- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BOLT, a behavior-oriented framework for autonomous driving that combines explicit behavioral representation learning, joint trajectory prediction and planning, and inference-time trajectory refinement. The framework consists of three main components: Behavior representation learning, Behavior-conditioned prediction and planning, and Differential-Flatness-Informed Trajectory Refinement (DFTR). It also introduces an extension of nuPlan-mini with behavioral pseudo labels derived through GMM-LDA modeling. Experiments are conducted on nuScenes for motion forecasting, nuPlan for closed-loop planning, and CommonRoad for driving simulation.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well-organized and easy to follow.
- An integrated prediction and planning framework. The framework connects behavioral representation learning with surrounding-agent prediction and ego planning.
Critical weaknesses
- The reliability of behavioral pseudo-labels are insufficiently established. The labels are inferred primarily from speed and acceleration, which can be heavily influenced by traffic conditions rather than driving preferences. The authors should provide independent validation of the pseudo-labels, ideally through human annotations or established behavioral indicators.
- The experimental comparisons are incomplete, and some performance improvements are marginal. Compared to recent strong baselines like PerReg [1] of CVPR25', the performance is far worse.
- The contributions of the individual architectural components are insufficiently isolated. BOLT combines multiple existing methodological elements, including GMM-LDA clustering, CfC temporal encoding, and prototype memory. The main novelty appears to lie in their integration rather than in a fundamentally new learning mechanism.
[1] Towards Generalizable Trajectory Prediction using Dual-Level Representation Learning and Adaptive Prompting
Questions for authors
- How do the authors verify that the GMM-LDA pseudo-labels represent driving behavior rather than road conditions or instantaneous motion states? Is there any evaluation against independently annotated driver behavior?
5 comments
We filter valid same-lane car-following cases with moving ego, positive gap and stable leader. The statistics in Table 2
Table 2. THW statistics for car-following samples grouped by GMM-LDA labels.
| Label source | Raw class | Total windows | Valid following samples | Median THW (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GMM-LDA | Aggressive | 1013 | 84 | 2.440 |
| GMM-LDA | Normal | 4798 | 410 | 2.562 |
| GMM-LDA | Conservative | 3038 | 123 | 2.823 |
Median THW increases monotonically from aggressive to conservative, matching traffic intuition. All three classes contain valid car-following samples, which demonstrates GMM-LDA labels capture meaningful interaction differences.
We fix the CfC encoder and only toggle auxiliary supervision to isolate the benefit of pseudo-labels. The loss formulations are: U0 and U1 share identical network, input, prediction head, initialization, batch order, optimizer and training budget. The prototype memory module is disabled, and three paired random seeds are used. The only difference is whether GMM-LDA supervision is enabled. Quantitative forecasting results are shown in Table 3.
Table 3. Trajectory forecasting performance for U0 and U1 settings.
| Setting | Mean ADE ± Std (m) | Mean FDE ± Std (m) |
|---|---|---|
| U0 (no pseudo-label) | 3.673 ± 0.522 | 6.295 ± 0.910 |
| U1 (GMM-LDA supervision) | 3.590 ± 0.687 | 6.143 ± 1.225 |
Under the 3-second open-loop forecasting setting, U1 reduces ADE by 2.25% and FDE by 2.40% on average. This confirms that auxiliary behavioral supervision yields consistent forecasting gains even with the temporal backbone fixed.
This ablation complements the classification recognition experiments: recognition results show model fitting capacity under two label definitions, while this experiment isolates the effect of behavioral supervision. We retain multi-seed statistics, confidence intervals and constant-velocity baseline in the main paper, and the conclusion is bounded to this auxiliary prediction task.
Thank you for your suggestions regarding component attribution and the rigor of our evaluation. If these responses and the additional experiments have addressed your primary concerns, we would appreciate it if you could consider increasing your score (if possible). Please let us know if any other issues remain that might affect your assessment, and we will be happy to provide further clarification. Thank you for your time and for reviewing our work.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive follow-up and for recognizing our additional experiments. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify the semantic interpretation of our behavioral pseudo-labels and their practical contribution to closed-loop planning.
- Semantic Interpretability of Behavioral Pseudo-Labels.
We acknowledge that the rule-based reference, which relies on related motion and interaction indicators, does not constitute fully independent semantic validation. Moreover, our GMM-LDA labeling process does not explicitly impose semantic constraints. Therefore, the resulting pseudo-labels are more appropriately interpreted as weakly supervised, coarse-grained behavioral modes rather than ground-truth driving styles.
To further examine their interpretability, we conduct an additional diagnostic analysis on car-following and merging scenarios, as presented in Table 7. To reduce contextual variability, we evaluate the two interaction types separately and restrict samples to those involving at most three surrounding traffic participants. This provides more comparable driving contexts with bounded local traffic complexity, although it does not eliminate all contextual differences.
Specifically, we evaluate time headway (THW) in car-following scenarios and accepted time gap in merging scenarios. These measures characterize inter-vehicle spacing and gap-acceptance tendencies beyond the speed and acceleration features directly used for GMM-LDA clustering. Both metrics exhibit a consistent ordering (Conservative > Normal > Aggressive). For example, the mean THW decreases from 2.82 s to 2.17 s, while the mean accepted gap decreases from 2.89 s to 1.93 s between conservative and aggressive categories. These consistent trends provide additional evidence that the pseudo-labels capture interpretable behavioral tendencies.
- Practical Contribution of Behavioral Modeling to Closed-Loop Planning.
We agree that the overall improvement from behavioral modeling on Val14 is relatively modest compared with DFTR. However, this does not necessarily reflect its contribution in individual driving situations, particularly those requiring interactions with surrounding vehicles.
To investigate this aspect, we further analyze selected challenging Val14 cases involving busy right turns, dense car-following, and left lane changes in traffic, alongside a low-interaction case for comparison (Table 8). BOLT consistently outperforms the no-behavior baseline in these selected interactive cases, improving CLS-NR by 3.93–5.39 points and CLS-R by 3.72–6.88 points. The largest improvement occurs in dense car-following, where CLS-NR/CLS-R increases from 85.74/79.36 to 91.13/86.24. In contrast, the low-interaction case exhibits smaller gains of 1.07/1.04 points.
These observations suggest that behavioral representations can provide additional value when planning requires reasoning about surrounding vehicles and their potential interactions. They also indicate that aggregate scores may obscure larger improvements in certain challenging cases. Nevertheless, we recognize that this targeted analysis is based on selected cases rather than exhaustive scenario-level evaluation.
Furthermore, our previously reported controlled ablation shows that correctly aligned behavioral supervision achieves 92.07/93.59 CLS-R/CLS-NR, compared with 91.87/93.31 without behavioral supervision and 91.82/93.25 with shuffled labels. This comparison provides complementary evidence that the benefit arises from meaningful trajectory–label correspondence rather than arbitrary auxiliary supervision.
- Clarification of Our Contribution and Limitations.
We acknowledge that our current pseudo-labeling approach does not establish a rigorous semantic taxonomy of driving styles, and that the aggregate contribution of behavioral modeling is smaller than that of DFTR. Nevertheless, our results suggest that even weakly supervised, coarse-grained behavioral representations can provide useful information for trajectory planning, with particularly encouraging improvements in the selected high-interaction cases.
Behavioral modeling and DFTR address different aspects of the problem: the former introduces interaction-relevant representations into prediction and planning, while the latter improves the kinematic feasibility and obstacle-related properties of the generated trajectories.
We will revise the manuscript to clarify the operational meaning of our behavioral labels, distinguish the contributions of the two modules, and explicitly acknowledge the limitations of semantic validation and scenario coverage. We believe these additional analyses provide a more precise understanding of the value and scope of structured behavioral supervision in closed-loop planning.
Response to Reviewer BD3j
Thank you for your question. We evaluate the GMM-LDA pseudo-labels against an independently defined physical-rule reference on the same nuPlan-mini samples. Built upon observable ego motion and interaction quantities, this rule suite offers a complementary automated benchmark for behavioral classification within short temporal windows. The rule suite is constructed from six observable quantities for each window i:
z_i = m_i \odot (1, 1, 1, 1, -1, -1)$$ where $\odot$ denotes element-wise multiplication. Let $L_k = Q_{0.15}(z_k)$ and $U_k = Q_{0.85}(z_k)$ denote the 15th and 85th percentile thresholds of the $k$-th dimension of $z$. The aggressive predicate $A_i$ and conservative predicate $C_i$ are defined as: $$A_i = \bigvee_{k=1}^{6} \left[z_{ik} > U_k\right], \quad C_i = \bigwedge_{k=1}^{6} \left[z_{ik} < L_k\right]$$ The rule-based label is assigned by: $$\tilde{y}_i^{\text{rule}} = \begin{cases} A & \text{if } A_i = 1; \\\\ C & \text{if } A_i = 0, C_i = 1; \\\\ N & \text{otherwise}. \end{cases}$$ The primitive kinematic variables are computed as follows: $$\bar{v}_i = \frac{1}{T_i} \sum_{t\in W_i} \Vert\mathbf{v}_t\Vert_2,\quad \mathbf{a}_t = \frac{\mathbf{v}_{t+1}-\mathbf{v}_t}{\Delta t_t},\quad \mathbf{j}_t = \frac{\mathbf{a}_{t+1}-\mathbf{a}_t}{\Delta t_t}$$ $$A_{\parallel,i} = \mathcal{A}_{\parallel}(\\{ |a_{\parallel,t}| \\}_{t\in W_i}),\quad A_{\perp,i} = \mathcal{A}_{\perp}(\\{ |a_{\perp,t}| \\}_{t\in W_i}),\quad J_i = \mathcal{A}_j(\\{\\|\mathbf{j}_t\\|_2\\}_{t\in W_i})$$ For interaction metrics, we adopt time headway ($\text{THW}$) and RSS safety margin: $$\text{THW}_t = \frac{s_t}{v_{e,t}},\quad H_i = \mathcal{A}_H(\\{\text{THW}_t\\}_{t\in V_i}), \quad M_t = s_t - d_{\text{RSS},t}, \quad M_i = \mathcal{A}_M(\\{M_t\\}_{t\in V_i})$$ The required RSS safe distance for same-direction driving is: $$d_{\text{RSS},t} = \left[v_{e,t}\rho + \frac{1}{2}a_+\rho^2 + \frac{(v_{e,t}+a_+\rho)^2}{2b_e} - \frac{v_{l,t}^2}{2b_l}\right]_+$$ with the positive clamp operator: $$[x]_+ = \max(x,0)$$ Here, $s_t$ is the gap between ego and the leading vehicle; $v_{e,t},v_{l,t}$ are ego and leader speeds; $\rho$ is reaction time; $a_+,b_e,b_l$ are acceleration bounds following the RSS formalization in [Hasuo (2022)](https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.03418). Mean speed, acceleration and jerk quantify motion and its temporal variation; THW and RSS margin quantify interaction clearance. The window summaries, quantile reference population and tie handling are fixed in the final rule specification. THW and RSS margin leverage surrounding vehicles' geometric information, which are extra interaction dimensions beyond the ego-only kinematic inputs used by GMM. All metrics are quantified toward aggressiveness. The 85th and 15th percentiles define aggressive and conservative intervals. A sample is aggressive if any metric falls into its aggressive interval; conservative only when all metrics are conservative; otherwise normal. We evaluate the labels from four aspects: label agreement, recognition performance, THW interpretability ablation, and downstream forecasting ablation.And updated the experimental results for behavior recognition presented in **Table 4** of the paper. On 443,218 aligned nuPlan-mini samples, 65.33\% of labels match between the two schemes. Disagreements mostly lie in the normal class. The overlap is asymmetric: nearly all rule-defined conservative samples are conservative under GMM-LDA, while only 57.86\% of GMM-LDA conservative samples are recognized as conservative by rules. Despite this non-trivial discrepancy between the two labeling schemes, both can serve as effective supervision for the behavior module in downstream planning. We compare their closed-loop performance on nuPlan Test14 in Table 1 **Table 1.** Closed-loop planning performance on nuPlan Val14 for BOLT variants trained with different behavior labels. Higher is better. Best and second-best results are bold and underlined, respectively. | Planner | CLS-R ↑ | CLS-NR ↑ | |:---|---:|---:| | BOLT (GMM-LDA label) | $\underline{92.07}$ | **93.59** | | BOLT (GMM-LDA label, w/o DFTR) | 90.04 | 91.41 | | BOLT (rule label) | **92.13** | $\underline{93.27}$ | | BOLT (rule label, w/o DFTR) | 90.11 | 91.38 | Both label sources yield competitive closed-loop scores. GMM-LDA pseudo-labels obtain a slightly higher CLS-NR score, while rule-based labels achieve stronger CLS-R performance.