- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on how to efficiently generate electrophysiological signals with a large number of sampling points while preserving local waveform details and spectral characteristics. The author proposes SiDe (Signal-space Detailer), which divides the computational process into two parts: the compressed Transformer backbone is responsible for the context and conditional information of the entire signal; the local one-dimensional convolution detailer simultaneously reads the features of the backbone and the noisy original signal, and predicts the update direction in the original signal space. The core idea is: compress the calculation in the backbone while retaining the direct path from the original signal to the output end, reducing the limitation of compressed representation on detail restoration. Main contributions:
- Proposes a local detail restoration structure suitable for electrophysiological signals.
- Systematically analyzes the problems caused by compression.
- Establishes a comprehensive verification combination. The most fully validated aspect is the quality of local signals and conditional responses; the true long-term dependencies, as well as whether the synthetic signals can be reliably used for the robustness evaluation of the real decoder, still require more direct experiments.
Critical strengths
- The performance improvement on the main task is significant and is supported by the strengthened baseline and various evaluation methods. This is the primary basis for my consideration: The paper has made clear progress in tasks with high sampling rates and multi-channel generation, and the main benefits have consistency across metrics and evaluators.
- The effect on the original signal pathway was subjected to a discernible controlled verification, forming a design basis that can be adopted by subsequent research. This point influenced my overall assessment because the paper provided operational experience on how the electrophysiological generation model arranges compression and detail restoration, increasing its contribution value to the community.
Critical weaknesses
- The core claim of long-term dependency lacks experiments that can directly test it. The main signal statistics of EMG are calculated on 0.5-second segments; although Sleep-EDF generates 5 minutes and 10 epochs at once, they are split into individual 30-second epochs for evaluation. Therefore, the existing results sufficiently prove the quality of local signals, but cannot rule out the possibility that "short segments are independently generated and then concatenated to achieve similar indicators". This gap directly limits the contribution strength of the paper in the "long sequence modeling" aspect, and is the most significant negative consideration.
- Compared with the existing original space generation methods, the contribution of the newly designed mechanism has not been fully separated. The comparison between SiDe and JiT involves changes in the output structure and the parameterization of predictions; while the bottleneck ablation mainly proves the importance of the original signal pathway, it cannot fully explain why SiDe is superior to JiT which already has an explicit original pathway. This enables me to recognize the empirical effect of the final architecture, but I still have doubts about its incremental independent method and the benefits proposed in the paper, and thus is not sufficient to give a stronger acceptance recommendation.
Questions for authors
- Among the current results, which pieces of evidence directly support "learning long-term dependencies or epoch-crossing relationships"? The main signal statistics of EMG are calculated on 0.5-second segments, while Sleep-EDF evaluates on a single 30-second epoch. In the existing analysis, is there any evidence that can distinguish "joint generation of the entire segment" from "concatenation of independent short segments"? If not, should the "long-range/cross-epoch dependencies" mentioned in the text be understood as the modeling capability of the architecture rather than a conclusion that has been experimentally verified?
- Can the existing comparison in Table 2 confirm the independent benefits of the specialized output structure of SiDe? Considering that the rFID gap between SiDe and ResNet-3/4 is small, does the existing evidence support a stable improvement in spectral recovery or a broader improvement in generation quality?
2 comments
Thank you very much for your careful follow-up and for taking the time to examine our additional experiments.
We are glad that the new controlled experiments addressed your concerns regarding cross-epoch dependencies and clarified the specific contributions of the Detailer. We also appreciate your recognition of the quality-efficiency trade-off demonstrated by SiDe-64.
We will incorporate the additional experiments, implementation details, and the identified limitation regarding temporal over-smoothing into the revised manuscript, while keeping our claims aligned with the supporting evidence.
Thank you again for your constructive feedback and thoughtful evaluation. We sincerely appreciate your support.
Thank you for the author's addition of targeted experiments. Regarding cross-epoch dependencies, the newly added joint generation and stage-matching independent concatenation control, as well as the classification analysis near the stage transition, substantially address my main concerns. These results provide direct evidence that was lacking in the original manuscript, supporting the claim that joint generation can retain the cross-epoch statistical correlations and transition-related features that independent concatenation cannot. I also agree with the author's report on the smoothing of time. The revised manuscript should retain this limitation and confine the conclusion to the statistical dependencies actually supported by the experiments.
Regarding the contribution of the specific detailer, the author clearly positions its main benefit as spectral restoration and acknowledges that it has a relatively small difference from rFID of ResNet-3/4. This explanation is consistent with the results in Table 2, resolving my doubts about the scope of the contribution. The new results of SiDe-64 also demonstrate a valuable trade-off between computational cost and generation quality, further enhancing the practicality of the method.
Based on the original manuscript and this response, I maintain the recommendation of weak acceptance. The author has clearly alleviated the most significant evidence gap and more accurately defined the benefits of the specialized output structure, so my support for acceptance is more sufficient than in the initial review. Please incorporate the new experiments, necessary implementation details, and identified limitations into the revised manuscript.