- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes HyperDetect, a hierarchy-aware deepfake detection framework that models real images, generic fake concepts, and specific forgery types in hyperbolic Lorentz space. It introduces hyperbolic angular contrastive learning to separate different forgery families, a hierarchical entailment loss to preserve parent-child relationships, and a domain dispersion regularizer to prevent different forgery domains from collapsing together. During inference, the model first performs real/fake detection and then further attributes fake samples to specific manipulation types.
Critical strengths
This paper provides a structured way to model relationships among different forgery types instead of treating them as independent flat classes. The combination of hyperbolic representation and hierarchical constraints makes the learned feature space more interpretable and explicitly preserves both shared forgery semantics and differences among specific manipulation types.
Critical weaknesses
-
Compared with conventional deepfake attribution that already distinguishes different manipulation types, what additional benefit is brought by explicitly imposing the proposed hierarchical structure, especially for unseen forgery generalization?
-
There are obvious formatting problems in the current manuscript. Line 304 even begins with “.”, and such an error should not appear in an academic paper. The font sizes of the three tables on Page 7 could also be further unified. The numbering before the descriptions corresponding to Equations (11) and (12) is also not standardized. The obvious misalignment in Tables 5 and 6 should not exist either. I also suggest unifying the reference format. Overall, I strongly suggest that the authors carefully revise it.
-
The paper lacks a Related Work section.
-
The main motivation, “moving beyond flat classification by exploiting hierarchical structures for better deepfake generalization,” has already been widely studied. Prior works have explored coarse-to-fine supervision, hierarchical labeling, hyperbolic representations, and hierarchical routing. Therefore, the current paper mainly repackages an established idea with a specific hyperbolic formulation, and its methodological novelty appears limited.
Questions for authors
The main motivation of this work has already been extensively explored in previous studies, including coarse-to-fine supervision, hierarchical labeling, hierarchy-aware representation learning, and hyperbolic modeling. Therefore, the motivation itself is not novel. Although this paper introduces a specific combination of angular contrastive learning, hierarchical entailment, and domain dispersion in hyperbolic space, it is currently unclear what fundamentally new capability or insight this formulation provides over existing hierarchical deepfake detection approaches.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer saMk (Part 2 of 2: Prior Hyperbolic Comparison, Related Work & Formatting)
Response to Reviewer saMk (Part 2 of 2)
2. Fundamental Methodological Novelty Beyond Prior Hierarchical/Hyperbolic Works
While coarse-to-fine labels and hyperbolic geometry have been explored in general classification and physical Face Anti-Spoofing (FAS, e.g., Hu et al., 2024; Han et al., 2023), directly transferring existing hyperbolic formulations to digital deepfake detection fails both theoretically and empirically, resulting in a 7.1% to 13.3% AUC drop (Appendix Table 14). HyperDetect introduces distinct theoretical solutions and forensic capabilities not present in prior work:
- Solving the Geometric Tension Between Inclusion and Separation (Propositions 1 & 2): Prior hyperbolic methods minimize geodesic distance, pulling diverse forgery subtypes toward the origin (Radial Collapse, Proposition 2) where hyperbolic space degenerates into Euclidean geometry and loses angular resolution. Conversely, enforcing rigid parent cones while separating diverse sub-domains forces child clusters outside the parent boundary (Multi-Domain Cone Escape, Proposition 1). HyperDetect decouples angular similarity () from radial depth and combines it with soft-cone Hierarchical Entailment () and Riemannian Domain Dispersion (), utilizing the exponentially expansive boundary of Lorentz space ().
- Controlled Isolation of Hyperbolic Gain: Equipping an Euclidean model with the exact same hierarchical prompt taxonomy yields only 89.4% average AUC, whereas HyperDetect's Lorentz geometry achieves 92.9% (+3.5% net gain).
- New Forensic Capabilities: Beyond binary detection, our radial-angular geometry enables multi-level forensic explanation retrieval that outperforms SIDA-13B with a 69%–91% human preference win rate (Fig. 8).
3. Addition of a Dedicated Related Work Section & Complete Formatting Revision
We agree that a dedicated Related Work section and careful formatting polish significantly improve the manuscript. In our revised PDF, we have completed all of the following updates:
- Added Section 2 (Related Work): Synthesizing (i) Generalizable Deepfake Detection, (ii) Hierarchical & Language-Guided Forensics, and (iii) Hyperbolic Representation Learning, explicitly contrasting prior distance-based objectives with our angular-radial decoupling.
- Line 304 Typo: Removed the stray leading period
"."and revised the sentence transition. - Table & Equation Consistency: Unified font sizes across Tables 1–3 on Page 7, fixed column alignment in Tables 5 and 6, and standardized equation descriptions/punctuation following Equations (11) and (12).
- Unified Bibliography: Removed duplicate entries (e.g., Liu et al. 2024a/b), completed missing venue citations, and standardized all BibTeX entries to ICLR format.
I thank the authors for their response. After considering it, I have decided to maintain my original score.
Response to Reviewer saMk (Part 1 of 2: Q1 & Novelty)
We thank Reviewer saMk for the candid feedback and for identifying specific formatting and structural issues in our manuscript. Due to OpenReview's character limit, we divide our response into Part 1 (Methodological Novelty) and Part 2 (Related Work & Formatting Revisions).
1. Additional Benefit Over Conventional Deepfake Attribution (Q1)
Conventional deepfake attribution treats manipulation types as flat, mutually exclusive categories (e.g., K-way cross-entropy over Real,DF,F2F,FS,NT). This flat formulation suffers from a fundamental limitation on unseen manipulations: when a novel generator (e.g., SimSwap or e4s) appears at test time, it does not belong to any seen leaf class, causing flat attribution models to either misclassify it as Real or suffer severe confidence drop.
Ours-Flat) versus our hierarchical formulation (Ours-Full), Tree Induced Error (TIE) drops from 0.42 to 0.08, and cross-dataset AUC improves from 90.2% to 92.9% (Table 8).GENERIC-FAKEcone acts as a semantic safety net. Even when an unseen manipulation escapes all Level-2 leaf cones, it still shares high-level ancestral forgery cues and remains captured inside the Level-1GENERIC-FAKEparent cone. We further verified this via an Out-of-Taxonomy experiment: removing all face-swapping prompts from the taxonomy only reduces CDF-v2 AUC slightly from 96.3% to 93.8%, whereas flat attribution models drop sharply.