- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DynPlanBench evaluates long-horizon LLM agents on temporal planning and commitment-aware replanning across 153 executable tasks in logistics, retail, and travel. Even the strongest models reach only ~48.7% success. Models mainly fail in global temporal consistency and commitment-state drift.
Critical strengths
The benchmark is fully executable with deterministic judges, which is important for RL training. And it explicitly models time-indexed world evolution together with persistent commitments after partial execution. Broad evaluation across many frontier models (I really appreciate that!!!). Plenty of ablations (also good!).
Critical weaknesses
Lack of novelty There are already tons of papers on evaluating temporal planning with irreversible commitments as well as adaptive planning. I think what this paper do is simply combining the challenges that previous paper has done, which provides limited novelty.
Lack of experiment details Basically I think the low score cannot be attribute to lack of adaptation abilities. The max turns is 150, which is fairly long, and the context pressure would be high for most models. The paper didn't report the actual turn statistics, and didn't report truncation rate, which is confusing.
Weird evaluation protocol The "Unrecovered errors" are mixing execution grounding ability with adaptation ability. The "Unrecovered errors" for gpt-5.6-sol has 23.3% execution errors, which is actually unbelievable. The author should report the execution error seperately, and honestly I don't think current proprietary models would still have this kind of problem. The author should at least try to optimize the prompt to avoid execution errors related to format or instruction following, so as to emphasis model's problem in adaptive planning.
Questions for authors
I think pass@4 > pass^4 is actually a good thing This provide diversity in models' policy distribution, which reflects that the model could be further RLed. I think actually if it collapsed to fixed behaviour pattern, then somehow it is overfitted to certain pattern in the training time.
The supplementary material is insufficient If the authors could release the whole benchmark, I can consider to raise the score. “Upon acceptance of the paper, we will publicly release the complete benchmark and all tasks.” is not a proper academic behaviour.
6 comments
Response to Reviewer saMK (2/3)
W2: Additional experimental details
We thank the reviewer for this valuable feedback. We have added interaction-length, tool-call, and context statistics, together with analyses of turn-cap hits and context-window truncation in Appendix B.3 "Interaction Length and Context".
1. Interaction, tool-call, and context statistics Following prior work [6], we adopt a maximum budget of 150 interaction turns. Only 7 of the 12,240 trajectories (0.057%) reached this limit, and none reached the context-window limit. We report the interaction-length, tool-call, and peak-context statistics below.
| Model | Mean turns | Max turns | Mean tool calls | Mean peak context | Max peak context |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-5.6 Sol | 18.9 | 53 | 90.1 | 41.7k | 156.2k |
| DeepSeek-V4-Pro | 21.7 | 61 | 75.8 | 37.7k | 102.4k |
| Overall | 24.0 | 150 | 73.5 | 38.4k | 217.0k |
2. Reducing context length does not improve performance. We further evaluated GPT-5.6 Sol and DeepSeek-V4-Pro with a memory variant following the Agentic Memory setting of [6] to reduce context length.
| Model | Full context | Agentic memory | Mean / max peak context (full → memory) |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-5.6 Sol | 44.6% | 43.3% | 41.7k/156.2k → 23.1k/55.0k |
| DeepSeek-V4-Pro | 35.8% | 33.7% | 37.7k/102.4k → 19.9k/43.4k |
Despite substantially shorter contexts, the success rate decreases by 1.3 and 2.1 points, suggesting that excessive context length is unlikely to be the primary cause of the observed failures.
W3: Execution-error analysis and clarification
1. Clarification of Execute errors
Thank you for pointing out the potential conflation between execution and adaptation ability. We clarify that 23.3% represents the proportion of execution errors among all manually annotated unrecovered error instances. Importantly, these errors are not limited to malformed tool calls or schema violations. As detailed in Appendix B.3 "Execute Errors", we classify a failure as an Execute error when an operation has been correctly established in the agent's preceding plan or reasoning, but the tool invocation fails to faithfully realize it. This taxonomy is designed to distinguish failures in deciding what to do from failures in correctly carrying out an otherwise appropriate decision. The breakdown is presented below and has been added to Appendix B.3. We have also included representative execution-error cases in the supplementary materials to illustrate how these failures are identified and categorized.
| Category | Share | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Parameter grounding | 90.9% | Correct decision, right tool, but a parameter value does not match the value the decision requires |
| └ Domain-semantic mapping | 30.3% | A natural-language requirement is mapped to the wrong system value |
| └ Constraint application | 27.3% | A value stated in the task or an event is not carried into the parameter |
| └ Observation utilization | 30.3% | A value available in tool responses is not used |
| └ Plan–action consistency | 3.0% | The plan holds the correct value, but the action uses a different one |
| Other execution errors | 9.1% | Wrong tool for the intended operation, or a violated action order |
| JSON/schema/missing-argument errors | 0% | No unrecovered errors in this category |
2. Execution-focused prompt optimization We added an Execution Checklist to the system prompt: before every write call, the model verifies schema-conformant arguments, copies IDs and categorical values verbatim from tool responses, carries over task-stated values exactly, and confirms each write from its response.
| Model | Original | + Execution Checklist |
|---|---|---|
| GPT-5.6 Sol | 44.6% | 45.1% |
| DeepSeek-V4-Pro | 35.8% | 35.9% |
Among the failed GPT-5.6 Sol trajectories, Execute error instances decreased only from 99 to 87, suggesting that explicit execution guidance has a limited impact on overall performance.
Q1: The gap between Pass@4 and Pass^4
Thank you for this insightful observation. We agree that the gap between Pass@4 and Pass^4 reflects variability in execution across attempts, rather than necessarily indicating a lack of capability. While Pass@4 measures whether an agent succeeds in at least one of four attempts, Pass^4 reflects consistent success across all four attempts. As you pointed out, this variability may also indicate diversity in the agent's policy distribution, suggesting potential for further improvement through RL. Maintaining such diversity may be valuable for avoiding premature convergence to fixed behavior patterns and exploring alternative successful strategies. DynPlanBench provides an executable and reproducible environment for studying how successful behaviors can be reinforced to improve execution consistency.
Q2: Release of the complete benchmark
Thank you for this suggestion. We have made the complete benchmark available in the Supplementary Material to facilitate future research.
Response to Reviewer saMK (3/3)
We hope these clarifications and additional analyses address your concerns. If any questions or concerns remain, we would be pleased to provide further clarification. Thank you again for your valuable time and constructive feedback!
Reference
[1] WebArena: A Realistic Web Environment for Building Autonomous Agents.
[2] VitaBench: Benchmarking LLM Agents with Versatile Interactive Tasks in Real-world Applications.
[3] TCP: a Benchmark for Temporal Constraint-Based Planning.
[4] Gaia2: Benchmarking LLM Agents on Dynamic and Asynchronous Environments.
[5] STT-Arena: A More Realistic Environment for Tool-Using with Spatio-Temporal Dynamics.
[6] VitaBench 2.0: Evaluating Personalized and Proactive Agents in Long-Term User Interactions.
Response to Reviewer saMK (1/3)
Dear Reviewer saMK,
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. Below we address each of your concerns point by point.
Thank you for raising this important concern. We agree that temporal planning, adaptive replanning, and commitment management have been studied in prior work. However, DynPlanBench explores a broader question: what capabilities are essential for agents to reliably accomplish long-horizon tasks in dynamic interactive environments? Rather than focusing on a particular application domain or planning paradigm, DynPlanBench aims to evaluate whether agents can maintain reliable task execution as world states evolve and commitments established by previous actions persist.
Drawing on representative agent benchmarks and interactive-service settings (e.g., WebArena [1] and VitaBench [2]), we instantiate this evaluation through tasks in logistics, retail, and travel. These scenarios serve as evaluation contexts rather than defining the scope of our research.
1. DynPlanBench evaluates two closely related capabilities essential for reliable long-horizon agent execution.
Temporal planning under time-indexed world evolution. DynPlanBench evaluates whether agents can acquire world states at the intended execution times of future actions and incorporate them into temporally feasible multi-step plans. Existing temporal planning benchmarks (TCP [3]) primarily focus on scheduling under time windows and deadlines, while real-time interaction benchmarks (Gaia2 [4]) emphasize timely execution and responses to asynchronous events. Neither specifically evaluates reasoning conditioned on future actions' actual execution times. We implement this capability through deterministic time-indexed functions for world states, allowing the same action to produce different outcomes at different execution times.
Commitment-aware replanning under persistent commitments. DynPlanBench evaluates whether agents can track and manage commitments created by previous actions, and replan when their validity and adjustment costs change over time. Existing adaptive planning benchmarks (STT-Arena [5]) focus on detecting changes, adapting to dynamic constraints, and repairing plans, but do not treat persistent commitments and their time-varying validity and adjustment costs as core evaluation targets. We model submission-type operations as persistent commitment objects with validity and adjustment costs that evolve through time-indexed and event-driven mechanisms, allowing us to evaluate whether agents account for the consequences of modifying previous commitments.
These two capabilities are closely coupled (
Section 5.1 "Task Complexity Analysis"): changes in world states can affect the feasibility of future actions and the validity or adjustment costs of existing commitments, while these commitments constrain the agent's available options when replanning. Thus, DynPlanBench goes beyond combining existing challenges by operationalizing and jointly evaluating their interaction in long-horizon agent execution. To our knowledge, existing LLM-agent benchmarks have not evaluated these requirements together within a unified executable environment. We have expanded the comparison with related work inSection 2 "Related Work"and added a mechanism-level comparison inAppendix A.1 "Comparison with Representative Agent Benchmarks".2. DynPlanBench reveals concrete limitations of frontier models.
Beyond the ablation studies and error analysis in
Section 5 "Analysis & Discussion", we further analyze model interaction trajectories. Across 553k queries, 37.8% return materially time-varying results, yet agents query travel times at the planned departure time in only 11.0% of cases. The inaccessibility rate is 2.6% for road segments verified at departure time, compared with 18.8% for unverified segments. These results indicate insufficient time-conditioned information retrieval and weak temporal consistency between planning and execution.We also find difficulties in managing persistent commitments. Following unexpected events, 98% of runs modify existing commitments, while 27.5% of cancellations incur avoidable penalties. This reveals limitations in accounting for commitment validity and adjustment costs during replanning (
Section 5.2andAppendix C).3. DynPlanBench establishes a foundation for scenario expansion and model training.
We provide executable environments, task data, interaction tools, and deterministic evaluators, supporting direct agent interaction and verifiable execution outcomes. This infrastructure also establishes a foundation for extending the benchmark to additional scenarios and tasks, as well as studying agent training and improvement in dynamic interactive environments.