- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an Pixelated electromagnetic structure design framework based on unsupervised representation learning and Bayesian optimization. Firstly, the author uses the engineering geometry prior to generate a large number of unlabeled structural layouts that meet specific geometric constraints without electromagnetic simulation, and uses VAE, AAE and WGAN-encoder to learn the low dimensional potential design space. Then, when the trained generation model is fixed, the latent variable is searched by Bayesian optimization, which is decoded into a specific structure, and the optimization is guided by the full wave electromagnetic simulation results. Finally, the author validates the framework on two design issues: reflectarray and on-chip transformer.
Critical strengths
- This paper presents a set of electromagnetic structure optimization process with practical application value. By using the engineering geometry prior to generate a large number of unlabeled legal layouts, it means that expensive full wave electromagnetic simulation data are not required in the learning phase, and the dependence on the training data with physical response labels is reduced.
- The author evaluates three kinds of representation learning methods on two design tasks, and verifies the effectiveness of the framework.
- The author has made a real reflection array. The measured pattern is consistent with the expected beam direction, which shows the application potential of this method in the design of practical electromagnetic devices.
Critical weaknesses
-
This paper is quite similar to the existing work. The design framework based on unsupervised representation learning and Bayesian optimization has been widely used[1][2][3].
The author believes that their difference lies in the use of geometric processing rather than finding the closest layout in the library[1]. However, geometric processing itself is not a new method. And the author has not proved that direct processing is superior to library matching. Furthermore, geometric processing can also be regarded as a huge implicit Library (projecting the generated shape onto the manifold formed by the legal shape)
[1] Tian Z, Yang Y, Zhou S, et al. High-dimensional Bayesian optimization for metamaterial design. MGE Advances. 2024; 2(4):e79. https://doi.org/10.1002/mgea.79
[2] R. Marzban, H. Abiri, R. Pestourie, and A. Adibi, “ HiLAB: A Hybrid Inverse-Design Framework.” Small Methods 9, no. 11 (2025): e00975. https://doi.org/10.1002/smtd.202500975
[3] Fan, Lei, and Zhongqing Su. "An efficient inverse design framework of manufacturable phononic metaplates via combining generative deep learning and Bayesian latent space exploration." Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 243 (2026): 113677.
-
Lack of in-depth exploration of the framework.
a. lack of simple key optimization baselines
Such as latent space + Random Search, PCA(t-SNE) + BO. These simple baselines can verify whether the latent space is effective and to what extent.b. lack of sufficient analysis of the learned latent design space.
The author did not discuss what kind of latent space is more suitable for downstream tasks, only tested three existing representation learning methods, and did not design new representation learning methods. A feasible example: a representation learning method is designed theoretically rather than experimentally, which is very suitable for Bayesian Optimization rather than other optimization methods (different optimization methods may adapt to different representation learning methods)
Questions for authors
I think it is more suitable for IEEE journals on electromagnetic computing, microwave engineering or antenna design, rather than ICLR conferences with machine learning method innovation as the main evaluation standard.
IEEE Journal on Multiscale and Multiphysics Computational Techniques
IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques
or conference
IEEE AP-S/URSI 2027
EuCAP 2027