- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies an interseting question: can the filtration itself provides more information rather than persistent homology, which requires more time to compute. The authors propose to build a sequence from the filtration and then naturally use a sequence model to downstream machine learing tasks. The sequence contains two major parts: hodgre stream built from the hodge laplacian of each simplical complex in the filtration and persistent rank stream for encoding the relation between different complexes. A third filtration coordinates are also considered. After obtaining the sequence, TCN is used for representation leanring. The proposed FiltSketch is tested on QM7b dataset for molecular property prediction and more traditional datasets like ModelNet10 for classification and regression tasks. Filtsketch is shown to have similar performance with non-topological models on some datasets.
Critical strengths
-
This paper proposes a principled way to learn directly from the filtrtation instead of the filtration->PH->vectorization pipeline. Filtsketch combines local Hodge stream with persistent rank as the sequence and use strandard sequence modeling technique. The hodge stream encodes spectral information and the persisent rank stream encodes the relation between complexes. The later one is an improvement from existing TopoFormer, which did not consider relational information explictly. This is a substantive methodological strength.
-
The results seems promising. The experiments covers molecular property prediction and point cloud classification/regression. These results support the practical usefulness of the proposed combionation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The computational advantage is not analyzed or empircally established. Avoiding exact persistent homology computation is an important motivation. But the paper did not report time complexity of report actual runtime, compared with exact persistent homology computation+vectorization. The peak memory or scaleup test are also not provided. The proposed Filtsketch still needs buliding simplicial complexes and appplying boundary operators. This leaves a central practical advangte insufficiently supported.
-
The comparisons did not isolate the contribution of the sketch representation. Although the Flood PH baseline share the same filtration, they use differernt dienstream model for different vectorization methods: PI uses CNN, ATOL uses XGBoost and FiltSkectch uses TCN. And the FiltSketch on ModelNet10 dataset uses cubical filtration without the corresponding PH baselines. These experiments provided limited evidence for the advantage of Filtsketch.
-
Insufficient comparison with TopoFormer. TopoForm is the cloest work, which uses Betti numbers on graph to build sequence and transformer for sequence modeling. It is a direct comparison of Filtsketch, which uses hodge and persistence rank stream to build sequence and TCN for sequence modeling. With fixed sequnce modeling method TCN/transformrt, the betti stream should be compared with the proposed stream. And with the same stream, different sequence modeling method should be considered.
two less minor points:
-
On the QM7b benchmark, only topological methods (TopoFormer) and Davies (2023) are considered. The comparision with point cloud baselines are missing. And the point cloud baselines are rather old.
-
The ablation study is rather limited on two datasets for two tasks. More datasets could make the reaults more reliable.
Questions for authors
- Can filtration learning method be combined into the proposed Filtsketch pipeline?
- On the only Rocks dataset dataset where topology method outperforms the non-topological point cloud baselines, can the author explain the reason behind this?
- Any stability analysis on the representation?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer CY6o (2/3)
W3: Insufficient comparison with TopoFormer. TopoForm is the cloest work, which uses Betti numbers on graph to build sequence and transformer for sequence modeling. It is a direct comparison of Filtsketch, which uses hodge and persistence rank stream to build sequence and TCN for sequence modeling. With fixed sequnce modeling method TCN/transformrt, the betti stream should be compared with the proposed stream. And with the same stream, different sequence modeling method should be considered.
As requested, we performed a control experiment, where we extend the TopoFormer (Uddin et al., 2026) features (originally Betti-0/1 and vertex, edge counts on graphs) to contain Betti-0/1/2 (obtained from computing PH), as well as the number of vertices, edges, triangles and tetrahedra. We then supply this "feature stream" to our downstream TCN model. Results on Rocks and MCB are given below:
| Model | FiltSketch | TopoFormer-style features |
|---|---|---|
| Rocks | 97.2 ± 1.0 | 95.9 ± 1.0 |
| MCB-C | 77.3 ± 3.0 | 75.4 ± 4.2 |
This shows that this type of feature stream is also competitive under exactly the same downstream (TCN) model but does not match the performance of FiltSketch.
For a comparison with fixed stream (FiltSketch) and different sequence modelling, we refer to our response to W1, where we compare with LSTM, GRU and the same CNN model that was used for the PI baseline but with 2D convolutions replaced by 1D convolutions. Moreover, below, we present an ablation over the different TCN components, to isolate which parts of our sequence modelling approach are relevant.
| FiltSketch | Bal. acc. ↑ | #Param. |
|---|---|---|
| + full (7-layer) TCN, original readout | 0.97 ± 0.01 | 1,588,235 |
| + 1-layer TCN (ks 3), original readout | 0.93 ± 0.02 | 395,144 |
| + 1-layer TCN (ks 3), mean + linear readout | 0.82 ± 0.06 | 261,639 |
| + 1-layer TCN (ks 1), mean + linear readout | 0.73 ± 0.07 | 261,383 |
Overall, we can draw several conclusions from these results: First, the 1-layer TCN retains strong performance (0.93 versus 0.97 balanced accuracy) with approximately 75% fewer parameters, showin that the sketches remain predictive with a substantially shallower backbone. Second, replacing the original readout and nonlinear prediction head with mean pooling and a linear classifier reduces accuracy to 0.82, indicating that aggregation and prediction contribute considerably. Third, restricting the remaining convolution to kernel size one further reduces accuracy to 0.73 while removing only 256 parameters, supporting the value of local cross-timepoint interactions rather than parameter count alone.
In summary, the results demonstrate that useful predictive information is in fact accessible to simpler models, while also showing that the full downstream architecture improves its extraction.
W4 (minor): On the QM7b benchmark, only topological methods (TopoFormer) and Davies (2023) are considered. The comparision with point cloud baselines are missing. And the point cloud baselines are rather old.
In Davies et al., the authors additionally list two neural baselines, DTNN (Schütt et al., 2017) and GGRNN (Shindo & Matsumoto, 2019) which both perform better than the persistent Laplacians and also better than FiltSketch on QM7b. We deliberately only compare against approaches that leverage topological information, but will acknowledge that neural models tend to perform better on this dataset. We however hypothesize that once difference filtrations are combined on QM7b, one may be able to match the neural baselines (like on ModelNet10).
W5 (minor): The ablation study is rather limited on two datasets for two tasks. More datasets could make the reaults more reliable.
We deliberately chose two datasets for our ablation that are quite different in nature, i.e., a point cloud dataset where we use Flood complexes and a graph dataset where we use the supplied Coulomb-matrix filtration. The same two datasets are now also used to assess the impact of using exact persistence ranks vs. our spectral summaries in the persistence rank stream (see Appendix F, Table 5).
Response to Reviewer CY6o (3/3)
Q1: Can filtration learning method be combined into the proposed Filtsketch pipeline?
While we won't rule it out, combining filtration learning with FiltSketch is challenging, and we think that a modified approach where filtration learning is targeted from the start would be more promising than trying to adjust the FiltSketch pipeline. For the latter, we see two immediate obstacles.
- First, we currently preselect the filtration levels , and the sketch depends on the filtration function only through the indicator functions , which are piecewise constant so gradients are zero. In principle, it would be possible to replace them by soft indicators, similar to what is done in (Differentiable Euler Characteristic Transforms for Shape Classification, Röell and Rieck, ICLR 2024), but one would need to look into that.
- Second, computational cost. We would need to backpropagate through the FiltSketch computation, whereas for PH the gradients are given by the persistence pairs, so no backpropagating through the PH computation is necessary.
Q2: On the only Rocks dataset dataset where topology method outperforms the non-topological point cloud baselines, can the author explain the reason behind this?
The neural network baselines fail on the rocks classification task (~50% accuracy on the binary problem). The underlying reason is the nature of the data. The dataset consists of large, dense point clouds containing up to 16 million points that simulate porous media, and was introduced by Graf et al. (NeurIPS 2026) to demonstrate the failure of subsampling based approaches; The class-specific information lies in the pores, i.e., unoccupied regions in the point cloud, but subsampling can only recognize unfilled regions that are larger than the sampling resolution.
The topology methods use Flood complexes to capture the full point cloud, but the neural networks must operate on a substantially smaller subsets due to memory and runtime constraints (following Graf et al., we uniformly sample 2k points).
Q3: Any stability analysis on the representation?
The Hodge stream itself is not stable, i.e., for filtration functions and , there is no bound of the form , where denotes the concatenated Hodge features.
The reason is the same as for homology at isolated filtration levels, i.e., small perturbations in the filtration values of the simplices could move many simplices across a sampled filtration level, and thereby produce large changes in the boundary matrices at that level.
The same reasoning applies to the rank stream, as it also relies on comparing two specific filtration levels, whose boundary matrix can change to a large extent.
Persistent homology instead records the filtration values where Betti numbers (and persistent ranks) change, and the multiset of all birth and death pairs depends Lipschitz-continuously on the filtration function.
Response to Reviewer CY6o (1/3)
We have now included a detailed runtime comparison between FiltSketch and PH+PI, as well as a breakdown of runtime across the different computational steps in Appendix E. For details, we kindly refer to our general comment to all reviewers on runtime and efficiency. Overall, our runtime study shows favorable scaling behavior of FiltSketch with smaller runtime than PH+PI when using the Flood complex and increasing the number of landmarks.
We used the PI+CNN and ATOL+XGBoost combinations, as they typically show strong performance, but we understand that a more systematic analysis on the downstream architecture provides stronger evidence whether the benefits are due to the representation itself. We therefore compare classification performance on the MCB-C dataset for different classification models between the FiltSketch and PI representations. Specifically, we evaluate both on the same CNN architecture that was used for PI in the main experiments (with 2D convolutions replaced by 1D convolutions for FiltSketch) and on MLPs. As non neural network methods we use k-NN, random forest, LightGBM and XGBoost. As additional sequence models for FiltSketch, we use a GRU and an LSTM. All models are trained on the same representations as in the original MCB-C experiment. Model specific hyperparameters are selected based on the validation accuracy on the first split (due to time constraints, we will tune on all splits and update the table).
We see two effects:
We have also added a PH+PI baseline using the same cubical complex filtration as for FiltSketch on ModelNet10, where, for each filtration direction, we compute H0, H1 and H2 PI's and feed them through a ResNet-style CNN. As with FiltSketch, aggregation is done via a DeepSet module and we use the same MLP classification head. We have updated Table 2 with the results, which show that the PH+PI approach also benefits from the cubical filtration, yet classification balanced accuracy remains below that of our FiltSketch approach (84% vs. 92%).
Finally, we want to clarify that we included the cubical complex filtration not to demonstrate an improvement of FiltSketch over other PH methods (which benefit as well from this construction, as can be seen from the added PH + PI result), but to show (1) that FiltSketch works with filtrations other than the Flood complex filtration and (2) that one can indeed almost match the performance of neural baselines with a topological approach.