- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper considers the problem of estimating partially linear model coefficients within four error budgets for both function class approximation error and statistical error. This paper claims to close the gap between the upper and lower bounds for expected absolute risk. The paper achieves a bound of , where are four error budges
Critical strengths
The paper closes the gap of upper and lower bounds for bounded public classes carefully established by two prior works. The tight lower bound established in this paper could be very interesting.
Critical weaknesses
It seems the paper largely follows the works of Gu et al. 2026 and Gu 2026 (TAME). However, the presentation can be improved such that this paper is more self-contained.
- The partially linear model was not introduced throughout the introduced, nor the association of four budget parameters to the model. This makes the discussion of the contribution hard to read for the general audience.
- Notation and are not defined. We should not assume that the readers are familiar with the notations from prior works.
- Line 43-44: "Since , the two-branch rate is minimax optimal in this experiment", while the paper has not introduced any experiment yet.
Questions for authors
It seems Gu 2026 already achieved matching upper and lower bound. How do you compare your results to theirs?