- Rating
- 3(+2)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce AlameinBench, a turn-based historical wargame benchmark for evaluating long-horizon strategic planning in LLM agents. The benchmark consists of three scenarios involving supply-constrained advances, minefield clearance, and timed withdrawals, each evaluated from both Axis and Allied perspectives. The authors also propose Strategy–Allocation–Execution (SAE), a modular neuro-symbolic reference agent, and evaluate six LLM profiles within this architecture alongside LLM-free heuristic policies and a rule-based self-play baseline.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient experimental rigor: The evaluation relies on a single fixed seed per condition, despite the stochastic nature of the game. Without multiple runs or statistical analysis, it is difficult to assess the reliability of the reported performance differences and model rankings.
- Limited novelty: The proposed benchmark shares similarities with existing wargame benchmarks (e.g., WGSR-Bench [1] and TextWargame [2]), while the SAE architecture builds upon established neuro-symbolic planning approaches (e.g., LLM-Modulo [3]). Although the benchmark combines logistics, phase constraints, and multi-unit coordination, the paper does not clearly establish what novel evaluation capabilities or methodological insights it offers beyond prior work.
- Missing architectural ablations: The paper lacks ablation studies to assess the contributions of individual SAE components, such as strategic decomposition, persistent task management, and symbolic checking. Comparisons against simpler LLM-based agents without SAE are also missing, making it difficult to establish the effectiveness of the proposed architecture.
- Limited benchmark diversity and discriminative power: The benchmark consists of only three fixed scenarios, two playable roles, and a single rule-based opponent, limiting its ability to assess generalizable strategic planning capabilities. Moreover, several conditions yield nearly identical scores across models. For example, in Table 4, five of the six SAE profiles score 35 in September Axis, and five score 55 in October Allies. This raises concerns about whether these conditions meaningfully distinguish agents' strategic capabilities.
- Limited insights into strategic planning capabilities: Although the paper provides score decompositions and selected trajectory analyses, it does not systematically connect performance differences to specific capabilities such as long-horizon planning, resource allocation, and adaptation to opponents. It also remains unclear whether the evaluation distinguishes strategic planning from action frequency and local tactical execution. Consequently, the results characterize task performance more clearly than they reveal models' underlying strategic strengths and weaknesses.
- Insufficient validation of LLM-Judge metrics: The supplementary LLM-Judge metrics, including missed opportunities and plan coherence, lack independent validation against human expert assessments or other objective measures. This raises concerns about their reliability as indicators of strategic planning quality.
References
[1] Qiyue Yin et al., "WGSR-Bench: Wargame-based Game-theoretic Strategic Reasoning Benchmark for Large Language Models," arXiv, 2025. https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.10264
[2] Zilie Chen et al., "TextWargame: A Benchmark Evaluating LLMs on Strategic Reasoning," ICCCS, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICCCS69761.2026.11613233
[3] Subbarao Kambhampati et al., "Position: LLMs Can't Plan, But Can Help Planning in LLM-Modulo Frameworks," ICML, 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01817
Questions for authors
- Role-dependent model behavior: What underlying model characteristics or strategic behaviors explain the Axis–Allies performance differences in Table 5? Could the authors provide trajectory-level evidence to substantiate their claims of model specialization?
- Robustness across opponent policies: All agents are evaluated against the same rule-based opponent. Could the authors additionally evaluate SAE agents against SR0–SR3 to investigate whether the reported performance differences persist across different opponent policies?
4 comments
I thank the authors for mostly addressing my concerns on paper's positioning (novelty), architecture comparison & simpler baselines and diversity & discrimination & judge validity and remaining questions. But, I think claim that seed effects are "small" is unsupported without justification because all results conducted with single runs. So, I recommend the author conduct the multi-seed experiments. In addition, I am not convinced that the authors provided meaningful insights about connection between specific strategic capabilities and the model's capabilities beyond simply reporting the models' scores. Could you provide further analysis linking the scores to concrete strategic capabilities?
Considering the current rebuttal status, I raised the score from clear rejection to weak rejection
Thank you. We added 12 direct GLM-5.3 SAE-versus-SR0 games across all six conditions and two seeds.
1. Central claims (W2-W4). AlameinBench contributes a historically grounded benchmark and auditable protocol; SAE is a reference baseline. SAE is strictly worst in 22/36 cells. Against the best LLM architectures, SR0 ties twice and loses four times. We will revise the Abstract, Sections 6-7, and Conclusion accordingly. Kimi's 17 under SAE versus 60-64 under other architectures makes its weakness configuration-dependent. Model specialization and action-count associations will be scoped to the tested configuration, without claiming SAE superiority or isolated component effects.
2. GLM's -13. We identified and fixed a bug affecting the original run; the corrected score is 56. Both used seed 1942, so this is not a seed comparison. We will correct Table 4, retain the original record, and keep original Judge correlations separate from corrected scores.
3. New experiments (W1, Q2). GLM-SAE directly faced SR0 under seeds 1942/1943 with identical code, prompts, model settings, budgets, and failure handling. Both batches used the same reasoning effort and streaming. Scores below are Axis VP; roles identify GLM's side.
| Scenario | Role | 1942 | 1943 |
|---|---|---|---|
| July | Axis | 28 | 31 |
| July | Allies | 25 | 25 |
| September | Axis | 48 | 45 |
| September | Allies | 44 | 50 |
| October | Axis | 50 | 47 |
| October | Allies | 57 | 57 |
The mean absolute score difference is 2.5 VP, maximum 6 VP. These measurements replace our blanket small-seed-effect claim. As A.3 explains, shared seeds do not align random draws across different action histories; model generation also varies. These results cover GLM-SAE versus SR0, not all-architecture rankings or SR1-SR3 robustness.
4. Reliability and planning (W5). Logs separate transport/protocol errors, rejected proposals, fallback actions, execution, and objective progress. All 12 games reached a final outcome, including eight fallback actions. The 162-move/no-clearance case shows why this separation matters: activity can coexist with no progress on the clearance objective. We will report reliability alongside task progress.
5. Judge (W6). Judge links structured annotations to trajectory evidence. Schema/citation checks establish conformance and traceability. Primary conclusions rely on engine scores and recorded execution; Judge provides auxiliary diagnostics. The six-profile correlation will be presented as exploratory association, not validation of judgment accuracy.
Thank you for the clarification. Based on the recent response, I decided to raise the score from weak reject to weak accept.
We thank the reviewer. Our contribution is AlameinBench, a benchmark simulating First El Alamein, Alam el Halfa, and Second El Alamein in 1942 North Africa. SAE is one baseline.
1. Experimental rigor. We evaluate six models and four architectures across six conditions with a common seed and opponent. The seed controls combat and non-engineer clearance rolls; we consider its overall impact small. Maps, deployments, phases, objectives, and scoring rules are fixed. Engineer clearance is deterministic when eligible; engine events record task outcomes.
2. Novelty. WGSR-Bench reports reasoning subtasks and an interactive example agent; TextWargame emphasizes text interfaces and action hierarchies. AlameinBench jointly links plans, actions, engine effects, score components, and costs over complete campaigns, a protocol absent from the examined WGSR report. This exposes preservation versus interdiction behind an improved defensive score. SAE implements principles related to LLM-Modulo; our contribution is the executable task family and joint diagnostics.
3. Architecture comparisons and simpler baselines. Direct selects actions; Hybrid combines model phase goals, program-generated candidates, and model selection; OAH adds risk-benefit filtering. These three omit SAE's persistent tasks and independent checker. All agents undergo legality checks. These provide explicit system comparisons of planning, candidate filtering, and task management under each architecture's tools and budgets.
Jul/Sep/Oct = July/September/October; A = Axis, L = Allies. Each cell lists Direct/Hybrid/OAH/SAE in final Axis VP.
4. Diversity and discrimination. Supply-qualified advance, coordinated clearance, and timed withdrawal test distinct dependencies from both roles. In the two highlighted conditions, Direct/Hybrid/OAH yield 12 distinct scores spanning 41-71 in September-Axis and 13 spanning 42-62 in October-Allies, across 18 model-architecture results each. These differences demonstrate discrimination within this task family despite SAE's clustering.
5. Strategic capabilities. We connect preparation, unit coordination, resource eligibility, and replanning to resulting task effects. DeepSeek's September-Axis run has 162 moves and nine replans but no clearance points. In July-Axis, DeepSeek remains at scoring column 36, while Sonnet reaches 40 with qualifying supply. These traces distinguish repeated activity from sustained objective progress.
6. Judge validity. Rule-computed outcomes anchor task-success claims; Judge assessments supplement them. Conversion measures confirmed opportunity use, severity grades misses, and coherence assesses within-turn action connections. Rubrics, step citations, duplicate/reference checks, and abstention make outputs inspectable. These checks establish protocol conformance and traceability to recorded steps. SR3's 46/50 conversion (92%) but improvement over SR0 in only one of six conditions shows that opportunity use and campaign success capture distinct outcomes.
Q1. Role-dependent behavior. September scoring records show GPT-6 Astra clears one mine as Axis (3 VP) but allows six to be cleared as Allies (18 VP); Sonnet 5 clears none but allows two (6 VP). In October-Allies, DeepSeek makes no moves or attacks in turns 11-15 while relaxing its withdrawal ceiling; Sonnet makes 16 late moves, and enemy withdrawal rewards are 75 versus 73. All SAE Allied runs avoid isolation penalties. These action and scoring records explain the observed role differences in objective pursuit and denial.
Q2. Different opponents. SR0-SR3 are evaluated baselines facing the common rule-based opponent. They share candidate generation/scoring and vary deterministic or randomized selection, providing heuristic references for model decisions. Keeping the opponent fixed makes task comparisons interpretable across systems. Their zero in-game model calls also anchor cost comparisons. SR0 matches or exceeds the best SAE score in four conditions, providing a direct reference for LLM-based planning.