acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Remember the Gist, Recover the Details: Task-Adaptive Agent Memory Generation

Abstract

With the rise of agent applications, effectively compressing large volumes of interaction history has become an important research problem. An ideal memory compression method should preserve as much task-relevant information as possible for downstream tasks. However, because relevance depends on the task—details useful for one task may be distractions for another— existing methods often struggle to retain task-specific details while filtering out task-irrelevant noise. We propose GiDe, a two-stage method that efficiently extracts both the main task information and task-specific details under a limited memory budget, reducing the interference of task-irrelevant noise with detail extraction. In the first stage, task-agnostic trajectory backbone extraction identifies key information directly from the original trajectory to produce a reusable semantic skeleton. In the second stage, task-specific detail supplementation actively queries the original trajectory for details missing from the skeleton, and combines them with the task information already captured in the first stage to form the final memory. Experiments on LoCoMo and LongMemEval-S with multiple backbone models, including GPT-4o-mini and Qwen, show that GiDe consistently outperforms existing memory compression methods, substantially improving both question-answering accuracy and F1 score while keeping total token consumption for compression low. The efficiency advantage is even more pronounced when the same trajectory is reused across multiple tasks.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Agent Memory, AI Agent, Multi-model reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_Ae3sOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies information reuse and detail preservation in long-term conversational memory. Because the importance of a fact depends on subsequent questions, premature compression may omit necessary details, whereas processing the full raw history for each question incurs substantial repeated overhead. The authors propose GiDe, a training-free two-stage method. First, it extracts backbone facts with source information from the dialogue history and repairs them through a QA-based checking procedure. Then, given the current question, it selects backbone evidence, identifies information gaps, and, when necessary, consults the original dialogue to construct the final task memory. The paper analyzes the method’s applicable conditions using a simplified information-theoretic model, evaluates question-answering performance on LoCoMo and LongMemEval-S, and supplements the study with component ablation, controlled retrieval, cross-model transfer, and amortized token-cost experiments.

Critical strengths
  1. The method addresses a clear and practically meaningful tension, and the division of labor between the two stages is well justified. When future questions are unknown, compressed memory struggles to retain all potentially necessary details. GiDe combines reusable facts with task-time detail recovery, allowing the backbone to both provide partial answers and help locate original evidence. In Table 3, removing Stage 1 causes a 3.07-point drop in F1, and removing detail recovery together with task-memory assembly causes a 6.97-point drop, supporting the contribution of both stages to the final performance. This gives the paper’s design a relatively clear empirical basis.
  2. The experiments support the practical value of the method from multiple angles. Under the GPT-4o-mini configuration, GiDe achieves an overall F1 of 59.76 on LoCoMo and an overall score of 84.0 on LongMemEval-S, with particularly strong performance on multi-hop and temporal reasoning categories. Controlled retrieval experiments further show that backbone clues can help locate necessary facts amid substantial distractor information; cross-model experiments and amortized cost experiments also provide evidence for the benefits of reuse. Taken together, these results suggest that the framework is worth further research and adoption.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Lack of direct comparison with the closest methods. Section 2.2 notes that ReadAgent, MemWalker, and AnchorMem already adopt a “pre-built summary or factual线索, then look up the original text” approach, but these methods are not included in the main experiments. As a result, the current results are insufficient to clearly establish GiDe’s additional contribution relative to similar frameworks. It is recommended to include at least one closest method and compare answer quality and processing cost under a consistent evaluation setup.
  2. The triggering condition for looking back at the original dialogue is unclear, and the backbone-first retrieval order lacks validation. Section 3.3 describes looking back at the original text when an information gap remains unresolved, while Appendices A.3 and A.10 link the look-back step to exhaustion of the backbone candidate pool and cap the retrieval loop at three steps. It is unclear how the system behaves when a gap persists, the candidate pool is not yet exhausted, but the step limit has been reached. Moreover, the paper does not compare a strategy that looks back at the original dialogue immediately after detecting a gap, making it difficult to judge the actual value of continuing to search the backbone in terms of quality and efficiency.
  3. The effectiveness of incremental updating is not supported by experiments. Section 3.2 and Appendix A.2 describe local updates when a new session arrives, but the experiments do not show answer quality or update cost as sessions are continuously added. In particular, when new information revises existing preferences, plans, or event states, it remains unclear whether local updates can maintain temporal consistency in memory. This limits the evidence for backbone reuse in sustained interaction scenarios.
  4. The handling of the EXTERNAL branch is unclear, affecting the interpretation of open-domain results. Section 3.1 assumes that answers are supported by the dialogue history, whereas Appendix A.3 allows returning EXTERNAL for general-knowledge questions, even though the reader is required to answer solely based on the provided evidence. The paper does not specify what happens after entering this branch, how often it is triggered, or whether comparison methods follow the same knowledge-use rules. Therefore, it is unclear how much of the open-domain gain can be attributed to memory selection and detail recovery.
  5. The reliability of subsequent recovery mechanisms when the initial backbone localization is wrong is not analyzed. GiDe uses person or event clues from the selected backbone to construct subsequent queries. If the initial retrieval links to a similar but incorrect event, supplementary retrieval may continue following the wrong clues to seek details. Section 4.2 considers clue misidentification, but the experiments do not show recovery performance when such errors actually occur. Thus, whether the method can correct initial mislocalization, and how strongly its gains depend on localization accuracy, requires further clarification.
Questions for authors
  1. Are there any direct comparisons with ReadAgent, MemWalker, or AnchorMem?
  2. When the knowledge gap persists but the retrieval step limit is reached, does the system necessarily fall back to the original text? Compared with immediate fallback, what are the empirical benefits of the backbone-first strategy?
  3. Has the answer quality and update overhead been evaluated when new sessions are incrementally added?
  4. How exactly does the EXTERNAL branch respond, how many times was it triggered, and are the knowledge usage rules consistent across all compared methods?
  5. If the initial localization of a person or event is incorrect, can the system correct it? Are there any relevant cases or statistics on the recovery success rate?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ae3s (1/3)

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive suggestions. Section, table, and figure numbers below refer to the revised manuscript.

[1/3] W1–W2, Q1–Q2. Closest methods and source lookup

Direct comparisons (W1, Q1). We added ReadAgent and AnchorMem on the same ten LoCoMo conversations and 1,540 non-adversarial questions. Within each model group, methods share the answer model and token-level F1 scorer, retaining their native prompts, retrieval and final-context policies. Table 5 below reports both answer quality and total construction-plus-answering tokens. This directly compares two of the closest source-lookup methods under the reported evaluation protocol (Sections 5.1–5.2 and 5.4; LoCoMo category scores in Tables 2–3).

Table 5. LoCoMo quality–cost comparison (selected rows; revised manuscript, Section 5.4)

MethodGPT-4o-mini F1 ↑Qwen2.5-14B F1 ↑GPT-4o-mini total tokens/q ↓
ReadAgent31.1636.918,873.7
AnchorMem48.2339.419,930.2
GiDe59.8157.598,382.8

What GiDe adds (W1, Q1). With GPT-4o-mini, GiDe improves F1 over ReadAgent and AnchorMem by 28.65 and 11.58 points while reducing total tokens by 5.5% and 15.6%. The quality ordering also holds with Qwen2.5-14B: 57.59 for GiDe, 36.91 for ReadAgent and 39.41 for AnchorMem. ReadAgent uses page summaries, and AnchorMem uses fact anchors and associated events. GiDe couples QA repair of compact facts with gap-directed source queries, so the same repaired facts support answering and help find omitted details (Table 1). The component results clarify this contribution: removing QA repair lowers F1 by 2.61 points; removing detail recovery lowers it by 9.73; using the question alone for source lookup lowers it by 3.22 (Section 5.3, Table 4). The quality–cost frontier is shown in Figure 3.

Source-lookup trigger (W2, Q2). Yes: if a gap persists at the three-step limit, source lookup is triggered even when unused backbone candidates remain. GiDe searches the backbone for at most three steps, followed by a final sufficiency check; candidate exhaustion can also trigger lookup. When the selected facts suffice, regular source lookup is skipped, while reader refusal can independently trigger recovery. This rule lets another stored fact fill a gap before consulting the original dialogue, while bounding the backbone search (Section 3.3 and Appendix A.3).

What the lookup ablations establish (W2, Q2). Selective recovery reaches 59.81 F1 at 7,128 online tokens per question, versus 57.60 at 10,489 for unconditional lookup after backbone search. Both variants first search the backbone; the unconditional variant also retrieves raw passages when the context is already judged sufficient. Thus, selective supplementation improves quality and reduces online cost in this comparison. GiDe also answers 386/1,540 questions without source lookup, with 85.23% model-judged accuracy on that subset, illustrating the backbone’s direct-answering role (Section 5.5). The specific comparison with immediate lookup at the first detected gap was not evaluated; Table 4 tests selective versus unconditional supplementation after search (Section 5.3).

Table 4. Source-lookup ablation (selected rows; revised manuscript, Section 5.3)

PolicyF1 ↑Reported online tokens/q ↓
Gap-driven source recovery59.817,128
Unconditional source lookup after backbone search57.6010,489
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ae3s (2/3)

[2/3] W3–W4, Q3–Q4. Incremental updates and EXTERNAL

Adding new history (W3, Q3). We evaluated addition and revision separately, since retaining new facts and reconciling changed facts pose different requirements. For addition, we kept the existing conv-26 backbone and processed conv-30’s 19 raw sessions through extraction, probing and repair before merging the new facts. This update costs 148,326 tokens across 156 calls. On the same 233 questions, the combined bank scores 56.65 F1 versus 56.78 for separately constructed and queried banks; online costs are 7,133 versus 7,243 tokens per question. This evaluates retrieval from the combined history after updating the existing bank (Section 5.5, Appendix B.4 and Table 10).

Table 10. Trajectory-addition results (revised manuscript, Appendix B.4)

MethodF1 ↑Accuracy (%) ↑Online tokens/question ↓
Incrementally update M0M_056.6587.557,133
Separate construction and retrieval56.7888.417,243

Revising current and historical states (W3, Q3). To examine the temporal-consistency concern, we added one synthetic revision session to conv-41. Editing the existing backbone and rebuilding from the revised history are evaluated on the same 16 questions: eight ask about current states and eight about historical states. The historical questions check whether earlier information remains available after a change. Both answering procedures and backbone editing use GPT-4o-mini; accuracy is automatically judged (Section 5.5, Appendix B.4 and Table 11).

Table 11. State-revision pilot (revised manuscript, Appendix B.4)

Update policyUpdate-stage tokens ↓F1 ↑Automatically judged ACC ↑
Edit existing backbone17,93280.45100.0%
Rebuild backbone257,49271.3787.5%

Update quality and cost. Editing uses 17,932 update tokens versus 257,492 for rebuilding, a 93.0% reduction, with F1 of 80.45 versus 71.37 and model-judged correctness of 16/16 versus 14/16. Answering all 16 questions correctly under this judge covers both the current-state and historical-state questions in the controlled revision. Together, Tables 10–11 provide quality and cost measurements for one trajectory addition and one revision session; repeated session-by-session updates over a long interaction stream were not evaluated (Appendix B.4).

EXTERNAL execution (W4, Q4). The EXTERNAL label in the controller prompt does not open a separate general-knowledge answering branch. In the evaluated path it is mapped to MISSING: GiDe continues retrieving from the conversation, and the final reader answers using the supplied context. Thus, EXTERNAL follows the same dialogue-retrieval procedure as other insufficient-context decisions, consistent with Section 3.1’s history-supported setting (Appendix A.3). Raw pre-mapping EXTERNAL frequencies were not retained. Baselines follow their native prompts, so knowledge-use rules were not separately standardized across methods (Section 5.1).

Interpreting open-domain performance. Appendix A.3 includes a separate question-only diagnostic on the 96 open-domain questions: 9 strictly correct answers, 4 incorrect answers and 83 exact abstentions. This shows that the answer model can supply some answers without retrieved dialogue. These counts describe question-only behavior; they do not decompose the model-knowledge and retrieval contributions to GiDe’s final score. We report the open-domain comparison as answer performance of the complete methods under the settings above (Tables 2–3).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ae3s (3/3)

[3/3] W5, Q5. Recovery from incorrect localization

Correction after an initial localization error (W5, Q5). We examined 385 questions from conv-26/30/41 using automatic post-hoc annotations of the retrieved context. Fifteen initially target the wrong person or event (3.9%); five have missing or confusing backbone clues (1.3%), overlapping the first group. Among 13 initially mislocalized questions with a first-round MISSING verdict and comparable later annotations, ten are labeled correctly localized after retrieval and recovery (S3), or 76.9%. These are context-localization labels for a defined subset, distinct from final answer accuracy (Appendix B.3 and Table 9).

Table 9. Localization diagnostics (selected rows; revised manuscript, Appendix B.3)

DiagnosticCountMeaning
Wrong initial person/event localization15 / 385Automatically annotated initial retrieval error
Missing or confusing backbone clue5 / 385Overlaps with the first category
Corrected at S3 in the defined MISSING subset10 / 13 (76.9%)Conditional pipeline localization correction

How the search target can change (W5, Q5). At later steps, the controller generates a focused query from the original question and the facts selected so far; source lookup uses the latest query, or the original question if none was generated. An initial person or event clue can therefore be revised as the context changes. The 10/13 result shows that initial errors can be corrected during this process. Three of these 13 cases were not labeled correctly localized at S3, so correction is not automatic. The statistic covers the subsequent retrieval-and-recovery process; it does not isolate source lookup alone or quantify final F1’s dependence on initial localization accuracy (Section 3.3 and Appendix B.3).

Complementary retrieval results. The 783-question test in Figure 5. Retrieval recall under distractors (anonymous link) examines source retrieval under distractors. Joint backbone-fact and source-session guidance raises top-3 recall of annotated dialogue turns from 61.94% to 71.26% at 99% target distractors. The same questions are used across distractor ratios. A separate fact-only test at 90% distractors changes recall by at most 0.005 across reported budgets (Section 5.5 and Appendix B.2). These tests measure retrieval guidance in their respective settings; Table 9 provides the direct observations of initial localization errors and subsequent correction. Evaluation question list (anonymous link).

Reviewer_LnvpOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies memory for long agent interaction histories, where the important details depend on the question being asked. The proposed method, GiDe, works in two stages without training. First, it extracts a reusable set of key facts (the "gist") from the history and repairs gaps using probe questions. Second, for each question, it checks whether these facts are enough, and if not, retrieves a few raw history chunks to recover the missing details. A simple theoretical model explains when this design keeps more useful information than fixed memory or plain retrieval. Experiments on LoCoMo and LongMemEval with GPT-4o-mini and Qwen2.5-14B show better scores than prior memory methods, along with ablations and a cost study.

Critical strengths
  • Simple, sensible design with strong headline numbers. Reusing a source-checked backbone and going back to the raw trajectory only when a gap is found is easy to follow and needs no training. The reported gains are large on the hard categories, for example LoCoMo multi-hop F1 of 62.68 against 40.43 for the best baseline (Table 1) and LongMemEval-S temporal reasoning of 85.8 (Table 2).

  • Ablations point to the right component. Table 3 shows that removing raw-detail recovery costs the most (-6.97 F1, -9.87 accuracy), which supports the paper's main claim that targeted recovery matters.

Critical weaknesses
  • Baselines are copied, not run under matched conditions. All LoCoMo baseline numbers come from Lei et al. (2026) and LongMemEval-S numbers from other papers (Table 1 and 2 captions). GiDe uses its own prompts, a multi-step gate (up to three steps), an optional LLM reranker, a refusal "rescue" retry, and possibly task-memory distillation (A.3, A.8, A.10). Context budgets, retrievers, and judge prompts are not shown to match the baselines. So the large gains may come from the pipeline and evaluation setup, not the two-stage idea. The closest methods named in Section 2.2 (ReadAgent, AnchorMem, MemMA, LazyMem) are not compared at all.

  • Evidence for efficiency and the mechanism is thin. The cost study uses one trajectory (conv-26, 120 questions) with extrapolated curves (Figure 3, A.5). On that panel RAG uses 2,102 tokens per question against 6,546 for GiDe, which weakens the "low token consumption" claim in the abstract. Ablations use 3 of 10 conversations with no variance or seeds. Figure 4 is a synthetic 50-template pilot, and Figure 1B is a small pilot whose correlation is "for the displayed points". No ablation separates the probe-and-repair loop from plain extraction, since "No Stage I" removes both.

  • The theory adds little beyond the design intuition. Section 4 uses independent uniform targets and erasure outcomes. The main results (Eqs. 6-9) follow almost directly from these assumptions. None of the parameters (p, f, a_c, epsilon) are measured on real data, so the analysis cannot check whether the dominance condition holds on LoCoMo or LongMemEval.

Questions for authors
  1. Which options were on in Tables 1 and 2: the reranker, the residual rescue and synthesis retry, and task-memory distillation into M_task (A.10, step 6)? If M_task is kept across questions, can information leak between test questions?
  2. Can you rerun at least Mem0, A-Mem, and a strong RAG baseline, plus one closely related method (e.g., ReadAgent or AnchorMem), with the same reader model, prompts, final context budget, and judge, and report token cost for each?
  3. A.2 says eight probes per conversation per round, while the A.9 prompt asks for five. How many probes and repairs were actually used, and what is the gain from repair alone over extraction alone?
  4. Please report the measured gate statistics (how often SUFFICIENT is wrong, how often raw recovery is triggered and succeeds) to link Section 4 to the experiments.
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Lnvp (1/3)

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive suggestions. Section, table, and figure numbers below refer to the revised manuscript.

[1/3] W1, Q1–Q2. Added comparisons and evaluation settings

Added comparisons and evaluation settings (W1, Q2). We reran Mem0, A-Mem, RAG and the other LoCoMo baselines on the same ten conversations and 1,540 non-adversarial questions, and added ReadAgent and AnchorMem. Each model group shares the answer model and token-level F1 scorer. Baselines retain their own prompts, retrieval, source access and final-context budgets. Table 5 reports quality alongside total GPT-4o-mini construction and answering tokens. All LongMemEval-S baselines were also rerun (Section 5.1, Tables 2–3 and 5, and Appendix B.5).

Results from the rerun comparisons. GiDe reaches 59.81 F1 with GPT-4o-mini and 57.59 with Qwen2.5-14B, compared with 56.17 and 55.90 for the strongest baselines in the respective groups. The 57.59 result uses Qwen for both backbone construction and Stage II; using a GPT-built backbone with Qwen Stage II gives 56.72. On LoCoMo multi-hop questions, GiDe obtains 62.68 versus 40.62 F1 with GPT-4o-mini. The LongMemEval-S reruns give GiDe an overall LLM-judged score of 82.9 versus 79.4 for the strongest baseline, including 85.8 versus 76.7 on temporal reasoning. Full category scores are reported in Tables 2–3 and Appendix B.5 (Table 12) (Section 5.2 and Appendix B.5).

Table 5. LoCoMo quality–cost comparison (revised manuscript, Section 5.4) F1 is reported for GPT-4o-mini and Qwen2.5-14B; tokens include memory construction and answering per question in the GPT-4o-mini setting. Figure 3: quality–cost Pareto frontier.

GroupMethodGPT-4o-mini F1 ↑Qwen2.5-14B F1 ↑GPT-4o-mini Tokens/q ↓
BasicFull Context35.0943.0719,677.2
BasicRAG40.5639.76449.2
MemoryMem047.3348.7634,881.3
MemoryMemOS45.9945.513,192.0
MemoryA-Mem34.4534.8613,824.3
MemoryCompassMem54.9752.6598,290.9
MemoryMemCoT56.1755.9020,535.0
Source lookupReadAgent31.1636.918,873.7
Source lookupAnchorMem48.2339.419,930.2
Source lookupGiDe59.8157.598,382.8

Shared evaluation protocol (revised manuscript, Section 5.1)

ItemShared evaluation setting
LoCoMo dataSame ten conversations and 1,540 non-adversarial questions
Answer modelGPT-4o-mini or Qwen2.5-14B; shared within each comparison group
ScoringSame token-level F1 scorer within each LoCoMo model group
CostMemory construction + answering tokens per question; GPT-4o-mini
Method settingsEach method retains its prompts, retrieval and answer-context construction

Memory use during evaluation (Q1). The factual backbone remains fixed during evaluation. Each question uses this backbone and its own retrieved passages; answers and recovered passages are not stored for later questions. Table 7 lists the active options (Appendix A.3).

Table 7. Main-experiment options (selected settings; revised manuscript, Appendix A.3)

Option named in Q1Main-table setting
RerankerEnabled: reranks retrieved evidence
Residual rescueEnabled: retrieves source evidence when the reader refuses to answer
Synthesis retryEnabled: makes another answer attempt using the available evidence
M_task (cross-question memory)Disabled: no cross-question memory updates

The supplementary code includes an optional Full configuration that enables M_task; the main-table results use the disabled setting above (Appendix A.3 and Table 7).

Comparison with closely related methods. ReadAgent uses page summaries to guide source lookup; AnchorMem expands fact anchors into original contexts and combines them with event summaries. GiDe checks and repairs compact facts before downstream questions are known, then uses the same facts to answer and to form a source query for the remaining gap. MemMA also uses QA repair and gap-directed memory-bank search. GiDe’s source recovery can additionally supply details absent from its compact backbone. Direct comparisons with ReadAgent and AnchorMem evaluate the complete design, while the repair and recovery ablations examine its components (Sections 2 and 5.3; Tables 1–2 and 4).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Lnvp (2/3)

[2/3] W2, Q2, Q3. Efficiency and component contributions

Full-data quality–cost comparison (W2, Q2). The revised cost study covers all ten LoCoMo conversations and 1,540 questions, counting construction once and answering tokens for every question with GPT-4o-mini. GiDe achieves 59.81 F1 at 8,382.8 total tokens per question. Relative to ReadAgent and AnchorMem, F1 increases by 28.65 and 11.58 points while tokens decrease by 5.5% and 15.6%, respectively. RAG uses 449.2 tokens per question at 40.56 F1. RAG, MemOS and GiDe form the Pareto frontier among the ten methods, with GiDe providing the highest answer quality (Sections 5.2 and 5.4, Tables 2–3 and 5, and Figure 3).

Repair beyond initial extraction (W2, Q3). We expanded the ablations to all ten LoCoMo conversations and 1,540 questions. Keeping the extracted backbone but removing QA repair gives 57.20 F1 versus 59.81 for full GiDe, isolating a 2.61-point repair gain. Removing source verification during repair gives 57.10; removing detail recovery gives 50.08; question-only source lookup gives 56.59. All variants disable cross-question memory updates. Table 4 reports online tokens, while Table 5 includes construction and answering. These are full-set point estimates without repeated-run variance (Section 5.3).

Table 4. Ablation results by stage (revised manuscript, Section 5.3)

StageConfigurationAnswer F1 ↑Online tokens/question ↓
FullGiDe59.817,128
Stage I: Backbone constructionNo Stage I54.0619,125
No QA repair57.207,281
No source verification during repair57.107,268
Stage II: Detail recoveryNo gate57.337,223
No detail recovery50.084,863
Unconditional source lookup after backbone search57.6010,489
Question-only source lookup56.596,959

Probe and repair settings (Q3). Each session generates three probes, covering single-session facts, cross-session links and temporal information. Across 272 sessions, 816 probes yield 389 failures used to plan repairs. Each repair batch handles up to eight failed probes; eight is the batch size, not the number of probes generated per session. Accepted memory-edit counts were not retained. Appendices A.2 (Table 6) and A.7 now use the same three-probe protocol and prompt; Table 4 isolates repair’s 2.61-point gain beyond extraction.

Retrieval test on real dialogue (W2). To examine whether backbone context helps find relevant source passages, we evaluate 783 LoCoMo questions with sufficient source material to construct the highest target distractor share (99%). The same question set is used at every distractor level. Each candidate pool retains annotated evidence turns and adds difficult passages from the dialogue history. At a target distractor share of 99% and a budget of three chunks, jointly adding backbone facts and source-session cues raises recall of annotated dialogue turns from 61.94% to 71.26%, a 9.32-point gain. The question-only source-lookup ablation tests the corresponding end-to-end effect: removing backbone and gap context lowers answer F1 by 3.22 points (Sections 5.3 and 5.5, Appendix B.2, Figure 5). Evaluation question list (anonymous link); Figure 5. Retrieval recall under distractors (anonymous link)

Motivation and mechanism (W2). Figure 1 uses a LoCoMo example to illustrate how different questions require different details from the same history. Table 4 measures the contribution of each component, and Figure 5 examines whether backbone context helps retrieve those details from real dialogue (Sections 5.3 and 5.5, Appendix B.2).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Lnvp (3/3)

[3/3] W3, Q4. Theoretical insights and gate behavior

Re-derived theoretical result (W3). To explain when GiDe’s reusable backbone and on-demand detail recovery reduce information cost, we have re-derived Section 4 within the information-theoretic caching framework. This framework separates storing information before requests are known from transmitting the remaining information after a request arrives, matching GiDe’s backbone construction and question-specific source recovery. The revised analysis allows unequal task frequencies and overlapping or correlated evidence, replacing the original uniform-target and erasure-outcome formulation. Let M0M_0 be the reusable backbone, JJ a task class, RJR_J the remaining source evidence for that class, NN the number of requests, and HH Shannon entropy in bits. For an admissible integer request count in the interval derived in Section 4, the theorem gives

CG=H(M0)+NH(RJ∣M0,J)<min⁡(CM∗,CR∗).C_{\mathrm{G}}=H(M_0)+N H(R_J\mid M_0,J)<\min\left(C_{\mathrm{M}}^{\ast},C_{\mathrm{R}}^{\ast}\right).

Here CGC_{\mathrm{G}} is an achievable information cost; CM∗C_{\mathrm{M}}^{\ast} and CR∗C_{\mathrm{R}}^{\ast} are the minimum costs of source-free pure memory and stateless retrieval under the same lossless-evidence requirement (Section 4, Theorem 1 and Appendix C).

Implications for backbone reuse. The average per-task cost is C‾G(N)=H(M0)/N+H(RJ∣M0,J)\overline C_{\mathrm{G}}(N)=H(M_0)/N+H(R_J\mid M_0,J). Reuse reduces the one-time backbone contribution as 1/N1/N, while each task pays for its remaining details. Theorem 1’s lower threshold specifies when reuse offsets prestorage; its upper threshold specifies when repeated supplementation makes full prestorage cheaper. Between them, the backbone avoids repeated delivery of shared information, and on-demand recovery avoids saving every potential task detail in advance. This explains the division between reusable facts and task-specific details. QA repair makes the reused facts more reliable; the repair and recovery ablations test these mechanisms in GiDe (Section 4, Theorem 1 and Corollary 1; Section 5.3).

Reuse and answer quality. Figure 4 shows how repeated use spreads the one-time backbone construction cost across questions. Across ten conversations in the tested order, average API tokens per question first fall below the plotted stateless retrieval configuration after 8–14 questions. The repair and recovery ablations show complementary quality gains: removing either reduces F1 by 2.61 or 9.73 points, respectively. Section 4 explains the corresponding division between reusable information and task-specific details in a lossless information-cost model (Sections 5.3–5.4, Table 4 and Appendix A.5). Figure 4. Backbone reuse and amortized cost (anonymous link)

Answerability and source recovery (Q4). On 385 questions from conv-26/30/41, automatic assessment finds incomplete context in 53 of 240 first-round SUFFICIENT decisions (22.1%); 145/385 receive MISSING (37.7%). Source lookup adds passages for 123/385 questions (31.9%), and 34 of these improve from partial/insufficient to full context (27.6%). These are context-sufficiency measures. The total number of lookup attempts, including empty returns, is unavailable in the current summaries (Appendix B.3 and Table 9).

Table 9. Answerability and source recovery (revised manuscript, Appendix B.3)

Diagnostic (385 questions)Count / denominatorRate
First-round SUFFICIENT with incomplete evidence53 / 24022.1%
First-round MISSING145 / 38537.7%
Questions receiving raw-source passages123 / 38531.9%
Added-source cases changing from partial/insufficient to full34 / 12327.6%

Effect of the sufficiency gate. Removing the gate lowers F1 from 59.81 to 57.33 and increases online tokens from 7,128 to 7,223 per question. Thus, checking whether the available context answers the question improves both answer quality and token efficiency in this comparison (Section 5.3 and Table 4).

Example of detail recovery. Asked when Gina mentioned Shia LaBeouf, the retrieved context does not connect the mention to its date. Source lookup recovers the mention in session 19, dated 23 July 2023, and the final answer matches that date. The automatic context label changes from insufficient to full (Appendix B.3).

Reviewer_NZQrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes GiDe, a training-free, two-stage memory framework for long-term LLM agents. In the first stage, GiDe constructs a reusable memory backbone by extracting key facts and relations from interaction histories and using self-generated questions to identify and repair missing information. In the second stage, it checks whether the stored memory is sufficient for a given query and retrieves missing details from the original history when necessary. The authors also provide an information-theoretic analysis of the two-stage design. Experiments on LoCoMo and LongMemEval-S show improvements over several memory baselines, while an efficiency analysis suggests lower amortized token costs.

Critical strengths

Practical design. The paper proposes a simple and effective two-stage memory framework that separates reusable memory construction from query-specific detail retrieval.

Token efficiency. The method achieves competitive accuracy while substantially reducing token consumption, demonstrating its potential for efficient long-term agent memory.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty. The core idea of maintaining a compact memory backbone and retrieving missing details from the original history is relatively intuitive. The paper does not sufficiently distinguish this approach from existing memory and retrieval methods or establish a clear methodological advance.

  2. Limited baseline comparability. The main experiments reuse baseline results from prior work. Without a unified evaluation of source access, retrieval settings, and computational budgets, it is difficult to assess the significance of the reported improvements.

  3. Limited theoretical insights. The information-theoretic analysis largely formalizes the intuition behind the two-stage design without yielding meaningful new insights or actionable design principles. It remains unclear how the analysis informs the proposed algorithm or predicts when it should outperform alternatives.

Questions for authors

See weakness

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer NZQr (1/3)

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive suggestions. Section, table, and figure numbers below refer to the revised manuscript.

[1/3] W1. Our contribution

GiDe combines construction-time QA repair with task-time, gap-driven source lookup. Before downstream questions are known, it checks and repairs a compact factual backbone against the original history. At task time, those facts support answering and help locate missing attributes or relations. Table 1 distinguishes this combination from related methods; Table 4 reports its component contributions (Sections 3.2–3.3).

Table 1. Comparison with related methods (revised manuscript, Section 2)

Answering workflowMethodMemory representationMemory roleQA-based repairSource lookupSource lookup guidance
Memory-bank answeringA-Mem [1]Raw turns + descriptionsAnswering———
Memory-bank answeringMemMA [2]Depends on memory systemAnswering✓——
Memory-guided source lookupReadAgent [3]Page summariesAnswering + source lookup—✓Question + summaries
Memory-guided source lookupAnchorMem [4]Fact anchorsSource lookup + event-based answering—✓Question + fact anchors
Memory-guided source lookupGiDeCompact factual backboneAnswering + source lookup✓✓Question + backbone clues + remaining gaps

✓: explicitly included; —: not explicit in the main workflow. Source lookup denotes a task-time step beyond memory retrieval; raw text may already be stored in memory entries.

A-Mem and MemMA. A-Mem stores raw turns together with generated descriptions, whereas GiDe separates a compact set of reusable facts from the original history used for supplementation. MemMA already includes QA repair and gap-directed memory-bank search. GiDe additionally uses the retrieved facts and unresolved gaps to query the original trajectory, allowing task-required details outside its compact backbone to be recovered. The no-QA-repair and no-detail-recovery tests examine these complementary roles: F1 decreases by 2.61 and 9.73 points, respectively, when each is removed (Table 1 and Table 4).

ReadAgent. ReadAgent uses page summaries to guide source lookup. GiDe forms a focused subquestion from the question, selected backbone facts and remaining gap. Replacing it with the question alone lowers F1 from 59.81 to 56.59. On 783 real-dialogue questions, joint backbone-fact and source-session guidance raises recall of annotated dialogue turns from 61.94% to 71.26% at 99% target distractors and three retrieved chunks (Sections 5.3 and 5.5, Table 4 and Appendix B.2, Figure 5). Figure 5. Retrieval recall under distractors (anonymous link)

AnchorMem. AnchorMem expands retrieved facts into original contexts and combines them with event summaries for answering. GiDe answers from its repaired factual backbone and retrieves source passages for unresolved details. On LoCoMo, 386 of 1,540 questions are answered without source lookup, with 85.23% model-judged accuracy on that subset (Sections 3.3 and 5.5; Tables 1–2).

Quality and efficiency. Relative to ReadAgent and AnchorMem, GiDe improves F1 by 28.65 and 11.58 points while reducing total tokens per question by 5.5% and 15.6%. Table 4 shows how QA repair, source verification and selective detail recovery contribute to this design (Sections 5.2–5.4, Tables 2–5 and Figure 3).

Table 4. Ablation results by stage (revised manuscript, Section 5.3)

StageVariantLoCoMo F1 ↑ΔF1
FullGiDe59.81—
Stage INo Stage I54.06−5.75
Stage INo QA repair57.20−2.61
Stage INo source check during repair57.10−2.71
Stage IIQuestion-only source lookup56.59−3.22
Stage IINo detail recovery50.08−9.73
Stage IIUnconditional source lookup after backbone search57.60−2.21

Figure 3. Pareto frontier of answer quality and total token cost on LoCoMo (GPT-4o-mini). RAG, MemOS, and GiDe are Pareto-optimal among the ten cost-evaluated methods; GiDe achieves the highest F1.

References: [1] Xu et al. A-Mem. NeurIPS, 2025. [2] Lin et al. MemMA. EMNLP, 2026. [3] Lee et al. ReadAgent. ICML, 2024. [4] Shen et al. AnchorMem. Findings of ACL, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer NZQr (2/3)

[2/3] W2. Baseline comparability

Added comparisons and evaluation settings. We reran the LoCoMo baselines, including ReadAgent and AnchorMem, on the same ten conversations and 1,540 non-adversarial questions. Within each model group, methods share the answer model and token-level F1 scorer. Table 5 compares answer quality and total construction-plus-answering tokens while retaining each method’s native prompts, source access, retrieval and final-context construction. The within-GiDe ablations separately test component contributions under the same evaluation setup (Sections 5.1, 5.3–5.4 and Tables 4–5).

Shared evaluation protocol (revised manuscript, Section 5.1)

ItemEvaluation setting
DataSame ten LoCoMo conversations and 1,540 questions
Answer modelGPT-4o-mini or Qwen2.5-14B, shared within each comparison
ScoringSame token-level F1 scorer
Method settingsEach method’s memory construction, prompts, retrieval, source access, and answer context
Token costConstruction + answering API tokens, divided by 1,540 questions; GPT-4o-mini setting

Results from the rerun comparisons. GiDe scores 59.81 F1 with GPT-4o-mini versus 56.17 for the strongest baseline, and 57.59 with Qwen2.5-14B versus 55.90. The 57.59 result uses Qwen for both backbone construction and Stage II. The table below reports the complete ten-method quality–cost comparison, including the close source-lookup methods. GiDe improves F1 over ReadAgent and AnchorMem while using fewer total tokens, placing it on the Pareto frontier with the highest answer F1. We also reran the LongMemEval-S baselines: GiDe obtains an overall LLM-judged score of 82.9 versus 79.4 for the strongest baseline, with temporal-reasoning scores of 85.8 versus 76.7. Full category scores appear in Tables 2–3 and Appendix B.5 (Table 12); total costs and the Pareto comparison appear in Section 5.4, Table 5 and Figure 3.

Table 5. LoCoMo quality–cost comparison (revised manuscript, Section 5.4)

GroupMethodGPT-4o-mini F1 ↑Qwen2.5-14B F1 ↑GPT-4o-mini Tokens/q ↓
BasicFull Context35.0943.0719,677.2
BasicRAG40.5639.76449.2
MemoryMem047.3348.7634,881.3
MemoryMemOS45.9945.513,192.0
MemoryA-Mem34.4534.8613,824.3
MemoryCompassMem54.9752.6598,290.9
MemoryMemCoT56.1755.9020,535.0
Source lookupReadAgent31.1636.918,873.7
Source lookupAnchorMem48.2339.419,930.2
Source lookupGiDe59.8157.598,382.8
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer NZQr (3/3)

[3/3] W3. Theoretical insights

Re-derived theoretical analysis. We have re-derived Section 4 using a two-stage information-theoretic caching framework to model a fixed backbone reused across requests. It allows unequal task frequencies and overlapping or correlated evidence. Let M0M_0 be the reusable backbone, JJ a task class, RJR_J its remaining source evidence, NN the number of requests, and HH Shannon entropy in bits. By comparing the information needed to deliver the same lossless task evidence, the model identifies a request-count range in which backbone prestorage and on-demand recovery have a joint information-cost advantage (Section 4 and Appendix C).

Main result. For an admissible integer request count in the interval derived in Section 4,

CG=H(M0)+NH(RJ∣M0,J)<min⁡(CM∗,CR∗).C_{\mathrm{G}}=H(M_0)+N H(R_J\mid M_0,J)<\min\left(C_{\mathrm{M}}^{\ast},C_{\mathrm{R}}^{\ast}\right).

Here CGC_{\mathrm{G}} is the achievable information cost of backbone prestorage and on-demand recovery. CM∗C_{\mathrm{M}}^{\ast} and CR∗C_{\mathrm{R}}^{\ast} are the minimum costs of source-free pure memory and stateless retrieval under the same evidence requirement. The lower endpoint specifies when reuse repays backbone prestorage; the upper endpoint specifies when repeated detail recovery makes full prestorage cheaper (Theorem 1).

Insight: useful information determines the payback horizon. The re-derived cost identities also give CR∗−CG=NI(YJ;M0∣J)−H(M0)C_{\mathrm{R}}^{\ast}-C_{\mathrm{G}}=N I(Y_J;M_0\mid J)-H(M_0), where YJY_J is the task evidence required by class JJ and II is mutual information. Each request benefits from the task-relevant information already available in the backbone, while prestorage is paid once. Consequently, backbones with the same storage cost can have different payback horizons depending on how much reusable task information they retain. This provides a concrete criterion for the value of a backbone: useful shared information per stored bit (Theorem 1 and Appendix C.5).

Insight: facts and details have complementary roles. The supplementation term H(RJ∣M0,J)H(R_J\mid M_0,J) measures the detail information still needed once the backbone is known. It motivates retaining reusable facts while recovering task-specific details on demand. The upper threshold identifies when repeated supplementation becomes more costly than prestoring all potential task evidence. GiDe realizes this allocation by answering from repaired facts when sufficient and using known people, events and relations to guide source retrieval when details are missing. The ablations evaluate these mechanisms: removing QA repair, detail recovery, or backbone/gap context from the source query reduces F1 by 2.61, 9.73 or 3.22 points, respectively (Section 5.3 and Table 4).

Observed amortization. Across ten conversations, GiDe’s measured average chat API tokens per question first fall below those of the plotted stateless retrieval configuration after 8–14 questions in the tested order. The backbone construction cost is paid once and shared by subsequent questions that reuse the same facts. These measurements show how reuse offsets construction overhead in this configuration, while the repair and detail-recovery experiments above show the corresponding answer-quality gains (Section 5.4 and Appendix A.5 and Figure 4). Figure 4. Backbone reuse and amortized cost (anonymous link)

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (2/2)

3. What the components contribute

Table 4. Ablation results by stage (revised manuscript, Section 5.3)

StageVariantLoCoMo F1 ↑ΔF1
FullGiDe59.81—
Stage INo Stage I54.06−5.75
Stage INo QA repair57.20−2.61
Stage INo source check during repair57.10−2.71
Stage IIQuestion-only source lookup56.59−3.22
Stage IINo detail recovery50.08−9.73
Stage IIUnconditional source lookup after backbone search57.60−2.21

Backbone repair improves the facts reused across questions: removing QA repair or source verification reduces F1 by 2.61 or 2.71 points. Task-time detail recovery contributes a further capability: removing it reduces F1 by 9.73 points. Question-only source lookup loses 3.22 points, showing the value of backbone context for finding missing details (Section 5.3 and Table 4).

Gap-driven recovery improves F1 from 57.60 to 59.81 and reduces online tokens from 10,489 to 7,128 per question compared with unconditional source lookup. Both variants complete backbone search before source lookup; the unconditional variant then retrieves source passages even when the evidence is judged sufficient. This comparison shows the quality–cost benefit of supplementing details selectively (Table 4).

4. Backbone reuse and cost amortization

Section 4 analyzes the information cost of lossless recovery for NN requests across KK task classes. The backbone is M0M_0; class JJ requires YJ=(EJ,RJ)Y_J=(E_J,R_J), where EJ=fJ(M0)E_J=f_J(M_0) is selected backbone information and RJR_J contains the remaining source details. HH denotes Shannon entropy in bits. The baseline costs are optimal within their stated restrictions, and GiDe’s cost is achievable (Theorem 1 in Section 4 and Appendix C).

Information-cost identities for Theorem 1 (revised manuscript, Section 4 and Appendix C)

SchemeTotal cost (bits)
Pure memoryCM∗=H(Y1,…,YK)C_{\mathrm M}^{*}=H(Y_1,\ldots,Y_K)
Retrieval without reuseCR∗=NH(YJ∣J)C_{\mathrm R}^{*}=NH(Y_J\mid J)
GiDe-style backboneCG=H(M0)+NH(RJ∣M0,J)C_{\mathrm G}=H(M_0)+NH(R_J\mid M_0,J)

For an integer request count in the interval specified in Section 4, CG<min⁡�0�C_{\mathrm G} < \min �0�. The lower threshold marks when reuse repays backbone storage; the upper threshold marks when repeated detail recovery makes full prestorage cheaper (Theorem 1). Corollary 1 gives the corresponding average per-task cost, with the backbone term decreasing as 1/N.

Figure 4 shows how construction cost is shared as more questions reuse the same backbone. Across ten conversations, GiDe’s average chat-model API tokens per question first fall below those of the plotted stateless retrieval configuration after 8–14 questions in the tested order. The curves illustrate the practical benefit of amortizing backbone construction over repeated use (Section 5.4 and Appendix A.5). Figure 4. Backbone reuse and amortized cost (anonymous link)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (1/2)

We thank the reviewers for their constructive feedback. Key additions and substantive revisions are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript. We have strengthened the related-method comparisons, evaluation, component analysis and theory. The responses below summarize the main findings; all section, table and figure numbers refer to the revised manuscript.

GiDe combines a compact factual backbone refined through QA-based repair with gap-driven recovery of details from the original history, enabling the backbone to support direct answering and guide source lookup.

1. Our Contribution

GiDe constructs and repairs the backbone before downstream questions are known. Its facts support both answering and the retrieval of missing details. On LoCoMo, 386 of 1,540 questions are answered without source lookup, with 85.23% model-judged accuracy on that subset. In the 783-question controlled retrieval test, adding backbone facts and source-session cues improves recall of annotated dialogue turns from 61.94% to 71.26% at a target distractor share of 99% and three retrieved chunks. Figure 5. Retrieval recall under distractors (anonymous link) (Sections 3.2–3.3 and 5.5; Table 1 and Appendix B.2, Figure 5).

Table 1. Comparison with related methods (revised manuscript, Section 2)

Answering workflowMethodMemory representationMemory roleQA-based repairSource lookupSource lookup guidance
Memory-bank answeringA-Mem [1]Raw turns + descriptionsAnswering———
Memory-bank answeringMemMA [2]Depends on memory systemAnswering✓——
Memory-guided source lookupReadAgent [3]Page summariesAnswering + source lookup—✓Question + summaries
Memory-guided source lookupAnchorMem [4]Fact anchorsSource lookup + event-based answering—✓Question + fact anchors
Memory-guided source lookupGiDeCompact factual backboneAnswering + source lookup✓✓Question + backbone clues + remaining gaps

✓: included; —: not explicit. QA-based repair: construction-time QA checks and fixes. Source lookup: retrieving original context beyond memory retrieval.

References: [1] Xu et al. A-Mem. NeurIPS, 2025. [2] Lin et al. MemMA. EMNLP, 2026. [3] Lee et al. ReadAgent. ICML, 2024. [4] Shen et al. AnchorMem. Findings of ACL, 2026.

2. Updated comparisons

We reran LoCoMo baselines, including ReadAgent and AnchorMem, on all 1,540 non-adversarial questions across ten conversations. Each model group shares the answer model and token-level F1 scorer while retaining method-specific prompts, retrieval settings, source access and answer context. In the main-table evaluation, GiDe keeps its factual backbone fixed and disables cross-question task-memory storage (Section 5.1 and Tables 2–3).

Tables 2–3 report LoCoMo F1 by question category for GPT-4o-mini and Qwen2.5-14B. Table 5 compares overall F1 and GPT-4o-mini token cost. Overall F1 is weighted by category size; cost includes construction and answering, with construction amortized over all 1,540 questions.

Table 5. LoCoMo quality–cost comparison (revised manuscript, Section 5.4)

GroupMethodGPT-4o-mini F1 ↑Qwen2.5-14B F1 ↑GPT-4o-mini Tokens/q ↓
BasicFull Context35.0943.0719,677.2
BasicRAG40.5639.76449.2
MemoryMem047.3348.7634,881.3
MemoryMemOS45.9945.513,192.0
MemoryA-Mem34.4534.8613,824.3
MemoryCompassMem54.9752.6598,290.9
MemoryMemCoT56.1755.9020,535.0
Source lookupReadAgent31.1636.918,873.7
Source lookupAnchorMem48.2339.419,930.2
Source lookupGiDe59.8157.598,382.8

RAG, MemOS and GiDe form the Pareto frontier among the ten cost-evaluated methods, with GiDe achieving the highest F1. Relative to AnchorMem, GiDe gains 11.58 F1 points while using 15.6% fewer tokens. With Qwen2.5-14B, GiDe scores 57.59 F1 versus 55.90 for the strongest LoCoMo baseline. The LongMemEval-S reruns also give GiDe the highest overall score (82.9 versus 79.4, LLM-judged; GPT-4o-mini setting). The gains are particularly large on LoCoMo multi-hop questions (62.68 versus 40.62 F1 with GPT-4o-mini) and LongMemEval-S temporal reasoning (85.8 versus 76.7) (Sections 5.2 and 5.4, Figure 3 and Appendix B.5, Table 12).

Figure 3. Pareto frontier of answer quality and total token cost on LoCoMo (GPT-4o-mini). RAG, MemOS, and GiDe are Pareto-optimal among the ten cost-evaluated methods; GiDe achieves the highest F1.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.