- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents DuCoMem, a long-term memory framework for LLMs that combines content compression, graph coarsening, and on-demand access to original records. Its main observation is that compression may preserve the content needed to answer a question while removing the details needed to find it. DuCoMem keeps these omitted cues as residual addresses, reduces the memory graph while retaining source mappings, and searches for additional evidence when the initial retrieval is insufficient. Experiments on LoCoMo and LongMemEval-S show improvements over the evaluated baselines across multiple answering models, with comparable reported retrieval token costs.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is clearly written, and the examples make the method easy to follow. The distinction between preserving content and preserving retrievability is useful and well explained. Residual addressing is a straightforward response to this problem, and it fits well with graph coarsening and local source recovery.
-
The experiment is solid. DuCoMem improves over SimpleMem on LoCoMo across all seven answering models and also performs well on LongMemEval-S. The ablations and compression analysis help explain where these gains come from.
Critical weaknesses
-
The comparisons cover several established methods, but a few relevant memory systems are missing, such as EverMemOS, SYNAPSE, and Zep. Adding a comparison would give a fuller picture of how DuCoMem performs against other methods.
-
The ablations could better isolate individual contributions. Removing only residual addressing while keeping the compressed representations fixed, would make the benefits of these components clearer.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors add a comparison with EverMemOS, SYNAPSE, or Zep on a shared benchmark?
-
Could the authors include an ablation that removes only residual addressing?
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment. We summarize our responses below.
W1 / Q1: Comparison with SYNAPSE
Response:
On LoCoMo with GPT-4.1-mini, DuCoMem outperforms SYNAPSE [C1] in all four question categories, improving Macro F1 by 3.98 points (49.72 vs. 45.74) while using about 43.0% fewer tokens per question (502 vs. 880). We evaluated SYNAPSE on LoCoMo using GPT-4.1-mini and the same scoring script as DuCoMem.
Answer quality and token cost. DuCoMem achieves a Macro F1 of 49.72, 3.98 points higher than SYNAPSE's 45.74, with gains across all four categories. The largest gain is on OpenDomain, where F1 rises from 28.85 to 35.63 (+6.78 points), followed by Temporal, where F1 rises from 56.52 to 60.84 (+4.32 points). Together, these two categories account for about 70% of the Macro F1 gain. DuCoMem also improves MultiHop and SingleHop F1 by 2.96 and 1.85 points, respectively. Under the manuscript's token cost metric, DuCoMem uses 502 tokens per question, about 43.0% fewer than SYNAPSE's 880.
Table C1. SYNAPSE and DuCoMem on LoCoMo with GPT-4.1-mini.
[C1] Jiang et al. Synapse: Empowering LLM Agents with Episodic-Semantic Memory via Spreading Activation. Findings of ACL 2026.
W2 / Q2: Ablation of residual addressing alone
Response:
Removing only residual addressing, with the compressed capsules, graph structure, and all other retrieval settings fixed, lowers Macro F1 on LoCoMo from 49.72 to 48.53, with the largest drop on SingleHop (62.11 to 56.52). These questions can often be answered from a single record, which residual cues help locate when the compressed capsule omits a distinctive name, place, or date. With residual addressing enabled, DuCoMem also makes fewer follow-up answering calls (94 vs. 103) and uses slightly fewer online tokens per question (502 vs. 505).
Results by question category. As shown in Table C2, the largest drop was on SingleHop, where F1 fell from 62.11 to 56.52. A single record can suffice to answer these questions. When the compressed capsule omits a distinctive name, place, or date, a residual term can still help retrieve that record. MultiHop and Temporal also declined by 0.72 and 0.39 points, respectively. OpenDomain improved by 1.97 points, showing that the effect varies by question category.
Online token cost. With residual addressing disabled, the number of answering calls after follow-up retrieval increased from 94 to 103. These additional calls help explain why total online LLM input and output tokens increased from 502 to 505 per question.
Table C2. LoCoMo F1 and online query cost with and without residual addressing.