- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
A RF-neuron-based SNN for efficient time & frequency domain learning of features, primarily from EEG data, also benchmarked on standard neuromorphic datasets. The architecture provides sparser outputs by setting a high, parameterised threshold (for the RF neuron) and using exact Euler discretisation instead of a widely adopted forward discretisation. For spatial filtering, 2D convolutions and pooling operations have been utilised.
Critical strengths
- Interesting threshold scaling reparameterization for sparser outputs.
- A thorough literature review on reset mechanisms to familiarise readers with the literature on RF neurons.
- Clearly state the data preprocessing and architecture hyperparameters for reproducibility and a complete understanding of the experimental results observed.
Critical weaknesses
- Marginal gains over baselines for neuromorphic datasets: The authors argue the importance of exact discretisation over the first-order baselines; however, the results do not agree, as RF methods (Higuchi et. al. 2024) outperform their methods, and the exact method marginally surpasses their method (mainly due to the proposed threshold scaling). Is there any limitation of the introduced method for recurrent tasks?
- The authors proposed SS-EEGNet from the prior method EEGNet. However, the authors failed to isolate the performance benefit of utilising a frequency-based RF method, which they argue is their primary contribution.
Questions for authors
- Why does the method not outperform prior methods (both RF and LIF-based) using the proposed discretisation and threshold strategy?
- Please assess the performance of your method on the long-range arena (LRA) datasets as well, in addition to EEG-specific datasets.
- Similarly, on the EEG tasks, please evaluate the performance of the already available recent SSM-based models too, such as PSpikeSSM, SpikingSSM, SH2RFSSM, etc.
- What is the benefit of a frequency-based feature extractor in RF neurons, and how exactly does it help in emotion recognition? (Shen et al., 2020) (as cited) utilises 4-D frequency-band-based features instead of the 3-D tensors for EEG-based emotion recognition. Can you isolate the performance benefits of such bands and explain how their performance differs from that of RF neurons?
- Maybe run ablations to see whether RF-based learnable frequency methods outperform such curated frequency-based features.
Please Engage in the Author–Reviewer Discussion
Dear Reviewers,
As the author–reviewer discussion period is approaching its deadline (November 18, AoE), I would like to kindly remind you to review the authors' rebuttals and actively engage in the discussion as soon as possible.
Please address any outstanding questions or concerns and update your assessments and ratings if appropriate.
Thank you very much for your time and efforts!
Best regards, Area Chair