- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a two-stage framework for text-guided zero-shot counting. A text-conditioned localization module first predicts a spatial mask, which is then used to select positive and negative visual exemplars for density regression. The method is evaluated on FSC-147 and a small diagnostic set designed to test text responsiveness.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a meaningful problem: obtaining a plausible count does not necessarily mean counting the objects specified by the prompt. The reported improvement on the diagnostic set is substantial, and the component ablations provide some evidence for the usefulness of gating and positive–negative matching.
Critical weaknesses
-
The implementation details do not describe a consistent model. Section 3.2 uses layers 9, 18, and 27 with feature dimension 1152, while Appendix A.1 specifies SigLIP-2 Base, which has 12 layers and hidden dimension 768. The reported 92M total parameters also appear incompatible with the stated full image–text backbone. More directly, Algorithm 1 applies ReLU immediately before sigmoid, so all mask values must be at least 0.5. Algorithm 2 then selects background exemplars using a threshold strictly below 0.5. As written, the background set is always empty and the background matching operation is undefined. These may be documentation errors, but they need to be reconciled with the implementation used for the reported experiments.
-
The most relevant comparison is missing. T2ICount (CVPR 2025) directly addresses text insensitivity and introduces FSC-147-S to evaluate text-guided counting beyond dominant-category bias. Without comparison to T2ICount, the paper does not establish its advance on its central research question. This matters especially because the main improvement comes from a custom set of only 60 images, while the FSC-147 test MAE improvement over LGCount is just 0.05, with worse validation MAE and test RMSE.
Questions for authors
-
Which exact SigLIP-2 checkpoint was used? Please reconcile the layer indices and feature dimensions with Appendix A.1, and clarify whether the reported parameter count includes both frozen encoders and the second-stage backbone.
-
Does the implemented mask head apply ReLU immediately before sigmoid? If so, how are background exemplars with mask values below 0.5 obtained? If not, please specify the actual operation sequence.
-
Can the authors provide a matched comparison with T2ICount on text responsiveness and counting accuracy? This comparison would materially affect my assessment of the contribution.