acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

StyleFinger: Learning Vehicle-Level Interaction Tendencies for Controllable Scenario Generation in Autonomous Driving Testing

Abstract

Scenario-based testing of autonomous vehicles requires surrounding agents that respond diversely yet realistically within the same traffic situation. Trajectory replay offers no behavioral diversity, while stochastic trajectory generators produce diversity without a stable, behavior-grounded control axis. We present StyleFinger, which learns a vehicle-level interaction tendency from non-overlapping segments of the same vehicle and exposes it as a continuous conditioning code for behavior generation. On NGSIM two-car interactions under a vehicle-disjoint, temporally non-overlapping, history-only protocol, same-vehicle retrieval of the learned tendency reaches an AUC of 0.754, indicating that the signal is persistent and recoverable. The tendency complements rather than replaces the scenario: intent prediction with scenario and style attains a macro-F1 of 0.678, versus 0.220 for style alone. Under an equal eight-candidate budget, style conditioning achieves 0.661 ground-truth behavior match and 0.893 observed behavior-bin coverage, versus 0.571 and 0.855 for stochastic latent sampling. Shuffling the scenario–style pairing collapses the intervention effect (1.542 vs. 0.315), indicating that the code carries behaviorally meaningful structure rather than acting as arbitrary noise. All evidence is open-loop; interactive closed-loop validation is left as future work.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
driving style, interaction tendency, vehicle-level representation learning, controllable trajectory generation, autonomous driving testing, conditional behavior generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_6pF3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents StyleFinger, a framework for learning a low-dimensional vehicle-level interaction tendency from temporally separated historical interactions and using it as a replaceable condition for trajectory generation. By keeping the current interaction scenario, partner replay, decoder, and sampling budget fixed while substituting only the tendency code, the method enables controlled variation of a target vehicle’s response.

Critical strengths

S1: The paper is clear, easy to read and well-motivated.

S2: The experiments provide encouraging evidence.

Critical weaknesses

I am not familiar with this topic. If my following weakness and question is not true, just omit it

W1: Presently there are no code, which hinders reproductivity

W2: The paper provides limited discussion of potential instability of the learned vehicle-level tendency.

W3: Stage 1 and Stage 2 use vehicle identity as supervision, raising the concern that the learned representation captures vehicle-specific cues rather than interaction tendencies.

W4: The StyleShuffle control might not fully isolate the contribution of the tendency condition itself.

Questions for authors

The assumption that different windows from the same vehicle reflect a stable interaction tendency is not sufficiently justified. Driving responses can vary substantially with contextual factors like lane configuration and traffic density.

Reviewer_ptN9OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses an interesting problem for practitioners evaluating structured planners with multi-agent behavior models. Practitioners often want to conduct controlled experiments by changing only one specific surrounding agent's behavior. The authors propose StyleFinger, which encodes an agent's history and uses that encoding to condition a learned trajectory decoder. Empirically, they show that the latent representation is useful for generating diverse behaviors in two-agent interactions extracted from NGSIM.

Critical strengths

Varying one surrounding vehicle’s response while keeping the traffic situation fixed is useful for controlled planner testing.

Critical weaknesses

Writing:

  • Introduction is missing a lot of citations, i.e. paragraph 2.

  • For problem formulation, no definition on the space each variable lives in, how do you represent the target history? Sequence of x-y positions, speed or orientations ?

  • Where do you get the interaction demand label and how far apart is the two temporally non-overlapping interval?

  • What guarantee do you have for z not being any of the labels you described? "a psychological personality label, a vehicle-identity classifier, or a universal aggressive conservative axis." This sounds more like an author's intention rather than evidence.

  • What is the meaning of "lateral/longitudinal label prediction", target waypoints? How do you get these labels?

  • In evaluation, what does MRR's definition?

Evaluations

  • From your evaluation, it is very hard to see what the trajectories look like in the scene for the 8 latent variables. Do a birdview with the two cars and draw the trajectories on top of it.

  • Table 3 and Figure 3 shows some evidence the usefulness of the latent variable but with 25 future steps at 10Hz which resulted in 4.0 ADE is hard to evaluate the quality of the predicted trajectory.

Questions for authors

Please see the questions asked in the weakness section.

One of the arguments motivating the proposed method incorrectly characterizes multimodal predictors for controllable simulation. See Figure 3 of DJINN [1] for an example where classifier guidance alters a specific agent's behavior without changing the other cars in the scene. Similar examples appear in SceneDiffuser [2] and MotionDiffuser [3]. Could the authors clarify the advantages of their approach?

[1] Niedoba, Matthew, et al. "A diffusion-model of joint interactive navigation." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 36 (2023): 55995-56011.

[2] Jiang, Chiyu M., et al. "Scenediffuser: Efficient and controllable driving simulation initialization and rollout." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 37 (2024): 55729-55760.

[3] Jiang, Chiyu, et al. "Motiondiffuser: Controllable multi-agent motion prediction using diffusion." Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF conference on computer vision and pattern recognition. 2023.

Reviewer_VgGFOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces StyleFinger, a framework that learns vehicle-level interaction tendencies to generate alternative vehicle responses under fixed interaction scenarios. It combines an action-grounded encoder with interaction-intention supervision and same-vehicle contrastive learning to obtain a five-dimensional tendency representation. Experiments on NGSIM two-vehicle interactions demonstrate improved vehicle-pair retrieval, observed-future matching, and observed-bin coverage compared with repetition and training-time tendency shuffling. However, the distinction between vehicle-specific tendencies and scenario-dependent interaction behaviors remains insufficiently validated, and the practical advantages over existing multimodal behavior generation methods are unclear. Furthermore, the evaluation is limited to open-loop trajectory generation, without demonstrating improvements in interactive realism or closed-loop safety testing.

Critical strengths
  1. A well-defined and auditable response-conditioning protocol. The fixed-scenario, equal-candidate-budget intervention provides a relatively clean way to inspect whether changing a history-derived code affects the generated target response, without conflating the result with changes to the local scenario or sampled residual latent. This makes the proposed interface relevant to controllable interaction testing.
  2. A useful distinction between diversity and data alignment. The StyleShuffle control retains response dispersion (0.675 versus 0.637) but reduces observed-future matching (0.554 versus 0.661) and rank agreement (0.729 versus 0.886). This is more informative than reporting trajectory diversity alone and lends support to the learned history–response association.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient evidence that the learned code isolates a meaningful vehicle-level interaction tendency.

The representation is explicitly trained with vehicle-identity and same-vehicle contrastive objectives, and the reported retrieval AUC (0.754; 0.631 under a 250-frame gap) primarily measures vehicle-associated discriminability. It does not establish that the code captures transferable response preference rather than vehicle-specific kinematics, local context, or residual identity information. As a result, the central separation between interaction demand and response tendency remains insufficiently validated.

  1. Limited interpretability and consistency analysis of the tendency prototypes.

The method selects eight tendency prototypes using farthest-first sampling in the learned latent space. However, it remains unclear whether these prototypes represent meaningful and consistent driving tendencies or merely diverse latent conditions. The qualitative results demonstrate trajectory variation under code substitution but do not establish the behavioral semantics or cross-scenario consistency of individual prototypes. Without such evidence, the practical distinction between the proposed style-conditioned generation and conventional latent-conditioned multimodal generation remains insufficiently supported.

  1. Limited comparative and downstream validation weakens the claimed contribution to autonomous-driving testing.

The principal generation comparisons are Repeat and a shuffled-label variant of the same architecture. There is no matched comparison against relevant style-conditioned or interaction-controllable generators, even though related work is discussed. The evaluation uses a single NGSIM US-101 source, two-car windows, and logged partner replay, so it cannot determine whether the responses remain plausible when other agents react, whether behavior is realistic, or whether the method improves safety-critical test coverage or failure discovery. These limitations substantially constrain the practical significance of the proposed testing interface.

Questions for authors
  1. Disentanglement and consistency of learned tendencies. How does the method ensure that the learned representation captures stable driving tendencies rather than scenario-dependent behaviors or vehicle-identity cues? Can the authors evaluate whether the embeddings remain consistent for the same vehicle across different interaction contexts and exhibit similarity across different vehicles with comparable behavioral tendencies?

  2. Contribution of tendency conditioning. Can the authors provide matched scenario-only, tendency-only, and random-code baselines for interaction-demand prediction and trajectory generation, while controlling for model capacity, decoder architecture, and candidate budget (K = 8)? How much improvement can be attributed specifically to the learned tendency representation rather than scenario information or generic latent sampling?

  3. How does StyleFinger compare with at least one existing style-conditioned/controllable traffic-generation method under a matched two-car protocol and sampling budget? Could the authors report both realism/fidelity and coverage rather than only adapted ADE/FDE predictor references?

  4. Can the authors clarify the exact definitions, binning schemes, units, and sensitivity of observed-future matching, observed-bin coverage, D_behavior, and tendency–behavior rank agreement? How stable are the conclusions to candidate count K, prototype-selection rule, and bin thresholds?

  5. Could the authors test whether tendency swapping causes physically implausible motion or collisions and, if feasible, demonstrate a small reactive-partner or planner-in-the-loop evaluation? This would help establish whether the observed open-loop variation is useful for testing rather than merely trajectory perturbation.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.