acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Beyond Recoverability: Understanding Failures in Intermediate Reasoning

Abstract

Intermediate representations are widely used to support reasoning in large language and multimodal models, yet they are typically evaluated by final-answer accuracy, which provides little insight into why a representation succeeds or fails. We introduce PADC, a diagnostic framework for localizing failures along the representation-to-answer pathway by separating Preservation, Access, Downstream Dependence, and Correct Computation. The framework is designed to distinguish whether failure arises because task-relevant information is not retained in the representation, cannot be reliably recovered by the model, fails to control downstream prediction, or is available and influential but still not transformed according to the task rule. Across controlled synthetic tasks and six natural-domain benchmarks, matched interventions reveal distinct signatures at these interfaces. Removing task-relevant structure produces strongly heterogeneous effects across tasks, indicating that relevance alone does not determine downstream necessity. In controlled relational reasoning, local task state can be recovered perfectly while composition over that state remains unreliable, separating state access from successful downstream integration. Most notably, held-out donor-state interchange induces systematic prediction shifts beyond matched sham interventions, yet the model rarely remains correct under both original and counterfactual states, showing that causal sensitivity to a recovered state is not sufficient for task-correct computation. The same qualitative separation persists across additional model families. Our results suggest that intermediate-representation quality should not be reduced to final accuracy, information retention, or recoverability alone; a useful reasoning representation must expose task-relevant state in a form that not only affects prediction, but supports the computation required to produce the correct answer.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Intermediate Reasoning Representations, State Recoverability, Downstream Dependence, Counterfactual Intervention, Reasoning Diagnostics, Multimodal Reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_3K78OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper defines PADC, a conceptual framework for determining the correctness of reasoning traces beyond just final answer accuracy. PADC identifies potential failure points at different stages of processing: Preservation (P) tests whether task-relevant information is present in the external representations of the problem’s state; Access (A) tests whether the model can accurately read out the state; Downstream dependence (D) tests whether the recovered state exerts a causal effect on model behavior; Correct computation tests whether models display correct counterfactual behavior (based on manipulations of the recovered state). The authors then perform experiments based on each of the four PADC dimensions. They show that the same reasoning trajectory rendered as image or text can produce different results; they then show that erasing task-relevant information has variable effects across tasks. Finally, they show that models can read out task states without being able to compose them, and that task-relevant information can have a selective causal effect on model answers without necessarily supporting correct counterfactual behavior.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework provides a useful taxonomy of the failure points in model reasoning: “is the problem’s state represented at all,” “can the model access it,” “do model answers depend causally on the accessed state,” and “does the model correctly perform computations over it” are an intuitive progression of questions that other researchers could adopt.

  2. The authors generally take care in their experimental design (which is especially evident in the Appendix). Each experiment is thoroughly explained and attempts to isolate a single PADC property; they also perform cross-model replications and try a variety of tasks. The inclusion of visual CoT alongside textual CoT is interesting, and the difference in performance between the two (despite controlling for the information presented) indicates that access is an important factor in model success.

Critical weaknesses
  1. While the framework itself is clear and could make for a strong contribution, the properties are mostly treated as independent throughout the experiments, when they actually depend on each other. For example, downstream dependence is only meaningful if the model can access the state; access only really makes sense when the information is preserved. Each property is tested on different items, tasks, and sometimes different models; no task instance is traced through all four stages, meaning that failures at a given stage can’t really be separated from failures at the upstream stages. Furthermore, because each property is tested using behavioral readouts, there is some degree of circularity; for example, how can preservation be accurately measured using model readouts if access and downstream dependence have not been established?

  2. It isn’t clear that the experiments actually isolate the properties they purport to test. Preservation seems to be defined as a property of the reasoning trace artifact rather than a property of the model. Since the traces are not actually generated by the model, it seems that Preservation holds by construction. Furthermore, Preservation is measured by how much the model relies on the erased information (correct me if I’m wrong); this just seems like another form of Downstream dependence to me rather than a measure of whether task-relevant information survives in the trace. The Access experiments don’t necessarily measure actual model access; directly asking models to read out the state doesn’t necessarily tell us if the model can access that state while solving a task (since it’s an entirely different context, and models could read out the state without actually representing it during intermediate reasoning).

Questions for authors

Clarification requests:

  1. Can the authors clarify how Preservation differs from Downstream dependence? They seem to be testing very similar ideas in the experiments.
  2. Can the authors clarify their choice to ablate externally generated CoT / VoT to test for preservation, as opposed to probing for information in the model’s internal states while it solves tasks? I initially got the impression that Preservation would be about testing whether relevant information is present at all throughout the reasoning process. It’s a bit unclear to me how using the model to read ablated traces actually tests that idea.

Suggestions for future work:

  1. Can the authors provide a diagnosis using the full PADC framework on a single set of test items (i.e., with each stage conditioned on the success of the prior stage)? For example, the authors observe that VoT underperforms on BFS; could PADC be applied there to explain why?
4 comments

Thank you for your valuable and constructive comments. We reply to your concerns as follows:

W1.While the framework itself is clear and could make for a strong contribution, the properties are mostly treated as independent throughout the experiments, when they actually depend on each other. For example, downstream dependence is only meaningful if the model can access the state; access only really makes sense when the information is preserved. Each property is tested on different items, tasks, and sometimes different models; no task instance is traced through all four stages, meaning that failures at a given stage can’t really be separated from failures at the upstream stages. Furthermore, because each property is tested using behavioral readouts, there is some degree of circularity; for example, how can preservation be accurately measured using model readouts if access and downstream dependence have not been established?

S1.Can the authors provide a diagnosis using the full PADC framework on a single set of test items (i.e., with each stage conditioned on the success of the prior stage)? For example, the authors observe that VoT underperforms on BFS; could PADC be applied there to explain why?

We added a repair comparison experiment on 167 BFS instances. We compared single-stage repair strategies with repairs selected based on PADC diagnoses. The results are shown below:

MethodCorrectAccuracy
Original VoT53/16731.74%
P-only repair56/16733.53%
A-only repair67/16740.12%
D-only repair21/16712.57%
C-only repair80/16747.90%
PADC-guided repair selection87/16752.10%

PADC-guided repair increased the number of correct answers from 53 to 87. Accuracy improved by 20.36%. C-only repair was the best single-stage repair. PADC-guided repair produced 7 more correct answers, with an accuracy gain of 4.19%. These results support selecting repair stages based on diagnostic results. D-only repair performed worse than the original VoT. This shows that repairing a fixed stage does not always improve performance.

We also tracked the pass counts during sequential diagnosis and repair. Only instances that passed the previous stage, either before or after repair, proceeded to the next stage. The results are shown below:

StageInstances EnteringPassed Before RepairPassed After RepairConditional Pass Rate After Repair
P167157167100.00%
A167155633.53%
D56324580.36%
C45253475.56%

Access was the main bottleneck under the current checks and repairs. After P repair, all 167 instances passed the Preservation check. However, only 15 passed the Access check before A repair. A repair increased this number to 56. Even after A repair, 111 instances still failed the check. Next, 56 instances entered D, and 45 passed after repair. These 45 instances then entered C, and 34 passed after repair.

Note: C follows the paired-state correctness criterion used in the paper. An instance must be answered correctly under both the original state and its corresponding counterfactual state to pass this check. Only 45 instances reached C because of the earlier checks. Of these, 34 passed the paired-state correctness check after repair. The other 11 had an incorrect answer in at least one state.

This does not mean that only 34 of all 167 instances were ultimately answered correctly. The first table reports single-state task accuracy across all 167 instances. PADC-guided repair yielded correct answers for 87 of them. The two measures cover different sets of instances and use different correctness criteria.

An instance may produce a correct answer on the original task but fail an earlier check. Such an instance does not proceed to C. An instance may also reach C and answer the original task correctly but fail on the counterfactual state. It would not pass the C check.

W2. It isn’t clear that the experiments actually isolate the properties they purport to test. Preservation seems to be defined as a property of the reasoning trace artifact rather than a property of the model. Since the traces are not actually generated by the model, it seems that Preservation holds by construction. Furthermore, Preservation is measured by how much the model relies on the erased information (correct me if I’m wrong); this just seems like another form of Downstream dependence to me rather than a measure of whether task-relevant information survives in the trace. The Access experiments don’t necessarily measure actual model access; directly asking models to read out the state doesn’t necessarily tell us if the model can access that state while solving a task (since it’s an entirely different context, and models could read out the state without actually representing it during intermediate reasoning).

Q1. Can the authors clarify how Preservation differs from Downstream dependence? They seem to be testing very similar ideas in the experiments.

The definition of P and its experimental procedure need to be explained at two separate levels:

  • Representation-level Preservation refers to whether the information and structure required by the task are retained in the external representation. For example, in BFS, we can check whether nodes, edges, and adjacency relations are fully preserved by comparing them with the task state. This is a property of the representation itself. It does not depend on the model's answer behavior.

  • Behavioral Consequence refers to the actual impact of this information on downstream predictions. We separately remove task-relevant and task-irrelevant structures. We then compare the changes in the model's support for the correct answer. If removing relevant structures causes a larger decrease, it indicates that these structures have an actual effect on the model's predictions.

The two are connected through the task-relevant structures being examined. The representation-level check determines whether the information is preserved. The erasure experiment measures the behavioral change after removing this information. Therefore, "independent of answer behavior" describes the representation-level definition of P, while relevant/irrelevant erasure provides behavioral evidence. Whether the information is fully preserved must be determined by comparing the representation with the task state.

D further examines whether the model can adjust its answer when the task state changes. After confirming that the information is preserved and passes the A check, we change the task state to another valid state. We then examine whether the answer probability changes in the expected direction and exceeds a predefined threshold.

For example, in BFS, the erasure experiment examines whether removing a critical edge reduces the support for the original correct answer. D examines whether changing the graph shifts the answer distribution toward the correct answer for the new state. These two measurements focus on different aspects: the effect of removing structures and the model's directional response to changes in the task state.

Q2. Can the authors clarify their choice to ablate externally generated CoT / VoT to test for preservation, as opposed to probing for information in the model’s internal states while it solves tasks? I initially got the impression that Preservation would be about testing whether relevant information is present at all throughout the reasoning process. It’s a bit unclear to me how using the model to read ablated traces actually tests that idea.

PADC studies the model–representation interface. It focuses on how task states are preserved in representations and how models read and use these states. Its main contribution is a diagnostic framework that connects four dimensions: information preservation, access, predictive dependence, and computational correctness. These stages examine different properties of the interface. The internal neural computation process of the model is beyond the direct scope of this work.

We use externally constructed CoT/VoT to keep the reasoning content fixed. The same canonical trajectory is encoded in two formats. We then apply targeted erasure interventions to specific relations and use matched control interventions. Preservation focuses on task-relevant information in the external representation. Under the intact condition, information preservation is guaranteed by construction. The erasure experiments measure how relevant structures affect model predictions. This setup allows us to compare different representation formats and the effects of their interventions. Freely generated model trajectories may also differ in correctness, completeness, and generation paths. These issues require separate investigation.

The differences between PADC and related work are summarized below:

Related ResearchMain Research QuestionHow PADC Differs
Causal Abstraction / Interchange Intervention(Lanham et al.,2023; Paul et al.,2024)Do variables in a representation have a causal effect on model outputs?PADC checks information preservation and access before intervening on task states. It also examines computational correctness.
Amnesic Probing (Tutek et al., 2025)How does model performance change after specific information is removed?PADC measures information preservation, state recovery, and predictive dependence separately. It distinguishes the effects of information removal from evidence of state recoverability.
Control Tasks (Jia et al., 2026)Do probing results come from the target information or other cues?PADC uses matched control conditions at each stage to test the validity of its diagnostic results.
CoT Faithfulness / Unfaithfulness (Wu et al., 2024; Hu et al., 2024)Does the reasoning trace faithfully reflect the basis of the model's answer?PADC separately examines state recovery, predictive dependence, and computational correctness. It also establishes a conditional diagnostic order.

This diagnostic order also defines what each measurement means. A checks whether the model can recover the state from the prompt. After a sample passes A, D checks whether the model's prediction changes in the expected direction when the task state changes. C then checks whether the answers are correct under both the original and counterfactual states.

For example, a model may correctly read the adjacency relations in BFS but still give the original answer after a critical edge is changed. In this case, predictive dependence needs further examination. Alternatively, the model may change its answer but still produce an incorrect result. In this case, computational correctness needs further examination.

  1. Lanham, T., et al. (2023). Measuring Faithfulness in Chain-of-Thought Reasoning. arXiv:2307.13702.
  2. Paul, D., West, R., Bosselut, A., & Faltings, B. (2024). Making Reasoning Matter: Measuring and Improving Faithfulness of Chain-of-Thought Reasoning. Findings of EMNLP 2024, 15012–15032.
  3. Tutek, M., Hashemi Chaleshtori, F., Marasović, A., & Belinkov, Y. (2025). Measuring Chain of Thought Faithfulness by Unlearning Reasoning Steps. EMNLP 2025, 9935–9960.
  4. Jia, J., Benton, J., & Easley, E. (2026). Faithfulness as Information Flow: Evaluating and Training Faithful Chain-of-Thought Reasoning. arXiv:2605.24286.
  5. Wu, W., Mao, S., Zhang, Y., Xia, Y., Dong, L., Cui, L., & Wei, F. (2024). Mind’s Eye of LLMs: Visualization-of-Thought Elicits Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. NeurIPS, 37.
  6. Hu, Y., Shi, W., Fu, X., Roth, D., Ostendorf, M., Zettlemoyer, L., Smith, N. A., & Krishna, R. (2024). Visual Sketchpad: Sketching as a Visual Chain of Thought for Multimodal Language Models. NeurIPS, 37.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on Our Revised Manuscript

Dear Reviewer 3K78,

As the discussion period draws to a close, we would appreciate any feedback you may have on our responses. It would be helpful to know whether our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your concerns, or whether any questions remain.

We understand that your time is limited and would be grateful for even a brief update. We would be happy to provide any further clarification.

Thank you again for your time and constructive feedback.

Best regards, The Authors

Reviewer_VNHiOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper argues that final-answer accuracy cannot explain why an intermediate reasoning representation succeeds or fails. It proposes PADC, which decomposes the representation-to-answer pathway into four externally testable properties: Preservation (is task-relevant state retained), Access (can the model recover it without the answer), Downstream Dependence (does changing the recovered state shift predictions beyond a matched sham), and Correct Computation (is the model correct under both original and counterfactual states). The motivation is that textual CoT and visual representations derived from the same trajectory yield large, task-dependent accuracy differences. Using Qwen2.5-VL-7B, with replication on InternVL3.5-8B and Qwen3-VL-8B, the authors report three main findings. Erasure effects vary widely across domains. Perfect local readout coexists with order-sensitive relational composition. Donor-state interchange produces small but significant excess shifts over sham, while both-state correctness remains around 7%. They interpret the last finding as evidence that causal sensitivity to a state does not imply correct computation over it.

Critical strengths
  • Final-answer accuracy is a poor basis for comparing intermediate-representation formats, and an operational, externally testable decomposition of the representation-to-answer pathway is a useful framing. The relation-order experiment (Table 5) is clean and informative: local target-edge readout is 100% under both orders, yet path judgment drops by ~10.5 pp under permutation. This cleanly separates local state access from relational integration.
  • The interchange design uses a matched sham with equal signed edit magnitude, solver-recomputed counterfactual answers, option-rotation averaging, a disjoint held-out cohort, and bootstrap intervals throughout. The appendix also candidly documents post-hoc analyses, the extension of the donor study after an initial result, evaluator limitations, and preregistered predictions that failed (Table 17). This level of disclosure is commendable and makes the work easier to assess.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The central D/C dissociation is largely explained by weak Downstream Dependence, not by incorrect computation.
    • Because the counterfactual is answer-changing by construction, the model can be correct under both states only if its prediction changes. Both-state correctness is therefore upper-bounded by the prediction-flip rate. With excess TV of only ~0.03, predictions rarely move, so low both-state correctness is expected even if the model computes correctly whenever it does respond. Clearing margins of 0.01/0.02 establishes statistical significance, not that the state controls prediction. The observed rate (0.075) is also well below the independence baseline implied by the marginal accuracies, which is consistent with answer persistence.
    • The appendix reinforces rather than resolves this concern. Both-state correctness rises together with dependence strength, both in the subgroup passing all reading probes (App. I.2: TV 0.129, both-state 0.151) and across models (Table 18). Answers are also largely insensitive to state content: character-reversing the state lowers accuracy by only ~1.6 pp (Table 13), and accuracy stays near 0.47 in seven of eight factorial arms (Table 16).
    • Moreover, Access is verified by a separate reader call, while field reading during answering is only 0.60–0.80 (App. I.2). Errors attributed to computation may therefore reflect in-pass access failures. The authors acknowledge this caveat in the appendix, but it is absent from the main-text conclusions. As a result, the evidence does not separate “the state does not control prediction” from “the state controls prediction but is computed incorrectly,” which is the paper’s claimed contribution.
  2. The framework is neither shown to localize failures nor shown to be actionable, and the motivating evidence is confounded.
    • The four stages are tested on different cohorts, tasks, and modalities, and no instance set is traced through all of them. Dependence and Computation are evaluated only on text states, which disconnects them from the multimodal motivation. The diagnostic validation identifies only 13.3% of post-recovery failures (Table 9).
    • The CoT–VoT gaps in Table 3 that motivate the paper are never explained in PADC terms, and they appear confounded by evaluation artifacts. With the complete oracle state, BFS and Insertion Sort accuracy is still 0.000 (Table 19), whereas candidate-array scoring of the same payload yields 144/167 and 166/167 (Table 11). Binary Search labels do not match the question (App. A.3), and no corrected comparison is reported.
    • Most importantly, the paper never shows a case where a PADC diagnosis leads to a stage-targeted fix that improves performance, so the value of the decomposition remains asserted rather than demonstrated. Its conceptual novelty is also unclear without positioning against interchange intervention and causal abstraction (Geiger et al.), amnesic probing (Elazar et al., 2021), control tasks (Hewitt & Liang, 2019), and CoT unfaithfulness (Turpin et al., 2023).
Questions for authors
  • What justifies the 0.01/0.02 dependence margins? What effect size would you consider evidence that the state controls prediction?
  • Can you verify Access within the answer-stage forward pass itself, not via a separate reader call? How many “post-recovery” errors remain once answer-stage field reading is correct?
  • Please report Table 3 with the semantic rescoring from App. C.2 and corrected Binary Search questions. Do the format-reversal conclusions still hold?
  • Can you trace a single instance set, including VoT inputs, through all four stages? For example, which stage accounts for the BFS and Binary Search CoT–VoT gaps? Can you show that a stage-targeted fix chosen by this diagnosis improves performance?
8 comments

Thank you for your valuable comments. We reply to your concerns as follows:

W1(1).The central D/C dissociation is largely explained by weak Downstream Dependence, not by incorrect computation. Because the counterfactual is answer-changing by construction, the model can be correct under both states only if its prediction changes. Both-state correctness is therefore upper-bounded by the prediction-flip rate. With excess TV of only ~0.03, predictions rarely move, so low both-state correctness is expected even if the model computes correctly whenever it does respond. Clearing margins of 0.01/0.02 establishes statistical significance, not that the state controls prediction. The observed rate (0.075) is also well below the independence baseline implied by the marginal accuracies, which is consistent with answer persistence.

W1(2).The appendix reinforces rather than resolves this concern. Both-state correctness rises together with dependence strength, both in the subgroup passing all reading probes (App. I.2: TV 0.129, both-state 0.151) and across models (Table 18). Answers are also largely insensitive to state content: character-reversing the state lowers accuracy by only ~1.6 pp (Table 13), and accuracy stays near 0.47 in seven of eight factorial arms (Table 16).

  • We appreciate the reviewer's analysis. However, small changes in probability distributions, low joint accuracy across two states, and similar overall accuracy before and after interventions do not directly demonstrate that the model consistently preserves its original answer, nor do they rule out the possibility that the model responds to state changes but still makes computational errors. An excess TV of approximately 0.03 does not imply that prediction flips are rare. It measures changes in the probability distribution relative to a control condition, whereas prediction flipping depends on the probability margin between candidate answers. Even a small distributional change can alter the highest-probability answer. Therefore, inferring the prediction-flip rate directly from excess TV and then using it to explain low accuracy lacks the necessary intermediate evidence. Similarly, the claim that "once the model responds, it can compute correctly" requires evidence from accuracy conditional on prediction flips.
  • The simultaneous increase in dependence strength and joint accuracy across the appendix experiments does not establish insufficient dependence as the sole cause of errors. Dependence may facilitate correct answering, but this does not mean that dependence is sufficient to guarantee correctness. Likewise, the approximately 1.6-percentage-point accuracy decrease caused by character reversal, together with similar overall accuracy across multiple experimental conditions, does not imply that predictions remain unchanged at the individual-sample level: transitions from correct to incorrect and from incorrect to correct may cancel each other out in aggregate statistics.
  • The product of marginal accuracies represents the expected joint accuracy only under the assumption that correctness under the two states is independent. Paired counterfactual experiments do not guarantee this assumption. Therefore, joint accuracy below this product is merely compatible with answer persistence, rather than conclusive evidence for this mechanism. Furthermore, exceeding the 0.01/0.02 effect-size thresholds does not, by itself, establish statistical significance.

Therefore, answer persistence should be treated as a competing explanation that requires further investigation, rather than a conclusion already established by these results. Distinguishing between the two explanations requires jointly examining prediction flips and correctness after flipping. This further motivates the need to evaluate D (whether the model responds to state changes) and C (whether its response is correct) separately.

W1(3). Moreover, Access is verified by a separate reader call, while field reading during answering is only 0.60–0.80 (App. I.2). Errors attributed to computation may therefore reflect in-pass access failures. The authors acknowledge this caveat in the appendix, but it is absent from the main-text conclusions. As a result, the evidence does not separate “the state does not control prediction” from “the state controls prediction but is computed incorrectly,” which is the paper’s claimed contribution.

Insufficient reading at the answer stage affects how we interpret the sources of errors. However, it does not prevent us from separately testing state dependence and answer correctness. We need to distinguish two questions:

  • Does changing the task state affect the prediction?
  • Does this change lead to a correct answer?

We test the first question through state interventions with matched controls. We test the second by comparing the model's answer with the correct answer determined by the task rules.

We added the following experiments and analyses of prediction behavior:

ExperimentEvaluation SamplesExperimental Procedure
State Recovery Confirmation1,221 graphs with accurately recovered states and valid counterfactualsWe modify task-relevant states so that the correct answer changes. We then evaluate predictions under both the original and counterfactual states.
Independent State Substitution845 sample pairs constructed from a separate set of 3,000 graphs. Both samples in each pair pass the accurate state recovery check.We replace one task-relevant relation while keeping the question, answer options, and other state information fixed. We also use matched sham interventions that do not change the correct answer.

In the independent state substitution experiment, the excess total variation (TV) was 0.0296. The excess directional response toward the new correct answer was 0.0661. Both values exceed the predefined thresholds. This shows that changes in task states affect model predictions. The answer-stage reading performance of approximately 0.60–0.80 does not eliminate this intervention effect.

We further examined the relationship between prediction changes and answer correctness. We divided the results into three categories. Prediction flip means that the model's most probable semantic answer differs between the original and counterfactual states. Both-state correctness means that the model answers correctly under both states. Since the counterfactual changes the correct answer, both-state correctness necessarily requires a prediction flip.

Prediction BehaviorState Recovery ConfirmationIndependent State Substitution
No prediction flip87.98%90.18%
Prediction flip, but at least one state is incorrect4.55%3.05%
Prediction flip, with both states answered correctly7.47%6.78%

We follow the aggregation procedure used in the original experiments. For the state recovery confirmation experiment, we first average the results across different edits and answer-option rotations within each graph. We then average across graphs. For the independent state substitution experiment, we first average the results across answer-option rotations within each sample pair. We then average across sample pairs.

We calculate the proportion of errors among prediction-flip cases. We use the weighted evaluation mass of all prediction-flip cases as the denominator. We use the weighted evaluation mass of cases with at least one incorrect answer as the numerator. The resulting proportions are 37.82% and 31.02% in the two experiments, respectively.

These errors occur even when the model has already changed its prediction. Therefore, unchanged answers cannot explain all the errors.

These results support our main conclusion: A change in task state can affect the prediction, but this does not guarantee correct answers under both states.

W2(1). The framework is neither shown to localize failures nor shown to be actionable, and the motivating evidence is confounded. The four stages are tested on different cohorts, tasks, and modalities, and no instance set is traced through all of them. Dependence and Computation are evaluated only on text states, which disconnects them from the multimodal motivation. The diagnostic validation identifies only 13.3% of post-recovery failures (Table 9).

W2(3). Most importantly, the paper never shows a case where a PADC diagnosis leads to a stage-targeted fix that improves performance, so the value of the decomposition remains asserted rather than demonstrated. Its conceptual novelty is also unclear without positioning against interchange intervention and causal abstraction (Geiger et al.), amnesic probing (Elazar et al., 2021), control tasks (Hewitt & Liang, 2019), and CoT unfaithfulness (Turpin et al., 2023).

Q4. Can you trace a single instance set, including VoT inputs, through all four stages? For example, which stage accounts for the BFS and Binary Search CoT–VoT gaps? Can you show that a stage-targeted fix chosen by this diagnosis improves performance?

  • We conducted additional stage-wise diagnosis and repair experiments on the same 167 BFS instances under both CoT and VoT inputs. Each downstream stage was evaluated only when the corresponding upstream check was passed, either initially or after repair. The results are presented below:
StageCoT: Entered → Passed Before Repair → Passed After RepairVoT: Entered → Passed Before Repair → Passed After Repair
P167 → 157 → 167167 → 157 → 167
A167 → 3 → 69167 → 15 → 56
D69 → 44 → 5556 → 32 → 45
C55 → 45 → 4945 → 25 → 34

These results show that the conditional pass rates after repair at the A stage are 41.32% for CoT and 33.53% for VoT. The corresponding rates at the D stage are largely comparable (79.71% vs. 80.36%), whereas the rates at the C stage are 89.09% and 75.56%, respectively. Thus, under the current diagnostic pipeline, the differences are concentrated in the access and computation checks rather than the downstream dependency check.

Diagnosis-guided repair also improves final task performance:

Input FormatNo RepairBest Single-Stage RepairPADC-guided Selective Repair
CoT71.26%73.65% (P)75.45%
VoT31.74%47.90% (C)52.10%

PADC-guided selective repair improves CoT and VoT accuracy by 4.19% and 20.36%, respectively. It also narrows the CoT–VoT performance gap in this experiment from 39.52% to 23.35%, supporting the practical value of diagnosis-guided repair.

We report the four-stage joint pass rate and final answer accuracy separately to avoid conflating correct task answers with passing all diagnostic checks.

W2(2). The CoT–VoT gaps in Table 3 that motivate the paper are never explained in PADC terms, and they appear confounded by evaluation artifacts. With the complete oracle state, BFS and Insertion Sort accuracy is still 0.000 (Table 19), whereas candidate-array scoring of the same payload yields 144/167 and 166/167 (Table 11). Binary Search labels do not match the question (App. A.3), and no corrected comparison is reported.

Q3. Please report Table 3 with the semantic rescoring from App. C.2 and corrected Binary Search questions. Do the format-reversal conclusions still hold?

  • We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. Following the semantic rescoring procedure described in Appendix C.2 and correcting the binary search issue, we recalculated the results in Table 3. The updated results are presented below:
TaskSamplesText CoTNative VoTRepaired VoTRepaired Extracted State
ProofWriter60056.1765.5034.6733.00
ProntoQA30030.6713.333.6778.33
Insertion Sort1670.0052.690.0095.21
Binary Search (Corrected)16780.2496.4179.0455.69
BFS16771.2631.740.00100.00

Compared with Text CoT, Native VoT achieves improvements of 9.33%, 52.69%, and 16.17% on ProofWriter, Insertion Sort, and Binary Search, respectively. However, it performs worse on ProntoQA and BFS, with decreases of 17.34% and 39.52%, respectively.

Therefore, even after adopting semantic scoring and correcting the binary search issue, the relative advantages of the two representation formats still reverse across tasks. These updated results further support our original conclusion that the effectiveness of a representation format is task-dependent.

Reviewer_n3KWOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a diagnostic framework PADC for localizing failures in intermediate reasoning, including: Preservation, Access, Downstream Dependence, and Correct Computation.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation is reasonable, and experimental results prove the necessity of proposing four diagnostic metrics for better failure localization.
  2. Experimental results further indicate that there is no strong correlation between the four diagnostic metrics, which is an interesting insight.
Critical weaknesses
  1. My major concern is that the current version does not compare with existing methods for reasoning failure diagnosis, which limits the framework's contribution. Comparisons with relevant baselines are necessary to show its advantages over existing approaches.
  2. While the paper investigates the performance of four individual metrics (P, A, D, and C), the paper does not provide enough evidence of the overall framework's effectiveness. Please add an experiment to show whether combining four diagnostic dimensions leads to more accurate at least.
  3. The framework identifies only 13.3% of post-recovery failures (Table 9), which is significantly lower than others. A more detailed analysis of this failure and its potential impact for the whole PADC framework should be added.
Questions for authors

N/A

2 comments

Thank you for your valuable comments. We reply to your concerns as follows:

W1. My major concern is that the current version does not compare with existing methods for reasoning failure diagnosis, which limits the framework's contribution. Comparisons with relevant baselines are necessary to show its advantages over existing approaches.

  • We added comparisons with LLM-as-a-Judge (Zheng et al., 2023) and Step-wise Verification (Miao et al., 2024) on the BFS VoT task to evaluate task performance after repairs guided by different diagnostic methods. All methods were evaluated on the same set of 167 BFS samples using the same model, Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct. The results are shown below:
Experimental SettingVoT Accuracy
Baseline31.74%
LLM-as-a-Judge44.31%
Step-wise Verification49.10%
P/A/D/C (Ours)52.10%

The accuracy achieved after repair guided by P/A/D/C reaches 52.10%, representing an improvement of 20.36% over the baseline, 7.79% over LLM-as-a-Judge, and 3.00% over Step-wise Verification. These results provide further evidence of P/A/D/C's effectiveness in guiding repairs through systematic reasoning failure diagnosis.

W2. While the paper investigates the performance of four individual metrics (P, A, D, and C), the paper does not provide enough evidence of the overall framework's effectiveness. Please add an experiment to show whether combining four diagnostic dimensions leads to more accurate at least.

  • We conducted additional experiments on the BFS dataset to evaluate the four P/A/D/C dimensions separately. We report task accuracy under both VoT and CoT settings. We compared six conditions: no repair, repair using only P, A, D, or C, and PADC-guided repair. The results are shown below:
Repair StrategyVoT AccuracyCoT Accuracy
Baseline31.74%71.26%
P-only Repair33.53%73.65%
A-only Repair40.12%70.06%
D-only Repair12.57%3.59%
C-only Repair47.90%67.66%
PADC-guided Repair52.10%75.45%

PADC-guided repair achieves the highest accuracy in both settings. Under VoT, accuracy increases from 31.74% to 52.10%, a gain of 20.36%. It also outperforms the best single-dimension repair (C-only) by 4.19%.

Under CoT, accuracy increases from 71.26% to 75.45%, a gain of 4.19%. It also outperforms the best single-dimension repair (P-only) by 1.80%.

However, D-only repair leads to a large drop in accuracy. D repair requires the model to read intermediate reasoning steps. Many samples fail at this stage and are counted as incorrect. This explains the lower accuracy.

W3. The framework identifies only 13.3% of post-recovery failures (Table 9), which is significantly lower than others. A more detailed analysis of this failure and its potential impact for the whole PADC framework should be added.

  • The 13.3% (40/300) reported in Table 9 represents samples that passed both the Access and D stages but still failed at the C stage. Most of the sample reduction occurred at the D stage. Among the 300 samples, 45 failed the Access check, while the remaining 255 passed. Of these 255 samples, 215 did not meet the downstream dependence threshold. The other 40 passed the D stage but still made computational errors at the C stage. The 215 samples were not classified as computational failures because there was insufficient evidence of downstream dependence. Therefore, the 13.3% represents the proportion of samples that met the complete criteria for computational failure. It does not represent the recall of failure detection after recovery.
  1. Zheng, L., et al. (2023). Judging LLM-as-a-Judge with MT-Bench and Chatbot Arena. NeurIPS 2023, Datasets and Benchmarks Track.
  2. Miao, N., Teh, Y. W., & Rainforth, T. (2024). SelfCheck: Using LLMs to Zero-Shot Check Their Own Step-by-Step Reasoning. ICLR 2024.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on Our Revised Manuscript

Dear Reviewer n3KW,

As the discussion period draws to a close, we would appreciate any feedback you may have on our responses. It would be helpful to know whether our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your concerns, or whether any questions remain.

We understand that your time is limited and would be grateful for even a brief update. We would be happy to provide any further clarification.

Thank you again for your time and constructive feedback.

Best regards, The Authors

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response to All Reviewers and the AC

We thank all three reviewers for their careful reviews and constructive feedback, as well as their recognition of the motivation, four-dimensional diagnostic framework, and experimental design of our work. In response to the reviewers' comments, we conducted the following additional experiments and analyses during the rebuttal period.

  1. Comparison of diagnostic methods and joint four-dimensional repair (n3KW: W1; VNHi: W2(3)). On the same 167 BFS samples, PADC-guided repair achieved 52.10% accuracy under VoT, outperforming LLM-as-a-Judge (44.31%) and Step-wise Verification (49.10%). Joint repair using all four dimensions achieved 52.10% under VoT and 75.45% under CoT. These results represent improvements of 20.36 and 4.19 percentage points over the respective baselines, and 4.19 and 1.80 percentage points over the best single-dimension repair. These results demonstrate the complementary roles of the four diagnostic dimensions and the effectiveness of PADC in guiding targeted repairs.
  2. Stage-wise diagnosis and failure localization on the same samples (VNHi: W2, Q4; 3K78: W1, S1). We performed P, A, D, and C checks sequentially on the same 167 BFS samples. Each subsequent stage was evaluated only on samples that passed the previous stage. After repair, the conditional pass rates for CoT and VoT were 41.32% and 33.53% at the A stage, 79.71% and 80.36% at the D stage, and 89.09% and 75.56% at the C stage, respectively. This experiment demonstrates the feasibility of applying PADC for sequential diagnosis on the same samples and reveals differences between reasoning formats at different stages.
  3. Distinguishing prediction dependence from computational correctness (VNHi: W1, Q2; 3K78: W2, Q1). We added two experiments: State Recovery Confirmation and Independent State Substitution, involving 1,221 graph samples and 845 independent sample pairs, respectively. Among samples with prediction changes, 37.82% and 31.02%, respectively, still had at least one incorrect answer under the two states. This directly supports the need to evaluate D and C separately: a model's response to changes in task states does not guarantee correct computation.
  4. State reading during answer generation (VNHi: W1, Q2). We conducted an additional field-reading experiment on 167 BFS samples. The experiment examined the model's continuous generation of state fields and final answers. Only two samples passed the field check, and both produced correct answers. This experiment further distinguishes Answer-free State Recovery from In-pass Access and shows that successful independent state recovery does not necessarily indicate correct state reading during answer generation.
  5. Threshold sensitivity and clarification of diagnostic metrics (VNHi: Q1; n3KW: W3). We evaluated all 16 combinations of the two effect thresholds for D. All three models met the criteria under the original thresholds, while their effect strengths differed under stricter thresholds. We also clarified that 13.3% (40/300) represents the proportion of samples that passed A and D but failed C, rather than the recall of failure detection.
  6. Task evaluation and related work (VNHi: Q3; 3K78: W1). We recalculated the CoT and VoT results using semantic rescoring and corrected the Binary Search task setup. The results show that VoT outperforms CoT on ProofWriter, Insertion Sort, and Binary Search, but performs worse on ProntoQA and BFS. This indicates that neither reasoning format has a consistent advantage across all tasks, and their relative performance varies by task. We also clarified the distinction between P and D. P examines whether task-relevant information and structures are preserved in the external representation. It uses information erasure experiments to evaluate the impact of this information on model predictions. D examines whether changing the task state, after confirming its preservation and passing the Access check, leads to corresponding changes in model predictions. Thus, P examines information preservation and its behavioral effects, while D examines the dependence of model predictions on task-state changes.

Our point-by-point responses to the reviewers' comments follow.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.