- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces PEAT (Progressive Editing via ASCII Art Transforms), a multi-turn image editing framework that uses ASCII art as a discrete, inspectable visual bottleneck. At each turn, an LLM updates the ASCII art and scene prompt from a user instruction, while the original image is retained as a separate appearance reference. After the final turn, an image editing model synthesizes the RGB output from the updated ASCII state, aggregated instruction, and original image. Experiments report smaller CLIP-I/AugCLIP degradation over four turns, higher fourth-turn AugCLIP/MANIQA/MUSIQ than six editors, and substantial inference-time and GPU-energy savings over sequential Qwen-Edit.
Critical strengths
-
The use of ASCII art as an intermediate editing state is novel and interpretable, providing a discrete, inspectable representation for multi-turn editing.
-
Separating the structural/editing state from the original appearance reference is a reasonable design for preserving identity and appearance while allowing semantic edits.
-
The efficiency results are promising, with reported reductions in inference time and GPU energy relative to sequential Qwen-Edit.
-
The multi-turn evaluation and comparison with six editors provide useful initial evidence for the proposed paradigm.
Critical weaknesses
-
The ASCII bottleneck has limited information capacity. ASCII art captures only coarse shape and tone, and may fail to preserve color, texture, fine geometry, and complex spatial relations. The paper should analyze when this bottleneck helps versus when it causes semantic loss, especially in crowded scenes, small objects, and precise spatial instructions.
-
Evaluation emphasizes perceptual quality rather than edit correctness. CLIP-I, AugCLIP, MANIQA, and MUSIQ do not directly measure whether the requested edits are correctly performed or whether unrelated regions are preserved. Instruction-following accuracy, region-level edit success, identity preservation, and human evaluation are needed.
-
The multi-turn protocol and efficiency comparison are insufficiently justified. It is unclear how the four turns are constructed, whether instructions are dependent, how errors accumulate, and whether the comparison with sequential Qwen-Edit uses matched hardware, batch size, LLM calls, and final synthesis cost. Full-pipeline efficiency accounting is needed.
-
The reliability of LLM-generated ASCII states is not validated. LLMs may produce inconsistent or malformed ASCII updates, and the final editor must correctly interpret the ASCII state together with the original image. The paper should report ASCII update accuracy, robustness to LLM errors, and ablations separating the ASCII state, scene prompt, and original-image reference.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses.
11 comments
W2. Evaluation of edit correctness
Thank you for the valuable comment. To evaluate edit correctness, we added a VLM-based evaluation with GPT-5.4 mini as the judge. We evaluated all methods on 110 source images from three benchmarks with four turns each, which is 440 turns per method (Table R1, Table R3). The judge labels each case as success, partial, failure, or unjudgeable, and we count only success as success.
Instruction-following accuracy. Edit SR is the ratio of turns where the current instruction is correctly performed, compared with the previous image. The overall Edit SR of PEAT is 85.8 / 87.5 / 90.0% on PIE / HAOC / CelebA-HQ, and it is at least 80% at every turn on all benchmarks. At turn 4, PEAT gets 83.3 / 82.0 / 83.3% and sequential Qwen-Edit gets 80.0 / 82.0 / 76.7%.
Preservation of unrelated regions. Cum. SR counts a turn as success only when all active instructions are satisfied and the unrequested content (background, composition, style, subject appearance) is preserved compared with the original image. At turn 4, PEAT gets 83.3 / 76.0 / 83.3% and sequential Qwen-Edit gets 73.3 / 78.0 / 63.3%. PEAT is 10.0 and 20.0 points higher on PIE and CelebA-HQ, and similar on HAOC. On PIE and CelebA-HQ, PEAT is higher than the four open-weight baselines and is second after Nano Banana. The difference between Edit SR and Cum. SR of PEAT at turn 4 is 0 / 6 / 0 points.
Identity preservation. CelebA-HQ is a face benchmark, and the Cum. SR criterion includes subject identity. At turn 4, the Cum. SR of PEAT is 83.3%, and the four open-weight baselines get 63.3–80.0%. PEAT also shows the smallest CLIP-I drop from turn 1 to turn 4 on CelebA-HQ (PEAT −0.056, Qwen-Edit −0.078, Nano Banana −0.093; Table R2).
Image-level metrics. On all three benchmarks, PEAT shows the smallest CLIP-I drop from turn 1 to turn 4 and the highest MUSIQ at turn 4 (Table R2).
W2. Table R1.
Table R1. Evaluation set (110 source images × 4 turns = 440 evaluated turns per method)
| Benchmark | Source images | Edit turns per image | Evaluated turns per method |
|---|---|---|---|
| PIE-Bench | 30 | 4 | 120 |
| HAOC | 50 | 4 | 200 |
| CelebA-HQ | 30 | 4 | 120 |
| Total | 110 | 4 | 440 |
Thank you for the constructive review. We appreciate your recognition of ASCII art as a discrete, inspectable intermediate editing state, and of the separation between the editing state and the original appearance reference. We begin with W2 below.
The additional experiments requested in the reviews have now finished running. We are compiling the results and will post each response as soon as it is ready.