acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Residual Re-entry Dependence: When Suspended States Are Not Sufficient for Resumption

Abstract

Task interruptions are increasingly common in language-model reasoning, but it remains unclear what information is sufficient for a model to resume a suspended computation. A natural assumption is that once the suspended task state and the next operation are known, the continuation is determined. We test this assumption and find that it can fail: even when the suspended state and continuation operation are held fixed, changing the intervening computation can systematically change the resumed result. We call this remaining influence residual re-entry dependence. To measure it, we construct controlled task-switching experiments that hold the suspended state and continuation operation fixed while varying the intervening computation. In a controlled arithmetic task, inserting an intervening computation reduces state-report accuracy from 100% to 76.67% and continuation accuracy from 100% to 72.85%. The two failures are not the same: in 17.99% of interrupted trials the model reports the suspended state correctly but continues incorrectly, while in 14.17% it reports the state incorrectly but nevertheless continues correctly. In a strict within-example factorial, simply changing the relation between the intervening and resumed operators changes continuation accuracy: exact operator matching yields a +6.08 percentage-point contrast, with the same direction on Llama-3.1-8B (+4.95 pp) but the opposite direction on Qwen2.5-3B (−10.42 pp). Thus, knowing the suspended state alone does not explain how the model resumes. Matched controls rule out two simple explanations: making the intervening numerical state conflict with the suspended state does not consistently worsen continuation, and explicit task-closure cues perform no better than matched filler text. We also find that interruptions broadly change how the resumed computation attends to the suspended-state span, but late-layer activation-patching effects that appear to transfer the state are largely explained by answer identity under same-answer controls. The same pattern appears in a natural reasoning task. On GSM8K, inserting an unrelated factual question changes final-answer accuracy little, whereas inserting another math problem reduces continuation accuracy by 3.2–6.1 percentage points in five of six models; the corresponding state probe degrades in all six. By contrast, in a symbolic permutation task, an apparent interruption effect disappears once operation priming is matched. Together, these results show that the suspended task state is not always a sufficient statistic for resumption: even when the state and next operation are fixed, what the model computes during the interruption can still change what happens after resumption.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
language models, reasoning, task interruption, task switching, reasoning re-entry, residual re-entry dependence, mechanistic interpretability, activation patching

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_1u9WOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how language models resume a task after being interrupted mid-solution by a distractor task. The setup the model sees is:

start to solve task T -> begin distractor task S -> resume solving task T.

A perfect model would manage its context in such a way that the intervening task S would not interfere with T; the resumption not be substantially disturbed by the distractor task.

In practice, over a range of tasks and models, the authors observe that interruption does interfere, as measured both by the model's ability to declaratively recall the interruption T-state, and its ability to carry the task to a successful conclusion. Interestingly, there are sometimes divergences between recall performance and task performance. The authors systemically vary the main and distractor tasks, studying how task structure and content shapes interference.

The tasks include a simple arithemtic task requiring registers, a symbolic state-tracking task, and GSM-8k. The experiments use several Qwen models and Llama-3.1-8B, with most of the main behavioral results coming from models with 3B–14B params.

The authors evaluate several mechanistic hypotheses, for example using activation patching and attention analyses. They cast doubt on several plausible candidates, but don't arrive at a definitive positive explanation.

Critical strengths
  • The general question of how models represent and track states across tasks is an interesting one, with potentially important practical implications.
  • I appreciated the careful control conditions used for most of the experiments.
  • While the mechanistic experiments failed to make a strong positive case for a particular representation scheme, I appreciated the authors' rigor in reporting their negative results.
  • I found the main result -- that models exhibit interruption interference even for very simple tasks -- surprising.
Critical weaknesses

In my opinion, the authors haven't yet made a convincing case for the importance of the task as studied, or the results.

I can imagine at least two versions of the paper that I think would have been very strong:

  • As noted in the introduction, juggling and interleaving tasks is an important part of modern agentic systems in complex and long and complex trajectories. So, I can imagine a valuable paper focused on behavioral analysis at scale, studying frontier-sized models in complicated, realistic tasks.
  • Conversely, I would also love to read a detailed mechanistic study of how models represent symbolic states, and how interference interacts with accessing these states. Even at smaller scales, a satisfying explanation would be compelling and useful.

As it stands, the paper falls between these two poles. The models are too small, and the tasks too toy, to generate lessons directly applicable in practice. And conversely, despite some interesting explorations, the results fall short of a substantially mechanistic account. As it stands, I think this work would fit better at a workshop than the main conference.

Smaller issues:

  • The description of the tasks is much too brief and vague; some concrete examples would help a lot.
  • Many of the figures, and their text labels, would benefit from being larger.
  • Pangram rates the text as 83% AI-generated, though this is consistent with AI use statement.
Questions for authors

No questions

1 comment

Thank you for such a careful and fair review. We appreciate that you read the control conditions closely, that you valued our negative mechanistic results, and that you described two stronger papers so clearly. You're right that the paper sits between them.

  1. The two papers you describe.

We think both directions are worth doing, and we plan to continue with both as follow-up work: (a) a behavioral study at scale, with frontier-size models and realistic agent trajectories, and (b) a deeper mechanistic study of how models store symbolic state and how interruption interferes with reading it back. We can't do either at full scale in this revision, so for now we made this paper's claims narrower and clearer. We also accept that workshop vs. main conference is a fair question.

  1. The submitted version ruled out mechanisms but didn't name one.

We agree, and this was the most important criticism we got. The new wrong-state control gives a positive account at the behavioral level. We keep the interrupted conversation fixed and change only the value we hand back at the resume turn:

  • Restating the correct suspended value: continuation goes from 55.8% to 96.5% (91.98% of baseline errors fixed).
  • Restating a wrong value: continuation drops to 8.8%.
  • In the original setup, 145 of the 213 baseline errors (68.1%) are exactly the supplied value with the next operation applied correctly.

So the arithmetic holds up. After the interruption, the model applies the operation to the wrong value. This says where the failure sits, and it could be proven wrong by a different error pattern. It is a behavioral account, not a mechanism inside the model, and the paper now says so.

  1. The tasks are toy, the models are small.

You're right, and our code-frame transfer is thin. Same-symbol vs. different-symbol across frames gives -7.0 [-12.0, -3.0] pp on Llama-3.1-8B and -5.0 [-9.0, -1.0] pp on Qwen2.5-3B. Five checkpoints sit at ceiling, and one is at the floor because it doesn't keep the output format. We don't claim more than that.

What the controlled tasks do give us is a list of variables to study. The results say interference depends on whether the interruption shares a representational form with the resumed computation, how deep it is, and how far away it is. Real agent runs vary these too. A tool output that overwrites a variable the caller still needs (same register, short distance) is very different from an unrelated file read (different register, long distance). We can't vary these with a known correct answer in a live trace, but we can here. So this work suggests what to measure in agent behavior; it does not measure it yet. This is the first thing we want to do in the larger follow-up.

  1. What the revision adds:
quantityvaluewhat it rules out
continuation loss vs. turn- and length-matched filler (Qwen2.5-7B)29.6 pp [23.7, 35.2]"it's just more context"
filler alone vs. clean0.0 ppsame
value shown but not computed vs. computed11.3 pp vs. 29.6 ppseeing a value is not the same as computing it
restating the correct suspended valuerepairs 84-100% of failuresthe arithmetic is intact
restating a wrong valuecontinuation 0-8.8%the model uses whatever value it is given
report correct, continuation wrong17.99%a state probe is not sufficient
report wrong, continuation correct14.17%and it is not necessary either

The last two rows are why we keep two probes and don't report a single "resumption" number.

  1. Smaller issues.
  • Task descriptions: we added a concrete worked example for each task in the main text. [CHECK]
  • Figures: Figure 1 is redrawn as a vector graphic with larger labels, and we are enlarging Figures 2-4 too.
  • AI-generated text: we don't dispute the measurement, and the AI-use statement in the paper accurately described how we used the tools. We are rewriting the prose; some before/after examples are in our reply to Reviewer rNkG.
Reviewer_DJBwOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates what information is required to correctly resume a task after a model’s execution has been interrupted. It finds that, in principle, the outcome of resuming a task can be determined if the state at the time of interruption and the subsequent intended action are known; however, in the actual operation of an LLM, the resulting outcome may not necessarily be deterministic. This is a important discovery for coding agent development.

Critical strengths

This paper raises a well-motivated problem that matters for agentic evaluation. The paper asks whether a model that has the correct suspended state and the next operation can resume a computation correctly, regardless of what it computed during an interruption. This question is directly relevant to how frontier models are now evaluated. Agentic benchmarks such as Terminal-Bench, and SWE-style settings like those used to train and evaluate DeepSWE, require a model to suspend a line of reasoning, process intervening content (tool outputs, logs, unrelated files, side tasks), and then resume the original computation. I think it is useful for frontier LLM labs' researcher to improve their coding agent models foundamentally.

The controlled paradigm can be scaled into training data. RegisterOps and the interrupted-GSM8K protocol are generated programmatically with known ground-truth states and answers. They can also vary the relation between the intervening and resumed computation in a fine-grained way. Although the paper is an analysis paper and does not propose a training method, this design gives a clear template for scalable synthetic data: interrupted code-execution traces, or interrupted reasoning traces with controlled interference, with verifiable targets. I expect the findings to motivate follow-up work on synthetic code and reasoning data aimed at robust re-entry. This is a meaningful downstream contribution beyond the analysis itself.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The models evaluated may not be representative of current training paradigms, and the composition of the training data serves as an uncontrolled confounding factor. All experiments utilized open-source models from 2024, along with one 2025 model, Qwen3-4B—all of which are chatbots. However, contemporary models have placed a significantly greater emphasis on code-related data and agentic interaction trajectories; in other words, they are "code agent" models. Such data inherently encompasses the structures investigated in this paper: interleaved computations, variable reassignments, nested calls, and "suspend/resume" patterns—such as call stacks, callback functions, and tool-call round trips. This composition of training data may alter how a model resumes a suspended computation. Consequently, the phenomenon of "residual re-entry dependence" observed in the paper might be specific to chatbot-style models and may not necessarily apply to agent-based models.

  2. Figure 1 is a low-quality bitmap (raster image) containing noticeable errors; it should be redrawn as a vector graphic. Although Figure 1 illustrates the core concept of the paper, it is embedded as a low-resolution JPEG (1024×424 pixels, approximately 190 ppi) rather than a vector graphic. Upon enlargement, the text and symbols become blurry, and artifacts from JPEG compression are clearly visible. Furthermore, the figure exhibits issues not typically found in professionally prepared diagrams:

The figure caption ("Figure 1: Re-entry evaluation from a shared resumed history…") is embedded directly within the bitmap image rather than being typeset via LaTeX. As a result, this text cannot be searched or selected, and its typographic style is inconsistent with the rest of the paper. The figure contains spelling errors, such as "Distibuted" and the redundant phrase "the same same duration." The notation is inconsistent: in some instances, subscripts are rendered as plain text (e.g., "S_A" in "What is S_A?" or "Pause State S_A"), whereas in other places, they appear in standard, properly typeset subscript format. These flaws tend to diminish the clarity of the paper’s core conceptual framework. I strongly recommend that the authors redraw Figure 1, convert it into a vector graphic, and simplify it.

Questions for authors

please refer to weakness section

1 comment

Thanks for the review. You're right that we didn't define the experiments clearly enough, and that we hadn't studied the interruption systematically. We fixed both in the revision.

Setup (now at the start of Section 2): the model works on Task A until it has a number S_A. We then interrupt with Task B. Then we ask it to resume Task A with its next operation O_A. The correct answer is S_A with O_A applied. We score two things on the same conversation: "report" (what was S_A?) and "continuation" (what is the final answer?). Every effect below is compared against a filler turn with the same number of turns and the same length as Task B.

  1. Which properties of the interruption matter?

We built a new set of controlled runs: 9 checkpoints, 228,944 paired cases, zero API errors. The old protocol replays to within 3 points (report 73.5% vs 76.7% published, continuation 70.2% vs 72.9%). We changed one property of Task B at a time and kept S_A and O_A fixed. Change in continuation accuracy (pp, 95% CI):

what we changed in Task BQwen2.5-7BQwen3-8BQwen3-14B
same operator family, 1 step-40.2 [-49.0, -31.7]-10.4 [-14.6, -6.3]-7.5 [-12.1, -3.5]
same family, 3 steps-47.9 [-57.9, -36.7]-15.0 [-21.7, -8.8]-2.6 [-5.1, -0.6]
different family (x2, units digit)-4.2 [-8.3, +0.4]-2.9 [-7.1, +0.8]-1.3 [-3.3, +0.8]
one extra filler turn before resuming-9.2 [-17.5, -1.9]-7.5 [-10.4, -4.6]-4.8 [-10.2, -0.8]

Main finding: if Task B uses a different kind of operation, the effect goes away (every interval includes zero). Format works the same way. When Task B builds a list instead of an integer, Qwen2.5-7B goes from -32.7 [-41.9, -24.0] to -1.9 [-8.1, +4.2]. So what matters is whether the interruption looks like the computation we need to resume, not whether there was an interruption at all. More steps hurt more on two models but not on Qwen3-14B, so we don't claim a general depth effect.

  1. How does this interact with the suspended state?

We changed one sentence at the resume turn. If we restate the correct S_A, 84-100% of baseline errors are fixed (six checkpoints). If we restate a wrong value, continuation drops to 0-8.8%. In the original setup, 145 of 213 baseline errors (68.1%) are exactly "some value, with O_A applied correctly". So the arithmetic is fine. After a similar interruption, the model applies it to the wrong number.

  1. What other experiments could answer this better?

We added four: (i) a filler matched in turns and length, to separate "more text" from "computed text"; (ii) an arm where the value is shown but not computed, which costs 11.3 pp vs 29.6 pp when the model has to compute it; (iii) a wrong-state control, because without it we can't tell "restating helps" from "any number anchors"; (iv) all four arms repeated on four post-2024 checkpoints.

  1. What do we mean by "dissociate", and why measure the two probes separately?

Both probes read the same conversation, but they can disagree on the same trial. In 17.99% of trials the model reports S_A correctly but continues wrong. In 14.17% it reports S_A wrong but still continues correctly. The overall accuracies (76.67% vs 72.85%) look only 3.8 pp apart, but 32.2% of individual trials disagree 5. The writing.

You're right, and we rewrote it. The sentence you quoted is now: "The assumption that fails is that the paused state and the next operation are enough to determine the answer. We don't claim the model forgets the value; it applies the operation correctly to whatever value it has. But if we keep both fixed and only change the interruption, the answer still changes." We rewrote the discussion in the same plain style and defined all notation at first use. We also redrew Figure 1 (see our reply to Reviewer DJBw).

  1. A correction to our own result.

While re-checking, we found a scoring problem in our main factorial contrast. The "exact match" cells are the cells where O_B = O_A, so a model that just copies the interrupting operator gets scored correct there automatically. On Qwen2.5-7B, 85 of 1200 unmatched cells (7.08%) give exactly S_A + O_B. A model with no operator sensitivity at all but that copy rate would already show +7.08 pp, and we observe +6.08 pp. So we no longer present this contrast as evidence of residual dependence. We report both versions: +6.08 pp as scored, and -1.00 pp (CI [-4.92, +2.92]) when copying is credited in both groups. The two replication models barely have this overlap (0.0% and 0.2%), so their results stand. We also fixed two other numbers; details are in our reply to Reviewer DJBw.

We also ran an error-type analysis (revised Section 5). Three of four error patterns occur more often than chance (state rewrite 2.4x, operator substitution 1.9x, value capture 1.7x, all p <= .002 on Qwen2.5-7B). Register misbinding does not (1.2x, p = .21). We present these as descriptions, not as separate causes, because restating S_A repairs all of them equally.

Reviewer_rNkGOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies what happens when a primary task is interrupted by a secondary tass: is the LLM able to resume and solve the primary task? The author find that this depends on the secondary task, and they try to determine properties that allow to understand how the distraction interferes.

Critical strengths

A control study of reasoning re-entry is provided that allows to identify and quantify residual re-entry dependence. The role of the distraction is studied experimentally.

Critical weaknesses

The experiments are not defined precisely enough to allow for a full critical insight. The paper is not written clearly enough. many sentences appear to be AI produced, for example the first sentence of the too brief discussion: "The central result is a failure of sufficiency, not a claim that models forget a scalar register:" - sufficiency of what? models forget? scalar register? I lack a much more systematic investigation of the interruption, in order to better understand what features matter. This is not easy, but clearly central.

Questions for authors

What are the properties of the interruption that matter? And how do these properties interact with the suspended state and the resumed tasking? What alternative experiments could answer this question better? What do you mean in your conclusion "the state report and the continuation dissociate on synthetic and natural tasks alike, so the two probes should be measured separately" - for what purpose? What do you mean by dissociate?

1 comment

Thanks for the review. You're right that the experiments weren't defined clearly and that we hadn't studied the interruption systematically. We fixed both. Quick setup so everything below is clear: the model computes Task A until it has a number S_A, then we interrupt with Task B, then ask it to resume Task A with its next operation O_A. The right answer is S_A with O_A applied. We score two things on the same conversation: "report" (what was S_A?) and "continuation" (what is the final answer?). Every effect below is measured against a filler turn with the same number of turns and the same length as Task B.

Q1. Which properties of the interruption matter?

We built a new set of controlled runs (9 checkpoints, 228,944 paired cases, zero API errors; the old protocol replays to within 3 points). We changed one property of the interruption at a time and kept S_A and O_A fixed. Change in continuation accuracy (pp, 95% CI):

what we changed in Task BQwen2.5-7BQwen3-8BQwen3-14B
same operator family, 1 step-40.2 [-49.0, -31.7]-10.4 [-14.6, -6.3]-7.5 [-12.1, -3.5]
same family, 3 steps-47.9 [-57.9, -36.7]-15.0 [-21.7, -8.8]-2.6 [-5.1, -0.6]
different family (x2, units digit)-4.2 [-8.3, +0.4]-2.9 [-7.1, +0.8]-1.3 [-3.3, +0.8]
one extra filler turn before resuming-9.2 [-17.5, -1.9]-7.5 [-10.4, -4.6]-4.8 [-10.2, -0.8]

The big finding: if Task B uses a different kind of operation, the effect basically goes away (all intervals include zero). Same for format: when Task B builds a list instead of an integer, Qwen2.5-7B goes from -32.7 [-41.9, -24.0] to -1.9 [-8.1, +4.2]. So what matters is whether the interruption looks like the computation you need to resume, not whether there was an interruption at all. More steps hurt more on two of the models but not on Qwen3-14B, so we don't claim a general depth effect.

Q2. How does this interact with the suspended state?

We changed one sentence at the resume turn. If we restate the correct S_A, 84-100% of the baseline errors get fixed (six checkpoints). If we restate a wrong value, continuation drops to 0-8.8%. Also, in the original setup, 145 of 213 baseline errors (68.1%) are exactly "the value the model had in mind, with O_A applied correctly". So the model does the arithmetic fine; after a similar interruption it just applies it to the wrong number.

Q3. What other experiments could answer this better?

We added four: (i) a filler matched in turns and length, to separate "more text" from "computed text"; (ii) an arm where the value is shown but not computed: it costs 11.3 pp vs 29.6 pp when the model has to compute it; (iii) a wrong-state control, because without it you can't tell "restating helps" from "any number anchors"; (iv) all four arms repeated on four post-2024 checkpoints.

Q4. What do we mean by "dissociate", and why measure the two probes separately?

Both probes read the same conversation but can disagree on the same trial. In 17.99% of trials the model reports S_A correctly but continues wrong. In 14.17% it reports S_A wrong but still continues correctly. The overall accuracies (76.67% vs 72.85%) look only 3.8 pp apart, but 32.2% of individual trials disagree, and those errors mostly cancel in the average. So a state probe alone would overstate resumption for some cases and understate it for others. That's why we report both. The definition is now in Section 1 where the term first appears.

Q5. The writing.

Fair criticism, including the sentence you quoted. We replaced it with: "The assumption that fails is that the paused state and the next operation are enough to determine the answer. We don't claim the model forgets the value; it applies the operation correctly to whatever value it has. But if we keep both fixed and only change the interruption, the answer still changes." We rewrote the discussion in the same plain style, defined notation at first use, and redrew Figure 1 as vector TikZ with larger labels.

A correction to our own result.

While re-auditing we found a problem with our main factorial contrast. The "exact match" cells are the ones where O_B = O_A, so a model that just copies the interrupting operator gets scored correct there automatically. On Qwen2.5-7B, 85 of 1200 unmatched cells (7.08%) give exactly S_A + O_B. A model with zero operator sensitivity but that copy rate would already show +7.08 pp, and we observe +6.08 pp. So we no longer present this as evidence of residual dependence. We report both versions: +6.08 pp as scored, and -1.00 pp (CI [-4.92, +2.92]) when copying is credited in both groups. The two replication models barely have this overlap (0.0% and 0.2%), so their results stand. We also fixed three other numbers; details are in our reply to Reviewer DJBw.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.