- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates a key question in sequential meta-learning-based model editing: to what extent do existing editors owe their performance to edit-signal transformations, such as hypernetworks, rather than to the subsequent parameter update rules? To address this question, the authors disentangle edit-signal transformation from parameter update construction. Through transformation removal, update-direction analysis, editing-location experiments, and ridge-regression ablations, they find that untransformed edit signals remain competitive in the evaluated sequential editing settings, while editing-layer selection and ridge-based updates substantially influence generality and locality.
Motivated by these observations, the authors propose RawEdit, a hypernetwork-free editor that directly uses the raw output gradient, scaled by a learned coefficient, as the desired residual. It constructs a closed-form update that combines current-edit fitting, protection of previously edited directions, and weight-perturbation regularization. Only two scalars are learned per edited layer to control edit strength and regularization.
Experiments cover four language models and two datasets, ZSRE and WikiBigEdit, along with evaluations of general capability preservation, multi-hop generalization, same-subject editing, long-form editing, and superficial editing under attack. The results show that RawEdit achieves strong performance in multiple configurations and remains competitive with more complex editors while using substantially fewer learnable parameters.
Critical strengths
-
The research question is clear and thought-provoking. The paper reexamines whether a core component of existing meta-learning-based editors is necessary. Separating edit-signal transformation from parameter update construction helps identify the contributions of individual design choices, rather than attributing the performance of the entire framework to the hypernetwork. This perspective provides useful guidance for future editor design.
-
The method is simple, with clearly motivated components. RawEdit’s objective explicitly addresses three requirements: fitting the current edit, protecting historical directions, and controlling update magnitude. The resulting design is easy to understand, and learning only two scalars per layer substantially simplifies the trainable editor.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is relatively limited. RawEdit’s methodological contribution primarily lies in simplifying and combining existing update formulations. Ridge-based updates and constraints incorporating editing history already appear in the prior methods discussed in the paper, and RawEdit follows RLEdit’s meta-training strategy. While this simplification has practical value, the methodological advance is relatively incremental. The paper could more clearly articulate the distinctive contribution of direct residual fitting and its combination with history-aware regularization, while distinguishing these methodological contributions from the empirical analysis.
-
The theoretical and mechanistic explanations remain limited. Although the paper provides an optimization objective and a closed-form update, its central conclusions are primarily supported by empirical observations. In particular, it does not systematically explain why learned transformations provide limited benefits in sequential editing but offer clear advantages in independent single-edit settings with MEND-style updates. The authors acknowledge this limitation in the conclusion. Further analysis of the conditions underlying this contrast and its relationship to the update rule would help clarify the scope of the findings and strengthen the paper’s theoretical depth.
Questions for authors
-
Performance gains involve metric trade-offs, and some claims require clearer support. RawEdit does not outperform the baselines across all settings and metrics. For example, in Table 3, on Qwen3-8B with ZSRE, RawEdit achieves ES/GS/LS scores of 80.9/73.3/67.7, compared with 97.8/89.2/54.4 for AlphaEdit. This represents a trade-off between better locality and lower efficacy and generality, rather than an across-the-board improvement. The claim in Section 6.2 that RawEdit consistently achieves the strongest overall editing performance across models and datasets therefore requires an explicit criterion for assessing overall performance, or should be stated more cautiously.
-
Evaluation of large-scale joint editing within a single batch remains limited. Although the paper reports sequential editing results with 20,000 and 17,000 accumulated edits, the main experiments use a fixed batch size of 100. The same-subject editing experiments also use batches of 100 edits. The evaluation does not cover substantially larger single batches, such as jointly applying 1,000 or 10,000 edit requests. Comparing performance and resource requirements across different batch sizes would help establish RawEdit’s scalability to large-scale joint editing.
3 comments
Author Response (2/2)
Q2. Evaluation of large-scale joint editing within a single batch remains limited.
We thank the reviewer for raising this point. We use a batch size of 100 for two reasons. First, this follows the sequential editing protocol adopted by our baselines, including UltraEdit, StableEdit, AlphaEdit, and SPHERE. Second, this setting allows us to examine long-term sequential editing through a sufficiently large number of consecutive model updates. Specifically, the 20k ZSRE edits and 17k WikiBigEdit edits are processed through 200 and 170 sequential updates, respectively. Using substantially larger batches would reduce the number of model updates, thereby providing fewer opportunities to evaluate the accumulation of editing effects over a long editing sequence.
Nevertheless, following the reviewer's suggestion, we investigate the effect of batch size on RawEdit using 10, 20, 100, 500, 1,000, and 10,000 edits per batch. We conduct these experiments across four model-dataset combinations: LLaMA3.1-8B and Qwen3-8B on ZSRE and WikiBigEdit. Furthermore, using LLaMA3.1-8B on WikiBigEdit (17K edits) as an example, we compare RawEdit with AlphaEdit, RLEdit, StableEdit, and UltraEdit under different batch sizes. In this comparison, we report ES, GS, LS, average time per edit (in seconds), and GPU memory consumption (in GB) during inference and training. All experiments are conducted on a single NVIDIA A100 GPU with 80 GB of memory, with all LLMs loaded in bfloat16 precision. The results are reported in Appendix D.2 of the revised submission (page 25).
As shown in Table 14 (page 26) and Figure 10 (page 24), editing performance generally improves with increasing batch size, but can deteriorate when the batch size becomes excessively large. For example, on LLaMA3.1-8B with WikiBigEdit (Table 14), RawEdit achieves its best ES (86.9) at a batch size of 1,000, compared with 80.6 at a batch size of 10. However, further increasing the batch size to 10,000 leads to a substantial drop in ES/GS (65.2/60.0). Similar trends can be observed across other baselines. This behavior can be explained by two competing factors: excessively small batches lead to frequent model updates and potential over-editing [1], whereas excessively large batches increase interference among edits within the same batch, potentially hindering effective editing [2].
To alleviate the latter issue, we apply multiple consecutive updates to each large batch. Specifically, after computing and applying an update using the current batch, we recompute the update on the same batch using the already updated model [3,4], repeating this process for the specified number of updates before proceeding to the next batch. We evaluate 1, 2, and 3 consecutive updates per batch with a batch size of 10,000. The results are reported below.
| Method | Number of Updates | ES | GS | LS | Time Per Edit | GPU Memory (inference) | GPU Memory (training) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RawEdit | 1 | 65.2 | 60.0 | 80.6 | 0.06 | 34 | 34 |
| RawEdit | 2 | 84.4 | 74.5 | 58.9 | 0.12 | 34 | 34 |
| RawEdit | 3 | 78.2 | 70.7 | 52.5 | 0.18 | 34 | 34 |
As shown, applying two updates substantially improves RawEdit's ES/GS from 65.2/60.0 to 84.4/74.5, while reducing LS from 80.6 to 58.9. This demonstrates that multiple updates can help mitigate the editing interference associated with large batches, although they also increase the computational cost.
Regarding resource requirements, meta-editors are faster than subject-based editors (e.g., AlphaEdit) because they directly construct weight updates from first-step gradient signals, whereas subject-based editors require iterative optimization to obtain the desired key-value pairs. Smaller batch sizes generally incur higher time per edit, as the weight update formulation needs to be computed and applied more frequently. Larger batches require more GPU memory because the update formulation involves larger matrices. For the training overhead of meta-editors, we refer to Table 11 (page 22) for a detailed comparison. RLEdit requires substantial memory to train the hypernetwork, while StableEdit maintains statistical information for whitening. Like AlphaEdit, RawEdit maintains historical Gram matrices to preserve previously edited knowledge. Importantly, history-aware regularization (HAR) is a plug-and-play component that can also be incorporated into other baselines, as demonstrated by our experiments in Table 13 (page 25).
[1] Model editing harms general abilities of large language models: Regularization to the rescue, EMNLP 2024.
[2] EAMET: Robust Massive Model Editing via Embedding Alignment Optimization, ICLR 2026.
[3] EMSEdit: Efficient Multi-Step Meta-Learning-based Model Editing, WWW 2026.
[4] Rethinking residual distribution in locate-then-edit model editing, NeurIPS 2025.
Dear Reviewer ZXK3,
We sincerely appreciate your positive assessment of our work and your recognition of its contributions. In particular, we are grateful that you found our investigation into the necessity of learned gradient transformations in sequential model editing thought-provoking, and recognized the value of disentangling edit-signal transformations from parameter update construction. We also appreciate your recognition of RawEdit's simplicity, clearly motivated components, and potential to provide useful guidance for future editor design.
Thank you also for your constructive questions, which have helped us further clarify and improve the paper. As the reviewer-author discussion period is approaching its deadline, for your convenience, we briefly summarize our responses:
-
Methodological contributions (W1): We clarified the distinctions between RawEdit and existing methods, particularly MEMIT/AlphaEdit and MALMEN, highlighting the differences in residual construction, historical regularization, token-wise gradient selection, and the removal of hypernetwork transformations. We refer to our detailed discussion in response to W2&Q2 of reviewer cafY.
-
Theoretical and mechanistic explanations (W2): We further discussed our hypothesis that evolving model states and history-dependent edit signals make non-trivial transformations more challenging to learn during sequential editing. We also provided additional experimental results on EMSEdit, which further support the transformation degeneration phenomenon, and discussed how StableEdit's theoretical analysis may provide a starting point for future investigation.
-
Performance trade-offs (Q1): We acknowledged the trade-off between efficacy, generality, and locality on Qwen3-8B and revised Section 6.2 to clarify that RawEdit achieves the highest overall performance, measured by ES+GS+LS, on three of the four models, while remaining competitive on Qwen3-8B.
-
Large-scale batch editing (Q2): Following your suggestion, we evaluated batch sizes ranging from 10 to 10,000 across four model-dataset combinations. We additionally compared RawEdit with AlphaEdit, RLEdit, StableEdit, and UltraEdit under different batch sizes, investigated multiple consecutive updates for batches of 10,000 edits, and reported the corresponding performance and resource requirements in Appendix D.2.
Given the importance of revealing the degeneration phenomenon of hypernetwork transformations in existing sequential meta-editing and its implications for future research, we hope our findings and the proposed RawEdit can provide useful insights to the community. If our clarifications have addressed your concerns and you also believe that our work can provide useful insights for future research on sequential model editing, we would greatly appreciate it if you would consider giving our work a higher rating.
Thank you again for your time and constructive feedback. We look forward to hearing from you.
Author Response (1/2)
We sincerely thank the reviewers for their valuable and constructive feedback. Our point-by-point responses follow below.
We thank the reviewer for raising this point. We refer the reviewer to our response to W2&Q2 raised by reviewer cafY, where we provide a detailed discussion of the methodological contributions of RawEdit and its distinctions from existing methods.
Reviewer cafY also raises this point. We refer the reviewer to our response to W3&Q3 of cafY for a related discussion. There, we hypothesize that, under sequential editing, continuously evolving model states introduce evolving, history-dependent edit signals, making it more challenging to learn non-trivial transformations. To improve learning stability under sequential editing, recent works have introduced various sequential stabilization techniques, including memory backtracking, lifelong normalization, and whitening [1,2,3,4]. Interestingly, we find that all these methods exhibit the transformation degeneration phenomenon identified in our work. In addition to RLEdit, UltraEdit, and StableEdit evaluated in our paper, we have the following additional results for EMSEdit [4], another sequential meta-editor based on hypernetwork transformations.
As shown, although EMSEdit achieves strong ES and GS performance, comparison with the untransformed baseline in Table 1 shows that directly using raw edit signals remains competitive and can even yield better results. More importantly, EMSEdit exhibits high cosine similarity between transformed and untransformed updates, further reinforcing our finding of transformation degeneration in state-of-the-art sequential meta-editors. These observations, together with RawEdit's superior performance (Table 3, Figure 3), make us reconsider how much we actually gain from hypernetwork transformations in sequential meta-editing.
As the reviewer points out, transformation degeneration is currently only an empirical finding. While it is useful and deserves further attention from the research community, we have not yet theoretically characterized its underlying mechanism. Understanding how stabilization techniques for sequential editing relate to the degeneration of learned transformations therefore remains an open question.
This question is particularly challenging because model states and the resulting edit-signal distributions continuously evolve with the editing history, making the learning dynamics of hypernetworks difficult to characterize. StableEdit provides a theoretical explanation of how lifelong normalization, combined with ridge-regularized regression, promotes stable sequential updates through bounded update norms and asymptotic orthogonality. We believe that this theoretical framework may provide a useful starting point for further investigating the relationship between learning stability and transformation degeneration.
[1] Reinforced Lifelong Editing for Language Models, ICML 2025.
[2] UltraEdit: Training-, Subject-, and Memory-Free Lifelong Editing in Language Models, TMLR 2026.
[3] More Edits, More Stable: Understanding the Lifelong Normalization in Sequential Model Editing, ICML 2026.
[4] EMSEdit: Efficient Multi-Step Meta-Learning-based Model Editing, WWW 2026.
We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. We agree that RawEdit does not outperform AlphaEdit on Qwen3-8B across all metrics, where AlphaEdit achieves higher ES and GS, whereas RawEdit achieves higher LS. This reflects a trade-off among editing efficacy, generality, and locality on Qwen3-8B, rather than an across-the-board improvement.
We have revised the statement in Section 6.2 (page 7) to avoid overstating our results and more accurately characterize RawEdit's performance.
(Line 373)
RawEdit consistently achieves the strongest overall editing performance across models and datasets.Revised:
RawEdit achieves the highest overall editing performance (measured by ES+GS+LS) on three of the four models (GPT2-XL, GPT-J-6B, and LLaMA3.1-8B), and remains competitive on Qwen3-8B.