- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes WBGFlow, an anomaly detection method for UAV power-line inspection that combines wavelet-based frequency decomposition with grouped, branch-conditioned normalizing flows. The method achieves competitive results on InsPLAD-fault and improves upon DifferNet. Additional ablation studies investigate the individual contributions of grouping, branch conditioning, and score selection to anomaly detection performance.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a relevant practical problem: anomaly detection under varying acquisition conditions.
- The proposed architecture combines existing components in a potentially useful way.
- The method improves upon DifferNet on InsPLAD-fault, and the authors provide component ablations.
Critical weaknesses
Weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. The method primarily combines established techniques, including frequency decomposition and conditional normalizing flows. While such a combination can constitute a valid contribution, the paper does not introduce a substantially new methodological principle. Its contribution therefore rests primarily on the empirical benefits of the proposed combination.
-
Insufficient validation of the central motivation. The paper emphasizes robustness to changes in background, viewpoint, and illumination. However, the experiments do not directly evaluate robustness to these factors. In particular, comparisons against simpler approaches using appropriate data augmentation would help establish whether the proposed architectural complexity is necessary.
-
Limited improvement over stronger existing methods. Although WBGFlow improves upon DifferNet on InsPLAD-fault (94.62% versus 92.46% image-level AUROC), its advantage becomes marginal when compared with stronger existing methods. For example, AttentDifferNet [3] reports 94.34%, while a more recent frequency-based approach [4] reports 94.70%. Furthermore, CLAdapter [5] reports substantially higher performance (98.29%), although it relies on pretrained foundation models and therefore represents a different methodological setting. Similarly, WBGFlow's 95.78% AUROC on MVTec AD is substantially below the approximately 99% achieved by stronger contemporary methods [1], [2]. These comparisons weaken the evidence that the proposed framework provides a meaningful advance over existing approaches.
References
[1] Q. Chen, H. Luo, C. Lv, and Z. Zhang, “A unified anomaly synthesis strategy with gradient ascent for industrial anomaly detection and localization,” in Proc. Eur. Conf. Comput. Vis., vol. 15125, 2024, pp. 37–54.
[2] A. Bauer, S. Nakajima, and K.-R. Müller, “Self-supervised autoencoders for visual anomaly detection,” Mathematics, vol. 12, no. 24, p. 3988, 2024.
[3] A. L. Vieira e Silva, F. Simões, D. Kowerko, T. Schlosser, F. Battisti, and V. Teichrieb, “Attention modules improve image-level anomaly detection for industrial inspection: A DifferNet case study,” in Proc. IEEE/CVF Winter Conf. Appl. Comput. Vis. (WACV), 2024, pp. 8246–8255.
[4] J. Wei, X. Liu, H. Ren, and X. Xu, “Unsupervised anomaly detection via multi-frequency structure and visual sampling,” in Proc. 2nd Int. Conf. Image Process., Multimedia Technol. Mach. Learn. (IPMML), 2025, pp. 245–249.
[5] Q. Li, F. He, H. Chen, X. Ning, K. Wang, and Z. Wang, “Unleashing foundation vision models: Adaptive transfer for diverse data-limited scientific domains,” in Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst. (NeurIPS), vol. 38, 2025.
Questions for authors
Questions for the Authors
-
Rationale behind the architectural choices: The paper describes several architectural choices, including frequency separation, grouped coupling, and shared conditional normalizing flows, but their underlying rationale remains unclear. For example, separating frequency components may improve the interpretability of individual branches, but why should it improve anomaly detection when neural networks can learn to distinguish such features internally? It would be helpful if the authors could clarify why these design choices are expected to be beneficial beyond the empirical results of the ablation studies.
-
Robustness to acquisition conditions: Since robustness to variations in background, viewpoint, and illumination is a central motivation, could the authors provide evidence that WBGFlow is less sensitive to these variations than existing methods?
-
Comparison with state-of-the-art methods: The evaluation would benefit from comparisons with stronger contemporary anomaly detection methods on both InsPLAD-fault and MVTec AD. In particular, how does WBGFlow compare with AttentDifferNet [3], the frequency-based approach [4], and CLAdapter [5] on InsPLAD-fault, as well as GLASS [1] and reconstruction-based approaches [2] on MVTec AD? Please discuss differences in training assumptions where relevant.
7 comments
Response to Reviewer 3 W2
Weakness 2
Thank you for the suggestion. To directly examine how acquisition changes affect detection, we added controlled imaging corruptions and a background evaluation on InsPLAD-fault. We also report the results for random in-plane rotation from Appendix Table B.2.
To address this point, we added a controlled acquisition corruption experiment.
Controlled imaging corruptions and matched training augmentation. For each training configuration, we used the same checkpoint, test split, and scoring rule to evaluate the original and corrupted images. We applied brightness changes, contrast reduction, Gaussian blur, and Gaussian noise to the same test images. To measure how much matched training augmentation can narrow the performance gap, we also evaluated DifferNet trained with that augmentation.
Table 3.1. Comparison with DifferNet trained with matched augmentation
| Test condition | DifferNet | DifferNet + Aug. | WBGFlow | DifferNet drop | WBGFlow drop | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clean | 89.60 | 90.19 | 93.97 | +3.78 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| Brightness change(mean dark/light, severity2) | 86.29 | 88.53 | 92.28 | +3.75 | 3.31 | 1.69 |
| Contrast reduction (0.70) | 83.77 | 87.46 | 92.54 | +5.08 | 5.83 | 1.43 |
| Gaussian blur (radius1.0) | 85.45 | 85.91 | 92.91 | +7.00 | 4.15 | 1.06 |
| Gaussian noise (std0.03) | 58.50 | 58.56 | 64.15 | +5.59 | 31.10 | 29.82 |
| Mean corrupted AUROC | 78.50 | 80.12 | 85.47 | +5.36 | 11.10 | 8.50 |
| Mean AUROC drop (pp) | 11.10 | 10.08 | 8.50 | -1.58 | – | – |
Each condition reports macro-average image-level AUROC (%) across the five equipment categories. DifferNet + Aug. denotes DifferNet trained with matched augmentation. The brightness result averages darkening and brightening at the same severity level. Drop is the difference between a method's AUROC on the original and corrupted images, in percentage points (pp). The mean corrupted AUROC and mean drop weight the four corruption types equally. The difference column subtracts the augmented DifferNet result from the WBGFlow result. Summary values and differences are calculated from the per-condition values shown and then rounded to two decimal places.
Matched training augmentation raises DifferNet's mean AUROC across the four corruptions from 78.50% to 80.12%. WBGFlow achieves higher AUROC than augmented DifferNet on all four corruptions, with a mean of 85.47%. Relative to each model's AUROC on the original images, the mean drop is 8.50 percentage points for WBGFlow and 10.08 for augmented DifferNet. With the augmentation used in this experiment, training augmentation narrows the gap, and WBGFlow retains its detection advantage.
Background changes. We randomly sampled 300 normal and anomalous images from the InsPLAD-fault test set and used manual background annotations to construct the background comparison.
Table 3.2. Detection performance on the InsPLAD-fault background evaluation subset
| Method | Clean AUROC (%) | Dark-background AUROC (%) | AUROC drop (pp) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| DifferNet | 87.71 | 77.60 | 10.11 |
| WBGFlow | 94.16 | 84.98 | 9.18 |
The results use 300 randomly sampled images from the InsPLAD-fault test set, including normal and anomalous samples. Both methods were evaluated on the same images and under the same background conditions. The AUROC drop is the AUROC under the original condition minus the AUROC under the dark-background condition, in percentage points (pp).
As shown in Table 3.2, WBGFlow achieves 84.98% image-level AUROC under dark backgrounds, 7.38 percentage points higher than DifferNet's 77.60%. Relative to their results on the original images, WBGFlow and DifferNet drop by 9.18 and 10.11 percentage points, respectively. WBGFlow maintains a higher detection AUROC with a smaller drop under the tested dark-background condition.
In-plane rotation. Appendix Table B.2 evaluates both methods with fixed checkpoints and matched random rotation sequences. With a single randomly rotated view (T=1), WBGFlow and DifferNet achieve five-category macro-average AUROC of 91.488% and 83.354%, respectively, a difference of 8.134 percentage points. WBGFlow achieves higher macro-average AUROC at all six tested view budgets. This result quantifies detection performance under random in-plane rotation.
We will include these results in the revision and limit our robustness conclusions to the conditions covered by this evaluation.
Response to Reviewer 3 W3
Weakness 3
Thank you for raising this point. We extended WBGFlow's evaluation from two to five independent training seeds. The five runs yield a mean macro-average image-level AUROC of 94.73%, with a sample standard deviation of 0.25 percentage points across seeds.
1. Comparison with AttentDifferNet
AttentDifferNet-SE reports an average AUROC of 94.34% on InsPLAD-fault. WBGFlow's five-seed mean is 94.73%, 0.39 percentage points higher. We also compared model parameter counts. In our implementations based on the paper's architecture descriptions, AttentDifferNet-SE and AttentDifferNet-CBAM contain 174.572M and 174.573M parameters, respectively, compared with 150.427M for WBGFlow. The counts for the two AttentDifferNet variants come from our unofficial implementations of the published architectures. WBGFlow achieves competitive detection performance with a more compact model.
2. Comparison with Multi-Frequency Structure and Visual Sampling
Table I of the Multi-Frequency paper reports a macro-average AUROC of 94.7%. WBGFlow's five-seed mean is 94.73%, which also rounds to 94.7% at the same one-decimal precision. The category results in Table I show that WBGFlow achieves higher AUROC in four of the five equipment categories.
Table 3.3. Category-level comparison with Multi-Frequency on InsPLAD-fault
| Category | Multi-Frequency | WBGFlow |
|---|---|---|
| Glass Insulator | 87.70 | 85.82 |
| Lightning Rod Suspension | 99.30 | 99.57 |
| Upper Shackle | 94.50 | 95.63 |
| Vari-grip | 94.30 | 94.57 |
| Yoke Suspension | 97.60 | 98.06 |
| Macro-average | 94.7 | 94.73 ± 0.25 |
The table reports image-level AUROC (%) on InsPLAD-fault. The Multi-Frequency results come from Table I of the original paper and retain its reported precision. WBGFlow's category-level results are means over five training seeds. The macro-average row reports the mean and sample standard deviation. Bold indicates the higher reported value for the category.
Based on the table, WBGFlow leads by 0.27, 1.13, 0.27, and 0.46 percentage points on Lightning Rod Suspension, Upper Shackle, Vari-grip, and Yoke Suspension, respectively. Multi-Frequency leads by 1.88 percentage points on Glass Insulator. The reported macro-average AUROCs are equal at one-decimal precision, and WBGFlow has higher reported AUROC in four of the five categories. We will report the comparison at that precision in the revision.
3. Comparison with CLAdapter
CLAdapter reports 98.29% AUROC under the InsPLAD-fault supervised fault classification protocol. WBGFlow uses an unsupervised anomaly detection protocol with only normal training samples. CLAdapter's published setup includes 5,108 training images and 6,417 test images, and it uses annotations to adapt the model during training. WBGFlow trains without fault images or their labels. Ranking CLAdapter's 98.29% against WBGFlow's 94.73% would require matched training supervision and evaluation data. We will clarify this protocol difference in the revision.
4. Performance on MVTec AD
WBGFlow achieves 95.78% image-level AUROC on MVTec AD, 0.88 percentage points above the 94.90% reported in the original DifferNet paper. GLASS [1] and Bauer et al.'s Self-Supervised Autoencoders [2] report 99.9% and 99.8%, respectively, both higher than WBGFlow. We will include these published results in the revision and clarify that our primary application is anomaly detection in uncontrolled power-line inspection.
Response to Reviewer 3 W1
Thank you for reviewing our paper and recognizing the importance of anomaly detection in uncontrolled power-line inspection and WBGFlow's improvement over DifferNet. We respond to each point below.
Weakness 1
Thank you for the feedback. We agree that frequency decomposition and conditional normalizing flows are established techniques. This work introduces a mechanism for shared, branch-conditioned density modeling across different frequency observations.
WBGFlow uses Grouped Coupling to preserve distinct feature groups for RAW, LL, and HF, so each branch retains its own latent representation through the invertible transformations. A Branch Identity Embedding in each coupling block identifies the observation to the shared subnetworks, allowing the same parameters to produce branch-specific affine transforms. WBGFlow shares coupling parameters across the three branches for joint density modeling while keeping their feature groups separate. This lets the branches share one flow instead of requiring a separate flow for each frequency.
The existing ablations show what each of these mechanisms contributes. On Upper Shackle in Table 3 of the original manuscript, Grouped Flow raises AUROC from 93.81% to 94.41%. Adding Branch Identity Embedding increases AUROC to 95.22%, and selective RAW+LL scoring raises it to 96.14%.
Using the same counting convention, WBGFlow has 150.427M total parameters, 13.82% fewer than DifferNet's 174.559M. In the expanded 5-seed evaluation on InsPLAD-fault, WBGFlow's macro-average AUROC exceeds DifferNet's by 2.27 percentage points.
WBGFlow improves on DifferNet with fewer parameters. The improvement is associated with how the frequency observations are organized and how their densities are modeled conditionally.