- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work investigates the theoretical connection between uniformly scaling flows (USFs) and deep one-class classification, and claims that maximum-likelihood training of a USF reduces to a one-class objective with implicit volume regularization. The authors further argue that USFs inherently guarantee density-aligned latent representations, and demonstrate improved training stability and competitive detection performance across tabular and image anomaly detection benchmarks.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a clean and step-by-step formal derivation of the equivalence between USF maximum likelihood estimation and the deep one-class objective, which offers a useful reference for understanding the relationship between the two paradigms.
- The empirical evaluation covers both tabular and image modalities, includes clean/contaminated training settings and pixel-/image-level evaluation, and reports extensive ablation studies.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited theoretical novelty, with worst-case constructions that lack real-world relevance. Uniformly scaling flows are not a new concept, dating back to NICE. Constant-Jacobian flows for anomaly detection were already explored by OneFlow. The core claimed theoretical contribution that MLE training of USFs reduces to a one-class distance objective is a straightforward algebraic consequence of the change-of-variables formula under a constant Jacobian. This connection has been implicitly understood in the field and lacks technical depth; formalizing it does not constitute a substantial theoretical advance.
- Unfair baseline comparisons and insufficient SOTA context. The stability advantage of USFs is tested against a weakly optimized non-USF baseline. The paper only applies simple tanh clamping to affine coupling layers, ignoring the large body of established stabilization techniques for normalizing flows. Without thorough hyperparameter tuning for the non-USF side, the conclusion that USFs are more stable is unconvincing. Also, the paper lacks comparison to current state-of-the-art anomaly detection methods.
- The paper claims to unify two central perspectives on anomaly detection, but the connection only holds for the narrow subclass of USFs, which have far weaker expressivity than general normalizing flows. This framing exaggerates the scope of the work; it does not unify the two broader paradigms.
- The repeated claim that density alignment is more valuable than expressivity is not universally supported by the authors' own data. On multiple tabular datasets, USFs underperform non-USFs by large margins. The paper only reports aggregate averages and does not analyze these failure cases, nor does it define boundary conditions for when USFs help or hurt.
- The paper fails to clearly delineate its contribution relative to OneFlow, the most closely related work. OneFlow also uses constant-Jacobian flows for one-class anomaly detection with a minimum-volume objective. The only core difference is that this work uses MLE instead of a custom minimum-volume loss, but the paper never demonstrates that MLE is superior, nor does it provide direct head-to-head comparison with OneFlow.
Questions for authors
Please see Weaknesses
3 comments
W3 (scope of the "unification" claim; USF expressivity)
We agree that "unify" overstates the scope and have replaced it by "connect". As detailed in G3, the MLE objective of a flow is a Deep-SVDD-type objective, i.e., a latent-distance term plus a term independent of , if and only if the flow is a USF. The connection is therefore specific to USFs by necessity, not by choice. We agree that USFs with a Gaussian base are less expressive; learnable radial bases keep the constant Jacobian and lower the held-out NLL below that of the non-USF on 17/20 and 19/20 datasets (now Section 5.1, Table 2b).
W4 (density alignment vs. expressivity; tabular failure cases; boundary conditions)
The paper does not report aggregate averages only. App. C gives per-dataset AUC-ROC for all eight methods in both regimes (Tables 5 and 6); Table 8 reports paired per-dataset effects of the learnable radial base against the Gaussian-base USF and the non-USF, with the number of seeds with a positive effect; App. D gives per-class image results.
We agree that the USF does not win everywhere; on some datasets (e.g., NSL-KDD, clean) it trails the non-USF clearly. We do not claim that alignment always outweighs expressivity. The claim is suite-level: the USF wins on 17/20 (clean) and 14/20 (contaminated) datasets against the non-USF; the clean difference is significant (Wilcoxon ), the contaminated one is not (). Section 5.1 now states this, including the win/loss counts.
On boundary conditions, the theory makes a clear prediction. A USF must realize all density variation by transport under constant volume change. It is therefore at a disadvantage when the nominal data require strongly varying local volume change, e.g., components of very different scale. A controlled experiment in the revised paper confirms this: with anomalies just outside the narrow component of the Gaussian mixture (G2), the USF falls clearly behind the non-USF in high dimension ( vs. AUC-ROC at ), and a learnable radial base does not close the gap (App. F; stated as a limitation in App. H). We will add a per-dataset failure analysis of the tabular results.
W5 (delineation from OneFlow; MLE vs. minimum-volume loss; head-to-head comparison)
A head-to-head comparison is part of the paper. OneFlow and its non-constant-Jacobian variant OneFlow-Gen are baselines in all tabular experiments (Table 1; per dataset in Tables 5 and 6), trained with the same coupling architecture and budget as USF and non-USF (Section 5.1, App. C). The comparison thus isolates the objective: maximum likelihood vs. minimal volume. The USF achieves a higher mean AUC-ROC ( vs. clean; vs. contaminated) and a better mean rank ( vs. ; vs. ). The gap between OneFlow and OneFlow-Gen mirrors that between USF and non-USF (Section 5.1), consistent with the constant Jacobian being the main driver in both families.
Conceptual delineation. The difference is not only the loss. OneFlow learns a minimum-volume hypersphere through a quantile-based criterion: only the points inside the target quantile shape the objective, and the model is not trained as a density estimator. Nothing ties the ordering by latent distance to density outside the sphere, which is where anomalies lie. MLE training of a USF yields on the whole space (Proposition 1(c)), so the alignment holds everywhere, including the tails. Both ingredients are needed: the constant Jacobian (without it, alignment fails, Proposition 1(b)) and the likelihood objective (without it, there is no density to align with). In practice, USFs need no custom objective and can replace affine flows inside existing likelihood-based detectors, as the image experiments show. We do not claim that MLE outperforms OneFlow's criterion; the margins are small. Our claim is equal-or-better performance together with a guarantee and drop-in compatibility.
Thanks for your response. However, I think the main flaw has not been fully addressed in this rebuttal. Therefore, I want to keep the original score.
W1 (theoretical novelty; NICE; OneFlow; worst-case constructions)
We do not claim that USFs are new; the paper introduces them with reference to NICE (Section 2), and we agree that the derivation is short. Our contribution is its consequence: MLE training of a USF is a one-class objective with built-in collapse prevention, and USFs are exactly the flows for which this holds (G3). This yields a density-alignment guarantee that non-USFs and Deep SVDD provably lack (Proposition 1).
Regarding "implicitly understood": the literature reports the empirical advantage of constant-Jacobian flows without explaining it. OneFlow finds its constant-Jacobian variant stronger than the general one; recent tabular evidence highlights likelihood-based detection with USFs (Kim et al., 2026); Behrmann et al. (2021) give stability bounds favouring additive coupling. None of these attribute the advantage to the density alignment of the latent geometry. Moreover, established flow-based detectors (FastFlow, CFlow, U-Flow) all default to affine coupling, suggesting that this connection may not yet be widely reflected and its implication considered in detector design. We would welcome references to prior work that states it explicitly and would be happy to cite them.
Worst-case constructions. We agree that they are not realistic data-generating processes, as the paper says (Remark 1, Limitations). They show that the setups of Deep SVDD and non-USFs provide no guarantee of alignment, not that misalignment is typical. That it arises in benign settings is shown by Fig. 3a and the Gaussian-mixture experiment in G2. OneFlow is addressed under W5.
W2 (non-USF baseline strength; stabilization techniques; SOTA comparison)
We respectfully note that the non-USF is not examined under tanh clamping alone. The paper evaluates several established stabilization techniques:
Tuning. USF, non-USF and OneFlow share one configuration of identical capacity (Section 5.1); the study tests a mechanism under controlled conditions and is not a leaderboard comparison (Limitations). Where tuning matters most for affine flows (clamp, mixing), it was done in favour of the non-USF. In the Gaussian-mixture experiments, both models are selected by the same hyperparameter search; on images, we use the hyperparameters of the original authors for the affine models (G4).
SOTA context. On tabular data, the comparison includes recent detectors, DOHSC (ICLR 2024), DASVDD (TKDE 2024) and URD (NeurIPS 2025), alongside Deep SVDD and OneFlow; the USF attains the best mean AUC-ROC and mean rank in both regimes (Table 1). On images, the experiments test a drop-in substitution; we make no state-of-the-art claim there and will add references to recent diffusion-based and vision–language-based detectors (G4).