acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Scaling Dexterous Manipulation via Action Representation Pretraining

Abstract

Large-scale vision, language, and video pretraining has substantially improved the perception and generalization capabilities of robotic manipulation models, but action generation for complex dexterous manipulation remains constrained by the scarcity of robot demonstrations. Limited robot demonstrations must be used to learn both action representations and task-conditioned action distributions, making it difficult to train action representations sufficiently and, in turn, limiting the ability of downstream generative models to generate complex dexterous actions. To address this limitation, we propose ARPG (Action Representation Pretraining and Generation), which explicitly separates action representation learning from action generation: we first pretrain an action representation encoder on large-scale human manipulation data. We then freeze the encoder and train a compact generative backbone (130M parameters) to learn task-conditioned action distributions in the encoder's representation space. Experimental results show that ARPG achieves state-of-the-art performance on the DexJoCo benchmark and improves the average success rate on bimanual dexterous manipulation from 10.1% for π₀.₅ to 44.7%. In a nested data-scaling experiment, downstream performance improves as human-manipulation pretraining data increase from 10 to 500 hours. These results indicate that action representation pretraining provides an independent scaling dimension for improving complex dexterous manipulation.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Embodied AI, Dexterous Manipulation, Action Representation Learning, Scalable Pretraining

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_4g9ROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

ARPG separates action representation learning from policy generation. It pretrains an action encoder by aligning human hand trajectories with frozen video features, then freezes the encoder and trains a robot-specific decoder and a conditional flow model on robot demonstrations. Evaluation covers DexJoCo, three physical manipulation tasks and representation ablations. A nested human-data study finds improved downstream success from 10 to 500 hours, with no further gain at 3,000 hours.

Critical strengths

The representation ablation is the strongest evidence for the method: visual alignment reaches 57.8%, versus 36.4% for Action-MAE and 30.5% for Action-iBOT, with robot data, observations and the downstream generator held fixed (Table 2). This makes the benefit more convincing than the headline comparison with larger policies alone.

The gains extend to physical manipulation: ARPG improves all three real-robot tasks, including coffee-bean pouring from 20.0% to 53.3% over 30 trials per method (Fig. 3). Together with the 44.7% multitask bimanual result on DexJoCo and a 0.46B-parameter deployed model, this gives the approach practical value.

Critical weaknesses

The headline simulation comparison does not establish that execution settings are matched. Baselines are taken from published DexJoCo results, while ARPG uses strict RTC with guidance from the previous action chunk (App. F); without a matched execution comparison, the contribution of this guidance to the bimanual gain remains unclear.

The pretraining budget for the scaling curves is unclear: Table 6 lists both 21,714 steps and three epochs, which cannot both stay fixed as the dataset grows. Since Fig. 4(c) shows that performance depends on training duration, the per-scale schedules are needed to interpret the data-expansion result.

Questions for authors

Does ARPG retain its bimanual advantage with matched action-chunk execution and RTC settings, or when its previous-chunk guidance is disabled? This would separate the representation benefit from execution changes.

What data subset, update count and checkpoint were used for each point in Fig. 4 and for the main model? Please clarify whether the data sweep fixes steps or epochs, and how Table 6 relates to the best reported 10k-step point in Fig. 4(c).

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4g9R(Part 1/3)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation of our work and the constructive suggestions. Your concerns regarding the fairness of action execution protocols and the transparency of scaling experiments are particularly insightful, as these are precisely the aspects that were not sufficiently clarified in our original manuscript. To address these concerns, we have conducted additional experiments and thorough investigations, while also improving the accompanying reproducibility materials. Our detailed responses are provided below.

W1 & Q1: Fair Comparison under a Unified Action Execution Protocol

Does ARPG retain its bimanual advantage with matched action-chunk execution and RTC settings, or when its previous-chunk guidance is disabled? This would separate the representation benefit from execution changes.

Yes, ARPG maintains a substantial advantage in bimanual manipulation even under matched execution protocols.

We fully agree with your concern that differences in execution protocols may introduce biases into performance comparisons. To thoroughly eliminate this potential confounding factor, we re-evaluated ARPG using exactly the same action-chunk execution mechanism as the DexJoCo baseline, while keeping the model weights, environments, and success criteria unchanged. As shown in the table below, ARPG continues to substantially outperform π0.5 on multi-task bimanual manipulation even under matched execution protocols. The additional experimental results are as follows:

MethodSingle-task Bimanual ↑Single-task Overall ↑Multi-task Bimanual ↑Multi-task Overall ↑
π0.5 (DexJoCo, published)35.354.110.135.0
ARPG (Original RTC)44.561.244.657.8
ARPG (Revised Chunk Execution)42.860.245.363.2

These results further support our central argument that the advantage of ARPG fundamentally stems from action representation pretraining rather than differences in execution mechanisms.

Additionally, we observed an interesting phenomenon. Since ARPG performs inference in a pretrained latent space, the final action chunk is obtained by decoding the entire latent representation through the decoder. This means that actions at different timesteps within an action chunk, as well as actions corresponding to different components at the same timestep, are highly coupled. Consequently, the conventional prefix-attention-based RTC guidance mechanism, which operates in the raw action space, cannot guarantee smooth transitions between consecutive action chunks in this setting.

To ensure a rigorous evaluation, we re-evaluated all results using the revised action-chunk execution mechanism while keeping the original model weights unchanged. Accordingly, we have updated the results in Table 1 and Table 11 of Appendix H, and provided detailed descriptions of the execution protocols for each method in Appendix F.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4g9R(Part 2/3)

W2 & Q2: Clarification of Scaling Experiment Configurations and Checkpoint Selection

What data subset, update count and checkpoint were used for each point in Fig. 4 and for the main model? Please clarify whether the data sweep fixes steps or epochs, and how Table 6 relates to the best reported 10k-step point in Fig. 4(c).

We sincerely apologize for the confusion caused by our original manuscript. We acknowledge that the relationship between these experimental settings was not clearly explained: Table 7 reports the complete pretraining configuration for the action encoder trained on 3,000 hours of data, whereas the scaling experiments in Figure 5 use fixed pretraining checkpoints for downstream evaluation.

We have carefully reviewed and summarized the exact configurations for each data point and the main models as follows:

Location / Data PointEncoder Pretraining DataEncoder ParametersEncoder Checkpoint (Updates)DiT Checkpoint (Updates)
Fig. 5(a): Robot-onlyDexJoCo, 8.8h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(a): Human 10hHuman-only, 10h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(a): Human 100hHuman-only, 100h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(a): Human 500hHuman-only, 500h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(a): Human 3000hHuman-only, ~3,000h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(b): 22MHuman-only, 500h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(b): 40MHuman-only, 500h40M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(b): 90MHuman-only, 500h90M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(c): 10kHuman-only, 500h22M10,000120,000
Fig. 5(c): 20kHuman-only, 500h22M20,000120,000
Fig. 5(c): 30kHuman-only, 500h22M30,000120,000
Table 1: Multi-task Main ModelHuman-only, 500h22M10,000120,000
Table 1: Single-task Main ModelsHuman-only, 500h22M10,000Single-arm: 30,000; Bimanual: 50,000

To ensure fair evaluation, we strictly controlled the experimental variables in both the data scaling experiments (Fig. 5a) and the model size scaling experiments (Fig. 5b), consistently using the encoder checkpoint at 10k updates and the DiT checkpoint at 120k updates for evaluation.

Based on these clarifications, we have explicitly distinguished these configurations in Appendix C and Appendix E, and provided a detailed configuration list in Appendix E.

Furthermore, we have conducted a systematic review of the other training and evaluation configurations reported in the manuscript, cross-checking them individually against the original configuration files, training logs, and actual model checkpoints used in the experiments. This ensures that the experimental settings reported in the manuscript are fully consistent with their corresponding implementations.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4g9R(Part 3/3)

Additional Reproducibility Materials

To facilitate the verification of our implementation and experimental results, we have organized and provided the following anonymous materials:

Once again, we sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful and constructive feedback. Your questions have helped us further improve the rigor of our experimental comparisons, the transparency of our training configurations, and the reproducibility of our work. We hope that the additional experiments and supplementary materials adequately address your concerns, and we would greatly appreciate any further comments or discussion.

Dear Reviewer 4g9R,

Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have carefully addressed your concerns in our rebuttal.

As the discussion period is coming to an end, we would greatly appreciate your thoughts on our responses. We would be happy to clarify any remaining concerns.

Thank you again for your time and consideration!

Reviewer_SMRoOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ARPG, a framework that decouples action representation pretraining from downstream action generation for dexterous robotic manipulation. The authors first pretrain an action encoder on large-scale human manipulation data by aligning action representations with visual features extracted from a pretrained video encoder. The pretrained action encoder is then frozen, and an action decoder is trained on robot demonstrations to reconstruct executable actions. A conditional generative policy is subsequently trained using Flow Matching to generate actions in the pretrained latent space rather than directly predicting raw actions. Experiments on the DexJoCo benchmark and real-world dexterous manipulation tasks show that ARPG outperforms existing baselines, particularly on bimanual manipulation tasks. The authors also investigate the scaling of action representation pretraining and demonstrate improved downstream performance when increasing the amount of human manipulation data from 10 to 500 hours.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper is well motivated and clearly presented. Decoupling action representation pretraining from downstream action generation is an interesting approach to leveraging large-scale human manipulation data for dexterous robotic manipulation.

  2. The experimental results are promising, particularly on challenging bimanual manipulation tasks. The paper provides evaluations in both simulation and the real world, along with useful ablation studies comparing different action representation learning methods, which support the effectiveness of vision–action alignment.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper lacks an analysis of robot demonstration data efficiency. Since a key motivation is to mitigate the scarcity of robot demonstrations through human data pretraining, it would be useful to evaluate ARPG under varying amounts of robot training data. Such an ablation would help determine whether pretrained action representations offer greater advantages in low-data settings.
Questions for authors
  1. Regarding W1, how does ARPG perform when the amount of robot demonstration data is reduced? It would be useful to conduct an ablation with varying amounts of robot demonstrations to investigate whether pretrained action representations provide greater benefits in low-data settings.
  2. While Table 2 compares different action representation learning methods, the analysis mainly focuses on downstream success rates. What properties make the learned action representations more suitable for generation? For example, how does the action reconstruction quality of Action-MAE, Action-iBOT, and Visual Alignment relate to their downstream performance?

I would be willing to raise my rating if the authors address my concerns.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer SMRo(Part 1/3)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation of our work and the constructive suggestions. Your questions regarding robot demonstration data efficiency and the intrinsic properties of action representations are highly insightful. Inspired by your feedback, we have conducted additional experiments and further investigated the properties of the action representation space and their influence on downstream generation. Our detailed responses are provided below.

W1 & Q1: Robot Data Efficiency through Action Representation Pretraining

How does ARPG perform when the amount of robot demonstration data is reduced? It would be useful to conduct an ablation with varying amounts of robot demonstrations to investigate whether pretrained action representations provide greater benefits in low-data settings.

ARPG maintains strong dexterous manipulation performance even when the amount of robot demonstration data is substantially reduced.

ARPG aims to explore an alternative to end-to-end policy pretraining that relies on large-scale robot demonstrations, by independently pretraining action representations on more scalable human manipulation data. This design reduces the dependence of action representation learning on robot data. Your suggestion further motivated us to investigate whether this design can also improve robot demonstration data efficiency during downstream training. To this end, we conducted additional data efficiency experiments under the DexJoCo multi-task setting, training ARPG with 5%, 10%, 25%, 50%, and 100% of the robot demonstrations, and evaluating π0.5 with 50% and 100% of the data. The results are shown below:

MethodRobot DataOverall Success ↑
π0.550%30.5%
π0.5100%35.0%
ARPG5%39.6%
ARPG10%40.0%
ARPG25%49.3%
ARPG50%49.1%
ARPG100%63.2%

The results demonstrate that with only 5% of the robot demonstration data, ARPG already outperforms π0.5 trained on the full dataset (39.6% vs. 35.0%). This indicates that pretrained action representations not only improve the final performance achievable with full training data, but also effectively support complex action generation when robot demonstrations are extremely scarce.

Furthermore, inspired by your suggestion, we also sought to investigate whether such representation priors could extend to the parameter efficiency of the generative model. The results are shown below:

DiT ParametersOverall Success ↑
17M29.5%
33M50.5%
68M57.5%
136M63.2%

We find that even when the DiT generation backbone is reduced to only 33M parameters, ARPG still achieves an overall success rate of approximately 51%, surpassing the 35.0% achieved by π0.5. Performance falls below this baseline only when the parameter count is further reduced to 17M.

We believe these findings further highlight the value of action representation pretraining. Although complex dexterous manipulation involves high-dimensional and diverse action trajectories, these trajectories also contain reusable patterns of motion and interaction. ARPG learns these shared patterns from large-scale human manipulation data and incorporates them into the action representation space, allowing downstream generation to leverage pretrained motion and interaction priors. This reduces the dependence of complex action generation on both target-robot demonstrations and generative model capacity, providing an alternative path toward improving robotic manipulation capabilities beyond simply scaling robot data and policy model size.

We have incorporated these additional experiments into Section 5.2 and Figure 4 of the revised manuscript, and further clarified the impact of action representation pretraining on both robot demonstration data efficiency and generative model parameter efficiency.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer SMRo(Part 2/3)

Q2 (Part 1/2): Action Recoverability and Motion–Interaction Semantics

While Table 2 compares different action representation learning methods, the analysis mainly focuses on downstream success rates. What properties make the learned action representations more suitable for generation? For example, how does the action reconstruction quality of Action-MAE, Action-iBOT, and Visual Alignment relate to their downstream performance?

We believe that the advantage of pretrained action representations for generation lies not only in preserving recoverable action information, but more importantly in leveraging large-scale self-supervised learning to embed motion and interaction semantics into the geometric structure of the action space, thereby reducing the difficulty of learning complex action distributions for downstream generative models.

To investigate this hypothesis more thoroughly, we have reorganized and expanded Section 5.4. We first examine the relationship between action recoverability and motion–interaction semantics.

Specifically, to evaluate action recoverability, we freeze the pretrained action encoders and use a single-layer linear head to reconstruct executable actions, measuring reconstruction quality using normalized mean squared error (NMSE).

To assess motion and interaction semantics, we introduce the Sensorimotor Alignment (S²) metric (Xie et al., 2026), which measures structural consistency between visual representations and physical motion. The original work demonstrated a strong positive correlation between this metric and robot manipulation success rates. We further extend S² to the action latent space by comparing the semantic neighborhood structures of action representations and pretrained visual representations, thereby evaluating their consistency in manipulation semantics.

The results are shown below:

RepresentationNMSE ↓S² ↑SR ↑
Raw Action—0.35721.3%
Action-MAE0.0042450.36145.8%
Action-iBOT0.0268410.36643.6%
Visual Alignment0.0437620.38163.2%

An interesting observation is that action reconstruction error does not exhibit a consistent relationship with downstream generation performance, whereas S² shows a more consistent positive trend.

A higher S² score indicates that the action space can better organize actions with similar manipulation semantics and capture information relevant to interactions with the environment.

This suggests that the manipulation and interaction semantics encoded in action representations may be a more critical factor influencing downstream generation performance.

We have incorporated comparisons of action reconstruction quality (NMSE) and Sensorimotor Alignment (S²) into Section 5.4 and Table 2(a) of the revised manuscript to further analyze the intrinsic properties of action representations and their relationship with downstream generation performance.

References

Yunfei Xie, Howard H. Qian, Shiyi Lan, Kaiyu Hang, and Chen Wei. Sensorimotor Alignment: A Platonic Proxy for Embodied Policy Success. arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.31670, 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.31670.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer SMRo(Part 3/3)

Q2 (Part 2/2): Generation-Space Geometry and Its Impact on Action Generation

In Q2 (Part 1/2), we found that the organization of motion and interaction semantics within action representations may play a more important role in downstream generation than action reconstruction quality.

To further investigate how the geometric structure of the generation space affects downstream action generation, we designed an experiment involving invertible space transformations, allowing us to examine the effects of different geometric transformations on generation performance while preserving the recoverability of action information.

Specifically, we apply three invertible transformations to the generation spaces of Raw Action and ARPG, respectively, and recover the generated actions using the corresponding inverse transformations.

Among these transformations, Orthogonal Rotation changes only the coordinate orientation, Anisotropic Scaling alters distances between samples while preserving linear relationships, and Nonlinear Twist further changes the relative geometric structure among samples.

The results are shown below:

TransformationRaw Action ↑ARPG ↑
Original21.3%63.2%
Orthogonal Rotation21.5%52.6%
Anisotropic Scaling0.0%57.3%
Nonlinear Twist18.4%0.0%

The results demonstrate that even when action information remains recoverable through inverse transformations, modifying the geometric structure of the generation space can still significantly affect downstream generation performance.

For ARPG, orthogonal rotation and anisotropic scaling lead to some performance degradation, whereas Nonlinear Twist causes the success rate to drop dramatically from 63.2% to 0%.

We believe that ARPG's generative advantage may arise from the relative organization of actions within the pretrained representation space. In such a space, actions with similar motion and interaction semantics can form more structured neighborhood relationships, and transitions between action patterns become more continuous and smooth, thereby substantially reducing the difficulty of learning complex action distributions for the generative model.

Taken together, these experiments suggest that the advantage of action representation pretraining lies in embedding motion and interaction semantics into the geometric structure of the action space through self-supervised learning. This enables actions with similar manipulation semantics to form more structured relative relationships within the representation space, thereby reducing the difficulty of learning complex action distributions for downstream generative models.

We have introduced additional experiments on invertible geometric transformations of the generation space in Section 5.4 and Table 2(b) of the revised manuscript to further explain the geometric properties of the action representation space and their influence on downstream generation performance.

Once again, we sincerely thank you for your insightful and constructive feedback. Your questions regarding robot data efficiency and representation properties have not only helped us more comprehensively evaluate the practical value of ARPG, but also motivated us to gain deeper insights into the geometric and semantic mechanisms underlying action representation pretraining. We hope that these additional experiments and in-depth analyses adequately address your concerns. We would also greatly appreciate any further comments on these new findings and look forward to learning from your insights in the continued discussion.

Reviewer_djV4OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ARPG (Action Representation Pretraining and Generation), a decoupled way of separating the learning of action representations and robot dexterous actions. The model is composed of an action encoder pretrained on large-scale human demonstration data and a generative action module to give actual robot actions. The results show a clear benefit of using a pretrained action encoder and a clear beneficial curve when scaling up the human data from 10 to 500 hours.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper brings a new perspective on decoupling action and low-level action representations, which gives a clean way of using human data. This method has the potential to unlock the use of massive amounts of human demonstration data.
  2. It also shows the improvement of their vision-action representation learning method over training without using human data and other sefl-supervised learning method in pretraining.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The data scaling analysis is not comprehensive or complete. The experimental results show that the scaling gains stop at 500h and performance drops at 3000h. Although the gains from scaling to 500h are impressive, readers might want to see what happens between 500h and 3000h and what the limit of scaling on this data is. It also seems that the authors use the 22M model for data scaling, which naturally raises the question of whether a larger model could further push the boundary beyond this 500h limit. Since the paper title is about scaling, I would expect a more thorough scaling experiment here; right now, it feels limited.
Questions for authors
  1. When reading the paper, I am curious about how the model handles multi-task scenarios. The paper says “task-conditioned,” but it seems that the only prompt is the image prompt. Does the model learn what to do by distinguishing between different scenarios/image inputs? If we change the scenarios/room, will the model still behaves well?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer djV4(Part 1/2)

We sincerely thank you for your careful evaluation and constructive suggestions. Your concerns about action representation scaling and multi-task performance under scene variations are insightful.To address these concerns, we have conducted additional joint scaling experiments and more challenging visual robustness evaluations. Our detailed responses are provided below.

W1: Further Analysis of Data and Model Scaling

The data scaling analysis is not comprehensive or complete. The experimental results show that the scaling gains stop at 500h and performance drops at 3000h. Although the gains from scaling to 500h are impressive, readers might want to see what happens between 500h and 3000h and what the limit of scaling on this data is. It also seems that the authors use the 22M model for data scaling, which naturally raises the question of whether a larger model could further push the boundary beyond this 500h limit. Since the paper title is about scaling, I would expect a more thorough scaling experiment here; right now, it feels limited.

Our additional experiments show that increasing model capacity does not overcome the current performance ceiling, whereas expanding the behavioral diversity of pretraining data appears to be a more effective direction for scaling.

In Figure 5 of the revised manuscript, we independently analyze three dimensions of scaling: pretraining data size, model capacity, and pretraining compute. To further address your question regarding the interaction between data scale and model capacity, we conducted additional joint scaling experiments. Results are shown below:

Pretraining DataBase (22M)Medium (40M)Large (90M)
500h63.2%57.5%55.5%
3000h59.6%52.2%50.4%

Furthermore, we introduced an additional 1,000-hour dataset with approximately the same task distribution as the 500-hour dataset, increasing the number of samples from existing tasks without substantially expanding behavioral coverage.

Encoder500h1000h3000h
Base (22M)63.2%56.7%59.5%

These results indicate that simply increasing the amount of data from existing manipulation tasks does not consistently improve downstream generation performance.

We hypothesize that this phenomenon may arise from two factors. First, our contrastive learning objective treats unpaired video–action samples as negative pairs. Consequently, semantically or kinematically similar manipulation sequences may also be treated as negatives, introducing potential false negatives during representation learning. Second, adding more samples from existing tasks does not necessarily introduce new motion patterns or interaction relationships.

Meanwhile, increasing model capacity also fails to surpass the current best performance. One possible explanation is that our pretraining objective primarily enforces sequence-level vision–action alignment, whereas the downstream generative model operates on token-level temporal action representations. The trade-off between global semantic representations and fine-grained structural information has long been a challenge in representation learning. Continued pretraining may improve global semantic performance while degrading local feature quality (Siméoni et al., 2025). For generative tasks, the local structure of representations can be more indicative of their utility for generation than global semantic performance (Singh et al., 2026). Consequently, increasing model capacity or pretraining compute may further improve global representation alignment without necessarily enhancing the fine-grained information required for downstream action generation.

Taken together, our findings suggest that expanding the behavioral diversity of pretraining data may be a more effective scaling direction. We have included these additional results and analyses in Appendix H of the revised manuscript.

References

Oriane Siméoni, Huy V. Vo, Maximilian Seitzer, Federico Baldassarre, Maxime Oquab, Cijo Jose, Vasil Khalidov, Marc Szafraniec, Seungeun Yi, Michaël Ramamonjisoa, Francisco Massa, Daniel Haziza, Luca Wehrstedt, Jianyuan Wang, Timothée Darcet, Théo Moutakanni, Leonel Sentana, Claire Roberts, Andrea Vedaldi, Jamie Tolan, John Brandt, Camille Couprie, Julien Mairal, Hervé Jégou, Patrick Labatut, and Piotr Bojanowski. DINOv3. arXiv preprint arXiv:2508.10104, 2025. https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.10104.

Jaskirat Singh, Xingjian Leng, Zongze Wu, Liang Zheng, Richard Zhang, Eli Shechtman, and Saining Xie. What matters for Representation Alignment: Global Information or Spatial Structure? In International Conference on Learning Representations, 2026a. https://proceedings.iclr.cc/paper_files/paper/2026/hash/3929a7785bd56f57edcff0152ab41289-Abstract-Conference.html.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer djV4(Part 2/2)

Q1: Multi-task Dexterous Manipulation and Robustness to Scene Variations

When reading the paper, I am curious about how the model handles multi-task scenarios. The paper says “task-conditioned,” but it seems that the only prompt is the image prompt. Does the model learn what to do by distinguishing between different scenarios/image inputs? If we change the scenarios/room, will the model still behaves well?

Yes. ARPG performs multi-task action generation by leveraging task-relevant information from visual observations and robot proprioceptive states, and maintains manipulation capabilities under more challenging visual conditions.

We would first like to clarify that ARPG primarily focuses on improving complex dexterous action generation, rather than open-world semantic understanding or generalization. Accordingly, we adopt a relatively simple architecture with DiT as the core generative backbone, using only visual observations and proprioceptive states as conditioning inputs, without explicit task IDs or language instructions. The model learns task-conditioned behavior implicitly by capturing the relationships between visual scenes, object configurations, and corresponding actions.

Despite not incorporating an additional language understanding module, ARPG demonstrates strong multi-task modeling capabilities. As shown in Table 1, while π0.5 experiences a substantial performance drop under multi-task training (54.1% → 35.0%), ARPG instead benefits from joint multi-task training, improving its overall success rate from 60.2% to 63.2%, substantially outperforming π0.5. Furthermore, our real-world robot experiments also employ joint multi-task training, enabling a unified policy to perform three long-horizon bimanual dexterous manipulation tasks.

To further address your question regarding scene variations, we conducted additional experiments under the more challenging rand-full setting of DexJoCo. Compared with the rand-obj setting used in the original manuscript, which randomizes object positions and table height, rand-full introduces additional visual variations, including camera poses, lighting directions and colors, and tabletop textures, to evaluate ARPG's performance under more complex visual conditions.

The additional results are summarized below:

TrainingMethodrand-obj Overall ↑rand-obj Bimanual ↑rand-full Overall ↑rand-full Bimanual ↑
Single-taskπ0.554.135.340.3031.86
Single-taskARPG60.242.845.8228.80
Multi-taskπ0.535.010.1——
Multi-taskARPG63.245.349.8239.20

The results show that ARPG maintains good dexterous manipulation performance even under more challenging visual randomization.

Notably, ARPG continues to benefit from joint multi-task training under the rand-full setting. Its overall success rate increases from 45.82% to 49.82%, while its bimanual success rate improves from 28.80% to 39.20%. These findings further demonstrate ARPG's multi-task modeling capabilities under complex visual conditions.

Overall, these results indicate that ARPG can effectively learn multiple complex dexterous manipulation tasks using only visual and proprioceptive conditioning, without relying on explicit language instructions or a large-scale vision–language model (VLM).

We have included the additional rand-full experiments and their evaluation settings in Appendix H of the revised manuscript to more clearly demonstrate ARPG's multi-task capabilities and robustness to scene variations.

We sincerely appreciate your rigorous and insightful feedback. Your questions have encouraged us to more comprehensively examine the limits of scaling and the properties of multi-task representations, substantially improving the depth and rigor of our analysis.

Dear Reviewer djV4,

Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have carefully addressed your concerns in our rebuttal.

As the discussion period is coming to an end, we would greatly appreciate your thoughts on our responses. We would be happy to clarify any remaining concerns.

Thank you again for your time and consideration!

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Rebuttal and Key Revisions

We sincerely thank all reviewers for their careful evaluations and highly constructive feedback. Their insightful comments have motivated us to conduct more in-depth investigations and extensive additional experiments. We have substantially revised the manuscript and summarize the key improvements below:

  1. Demonstrating Strong Data and Parameter Efficiency: Our additional experiments show that ARPG, trained with only 5% of the robot demonstration data, already outperforms π0.5 trained on the full dataset. Furthermore, ARPG maintains strong performance even when the generative backbone is reduced to only 33M parameters. (See Section 5.2 and Figure 4; addressing Reviewer SMRo.)
  2. Providing Deeper Insights into Action Representation Properties: We introduce action reconstruction error, the S² metric, and invertible space transformation experiments. Our findings suggest that the structured neighborhood relationships within the action representation space, which encode motion and interaction semantics, may play a more critical role in downstream generation performance than action recoverability alone. (See Section 5.4, Tables 2(a) and 2(b), and Appendix I; addressing Reviewer SMRo.)
  3. Validating Multi-Task Robustness under Scene Variations: We conduct additional experiments under the more challenging DexJoCo rand-full setting. The results demonstrate that ARPG maintains strong multi-task manipulation performance under more complex visual conditions, without relying on explicit language instructions. (See Appendix H, Table 12; addressing Reviewer djV4.)
  4. Clarifying Evaluation Fairness and Experimental Transparency: We re-evaluate ARPG using an action-chunk execution protocol matched to the baseline, under which the multi-task overall success rate improves from 57.8% to 63.2%. This effectively controls for potential confounding effects introduced by execution protocol differences and provides stronger evidence that ARPG's performance advantage stems from pretrained action representations. We also clarify the configurations and checkpoint selections for all scaling experiments. (See Table 1, Appendix E, Table 9, and Appendix F; addressing Reviewer 4g9R.)
  5. Providing Comprehensive Reproducibility Materials: To facilitate verification and reproducibility, we have made the following anonymous resources available:

Once again, we sincerely appreciate the reviewers' insightful observations and constructive suggestions. We have submitted the revised manuscript, with all revisions highlighted in red for ease of review. We believe that these substantial improvements further strengthen the experimental rigor, reproducibility, and scientific contributions of our work, and that ARPG offers a valuable and promising direction for advancing complex dexterous manipulation.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.