- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MoCouple, a framework designed to enhance the generalizability of audio-visual deepfake detection by learning fine-grained motion coupling.
Critical strengths
The motivation is good, with the authors pointing out that relying solely on local audio-lip synchronization is inadequate. Natural speaking inherently demands complex joint coordination among speech, facial expressions, and head movements.
Critical weaknesses
- The validation experiments in Section 3 fall short of fully supporting the claim of successfully extracting fine-grained joint features. Specifically, this section relies merely on distribution visualization and the MMD metric, lacking independent validation and ablation studies to demonstrate how each pre-training objective effectively captures specific motion dependencies.
- Moreover, the proposed cross-modal feature fusion and evidence fusion designs lack novelty.
- This paper also suffers from poor readability. Figure 1 is blurry, and the caption for Table 1 should be placed consistently above the table.
Questions for authors
Robustness evaluations under complex visual conditions are absent. Could the authors provide additional robustness validation results for MoCouple in scenarios involving facial occlusion and varying illumination?