- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper embeds a protective signal before image release to help locate subsequent edits. EditInk supports black-box editors, and the experiments demonstrate localization across several editing settings.
Critical strengths
The experiments use actual editor outputs rather than region-composited images, making the evaluation closer to practical use.
Critical weaknesses
Comparisons on unseen API editors are missing. These would give a fuller picture of the method’s generalization.
Questions for authors
- Please evaluate EditInk on more unseen editors, including both local and API editors.
- Do the target masks for GPT/Grok outputs represent the intended semantic edits, or are they derived from before-and-after image differences? Please explain how the masks are constructed and how global appearance changes are handled.
- The paper has some grammatical issues that should be corrected. For example, “thus can supports any black-box editors” is ungrammatical; the sentence about the Face Data source and split in Section 5.1 needs rewriting; and the “Eq. equation” references should be fixed.