- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents DexBeyond, a framework for scaling dexterous manipulation data through a combination of large-scale human hand-object interaction collection, motion generation, and iterative simulation-based data expansion. The framework consists of three components: DexBeyond-D, a real-world hand-object interaction dataset; DexBeyond-G, a conditional diffusion model for generating interaction trajectories conditioned on object geometry and motion descriptions; and DexBeyond-FW, an iterative flywheel that refines, filters, and expands generated interactions for unseen objects through simulation rollouts.
Critical strengths
-
The scale and coverage of DexBeyond-D are impressive for dexterous hand-object interaction data. Compared with prior datasets focused on grasping or smaller-scale in-hand manipulation, the dataset substantially expands both object diversity and continuous interaction diversity. The combination of long-horizon interaction sequences, reconstructed MANO trajectories, and object meshes makes the resource potentially useful for multiple downstream problems beyond the specific experiments in the paper.
-
The paper presents a fairly comprehensive end-to-end system for scaling dexterous manipulation data. In addition to collecting real interaction data, the authors integrate motion generation, geometry-aware refinement, feasibility filtering, and iterative rollout expansion into a unified pipeline. While many components build on existing ideas, the overall system is well engineered and the experimental section is reasonably thorough, including downstream controller evaluation in both simulation and limited real-world deployment.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty appears relatively limited compared with the scale of the system. Many core components, including conditional diffusion-based HOI generation, geometry-aware contact and penetration losses, simulation-based feasibility filtering, and iterative rollout expansion, have strong precedents in prior work on hand-object interaction generation and robotic data flywheels. As a result, the main contribution seems to come more from engineering integration, scaling, and dataset construction rather than from fundamentally new modeling or learning ideas. While the resulting system is comprehensive, it is less clear what the key conceptual advance is beyond combining existing ingredients at larger scale.
-
The claims around unseen-object generalization rely heavily on simulation-based refinement and evaluation. DexBeyond-FW generates candidate interactions, filters them through Isaac Gym-based physical checks, and improves performance through iterative simulation rollouts, but the paper provides only limited real-world validation. Given the well-known sim-to-real challenges in dexterous in-hand manipulation, especially for contact-rich finger coordination and friction-sensitive interactions, it remains unclear whether the generated “physically feasible” interactions correspond to robust real-world behaviors. This concern is important because a central claim of the paper is scalable generalization to unseen objects without additional demonstrations, yet this capability is not convincingly validated outside simulation.
Questions for authors
-
The paper positions DexBeyond-FW as enabling generalization to unseen objects without additional demonstrations. However, all iterative refinement and rollout expansion are performed in simulation. Do the authors have any evidence that the synthesized interactions for unseen objects transfer to real-world execution, even qualitatively? This would substantially affect the strength of the paper’s central claim.
-
The text prompts are automatically constructed from discretized object translation and rotation statistics extracted from the target trajectories. Could the authors clarify how much the generation task depends on these tightly coupled motion descriptors? In particular, how different is this setting from conditioning directly on low-level motion summaries rather than semantic language-guided interaction generation?
-
Many components of the framework appear closely related to prior HOI generation and robotic data flywheel pipelines. Could the authors clarify which components they believe provide the primary conceptual advance beyond scaling and system integration?
This is still a relatively underexplored area. I would like to raise my score if clearer evidence around novelty are offered.
5 comments
Response to W2 and Q1: Real-World Generalization, Physical Feasibility, and Sim-to-Real Transfer of DexBeyond-FW [2/3]
W2 & Q1: Real-World Generalization to Unseen Objects
W2: DexBeyond-FW generates candidate interactions, filters them through Isaac Gym-based physical checks, and improves performance through iterative simulation rollouts, but the paper provides only limited real-world validation.
Q1: Do the authors have any evidence that the synthesized interactions for unseen objects transfer to real-world execution, even qualitatively?
R2 (W2/Q1). We provide additional real-world experiments to address your concern regarding the transferability of DexBeyond-FW.
(1) Why real-world FW results were not originally presented. We clarify that DexBeyond-FW is evaluated using real captured interaction trajectories, rather than generated trajectories. In DexBeyond-FW, all target-object demonstrations are excluded from generator training, controller training, and flywheel updates, and are reserved for evaluation. Thus, our original simulation evaluation already measures the ability to track real captured interactions on unseen objects, with the sim-to-real gap being the primary additional challenge in physical deployment.
(2) Additional real-world validation. We deploy DexBeyond-FW on the SharpaWave robotic hand and compare the reported sim-to-real SR retention across three training strategies:
| Training Data | Simulation SR↑ | Real-World SR↑ | Retention↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Real Data | 60.2% | 42.1% | 69.9% |
| Real + Generated Data | 69.1% | 54.4% | 78.7% |
| DexBeyond-FW | 40.7% | 29.8% | 73.2% |
DexBeyond-FW retains approximately 73.2% of its simulation SR, comparable in magnitude to the reported ratios of real-data-based controllers. Although the evaluation object sets differ, these results suggest that FW-generated interactions do not introduce disproportionately severe sim-to-real degradation.
(3) Qualitative comparison. In DexBeyond-FW evaluation, we compare ring-object manipulation under three settings: (1) FW-trained controller in simulation, (2) real-data-trained controller in the real world, and (3) FW-trained controller in the real world. The two real-world controllers exhibit similar manipulation patterns, supporting the real-world transferability of FW-generated interactions.
Together, these results demonstrate that DexBeyond-FW supports real-world manipulation of unseen objects without additional target-object demonstrations for training, with comparable relative sim-to-real transfer performance.
W2: Physical Feasibility and Sim-to-Real Transfer
W2: Given the well-known sim-to-real challenges in dexterous in-hand manipulation, especially for contact-rich finger coordination and friction-sensitive interactions, it remains unclear whether the generated "physically feasible" interactions correspond to robust real-world behaviors.
R3 (W2). We clarify the role of simulation-based feasibility evaluation and our sim-to-real transfer strategy.
(1) Simulation-based dexterous manipulation. Training dexterous controllers in simulation and transferring them to real robots is a widely established approach, particularly because collecting large-scale real-world demonstrations for high-DoF in-hand manipulation is challenging.
Our PFD follows this paradigm, combining geometric checks with 10–20 physics simulation steps to detect penetration, slipping, or ejection. Its purpose is to provide physically feasible and trackable reference subgoals for controller training and exploration, rather than guarantee real-world success.
(2) Preparing for sim-to-real transfer. To address actuator latency, joint noise, friction, and object-property variations, we apply domain randomization during controller training, including joint noise, external forces, wrist orientation perturbations, and variations in object density and friction. These measures improve robustness to simulation inaccuracies.
(3) Real-world transfer results. As shown in R2, DexBeyond-FW achieves 40.7% SR in simulation and 29.8% in the real world, retaining approximately 73.2% of its simulation SR. Additional demonstrations are provided in real-world evaluation and DexBeyond-FW.
Therefore, PFD provides feasible reference subgoals rather than guaranteed real-world execution, while our additional experiments demonstrate that the resulting interactions can successfully transfer to unseen objects despite the sim-to-real gap.
Response to Q2: Motion-Intensity vs. Semantic Conditioning and Language-Based Prompt Ablation [3/3]
Q2: Motion-Intensity Prompts versus Semantic Language Conditioning
Q2: The text prompts are automatically constructed from discretized object translation and rotation statistics extracted from the target trajectories. Could the authors clarify how much the generation task depends on these tightly coupled motion descriptors? In particular, how different is this setting from conditioning directly on low-level motion summaries rather than semantic language-guided interaction generation?
R4 (Q2). We emphasize that motion-intensity conditioning is a deliberate choice aligned with our goal of expanding interaction diversity, rather than generating predefined semantic behaviors.
(1) Why motion-intensity prompts? Compared with high-level behavior labels, motion-intensity descriptions directly characterize object translation and rotation magnitudes over two temporal segments, providing finer control over in-hand motion diversity. These descriptions are derived from captured trajectories during training, while the desired conditions can be specified at inference time.
(2) Comparison with semantic conditioning. We additionally train a separate DexBeyond-G variant using behavior-label prompts and compare both strategies:
| Method | Pen.↓ | Cont.↑ | Cells↑ | RS↑ | FS↑ | FST↑ | PCT/s↑ | CMT/s↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Motion-intensity levels | 0.11 | 92.51 | 33.04 | 154.84 | 26.12 | 31.45 | 7.28 | 4.98 |
| Behavioral semantics | 0.12 | 95.54 | 18.91 | 56.74 | 18.74 | 24.70 | 6.03 | 3.06 |
Motion-intensity conditioning outperforms behavioral conditioning on all six interaction-diversity metrics, supporting our choice for diversity expansion. In contrast, behavioral conditioning enables specified semantic interactions but offers less direct control over motion characteristics. Qualitative results are provided in DexBeyond-G (template) and DexBeyond-G (behavior).
(3) Why language-based prompts instead of discrete values? We compare T5-based motion-intensity prompts with direct discrete conditioning using Prompt-acc. Specifically, we extract the maximum object translation and rotation from each of the two segments of a generated trajectory, discretize them using the same intensity thresholds as the input prompts, and compute the matching accuracy for translation, rotation, and their joint agreement (Both).
| Method | Translation↑ | Rotation↑ | Both↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discrete | 44.62% | 71.82% | 33.18% |
| Ours (T5) | 46.81% | 81.22% | 39.94% |
Our T5-based prompts outperform discrete conditioning across all three metrics. Moreover, natural-language conditioning can be readily extended to higher-level semantic interaction generation, offering greater flexibility than task-specific discrete codes.
Thus, our prompts are intentionally structured motion descriptions rather than unrestricted semantic instructions, better serving our objective of scaling interaction diversity while retaining the flexibility of language-based conditioning.
We hope these additional experiments and clarifications address your concerns regarding methodological novelty, real-world generalization, physical feasibility, and motion conditioning. We would appreciate your reconsideration of the assessment.
Response to W1 and Q3: Methodological Novelty, Conceptual Contributions, and the Data-Centric Flywheel Framework [1/3]
We thank the reviewer for the detailed review. We clarify the conceptual contributions of DexBeyond and provide additional experimental evidence below.
W1 & Q3: Methodological Novelty and Conceptual Contributions
R1 (W1/Q3). We would like to emphasize that DexBeyond is not simply an engineering integration of existing modules, but a unified, data-centric framework for scaling dexterous manipulation across interaction and object diversity.
Conceptual distinction and design rationale. Existing HOI generation methods (e.g., Text2HOI, LatentHOI) primarily focus on motion synthesis, while robotic data flywheels (e.g., DexFlyWheel) emphasize policy improvement through iterative learning and rollouts. In contrast, DexBeyond investigates how to systematically scale dexterous manipulation data itself.
We argue that a framework with genuine scaling and self-improvement potential must address three interdependent challenges: (1) establishing a high-quality data foundation, (2) expanding interaction diversity beyond captured demonstrations, and (3) generalizing to unseen objects through iterative feedback. These requirements motivate DexBeyond-D, DexBeyond-G, and DexBeyond-FW, respectively. The components are therefore designed to overcome successive bottlenecks, rather than arbitrarily assembled.
(1) DexBeyond-D: Establishing the data foundation. Scaling first requires high-quality, diverse interaction data, which existing datasets provide only to a limited extent. We construct DexBeyond-D with 58.03 hours of interactions, 219 objects across 77 categories, and 30 behaviors, providing 46.8× more interaction duration and 12.8× more object categories than DexterHand, the closest dataset in scope.
(2) DexBeyond-G: Expanding interaction diversity. However, even large-scale collection cannot exhaustively cover all valid interactions, while additional demonstrations are costly. We therefore develop DexBeyond-G to generate diverse interactions conditioned on object geometry and motion descriptions, improving downstream controller SR from 60.2% to 69.1% (Table 2).
(3) DexBeyond-FW: Generalizing to unseen objects. Although DexBeyond-G can propose interactions for unseen objects, these often contain penetration, missing contacts, and self-collisions, making them unsuitable for direct controller training. This motivates DexBeyond-FW, which uses geometric refinement (GR), physical feasibility detection (PFD), cross-round merge (CRM), and iterative rollouts to transform these proposals into feasible interaction data. Successful rollouts are fed back into the generator, enabling self-improvement without additional demonstrations for unseen objects.
To isolate the contribution of generator updates, we introduce a fixed-generator baseline, where the generator remains frozen after round 1, with matched controller-training budgets and identical test references:
The full flywheel substantially outperforms the fixed-generator baseline (40.7% vs. 12.2%). Furthermore, removing GR+PFD or CRM reduces SR from 44.3% to 19.2% or 14.3%, respectively, in the separate three-object ablation (Table 5), demonstrating their essential roles in effective data expansion.
In summary, our primary conceptual contribution is a closed-loop framework that connects real interaction data, geometry-conditioned generation, and physically grounded self-improvement to progressively scale both interaction and object coverage.