- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FakeFlow, a Flow Matching-based generative classification framework that improves the cross-generator generalization of AI-generated image detection by formulating classification, unlike traditional discriminative methods that map visual features directly to real or fake labels, as an image-conditioned continuous transport process in label space. Specifically, the authors design two complementary parameterizations—FakeFlowDrift, which directly predicts the trajectory velocity field, and FakeFlowLeap, which predicts the target label vector and converts it into an update velocity—and introduce Classifier-Free Guidance (CFG) to enhance the influence of image-conditioned information on the final prediction. Experiments on four benchmarks—GenImage, AIGI-Holmes, AIGI-Now, and In-the-Wild—demonstrate strong generalization to unseen generators and real-world scenarios.
Critical strengths
-
Innovative classification modeling. The key contribution is reformulating binary classification as a generative flow-matching process in label space. Rather than focusing on visual feature extraction or forgery-trace modeling, the authors start from the classification decision process itself, offering a new perspective for cross-generator generalization.
-
Clear technical motivation for dual parameterization. FakeFlowDrift and FakeFlowLeap adopt velocity-field and target-label prediction, respectively. Though equivalent in ideal single-step form, their different training objectives and temporal error weighting yield different generalization characteristics, enriching both the method and the analysis of flow-matching parameterization.
-
CFG with theoretical analysis enhances completeness. CFG is applied to label-space classification, with a control-variate analysis of its role in reducing initial-state fluctuations, providing mathematical grounding for the design.
Critical weaknesses
-
The explanation of the generalization mechanism could be strengthened. Why continuous trajectory supervision adapts better to unseen generators than traditional classification objectives remains insufficiently explained. Intuitive analysis is suggested.
-
The performance gap between the two parameterizations is under-discussed. FakeFlowLeap performs better on multiple generator benchmarks, while FakeFlowDrift excels on In-the-Wild. Further discussion in light of training objectives and temporal error weighting is suggested.
-
Computational efficiency analysis could be improved. Despite single-step inference, a direct comparison with the DINOv3 linear baseline in inference latency and computational overhead is missing.
-
CFG's effect varies across datasets. Ablations show CFG does not always help; on In-the-Wild, FakeFlowLeap even degrades. Further explanation of CFG's applicable conditions is suggested.
Questions for authors
-
Since FakeFlow uses single-step inference, can the authors explain why continuous label-trajectory supervision during training yields better cross-generator generalization than direct label regression?
-
Do the authors attribute the performance gap between FakeFlowDrift and FakeFlowLeap mainly to their different temporal error weighting mechanisms?
-
With a frozen DINOv3 encoder, how dependent is the method on the visual backbone? Would label-space flow matching still yield similar gains with smaller or other pre-trained visual models?
-
Can the authors compare FakeFlow with the DINOv3 linear baseline in inference latency and computational complexity to clarify deployment efficiency?
-
Since FakeFlow starts from a random Gaussian state, can the authors analyze the impact of initial noise on classification—e.g., reporting prediction consistency and accuracy variance across multiple random initial states to verify single-step stability?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer cqp6
Q4: Under what conditions is CFG applicable?
Response: We thank the reviewer for the question. CFG amplifies the difference between image-conditioned and unconditional predictions, thereby strengthening the model’s existing discriminative tendency.
As shown in RF4, both variants benefit from CFG on the three generator-based benchmarks. On In-the-Wild, Drift still benefits, improving from 94.43% to 94.87%, whereas Leap’s accuracy decreases from 93.36% to 92.78%. This behavior is consistent with CFG reinforcing Leap’s closer fitting of generator-produced forgery patterns.
RF4. Effect of CFG on detection accuracy (%). Bold indicates the better result within each variant.
| Method | CFG | GenImage | AIGI-Holmes | AIGI-Now | In-the-Wild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FakeFlow-Drift | Without | 96.72 | 97.45 | 87.62 | 94.43 |
| FakeFlow-Drift | With | 97.05 | 97.77 | 88.65 | 94.87 |
| FakeFlow-Leap | Without | 96.98 | 97.73 | 89.12 | 93.36 |
| FakeFlow-Leap | With | 97.54 | 98.24 | 91.60 | 92.78 |
Q5: How much does the method depend on the backbone, and does it still help with smaller or other backbones?
Response: We thank the reviewer for the question. We replace the backbone with the smaller DINOv3 ViT-L/16 and with another pretrained model, CLIP ViT-L/14@336px, keep the training data and preprocessing unchanged, and retrain the linear baseline, FakeFlow-Drift, and FakeFlow-Leap, as shown in RF5 and RF6.
RF5. Comparison using DINOv3 ViT-L/16 with the same training data and preprocessing.
| Backbone + Method (Acc., %) | GenImage | AIGI-Holmes | AIGI-Now | In-the-Wild |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DINOv3 ViT-L/16 + Linear | 87.98 | 92.83 | 83.40 | 87.28 |
| DINOv3 ViT-L/16 + FakeFlow-Drift | 90.33 | 94.06 | 84.83 | 91.01 |
| DINOv3 ViT-L/16 + FakeFlow-Leap | 89.72 | 95.10 | 85.87 | 89.68 |
RF6. Comparison using CLIP ViT-L/14@336px with the same training data and preprocessing.
| Backbone + Method (Acc., %) | GenImage | AIGI-Holmes | AIGI-Now | In-the-Wild |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CLIP ViT-L/14@336px + Linear | 79.57 | 82.73 | 64.00 | 61.14 |
| CLIP ViT-L/14@336px + FakeFlow-Drift | 80.07 | 84.27 | 67.53 | 63.67 |
| CLIP ViT-L/14@336px + FakeFlow-Leap | 83.20 | 85.46 | 67.68 | 61.46 |
A stronger backbone yields higher overall accuracy, indicating that the absolute level of detection performance depends on the representational capacity of the backbone. Nevertheless, on both backbones, Drift and Leap outperform the linear baseline with the same backbone on all four benchmarks, showing that label-space flow matching also brings improvements with smaller or other pretrained models.
Q6: How does the initial noise affect classification, and is one-step inference stable?
Response: We thank the reviewer for the question. We fix the trained model and the test sets and only change the random seed of the initial Gaussian noise. We perform one-step inference from 10 different initial states and report the mean and standard deviation of accuracy, as well as the proportion of samples whose predictions are identical across all initial states (consistency rate), as shown in RF7.
RF7. One-step inference stability across 10 initial Gaussian noise seeds.
| Model | Benchmark | Accuracy (%, mean ± std) | Consistency (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| FakeFlow-Drift | GenImage | 97.1 ± 0.02 | 99.25 |
| FakeFlow-Drift | AIGI-Holmes | 97.8 ± 0.01 | 99.50 |
| FakeFlow-Drift | AIGI-Now | 88.7 ± 0.05 | 99.14 |
| FakeFlow-Drift | In-the-Wild | 94.9 ± 0.11 | 99.01 |
| FakeFlow-Leap | GenImage | 97.5 ± 0.04 | 96.07 |
| FakeFlow-Leap | AIGI-Holmes | 98.2 ± 0.05 | 95.26 |
| FakeFlow-Leap | AIGI-Now | 91.6 ± 0.10 | 95.20 |
| FakeFlow-Leap | In-the-Wild | 92.8 ± 0.16 | 95.55 |
On all four benchmarks, the standard deviation of accuracy for both variants does not exceed 0.16 percentage points; the consistency rate of Drift is above 99% and that of Leap is above 95%. This shows that the initial noise has very little effect on the final decision and that one-step inference is stable.
Thank you to the author for the detailed response. It fully addressed my questions, so I have raised my score to 4.
Thank You for Your Follow-up and Recognition of Our Work
Dear Reviewer cqp6,
Thank you for confirming that our responses have fully addressed your questions. We appreciate your careful reassessment and constructive suggestions, which have helped us strengthen the analysis and evaluation of our work. Thank you again for your time and support.
Best regards,
The Authors
Response to Reviewer cqp6
Q1: What advantages does continuous label-trajectory supervision offer over direct label regression?
Response: We thank the reviewer for the question. We clarify the role of trajectory supervision and provide supporting evidence from a controlled experiment.
🔹 (1) Training constraints across label states and time.
Conventional classification objectives and direct label regression learn a direct mapping from image features to labels. Continuous label-trajectory supervision extends this objective by requiring the model to predict the same target label from states with different noise levels, conditioned on the same image.
This introduces training constraints across both label states and time, encouraging the model to use image evidence consistently under varying label-state uncertainty. The resulting supervision supports learning discriminative cues that transfer to unseen generators.
These benefits are acquired during training and retained with efficient one-step inference.
🔹 (2) Controlled evaluation of trajectory supervision.
To assess this contribution, we retrain both variants with the training time fixed at t=0, keeping all other settings unchanged. This removes supervision along the trajectory while preserving the model architecture.
RF1. Full-trajectory supervision versus training only at t=0.
As shown in RF1:
These controlled results support continuous label-trajectory supervision as a key contributor to generalization, with particularly pronounced benefits on AIGI-Now and In-the-Wild.
Q2: How does temporal error weighting affect the performance of Drift and Leap?
Response: We thank the reviewer for the question. We attribute the performance difference primarily to the different temporal error weighting of the two variants, which leads to complementary behavior across evaluation settings.
🔹 (1) Different emphasis during training.
Drift regresses velocity with equal weight at every time step, whereas Leap regresses labels with weight r(t)⁻², which increases toward the trajectory endpoint. Leap’s stronger endpoint emphasis can favor closer fitting of generator-produced forgery patterns, while Drift’s uniform weighting can favor a more relaxed decision boundary and greater robustness under distribution shifts.
🔹 (2) Complementary behavior across benchmarks.
Leap performs better on GenImage, AIGI-Holmes, and AIGI-Now, which follow the generator-based evaluation paradigm. Drift performs better on In-the-Wild, where web collection and human filtering introduce additional distribution shifts.
The same relative ranking is observed on WildAIGC-Bench V3, OpenFake Reddit, and ReWIND. As shown in RF2, **Drift achieves the highest accuracy.
RF2. Additional evaluation on real-world datasets.
Q3: How do the inference latency and computational cost compare with the linear baseline?
Response: We measure the inference latency and computational cost of the DINOv3 linear baseline and FakeFlow on the same hardware, as shown in RF3.
RF3. Inference latency and computational cost on the same hardware.
FakeFlow requires only one inference step, the DINOv3 backbone features are computed only once, and the additional overhead comes only from the lightweight prediction head. Compared with the linear baseline, Drift and Leap increase the inference latency by only about 1.2 ms per image and the computational cost by only about 7 GFLOPs per image, corresponding to approximately 1.7% additional latency and 0.25% additional computation.