- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents DisCoMesh, a method for generating artist-created meshes that represents a point cloud shape as a set of semantic parts and generates all parts simultaneously through discrete diffusion denoising with an hourglass architecture. Unlike existing methods, it introduces a Global Interaction Module (GIM) to preserve dependencies between parts. GIM efficiently maintains inter-part consistency using bounding box conditioning, global point cloud conditioning, and sparse inter-part attention over compressed global summaries, similar parts, and adjacent parts.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies limited modeling of inter-part relationships as a limitation of existing part-based generation methods and proposes a sparse attention mechanism to efficiently capture these relationships.
-
The method generates highly detailed artistic meshes and demonstrates strong quantitative performance and fast generation speeds.
-
The paper is clearly written and easy to follow, with informative figures and well-designed experiments. The impressive agent-based editing application further demonstrates its potential for broader use.
Critical weaknesses
Limited Originality
The proposed method largely reads as a well-executed combination of ideas from existing part generation research and artistic mesh generation methods. Specifically:
- The discrete diffusion modeling framework resembles that of TSSR.
- Part-aware self-attention, cross attention, global attention is largely used in part and scene generation work. (PartCrater, MIDI, etc.)
- The hourglass architecture has appeared in Meshtron, FlashMesh, and iFlame.
- The proposed Part-Aware Sparse Self-Attention appears to adapt Native Sparse Contextual Attention in MeshRipple by operating on parts rather than triangles.
Trade-off between efficiency and joint generation
The motivation of this paper is prior part generation methods inadequately model relationships between parts. However, limiting inter-part interactions is a deliberate design choice to reduce the token length and support larger meshes by generating part-by-part. Although PSSA reduces memory usage, the proposed method still appears to require generating all parts jointly, raising questions about its scalability compared with methods that generate parts independently.
Minor weakness
The paper should explicitly acknowledge that its Part-Aware Sparse Self-Attention is inspired by DeepSeek’s Native Sparse Attention and MeshRipple's Native Sparse Contextual Attention.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify how their approach goes beyond a direct integration of existing techniques?
-
What is the maximum number of faces the proposed method can generate, and how does this compare with other methods?
-
How does DiscoMesh address this limitation while retaining the computational benefits of part-based generation?
-
For symmetric parts, such as the left and right arms, does contextual attention capture their relationship when nearest-neighbor attention does not? Providing attention maps illustrating this would help clarify the benefits of contextual attention.
-
How does DiscoMesh handle the boundary parts during both inference and editing?
2 comments
Two main weakness remain insufficiently addressed.
Further Clarification Requested
Thank you for the response and additional results. However, my two main concerns remain insufficiently addressed.
-
Originality. The response restates how PASSA differs from NSA and MeshRipple, through part-level units and bounding-box adjacency, but it does not explain why this is more than an adaptation of existing techniques. What specific technical challenge in joint part-wise generation do existing methods fail to address? Is there evidence that a straightforward integration is insufficient, such as a comparison with NSA’s sliding-window attention applied to parts or with dense cross-part attention?
-
Scalability. Only peak memory is reported for the 43,655-face result. Can DisCoMesh maintain its generation quality and efficiency at the scale of MeshMosaic (100K+ faces), ideally compared on more complex shape? In addition, the multi-pass strategy remains unvalidated. Since joint generation is a core claim, how would parts in different groups interact and remain consistent with each other? If this cannot be validated, it should be clearly stated as a limitation.
Thank you for your review. We apologize for any ambiguity in the original manuscript. We hope our clarification of the method’s originality and our additional experimental results address your concerns.
W1 / Q1. Motivation for joint part generation. We would like to clarify the motivation and novelty of DisCoMesh. As discussed in Appendix G and illustrated in Fig. 20 of the revised manuscript, we observe substantial differences in local topology and geometry across semantic parts, with no clear ordering dependency among them, as also noted by Reviewer S6CP. These observations motivate our part-wise modeling and joint denoising formulation, in which all parts evolve simultaneously and PASSA coordinates their generation through sparse cross-part attention. DisCoMesh achieves the best generation quality among the evaluated methods while maintaining competitive inference speed (Table 1 and Fig. 13 of the revised manuscript).
Distinctions from prior work. PASSA changes both the unit of interaction and the rules for selecting which parts communicate. MeshRipple operates at the triangle level, whereas the content-adaptive route in PASSA uses part-level content to determine which parts interact. This allows a part to attend to another part even when the two are spatially distant. The spatial route introduces a 3D inductive bias by defining neighbors through the adjacency of part bounding boxes, in contrast to NSA’s sliding window over sequence positions. The Hourglass Transformer is a natural choice for our backbone because its hierarchical compression is well suited to modeling mesh sequences. Our contribution lies in how DisCoMesh generates parts simultaneously and coordinates them through content-adaptive and spatially grounded sparse attention. We have clarified these design differences and cited NSA and MeshRipple in Appendix F.4.
W2 / Q2 / Q3. Scalability of joint and multi-pass generation.
Scalability. DisCoMesh scales well when all parts are generated jointly. The largest mesh we generated in a single joint run contained 43,655 faces across 141 parts. Peak GPU memory usage was 43.66 GiB, leaving substantial memory headroom. For comparison, PartDiffuser evaluates on meshes with fewer than 4,000 faces, while MeshMosaic reports generating meshes with over 100K triangles through autoregressive patch generation.
Multi-pass generation. To scale beyond the size of a single joint run, a natural extension is to adopt a grouping strategy inspired by PartPacker [4]. The parts could be partitioned into groups and denoised over multiple passes, with all parts in each group generated jointly. This would limit the number of tokens processed in each pass while retaining parallel denoising within each group, providing a way to target meshes with over 100K faces.
Q4. Attention between symmetric parts. The attention map in Fig. 18 in the revised manuscript shows that the content-adaptive route captures interactions between symmetric parts even when they are not direct spatial neighbors.
Q5. Part boundaries during inference and editing. During training, the inter-part loss uses vertices shared by adjacent parts in the ground-truth mesh to encourage boundary alignment. At inference, corresponding boundary vertices tend to lie close together in the global frame and can be stitched using a rule-based merge.
During editing, we provide the preserved parts to the agent as spatial context and instruct it to generate voxels that connect to those parts at the intended interface. The 3D shape generator uses these voxels to produce a reference shape for the edited part. The agent then calls DisCoMesh to generate its topology from that reference shape. This guides the edited boundary into alignment with the preserved parts while keeping their geometry and topology unchanged, as illustrated in Figs. 5 and 6 of the revised manuscript.
[4] Tang et al. Efficient Part-level 3D Object Generation via Dual Volume Packing. 2025. https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.09980