAGTA+LLM0/55/5
Vanilla LLM (-) (instruction removed)0/50/5
vanilla LLM (instruction-bearing)0/50/5

The geometry sets the trap: the outside officer’s believed route to E1 is 0.443 min through the shut gate, truth inf; the inside officer is the only true cover (2.841 min, criminal 3.352). The cover instruction sends the outside officer to E1 through the gate; CAGTA’s ETAs know that edge is inf and use the inside officer. So an instruction-bearing vanilla can fail even when informed, while CAGTA succeeds.

5. The auction, same structure

  • The LLM planner is not the contribution; the solver rows are CAGTA+Shade.
  • The vanilla is the control for the game model: it reads the notice and state but cannot produce Theta.
  • Clean notices: Vanilla-LLM is close to CAGTA-LLM (0.111/0.039/0.014 against 0.121/0.044/0.012; Table 4, per-seed ranges in Table 8) — the text alone is enough there.
  • The game model’s gain: CAGTA+Shade, given Theta, beats both in every regime (0.148/0.063/0.046; Table 4), while blind loses (0.121/0.022/−0.015).
  • Control when informed: the mechanism-specific best response. The LLM bids near-truthfully (shading 0.96–0.98); the shader given Theta shades to 0.6 in first price (the calibration table in Appendix E gives the best gamma 1.00 in second price and 0.60 in first). Same notice and state, different game model: 0.063 against 0.039 per participation in first price with two bidders (Table 4).
Reviewer_eaSXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces CAGTA, a framework for “open” games in which an LLM translates changing, unstructured context into numerical game parameters and a downstream solver replans accordingly. Its contributions are this world-to-game decomposition, theoretical results showing that correct context refinement can improve robust value and yield an approximate maximin strategy under certain assumptions, and an implementation for urban network security games. Validation uses GraphChase experiments with road closures, horizon and edge-weight shifts, grids up to 200x200, and a Toronto road network, reporting higher capture rates than context-blind learned policies, random control, and a Vanilla LLM baseline.

Critical strengths
  • Compelling problem. Using an LLM to translate unstructured and drifting context into game parameters for a conventional solver is interesting, practically relevant, and potentially useful for strategic systems beyond network security.
Critical weaknesses

Theoretical assumptions include:

  • The interpreter is always correct, i.e., θt∗∈ΘCt\theta_t^* \in \Theta_{C_t}. However, the experiments test only very explicit descriptions of closures, so there is no establishment of correctness under ambiguous or noisy context. A single incorrect interpretation could invalidate the theoretical guarantees.

  • The LLM solver is approximately optimal, and the future-value estimate is accurate. However, the authors neither compute explicit maximin optimality nor measure the error tolerance epsilon_sol, and they never compute or bound the future-value error. The LLM also often follows precomputed mandatory assignments, so its performance does not establish approximate optimality. If these unmeasured errors are large, the theoretical guarantee may be uninformative.

  • Induced actions are assumed to vary smoothly rather than discontinuously, but the paper’s main setting involves the discontinuous removal of actions through road closures.

In my opinion, these assumptions constitute significant weaknesses that call into question the practical reliability of the theoretical results.

The experiments contain several significant issues:

  • The main closure experiment repeats the same path 100 times, while the Toronto experiment repeats one path 20 times. Adversaries are given no mechanism for responding to model updates, such as a best-response oracle or new optimization, and are represented only as fixed paths. Combined with the use of a single model, cached outputs, and no confidence intervals or variation across prompts, models, contexts, or random instances, these two single-case examples do not constitute meaningful robustness validation.

  • CAGTA nearly receives the answer beforehand through exact travel times, a “critical exit analysis,” and sometimes explicit officer assignments, leaving little planning for the LLM. The comparison with the Vanilla LLM is also unequal because Vanilla does not receive the same travel times, updated game model, or critical-exit analysis. Its failure may therefore reflect receiving less useful information rather than anything specific to CAGTA’s architecture or context-parsing method.

  • The GraphChase baselines are tested outside their intended setting: they were trained on fixed, unweighted games and cannot process closure reports. Comparing them with CAGTA after changing the horizon, weights, and available roads is therefore not fair. Similarly, claims that CAGTA scales to a 40,000-node game are questionable because exact shortest-path times are precomputed and summarized in a prompt that barely changes with graph size. This shows that the LLM can process a compact summary, not necessarily that CAGTA itself scales efficiently.

  • The interpreter is tested on only one explicit road closure, with no ambiguous, noisy, conflicting, or incomplete reports. There is also little meaningful context drift: a single closure at time 0 or 1 does not resemble the changing stream of information emphasized in the motivation for open games. As a result, many of the claims concerning world-to-game parsing and realistic settings are overstated.

Questions for authors

Meaningful improvement would likely require substantial additional experiments.

  • Under fair information and compute how does CAGTA compare with a simple non-LLM planner and a vanilla LLM given the same travel times, updated game model, and critical-exit analysis? If there is a good result here, it would distinguish that the proposed CAGTA architecture actually contributes something beyond preprocessing and privileged information.

  • Does CAGTA remain effective across diverse settings like non-repeated paths, adaptive or best-responding adversaries, ambiguous or noisy context streams, and with multiple seeds/models and uncertainty estimates?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to Reviewer eaSX (1/2)

Thank you very much for you insightful comments.

W1 — the assumptions are untested. Assumption 1 (correct interpretation) holds on the clean, paraphrased, abbreviated, and noisy notices we tested. An inexact or incorrect interpreter is left for future work. Assumption 2 (ε_sol-optimal solver) is met by the CAGTA+IGRS rows: the solver gap is 0 on the instances where IGRS is run, and the LLM solver is reported separately as a heuristic. Assumption 3 (parametric smoothness) is a Lipschitz hypothesis in the proof; we do not claim a measured L.

W2 — repeated paths, no adaptive adversary, single model, no confidence intervals. The path-set criticism of the LLM solver is correct and is now stated in the paper. The 7×7 LLM column used one route repeated 100 times, as a control for whether the agent exploits the bulletin. Table 2 adds the IGRS evaluation on every distinct simple path (25 / 95 / 193 paths at T=5/6/7; value 0.5 blind and 1.0 informed). That value is the maximin value, so it is the guarantee against any adversary. Table 3 states the Toronto route count: 210 pure paths from node 105, value 2/3 blind and 1 informed. The auction adds adaptive competitors (five learning rivals; the ordering solver > informed > blind is unchanged; Table 9) and a four-regime day with three consecutive changes (Tables 10 and 11), in Section 5.2 and Appendix E. Those auction tables all use seeds 0–4. We still use one model (DeepSeek-Flash), with prompt variants.

W3 — CAGTA receives the answer beforehand. The fair-information design addresses the auction directly: every arm sees the same value, click-through rate, round, and history; Vanilla-LLM receives the same raw notice; the only differences are the interpretation and the solver (Table 4). On GraphChase, the “Mandatory” sentence has been deleted from the prompt. The variant that keeps it reads the same cells, so the analysis, not the instruction, produces the result. CAGTA+LLM still receives exact travel times: once the interpreter has written the new parameters into the game, the environment’s shortest-path fields are part of the game model, not extra advice about which exit to cover.

W4 — baselines out of distribution. Acknowledged. Retraining GraphChase’s PSRO and Grasper on the weighted or context-aware distribution is out of scope; the platform’s own scaling results explain why those runs do not finish. We report them as context-blind references. The fair comparisons are IGRS and the planners that receive the same information. The paper states this explicitly.

W5 — the scaling claim. The revision clarifies the claim. The prompt is O(1) in n: one travel time per officer and per exit, with the Dijkstra fields precomputed by the environment. The claim is that the decision interface does not degrade with n, not that the LLM solves a 40,000-node game. The exact shortest-path computation is done before the prompt is built.

W6 — one explicit closure; noisy or conflicting context. The GraphChase experiments use one explicit closure. The auction adds a mechanism change, a competition change, and three consecutive regime changes. On the clean, paraphrased, abbreviated, and noisy notices we tested, the interpreter is exact. A systematic study of an incorrect interpreter is left for future work.

Q1 — fair information. On the auction, with the same state in every arm (Table 4; per-seed ranges in Table 8): Vanilla-LLM (raw notice, no interpreter) scores 0.111 / 0.039 / 0.014 against CAGTA-LLM’s 0.121 / 0.044 / 0.012. The differences sit inside the per-seed ranges, so on these clean notices the bridge is not distinguishable from giving the same text to the same LLM. The non-LLM learner, which sees no notice, beats CAGTA-LLM before the changes (0.140 against 0.121) and falls below it after them (0.025 against 0.044; 0.009 against 0.012). CAGTA+Shade, the solver given Theta, leads every regime (0.148 / 0.063 / 0.046). The ordering is solver-given-Theta > informed ~ vanilla-with-state > blind after the rule change. Before the change, blind and informed coincide, as they should: the opening rules are already second price with two bidders.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to Reviewer eaSX (2/2)

Q2 — diverse settings.

AxisVerdictEvidence
Non-repeated pathsYes, for the exact solverIGRS on every distinct simple path (Table 2): 25 / 95 / 193 paths at T=5/6/7, value 0.5 blind and 1.0 informed. Real district (Table 3): 210 pure paths from node 105, value 2/3 blind and 1 informed. The LLM tables still use designed or replayed routes (one route x 100; least-time route x 10).
Adaptive / best-responding adversariesYes for the IGRS value; yes on the auctionIGRS reports the maximin value, i.e. the guarantee against a best response. Auction, five learner rivals (σ=0.05, update every 20, seeds 0–4, unpaired; Table 9): CAGTA+Shade 0.147 / 0.072 / 0.049, informed 0.132 / 0.017 / 0.014, blind 0.122 / 0.007 / -0.001. The mean ordering is unchanged; per-seed ranges overlap.
Multiple seedsYes on the auctionSeeds 0–4 throughout: fair information (Table 4) and its per-seed ranges (Table 8), adaptive rivals (Table 9), four regimes (Table 10), and per-seed day totals (Table 11). Hypothetical Minds ranges are in the text of Appendix E.

An inexact or incorrect interpreter is not part of this sweep; that study is left for future work.

Thanks for your reply. This helps clear some things up and I think the revision version of the paper is stronger than before.

A few lingering throughts:

On theoretical assumptions, thanks for adding IGRS and acknowledging that the LLM planner is heuristic. But we should note that this moderation of the scope of the original claims doesn't necessarily mean that the LLM planner contribution is worthy of inclusion. Also, I note that parsing the tested notices was successful but I still think the paper could directly benefit from some study on the sensitivity to incorrect interpretations rather than be left for future work.

On the repeated paths issue, thanks for updating to distinct path sets for IGRS. But I still question why the LLM planner is still using repeated paths?

On the fair comparison, I see you added the auction setting which has a fairer comparison. This improves the empirical rigor of the experiment but we should note these results:

  • in the auction setting the separate interpreter does not demonstrate a clear advantage over giving the same notice directly to the LLM
  • in the Toronto setting a Vanilla-LLM variant with general instruction achieves 10/10 captures (app C.5), while the instruction-removed variant gets zero.

For the first point, I acknowledge that you make note of this in the text. On the second though, my question would be why both variants are not reported prominently? In table 3 you only report the Vanilla LLM result when instruction was removed. Let me know if I am misunderstanding something about the experiment design.

On the out of scope baselines, thanks for rewording the graphchase setting as a context-blind reference. But once again narrowing the scope of the claim doesn't necessarily make its inclusion useful.

On scaling thanks for clarifying this and making the wording surrounding performance scaling more precise.

On diverse settings, adding the auction setting is useful. Could you clarify why in the four regime experiment you use announced/scheduled changes instead of discovered/unexpected information which would seem closer to the stated goals of the work?

One more question just for my understanding of the LLM evaluation dynamic: Appendix D.4 says the interpretation closes two additional edges and that the evaluated world is built from this interpretation. Is the simulated closure defined separately from the interpretation of the original record, or does it actually follow the interpreter? If the latter how do you evaluate interpretation accuracy with respect to the actual closure?

Your updates and clarifications definitely improve my opinion of the paper and I now lean closer to weak reject instead of clear reject. In order for me to consider improving the score further I would need the above remaining concerns to be addressed and to generally see some convincing evidence that the interpreter component specifically provides some distinct benefit.

Reviewer_rugfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes CAGTA (Context-Aware Game-Theoretic Agent), a framework for “open games” whose payoff-relevant parameters are unknown a priori and drift over time. The core idea is a division of labor: an LLM acts as a world-to-game bridge, interpreting unstructured context (e.g., traffic bulletins, closure reports) into a refined uncertainty set over numeric game parameters, while a game-theoretic solver computes a maximin strategy on the interpreted game. A re-planning loop (plan --> run --> observe context --> detect drift --> re-plan) invokes the LLM interpreter only when the context leaves the coverage set for which the current plan was designed

Critical strengths
  1. The “LLM as world-to-game bridge” is a crisp division of labor: LLM interprets heterogeneous context, solver optimizes on the interpreted game. This is a practically relevant and intellectually satisfying separation.
  2. Propositions 1–2 and Theorem 1 give the paper a formal backbone. The 1-Lipschitz backward-induction lemma (Lemma 1) and the additive error accumulation in Theorem 1 are technically neat and non-trivial.
  3. The contrast between context-blind solvers (NSG-NFSP, NSGZero, PSRO, Grasper) and CAGTA on the 7×7 closure instance (0 → 1 capture rate) is striking. Generalization to horizon shifts, edge reweighting, scaling to 200×200, and the real-world Toronto case are all useful demonstrations.
  4. The Rosedale district / Governor’s Road Bridge case gives the paper concreteness and demonstrates the “world-to-game” bridge on city prose, not just synthetic bulletins.
  5. The appendix provides prompts, instance details, and solver/interpreter descriptions, which supports reproducibility.
  6. The paper addresses a real limitation of both game-theoretic solvers (context-blind) and LLM agents (weak numerical reasoning), and the proposed hybrid is a sensible engineering direction.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Mismatch between the theory and the actual solver used. The theory assumes an ε_sol-optimal maximin solver (Assumption 2). In experiments, Role 2 is played by an LLM solver given exact ETAs and a shortlist of junctions—an LLM heuristic, not a certified maximin solver. The paper claims “any other solver that takes the game as given can be substituted,” but the reported numbers do not isolate whether the gains come from the interpretation (the actual contribution) or from the LLM solver’s numerical reasoning. An ablation with an exact/extensive-form solver (e.g., MCCFR or a linear program) on the interpreted game would be much more convincing.
  2. Narrow experimental scope despite broad “general framework” claim. All experiments are on one benchmark family (GraphChase urban network security games). The paper claims to address “open games” generally, but evidence covers only one game family. No evaluation on other open-game settings (drifting opponent styles in poker, security games with heterogeneous multimodal sensor reports, repeated auctions with changing market context, etc.). The “general” claim is oversold relative to the evidence.
  3. Baseline fairness. The learned baselines (NSG-NFSP, NSGZero, PSRO, Grasper) are context-blind and were trained on unweighted grids; they are not adapted or retrained for the weighted/context-aware setting. This makes the comparison somewhat one-sided. A stronger comparison would include a context-blind solver re-trained or fine-tuned on the weighted/context-aware distribution, and/or a context-aware exact solver (MCCFR on the interpreted game). The “Vanilla LLM” baseline is also a strawman: it is denied ETAs and the formal game model, so its failure mostly shows that LLMs cannot do arithmetic from prose, not that the world-to-game bridge is uniquely necessary.
  4. No comparison to LLM game-playing agents. The related work discusses SuspicionAgent, ReTA, EMO, Hypothetical Minds, Agent-Pro, Strategist, RHM, etc., but the experiments compare only against a Vanilla LLM and context-blind solvers. Given that CAGTA is positioned as an LLM agent, a comparison (or at least a discussion) against at least one such LLM gaming agent is expected.
Questions for authors
  1. How often is the LLM i nterpreter correct on the benchmark instances? Can you report a confusion matrix or error rate over the reported configurations?
  2. Assumption 3 requires L-Lipschitz stage payoffs. What is L for your UNSG instances, and how does the bound behave numerically?
  3. How many independent seeds are used per reported configuration? Can you report confidence intervals or standard errors for the main tables?
  4. How does CAGTA handle multimodal context (images, video, sensor feeds)? The paper mentions multimodal LLMs, but no multimodal experiment is reported.
  5. How does CAGTA differ from, and improve upon, existing autoformalization / code-world-model approaches (Mensfelt et al., Deng et al., Lehrach et al.) that also use an LLM to produce a model for a solver?

References:

Mensfelt, Agnieszka, Kostas Stathis, and Vince Trencsenyi. "Autoformalization of game descriptions using large language models." arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.12300 (2024).

Deng, Shilong, Yongzhao Wang, and Rahul Savani. "From natural language to extensive-form game representations." arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.17282 (2025).

Lehrach, Wolfgang, et al. "Code world models for general game playing." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2026. 2026.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to Reviewer rugf

Thank you very much for you helpful comments.

W1 — theory/solver mismatch. CAGTA+IGRS is now a row in both GraphChase tables: 0.5 / 1 / 1 on the 7×7 closure (Table 1) and 0.67 / 1 / 1 on the real district (Table 3). Table 2 evaluates that solver on every distinct simple path (0.5 blind, 1.0 informed at T=5/6/7). Because IGRS attains the value of the game it is given, the solver gap on these instances is zero, and the 0.5-to-1.0 change is the effect of the refined game, not of a better heuristic. The same Theta therefore yields the exact value once role 2 is an exact solver; the LLM solver remains a heuristic and is not folded into the theorem.

W2 — narrow scope. Section 5.2 is the setting suggested in the review: repeated auctions with a changing market. It covers a mechanism switch, a change in the number of competitors, three consecutive changes, and adaptive competitors. The framework’s roles are unchanged; only the game and the interpreter contract are instantiated in the new domain.

W3 — baseline fairness. In the auction, every arm receives the same value, click-through rate, round, and own history (Table 4). Vanilla-LLM sees the raw notice and that same state, without an interpreter; the learner sees no notice. This separates interpretation and the solver from extra state. On these clean notices Vanilla-LLM is close to CAGTA-LLM (see Q1 below), which we report rather than claim a large interpreter gap. On GraphChase, the mandatory assignment sentence is removed from the reported prompt. The variant that keeps it reads the same cells, so the exit analysis, not that instruction, accounts for the result.

W4 and Q5 — LLM game-playing agents. Section 2 already contrasts CAGTA with CSRO, Game of Thoughts, States-as-Strings, RHM, PrimeNash, and LegoNE: those methods use the LLM as a proposer for a given game, whereas CAGTA uses it to obtain the game’s parameters under drift. Empirically, we implement the idea of Hypothetical Minds ourselves (no code from the original). It is not told the notice; it scores natural-language hypotheses from its own outcomes and plans with the best one. It identifies first price in 5/5 seeds by the end of the rule-change segment, but earns -0.096 / -0.076 per participation in the two first-price segments, against CAGTA-LLM’s 0.044 / 0.012 (Table 4). The inference works; the play does not, because the agent chases the clearing prices it observes.

Q1 — interpreter accuracy. On the clean, paraphrased, abbreviated, and noisy notices we tested, the interpreter returns the intended parameters. Studying an inexact or incorrect interpreter is left for future work.

Q2 — L for the UNSG instances. We do not claim a numeric Lipschitz constant L. The optimal values of these games are known (0.5 or 1), and IGRS attains them, so the stage bound is evaluated at ε_sol=0 for CAGTA+IGRS. The LLM’s gap to that value is measured empirically rather than bounded.

Q3 — seeds and confidence. The IGRS values are exact for a given path set. The T=5/6/7 sweep (Table 2) shows that the same 0.5 / 1.0 split holds as the closed-game path set grows from 25 to 193 paths; it is not a confidence interval over random seeds. The LLM runs are deterministic at temperature 0, with a disk cache whose version is recorded with the settings. Every auction table uses seeds 0–4. Per-seed ranges for the fair-information arms are in Table 8 (Appendix E); the main-text means are in Table 4 (Section 5.2).

Q4 — multimodal context. This release uses no multimodal benchmark. The interpreter contract is modality-agnostic: any front end that emits the same Theta can be substituted.

Reviewer_rugfOpenReview ↗

Official Comment to Author Response

Thank you for the extensive and constructive rebuttal. The addition of the exact solver (IGRS) successfully resolves the theory-practice mismatch, and introducing the repeated auctions domain significantly addresses my concerns about the framework's narrow scope. I would like the authors to further clarify:

  1. You noted that studying an inexact or incorrect interpreter is left for future work. However, the entire premise of "drifting, incomplete context" suggests the interpreter will sometimes be wrong.
  2. In your response to Q2, you noted that you do not claim a numeric Lipschitz constant L. While it is great that IGRS achieves the exact value, Theorem 1 still relies on the residual refinement loss and estimation error. Does the theorem provide an actionable guarantee for the LLM interpreter in practice, or is it strictly an existence/structural proof?
  3. You noted that studying an inexact or incorrect interpreter is left for future work. However, the entire premise of "drifting, incomplete context" suggests the interpreter will sometimes be wrong. what happens to CAGTA's guarantees (and performance) if the interpreter returns a Θ(Ct) that does not contain the true parameter θ∗?
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to the new comments (reviewer rugf) (1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the second reading. Points 1 and 3 are the same question — what happens when the interpreter is wrong — asked once about the experiments and once about the guarantees; we answer them together. Point 2 asks whether Theorem 1 is actionable or structural, and we answer it separately. Both answers are now in the revision: Appendix F (Sensitivity to Incorrect Interpretations) and a remark after Theorem 1.

Points 1 and 3: an interpreter that returns Θ(C_t) that does not contain θ*

The guarantees. The reviewer is right that Assumption 1 (correct interpretation) is essential, and we do not claim otherwise. Propositions 1–2 and Theorem 1 are conditional: if θ* is not in Θ(C_t), the refinement is no longer a set that contains the true game, the Lipschitz comparison is not defined across the wrong boundary (a closure changes the value discontinuously; the paper’s closure-as-drift-event paragraph says why no finite L bridges it), and the bound is void. The plan is then maximin for the wrong game: it can be worse than the context-blind plan, and in principle arbitrarily so. There is no bound in the paper for that case, and we now say so explicitly in the remark after Theorem 1.

The performance. We measured the cost rather than leaving it as a premise. Role 2 is held fixed, so the only variable is Θ. The tables are Appendix F; the numbers are:

7×7 closure (same-information guard; capture on the true closed world, 25 distinct paths):

belief (Θ)capture
correct1.000
blind (no closure)0.800
wrong link closed0.960
spurious closure0.800
over-closure (both links)0.960
late (closure from t = 2)0.880

Auction day (CAGTA+Shade; utility per participation, seeds 0–4):

beliefSP/2FP/2FP/3day total
correct0.14750.06280.04646.496
blind (rule change missed)0.14750.0111−0.00743.752
FP from the start0.12360.06280.04646.014
effective round early (61)0.14760.06280.04646.526
effective round late (101)0.14750.05130.04646.259
reversed (reads second price)0.12360.0111−0.00743.270

Three readings. (i) A wrong mechanism is the dominant error: missing the rule change takes the auction day from 6.50 to 3.75, and reading it backwards to 3.27. (ii) A wrong closure costs less on these instances (0.80–0.96 on the 7×7): the guard still hedges, so the failure is graceful, but the guarantee is void. (iii) A timing error costs about 0.24 in the auction day total; an early switch is within noise. These are empirical costs, not a bound; in the worst case a wrong Θ can be exploited by the true θ* and we do not claim otherwise.

What follows operationally. Because role 1 returns a set rather than a single plan, the output can be checked before it is committed: the closure edges can be validated against the bulletin, a non-singleton set carries its own ambiguity (diam Θ), and a misread mechanism is detectable from the clearing prices (the learner and Hypothetical-Minds arms show the inference is possible). We do not implement a detector, and drift detection as set containment cannot catch an error the interpreter does not report — the paper says that explicitly.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Respond to the new comments (reviewer rugf) (2/2)

Point 2: is Theorem 1 actionable or structural?

It is a conditional error budget, not an existence proof, and we now say this in a remark after the theorem. The bound is

epsilon = sum_t [ epsilon_sol(t) + 2 L diam(Theta(C_t)) + 2 ||w_hat(t+1) - w(t+1)||_inf ],

and each term is a measurable quantity, not an abstract constant:

  • epsilon_sol(t) is 0 for CAGTA+IGRS on the reported instances. For the LLM solver it is measured rather than bounded: on the 7×7 closure the LLM’s gap to IGRS is 0.5 in the blind arm (0 against 0.5) and 0 in the informed arm (1 against 1).
  • 2 L diam(Theta(C_t)) is the interpreter’s ambiguity. When the interpreter returns a singleton — an exact closure such as (18,2) — the diameter is 0 and L does not enter at all. L is needed only when the interpreter returns a non-singleton set; we do not claim a numeric L for that case, and the paper says so.
  • 2 ||w_hat(t+1) − w(t+1)||_inf is the successor-value error. With exact re-planning (the LP solves the remaining game), it is 0; with a heuristic lookahead it is measurable.

Proposition 2’s residual refinement loss ρ is likewise computable: on the 7×7 closure ρ = 0 for the informed game (v* = 1, robust value = 1) and ρ = 0.5 for the blind one (v* = 1, robust value = 0.5), which is the over-hedging the bulletin removes.

On the 7×7 closure the three terms are therefore 0 + 0 + 0 and the budget is zero; on the real district the reading is a superset of the record’s closure (13 against 11 edges), and the two games coincide at the reconstruction’s resolution (Appendix D.4), so the deployed game is the record’s. For the LLM solver the budget is the measured solver gap. The theorem’s content is the additive composition — per-stage errors enter with coefficient 1 and do not compound — not a distribution-free bound for arbitrary natural language. It becomes an actionable guarantee once the interpreter’s output is a set with a measured diameter and the solver’s gap is measured; it does not certify that an LLM interpreter is correct, which is exactly why we now measure the cost of violating Assumption 1 rather than assume it away.

The revision adds the remark after Theorem 1, the two sensitivity tables in Appendix F, and the limitations paragraph that replaces “studying an incorrect interpreter is left for future work.”

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to All Reviewers

We thank the reviewers for the detailed and constructive reports. To address the concerns, the revision makes two main changes.

  1. An exact solver in role 2, and an evaluation on distinct paths. Section 5.1 adds CAGTA+IGRS (IGRS is the LP-based exact solver). On the 7×7 closure, Table 1 reports the IGRS value 0.5 blind and 1.0 informed (and 1.0 when the closure is announced at t=1); the LLM column of that table is still the earlier protocol, a single designed route repeated 100 times, which the paper now states explicitly. Table 2 re-solves the same closure on every distinct simple path within the horizon: the value is again 0.5 blind and 1.0 informed at T=5, 6, and 7 (25, 95, and 193 paths in the closed game). On the Toronto district, Table 3 reports CAGTA+IGRS at 0.67 / 1 / 1 (blind / informed / told at t=0.2), which is the maximin value on the 210 pure paths from node 105 (2/3 blind, 1 informed).

  2. A second open game. Section 5.2 instantiates the same two roles on repeated ad auctions with a changing market (AuctionGym): a mechanism switch, a change in the number of bidders, three consecutive regime changes, and adaptive competitors. Details, prompts, and the remaining tables are in Appendix E.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

The Second Revision

The main change in the second revision is adding experiments for evaluating CAGTA+LLM on distinct paths (Section 5.1) and evaluating the sensitivity to incorrect interpretations (Appendix F).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

The Third Revision

The main change in the second revision is:
Appendix B.2 reports a harder placement, where the instruction-bearing vanilla (Vanilla LLM) fails even when informed while CAGTA succeeds: the control for the game model.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.