W1. Fusing spatiotemporal information with the use of GNNs and different neural networks (e.g., CNNs, RNNs, Transformers, etc.) is an interesting avenue for tackling problems where there are signals in multiple axes (space, time, image, text, etc.). Nonetheless, this is not a new idea, nor are the authors able to design a new method/framework where the gains are notable or there is a novel analysis. The pipeline is mostly assembled from existing building blocks, e.g., applying GCNs over distance, correlation, or environmental phenomena graphs, soft prompts computed from a GNN representation as in GraphToken (Perozzi et al., 2024), a prompt organized following Wang et al. (2024), and LoRA fine-tuning (Hu et al., 2022). Works such as Cao et al. (2020), Netto et al. (2022), and Barros et al. (2024) have already been working with such ideas and demonstrated the effectiveness and robustness of such modeling, providing important theoretical and empirical analysis. Spatiotemporal GNN forecasting also has a long history, e.g., Li et al. (2018) and Wu et al. (2019), including for geophysical fields (Lam et al., 2023). But apart from Kipf and Welling (2017), every work discussed in Section 2 appeared in 2024 or later, most of them in 2025 or 2026. It would be worth having discussions on such papers, as well as others that appeared before 2025, in the related work section.
W2. Though the authors claim to achieve better performance compared to the tested baselines, this is hard to verify given that there are no standard deviations, and the results apparentely come from a single seed. That is important, especially given that the results are fairly close when compared with the baselines, and we cannot guarantee any statistical significance. The ablations of Table 3 raise a similar concern, since removing the static knowledge text, which, according to the text in the main body (l.209), is the same text K for every sample and thus carries no sample-specific information, even improves RMSE. This suggests that the differences in Table 3 may be within run-to-run variability. Finally, the controls that would calibrate the gains are missing. The No GNN variant of Table 3, which receives no spatial or environmental information beyond the histories and coordinates of the target cell, already outperforms every baseline except PCFNet in mean RMSE and MAE, so persistence and climatology baselines are needed to show how much of the skill comes from local persistence, as is an LLM-free variant of the same pipeline to show what the LLM adds. LLM-based forecasters discussed in Section 2 are not compared either.
W3. Many details are left out of the paper. For instance, what is the observation/acquisition frequency of the data? What is the time interval between prediction steps? It is also not explained how the sources are aligned in time. Neither a complete prompt nor the text K is shown, and the decoding strategy, the handling of malformed generations, and the training and inference costs are never described. Several constants of the graph construction, as well as the kernel parameters (Eq. (5)), are fixed without justification or sensitivity analysis, and the correlations (Eq. (4)) are estimated from only ten values per node, with the neighbors selected among all ocean nodes, which makes the dynamic graph very sensitive to noise. The notation could also be improved, since Fs and Ftd are used in l.154-155 but only defined in Section 3.3, at,i,j in Eq. (10) is never defined, α is a scalar in l.282 but belongs to R48 in Figure 1, and Figure 1 uses T and M where the text uses L and N, while also using L for the number of Transformer blocks and M for the prompt length. There are also typos, e.g., "esponse" (l.289), "Figure. 1" (l.190), and missing spaces in l.266-267.
Response to Reviewer MiLi
Thank you for finding the motivation clear, the combination of environmental text and spatial information reasonable, and the forecasting results competitive.
W1 / Q3. Separate static and dynamic graphs
The table reports daily results for dual-graph Ours and the static-only model.
On the ten-day means, Ours has RMSE 0.445 versus 0.447 for static-only (0.002, or 0.447%, lower), MAE 0.323 versus 0.339 (0.016, or 4.720%, lower), and R² 0.955 versus 0.946 (0.009 higher).
The dynamic-only and no-graph experiments are in progress; their results will be included in the revised version.
W2 / Q2. The LLM and other regions
We added the same-input non-LLM control E1. The daily results are:
On the reported ten-day means, Ours outperforms E1 on all three metrics: RMSE is lower by 0.240 (35.036%), MAE by 0.238 (42.424%), and R² is higher by 0.074. Ours is also better on each of the ten days for all three metrics.
The East China Sea evaluation is in progress; its results will be included in the revised version.
Q1. Dataset splits and sampling
Each sample combines a forecast origin and an ocean cell. It contains ten historical days and ten target days. The full 20-day window stays within its split.
The training, validation, and test sets contain 212,350, 23,280, and 5,308,285 samples, respectively.
Training and validation use feature-coverage sampling. The features include spatial blocks, coastal/open-ocean location, cyclone influence, temperature, and trends. Each day, a greedy procedure selects cells to cover these feature groups.
The purpose is to reduce training and validation costs. Adjacent cells and overlapping time windows contain similar information, so exhaustive enumeration produces many similar examples. Feature-coverage sampling aims to retain different regions, cyclone conditions, and temperature-change patterns while reducing repeated computation.
Q4. East China Sea evaluation
The East China Sea domain is defined as latitude [28°,32°] and longitude [123.25°,129.25°] at 0.25° resolution, containing 384 ocean cells in total. The time splits are the same as for the South China Sea.
The East China Sea experiment is in progress; results will be included in the revised version.