acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

LOCM: Behavioral Refinement of Reward-Induced Trajectory Equivalence in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning, different policies may achieve similar cumulative returns while exhibiting distinct execution behaviors. We interpret this return degeneracy as a structural consequence of compressing high-dimensional joint trajectories into a scalar task return, thereby inducing behaviorally heterogeneous return-equivalent sets. Our theoretical analysis indicates that scalar task returns can locally induce high-dimensional sets of return-equivalent trajectories, while appropriately chosen trajectory-level behavioral representations can further distinguish behavioral variations that remain unresolved by the original task return. Based on this view, we propose LOCM (LLM-Calibrated Observable Coordination Modeling), a trajectory-aware behavioral refinement framework that further refines execution behavior within an -optimal task-performance set rather than replacing the original task objective. LOCM combines interpretable joint-action behavioral coordinates, phase-adaptive weighting through an LLM-assisted semantic interface and numerical adapter, and an outcome anchor that constrains task-performance degradation. Experiments on power distribution network control and traffic-control tasks show persistent behavioral differences among near-return trajectories, identify locally reducible execution overhead, and demonstrate that LOCM reduces action variation across multiple MARL backbones while maintaining competitive task performance. These results support task-preserving behavioral refinement as a principled mechanism for mitigating reward-induced execution ambiguity.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning, Return Degeneracy, Behavioral Refinement, Coordination Modeling, Large Language Models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_5qSiOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies return degeneracy in cooperative MARL and proposes LOCM, a behavioral refinement framework based on observable behavioral metrics, phase-level LLM-assisted calibration, and an outcome anchor. Experiments on power-distribution and traffic-signal control evaluate near-return behavioral heterogeneity and the effect of LOCM across multiple MARL backbones.

Critical strengths

1.The paper goes beyond merely observing behavioral differences among similar-return trajectories and builds a coherent validation chain from near-return matching to controlled intervention and end-to-end refinement. The equal-budget and paired intervention experiments are particularly useful because they test whether observed behavioral differences correspond to locally reducible execution activity rather than descriptive variation alone.

2.The paper is careful in delimiting its claims. Both the theory and experiments explicitly expose important boundaries, including the local nature of the geometric analysis, near-zero intervention effects in low-activity settings, and backbone-dependent task–behavior trade-offs. This makes the main empirical findings more credible.

Critical weaknesses

1.The task-preserving claim is not fully supported by the implementation. The theoretical ϵ\epsilon-optimal constraint is replaced by a reference-relative acceptance gate, while guided MASAC omits environmental rewards. Direct evidence that the implementation meets the intended task-performance tolerance is therefore needed.

2.The source of behavioral improvement remains unclear. The adapter includes auxiliary action-intensity and collective-pull variables outside the proposed behavioral representation. An ablation is needed to isolate their effects from trajectory-level behavioral refinement.

Questions for authors

1.Could the authors provide direct evidence that the implemented LOCM procedure satisfies the intended task-preservation tolerance relative to the reference policy?

2.Could the authors isolate the contribution of the trajectory-level behavioral penalties from the auxiliary action-intensity and collective-pull controls, e.g., through an ablation without the auxiliary action-style pathway?

Reviewer_e5XDOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces LOCM, a trajectory-aware framework for cooperative MARL that addresses reward-induced trajectory equivalence, distinct execution behaviors yielding similar cumulative returns. They have used LLM-guided numerical adapter to adjust behavioral penalties during MARL training. They tested it on battery-storage and traffic-signal control.

Critical strengths

None.

Critical weaknesses

I split my issues in three main categories: Writing, Formalism and Experiments.

Writing Issues

Papers cited in line 45 Rashid et al 2018, Son et al 2019 are CTDE methods work on Dec-POMDP, which use shared reward among agents, and they are credit assignment works. Also there are multiple referring to things that are not introduced such as Research Questions. Most Importantly, papers should have a section named background, definitions or preliminaries describing notations and the settings the paper wants to works on, this paper does have this section.

Formalism Issues

Nothing is defined, what is the model we are working on, what is cooperative multi-agent Markov game, what is formal setting for that. No Notation is defined for example: ss, rr, T\mathcal{T}, M\mathcal{M}, G~\tilde{G}, T\mathrm{T}, z0z_0, kerker, Φ\Phi, Ψ\Psi, ρ\rho, and ... is not defined. Also the definitions presented should be agnostic to the tasks used, you can use examples to make a flow easier but just defining things over traffic-control tasks is wrong. There are math errors as well, GG takes a trajectory, how G~\tilde{G} takes a vector with dimension d? And finally, I get lost after 3.2 because nothing was defined and I could not understand the theoretical part of the paper, after this section.

Experiments

What is happening in the tables, there is no cross refereeing to them. For example, as I see in Table 3, in 2/3 of cases the return is reducing for LOCM, and the question is what is the advantage of LOCM? What are the benchmarks used for this paper, what are their context and what is their objective?

At the end, I think this paper needs major revisions, and it is not ready get accepted in ICLR.

Questions for authors

Please respond to the comments I wrote in the Critical Weaknesses section.

Reviewer_zbFFOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies reward-induced trajectory equivalence in cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). The authors observe that policies with similar cumulative environmental returns can exhibit substantially different execution behaviors, including action-sign counteraction, dominant-agent switching, and temporal action variation. They formalize this phenomenon as return degeneracy and analyze its local geometric structure.

The paper introduces LOCM (LLM-Calibrated Observable Coordination Modeling), a trajectory-aware behavioral refinement framework designed to improve execution behavior without replacing the original task objective. LOCM combines three observable behavioral coordinates with phase-adaptive calibration, an LLM-assisted semantic interface, a trainable numerical adapter, and a reference-relative outcome anchor. The LLM provides phase-level semantic diagnoses rather than generating real-time actions or directly specifying numerical reward coefficients.

The theoretical analysis characterizes the local dimension of trajectory sets that remain indistinguishable under a scalar return and shows how additional behavioral representations can reduce the locally unresolved dimension. The proposed framework is motivated by an ideal epsilon-optimal task-performance formulation, while its practical implementation uses reference-relative acceptance criteria.

The empirical evaluation consists of three stages: near-return matching to establish behavioral heterogeneity, controlled open-loop interventions to investigate locally reducible execution activity, and end-to-end evaluation of behavioral refinement. Experiments cover continuous-action power distribution network control and discrete-action traffic signal control, using multiple MARL backbones. The reported results show reductions in action magnitude and temporal variation, alongside generally competitive task performance, although the trade-offs vary across backbones and metrics. Ablation studies and alternative calibration strategies further investigate the contributions of the behavioral refinement mechanism, numerical adapter, outcome anchor, and LLM-assisted calibration.

Critical strengths
  1. A meaningful problem formulation. The paper identifies an important distinction between task-level success and execution-level behavior. Two cooperative policies may achieve similar cumulative returns while differing in action coordination, temporal variation, and the distribution of control effort. Treating this residual behavioral ambiguity as a separate problem is conceptually useful and complements conventional credit-assignment methods.

  2. A theoretically motivated behavioral representation. The local geometric analysis formalizes how a scalar return can leave multiple trajectory variations unresolved. Theorem 1 relates the rank of the behavioral representation restricted to return-null directions to the reduction in local unresolved dimensionality. The authors appropriately acknowledge that this is a representation-level result and does not establish that a scalarized training objective will exploit every such direction.

  3. A staged empirical evaluation. The three research questions separate the existence of behavioral heterogeneity, the potential for local execution refinement, and the effectiveness of end-to-end training. This structure helps distinguish descriptive evidence from intervention-based evidence and final policy performance. In particular, the open-loop intervention experiments attempt to test whether selected action activity can be reduced without degrading the original environmental return.

  4. Evaluation across multiple backbones and control domains. The paper considers MASAC, HAPPO, and MADPO in power distribution network control, as well as a discrete-action traffic-control setting. The results show that LOCM can reduce action magnitude and temporal variation across multiple configurations. The traffic-control results also provide useful evidence that the proposed behavioral refinement mechanism is not restricted to one continuous-action environment.

  5. Useful ablation and calibration comparisons. Table 6 on page 9 examines variants that remove behavioral coordination, use static calibration, replace the numerical adapter, remove the outcome anchor, or replace the LLM-based diagnosis with a rule-based alternative. Appendix D.8 further compares full LOCM with fixed, rule-based, and semantically shuffled calibration. These experiments help distinguish the contribution of the general behavioral-refinement mechanism from that of the individual calibration components.

  6. Attention to implementation and reproducibility. The appendices document the training protocols, behavioral metrics, numerical adapter, semantic interface, reference-relative acceptance gate, and fallback mechanism. The phase-level use of the LLM also avoids placing language-model inference in the real-time control loop, making the proposed system more practical than a design that requires an LLM for every action.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The practical task-preservation mechanism does not establish the theoretical epsilon-optimal guarantee. Section 3.3 defines an ideal admissible set of policies whose expected return is within epsilon of the optimal return. The implementation instead uses a reference-relative physical acceptance gate. In the power-distribution setting, Appendix F.3.2 requires phase-level average voltage deviation to remain within 5% of its reference and average network loss within 10% of its reference. The paper explicitly acknowledges that this gate is not mathematically identical to the analytical penalty and does not guarantee exact membership in the epsilon-optimal set. Consequently, the practical results support reference-relative performance preservation rather than a formal guarantee of epsilon-optimal task performance. The distinction should be more prominent in the paper's claims and conclusions.

  2. The independent contribution of LLM-assisted calibration remains unclear. The proposed method gives the LLM a relatively narrow role: it produces phase-level semantic diagnoses, which supervise a trainable numerical adapter. However, Appendix D.8 shows that fixed and rule-based calibration can also perform competitively. The paper reports that LOCM-Fixed achieves the highest mean environmental return and the largest reductions in several execution metrics, while full LOCM performs best on selected physical metrics, including voltage deviation and network loss. These findings suggest that behavioral refinement itself may account for much of the benefit, while the LLM selects a particular operating point in the task–behavior trade-off. The paper should more clearly establish when semantic calibration is necessary or preferable to simpler alternatives, particularly considering its additional API dependency and potential cost.

  3. The behavioral proxies are not direct measures of coordination quality. LOCM uses action-sign counteraction, dominant-agent switching, and temporal action variation. These metrics are observable and interpretable, but their relationship to efficiency, stability, and coordination depends on the task. For example, reducing action variation may suppress necessary corrective responses, while reducing counteraction may not always be desirable when agents have distinct responsibilities. The paper acknowledges that the metrics are not universally monotonic measures of coordination quality. Nevertheless, the end-to-end conclusions sometimes interpret their reduction as improved execution behavior. Stronger evidence linking the selected proxies to operational benefits, stability, or energy efficiency would make these claims more convincing.

  4. The near-return matching evidence has limited coverage at strict tolerances. Table 1 on page 6 reports 345 raw matches at a 2% relative return tolerance, but these reduce to 23 deduplicated pairs covering only 12 of 50 scenarios. The coverage improves at looser tolerances, but increasing the tolerance also weakens the claim that the trajectories are genuinely comparable in task performance. The behavioral differences reported in the table are informative, yet the results leave open how representative the matched trajectories are of the full scenario distribution. The paper would benefit from clearer discussion of this selection effect and stronger evidence that the conclusions are robust to alternative matching and deduplication procedures.

  5. The open-loop intervention results are backbone-dependent. In Table 2 on page 7, the behavioral-coordinate-based intervention yields positive return changes for MASAC, with 100% non-decrease across the 23 selected trajectories. However, for MAPPO, the same diagnostic produces a small negative return change, with 0% non-decrease across 12 trajectories; the realized action-removal amount is also very small. This suggests that the behavioral representation does not identify equally useful removable activity across the two policy families. The intervention study therefore provides evidence of locally reducible activity in particular settings, rather than a general demonstration that the proposed behavioral representation identifies unnecessary execution activity across MARL algorithms.

  6. The end-to-end results show task–behavior trade-offs rather than uniform improvement. Under the standard power-distribution protocol, MASAC-LOCM improves return, whereas HAPPO-LOCM and MADPO-LOCM exhibit modest return decreases. The monthly evaluation also reports a clear increase in cumulative voltage deviation for MASAC-LOCM, despite improvements in several other physical metrics. In traffic control, the reported behavioral metrics improve broadly, but role switching and burden trend increase. These results are not inherently problematic, because the framework does not assume that every behavioral coordinate should decrease. However, they indicate that the method's success depends on how the trade-off is defined and evaluated. The paper should more explicitly identify which metrics are primary acceptance criteria and which are secondary diagnostics.

  7. The statistical evidence for independent training generalization is limited. The independent-training-seed analysis uses three seeds per method, while many other results aggregate over ten fixed evaluation seeds. These are different sources of variability, and the manuscript appropriately distinguishes them. Nevertheless, three independent training runs provide limited evidence for broad claims about robustness across training randomness. The reported reductions in action magnitude and variation are encouraging, but additional independent training seeds and uncertainty estimates for paired differences would provide stronger evidence that the improvements are reliable.

  8. The theoretical analysis is local and does not directly characterize optimization dynamics. Proposition 1 and Theorem 1 describe the local geometry of trajectory equivalence under regularity assumptions. The paper also acknowledges that discrete-control trajectories require a smooth local embedding or relaxation for this analysis. These results explain why behavioral information can distinguish variations unresolved by scalar return, but they do not show that the proposed behavioral coordinates are sufficient, that their effects remain meaningful across distant trajectory regions, or that LOCM's practical optimization converges to a desirable solution. The theoretical contribution would be stronger if the paper more directly connected the local rank analysis to the behavior of the implemented learning algorithm.

  9. The role of auxiliary action-style controls is not fully covered by the theoretical formulation. The implementation includes auxiliary variables for action intensity and collective pull in addition to the three behavioral coordinates analyzed in the main theory. The paper explicitly states that these auxiliary variables are excluded from the geometric analysis and from the behavioral diagnostics used in the first two research questions. This separation is understandable, but it complicates attribution: some end-to-end gains may arise from implementation-level action-style modifications rather than the theoretically analyzed behavioral representation alone. A clearer component-level account of their effects would strengthen the correspondence between the theory and the proposed method.

Questions for authors
  1. Theoretical guarantee versus practical implementation: The paper defines an ideal epsilon-optimal policy set but implements task preservation through reference-relative thresholds on voltage deviation and network loss. Can the authors provide conditions under which this practical acceptance gate implies a meaningful bound on expected environmental return? If such a guarantee is unavailable, could the claims be explicitly restricted to reference-relative physical performance preservation?

  2. Necessity of LLM-assisted calibration: Appendix D.8 shows that fixed and rule-based calibration remain competitive, with LOCM-Fixed outperforming full LOCM on several reported metrics. What specific benefits does the LLM provide that cannot be obtained through a simpler adaptive rule or learned calibration mechanism? Can the authors quantify the incremental benefit relative to these alternatives across multiple training seeds?

  3. Validity of behavioral proxies: How do the authors validate that lower action-sign counteraction, dominant-agent switching, and temporal action variation correspond to better execution behavior in each domain? Could the authors provide operational measures or targeted analyses showing when reducing each coordinate improves efficiency or stability, and when it may suppress necessary control responses?

  4. Robustness of near-return matching: At a 2% return tolerance, the 345 raw matches reduce to 23 deduplicated pairs across only 12 of 50 scenarios. How sensitive are the conclusions to the matching tolerance, trajectory deduplication procedure, and scenario coverage? Can the authors provide additional evidence that the observed behavioral heterogeneity is representative of a broader set of task-comparable trajectories?

  5. Backbone-dependent intervention effects: Why does the behavioral-coordinate-based open-loop intervention yield positive return changes for MASAC but near-zero or slightly negative changes for MAPPO? Does this reflect differences in action scales, policy parameterization, or the nature of the execution activity identified by the behavioral proxies? How should this result affect the generality of the claimed locally reducible execution overhead?

  6. Independent training-seed robustness: The cross-seed analysis uses three independent training seeds per method. Do the reported behavioral improvements remain statistically distinguishable from the corresponding baselines when uncertainty is calculated across independent training runs rather than evaluation scenarios? Can the authors provide additional seeds or paired uncertainty estimates?

  7. Contribution of auxiliary action-style controls: The implemented framework includes action-intensity and collective-pull controls that are not part of the three-coordinate theoretical analysis. How much of the end-to-end improvement comes from these controls, compared with the theoretically analyzed behavioral penalties? Can the authors provide ablations that isolate their individual contributions?

  8. Generality of the local theory: The geometric analysis relies on local regularity assumptions, and discrete-action trajectories are treated through a smooth embedding or relaxation. What conclusions remain valid for discrete control without this relaxation, and how does the local representation-level result inform optimization over complete trajectories or policies in the evaluated environments?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.