- Rating
- 1(−1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates how episodically bounded prediction rewards can lead to severe performance degradation in language-agent reinforcement learning. The authors attribute this phenomenon to step-pooled GRPO normalization, where standard-deviation scaling can effectively cancel the auxiliary reward coefficient. Experiments on ALFWorld and WebShop, together with several interventions, provide empirical support for this explanation.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a relevant problem in auxiliary reward design for language agents.
- The observed performance collapse across multiple model sizes is striking, and the quantitative agreement between the theoretical prediction and measured normalization statistics is interesting.
- The normalization and trajectory-aggregation interventions provide useful diagnostic evidence.
Critical weaknesses
-
Clarity and presentation. The manuscript suffers from substantial writing and organizational issues beyond its excessive use of nonstandard and implementation-specific terminology. The presentation is unnecessarily dense and repetitive, with technical details, experimental results, and numerical observations frequently introduced before their significance is clearly explained. The narrative also shifts between theoretical arguments, implementation details, and numerous experimental interventions without a sufficiently coherent logical progression. Consequently, it is often difficult to identify the central contribution or distinguish established mathematical properties from genuinely novel findings. Overall, the paper is unnecessarily difficult to read and follow.
-
Insufficient differentiation from prior work. The central observation that user-specified reward coefficients do not directly determine the effective contributions of reward components after GRPO normalization has already been explicitly studied in prior work, including MO-GRPO[1], GDPO[2], and Constrained GRPO[3]. These studies have also proposed and empirically validated remedies based on decoupled reward or advantage normalization. The present paper largely revisits this known issue in a specific multi-turn agent setting. While the telescoping reward construction and first-step boundary analysis are interesting, it remains unclear what fundamentally new theoretical insight they establish beyond existing results. Moreover, the paper does not adequately distinguish its proposed interventions from prior solutions or evaluate whether existing methods can already prevent the observed failure.
[1]Ichihara, Yuki, et al. "Mo-grpo: Mitigating reward hacking of group relative policy optimization on multi-objective problems." Transactions of the Association for Computational Linguistics 14 (2026): 1867-1882.
[2]Liu, Shih-Yang, et al. "Gdpo: Group reward-decoupled normalization policy optimization for multi-reward rl optimization." arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.05242 (2026).
[3]Girgis, Roger, et al. "Constrained Group Relative Policy Optimization." arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.05863 (2026).
Questions for authors
Please refer to the concerns raised in the Weaknesses.
9 comments
How does the contribution relate to MO-GRPO, GDPO, and Constrained GRPO?
Response. The contribution connects a telescoping prediction reward to the temporal unit and normalization population used by a language-agent estimator. Related work provides the normalization and component-weighting context summarized below.
| Related method | Relevant operation | Connection to this analysis |
|---|---|---|
| MO-GRPO | Variance-based reward reweighting | Effective component weighting after normalization |
| GDPO | Component normalization before combination | The step-sample adaptation tested below |
| Constrained GRPO | Scalarization of standardized advantages | Shared-denominator coupling and the order of transformations |
| ACOER | Correct-only efficiency rewards and adaptive controls | Motivation for the trajectory-success-gated prediction-reward control |
Prediction reward is a signed difference of consecutive potentials. Its raw sum is bounded independently of horizon because the intermediate potential values cancel. The step-pooled estimator first combines each prediction increment with the task outcome and penalty and then computes group statistics across interaction rows. The return identity and the estimator transformation therefore act on different objects.
| Operation | Relation to this analysis |
|---|---|
| MO-GRPO, GDPO, Constrained GRPO | Component weighting and normalization order |
| Mean-only normalization | Direct intervention on standard-deviation division |
| Telescoping prediction reward | Signed increments sum to a bounded trajectory return |
| Step-pooled estimator | Interaction rows define the score distribution before normalization |
| Reported comparisons | Complete factorials, success gating, decoupled normalization, and native gradient measurements |
The central question is how a trajectory-return bound translates through step pooling and normalization into the weights supplied to the policy loss. The conditional calculation makes the mechanism quantitative, telemetry measures the score components in actual training, and the interventions test changes at specific locations in that pipeline.
The distinction between interventions is operational. Component decoupling changes how reward channels enter their denominators. Mean-only removes standard-deviation division. Trajectory-first changes the temporal quantity presented to normalization. Success gating controls prediction-reward injection according to the trajectory's task outcome. The native gradient probes measure the normalizer transformation directly at the policy-loss stage.
The experimental matrix measures these operations with explicit comparison cells. At 4B, the normalizer interaction is +17.14 pp. At 1.7B, the temporal-estimator interaction is +15.71 pp at the fixed endpoint. Success gating and the specified GDPO adaptation each improve the standard reward-enabled endpoint by +20.71 pp. These results connect the mathematical interface to the actual behavior of the trained agents.
This provides a concrete empirical diagnosis of the return-to-estimator transformation. It also yields an actionable measurement principle: track the reward components and their covariance at the normalization population actually used by the loss, and evaluate interventions with their complete task and reward references.
How does decoupled normalization perform in the controlled comparison?
Response. We completed a step-sample GDPO adaptation with the following explicit channel definitions and normalization sequence.
| Stage | Specified implementation |
|---|---|
| Task channel | Task score minus invalid-action penalty |
| Prediction channel | Unweighted prediction-score delta |
| Within-group normalization | Normalize each channel separately |
| Channel combination | Weights 1 for task-minus-penalty and 0.1 for prediction |
| Final normalization | Sample-normalize over active step rows |
| Training interface | Step samples from the multi-turn language-agent rollout |
The task channel contains task score minus invalid-action penalty. The prediction channel contains the unweighted prediction-potential increment. Each channel is normalized within the task group, then combined using weights 1 and 0.1. The combined values are sample-normalized across active step rows. The reward priorities are therefore applied to component-normalized values, and the final step-sample normalization is part of the tested estimator.
All three reference rows below use the same 4B checkpoint-75 protocol, prediction interface, and 140-game endpoint panel.
| 4B condition | Success at checkpoint 75 | Difference from standard prediction reward |
|---|---|---|
| Standard prediction reward | 18 / 140 (12.86%) | Reference |
| Specified GDPO adaptation | 47 / 140 (33.57%) | +20.71 pp |
| Reward-off / standard normalization | 50 / 140 (35.71%) | +22.86 pp |
The specified GDPO adaptation raises success from 18/140 to 47/140, a gain of 29 successful games or +20.71 pp relative to standard prediction rewards. The standard reward-off reference is 50/140. These values identify the direct estimator comparison and the corresponding task-only reference.
The normalization sequence explains the operation being tested. Standard prediction-reward normalization combines components before computing the denominator. The GDPO adaptation constructs component-normalized values first and then combines them. Task outcome, penalty, prediction increment, within-group normalization, and final active-step normalization are all specified, allowing the result to be interpreted in terms of the implemented computation.
The submitted evidence also contains decoupled-cap conditions. Their historical endpoints and references are listed separately because they use their original implementation and training protocol.
| Evidence | Decoupled-condition success | Respective comparison |
|---|---|---|
| Historical decoupled-cap condition 1 | 27.9% | 42.9% historical reference |
| Historical decoupled-cap condition 2 | 32.1% | 40.7% historical reference |
| New step-sample GDPO adaptation | 33.57% | 12.86% standard prediction-reward control at checkpoint 75 |
The new result records the step-sample procedure described above. The historical rows record capped decoupled controls with their respective task references. Presenting these definitions and values together makes the connection to prior decoupling experiments explicit while preserving the comparison represented by each row.
The secondary 4B window gives a mean validation success of 36.46% for the new adaptation and 18.23% for standard prediction rewards. These window summaries complement the 33.57% and 12.86% fixed endpoints. Both measurement views show the improvement associated with this specified decoupled estimator in the reward-enabled setting.
Thank you for emphasizing contribution, related work, and experimental organization. We explain the temporal reward/estimator question through its equations, the complete controlled outcomes, and the specified decoupled-normalization implementation.
Definitions used in this response. For trajectory i and interaction step t, Ti is its number of scored steps, Φi,t∈[0,1] is the scored prediction accuracy, Φi,0=0, and si,t=Φi,t−Φi,t−1. The auxiliary reward is λsi,t with λ=0.1 when enabled; reward-off disables its injection while retaining prediction generation. The terminal task score is qi∈{0,10} and pi,t≥0 is the invalid-action penalty. The step score is xi,t=qi+λsi,t−pi,t. Standard normalization centers and divides by the within-group standard deviation plus ϵ=10−6; mean-only centers without this division. Success is the fraction of evaluated games solved; differences in success rates are reported in percentage points (pp).
Supplementary protocol. The 4B model is Qwen3-4B and the 1.7B model is Qwen3-1.7B. Each condition has one completed training run from the initial model. Fixed endpoints are outer iteration 75 for 4B and 50 for 1.7B, specified before observing their endpoint results; one outer iteration can contain multiple optimizer minibatches. Every endpoint uses the same frozen 140 unique ALFWorld seen games. Training/evaluation temperatures are 1.0/0.4, learning rate is constant at 10−6, and each outer iteration samples eight task groups with four trajectories per group, with a maximum horizon of 50. The prompt/response limits are 1,536/512 tokens with middle prompt truncation. Secondary validation uses 32 episodes per checkpoint. These are fixed-budget supplementary runs, separate from the historical 150/60-update results.