- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes FairShift, a novel post-training approach for fairness-aware graph generation. Unlike previous similar solutions, FairShift works on a pre-trained graph diffusion model to drive only the generated edges towards an optimal state that can guarantee good fairness and utility scores in a downstream link prediction task. That is, the graph diffusion model's weights are not modified, but also the node features (including sensitive attributes) are not changed. The model comes with two variants, one named FairShift-T and the other FairShift-F. The first one learns T scalar parameters, one per each reverse time step of the generation process, and they are calibrated over replayed trajectories leveraging surrogate losses that account for fairness and utility. Conversely, the second variant uses a constant shift strength for all reverse steps. Concretely, the graph diffusion model samples an edge logit (indicating the existence of that edge) at each time step during the reverse process. On that basis, FairShift predicts a statistical parity (SP) proxy over cached pair scores, and modifies (shifts) the logit accordingly, eventually sampling new edges with the computed logits. For completeness, the authors also provide a version of the model that predicts equal opportunity (EO) instead of statistical parity (SP) as the fairness guidance. Results on three datasets and against five baselines demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed approach on utility and fairness metrics.
Critical strengths
I think the paper has the merits to address an important and still open challenge in the literature, namely, how to handle the generation of graph data through graph diffusion models to be used for downstream prediction task (e.g., link prediction). The proposed methodology is well-placed within the existing literature, by identifying the key differences with other similar baselines. The code is released at review time, thus ensuring the reproducibility of the results.
Critical weaknesses
I have some concerns regarding the work, which I can summarize in three main points.
Motivation-wise, I do not understand what is the benefit of modifying the edges logit instead, for instance, of the node features. In my understanding, in both cases you are not altering the training phase of the graph diffusion model, but you are intervening in modifying the final topology of the generated graph.
Methodology-wise, I admit I had a little bit of a hard time understanding some particular steps in the methodology description. For instance, it is not completely clear to me what is, and also what are the parameters to be learned with the optimization of equation 11. Are they the from equation 10? I would ask the authors to further clarify this aspect. Additionally, it is not clear to me why they only compute a proxy of the SP metric (equation 7), and not of the utility metric as well. Should the model seek a sort of trade-off between the two measures? Finally, I would like to ask the authors what is the meaning of "valid graphs" as described in lines 279-281 and in equation 11.
Finally, experiments-wise, I would have expected also to see some results reporting the running times required for the proposed methodology. I think this would provide a nice complementary dimension to the provided evaluations, and (if I am not mistaken) I do not see such an analysis in any of the sections from the main paper and the appendix.
Questions for authors
My main questions may be summarized as follows.
-
Can the authors please clarify the motivation concerns I raised in the above? In particular, I did not get why modifying the edges logit during graph generation would represent a benefit with respect to, say, modifying the node features.
-
Can the authors please clarify the methodological concerns I raised in the above? In particular, there are some highlighted terms and notations that would require further discussion.
-
I would be curious to understand whether the proposed approach can be adapted also for other downstream tasks other than link prediction, such as node classification; would this imply a complete modification of the methodology?
-
Have the authors computed the running times for the proposed methodology? Is the model faster than the other presented baselines?
7 comments
Dear Authors,
Thanks for the rebuttal and the modifications to the manuscript, which I carefully assessed.
-
1. Edge logits. Thank you for the clarification. I agree that directly modifying node features to enforce fairness could be disruptive. However, it is worth noting that in graph data, especially when processed by graph learning models such as GNNs, node features and topology are tightly coupled. Even if node features are left untouched, altering the topology indirectly changes them: during message passing, each node’s representation is updated based (also) on its neighborhood, which is determined by the graph structure.
-
2. Equation 11. Thanks for having provided a more careful presentation of equation 11 and its connection to equation 10. In general, I think now the methodological part appear clearer and easier to follow overall.
-
3. Utility. Thanks for this clarification, now I understand the role of fairness and utility, having provided a further explanation on equation 12 and in Section 4.3.
-
4. Valid graphs. Thanks for having clarified the meaning of "valid graphs", with additional context provided in Appendices A.4 and B.3.
-
5. Node classification. OK, this is also clear now. I guess this point somehow connects to the "edge logits" motivation discussed in point 1, right? Or, do you still maintain node features should not be changed during the fairness-aware generation?
-
6. Running time. Thank you for the additional experiments, that prove how FairShift can combine efficacy and efficiency.
Thank you for your careful reassessment and helpful follow-up. We agree that Points 1 and 5 are closely connected and clarify our position below.
1. Edge logits and preservation of node information
We agree that topology and node features jointly determine downstream representations, utility, and fairness. Changing the topology changes the information aggregated during message passing and therefore the learned node representations. This is an intended channel through which our intervention can affect downstream fairness. Our claim about preserving node information concerns the observed attributes and the backbone's feature-handling mechanism.
More precisely, FairShift leaves each backbone's native treatment of node features unchanged:
- EDGE-cond: the observed node features and group attributes remain fixed while FairShift adjusts edge generation.
- The FairWire-style joint backbone (FW-bb): features and edges are generated jointly, and FairShift intervenes only in the edge branch while retaining the original feature-generation mechanism.
This distinction is stated in Section 3.1, with the backbone interfaces detailed in Section 4.5 and Appendix D.2. Edge generation remains dependent on node features. In a coupled joint generator, changes to the graph state can also influence subsequent feature predictions even though the feature-update rule remains unchanged. Thus, preserving this rule does not imply identical feature realizations or hidden representations.
The benefit of the fixed-feature setting is described in Section 3.1 and our previous response: when node attributes represent observed information about individuals, we can adapt their relational structure while retaining that information and the original group definitions. Attribute-based interventions, such as the sensitive-attribute switching discussed for FAROS in Section 2.2, address a different intervention target. Our setting asks: given these node attributes, what topology would support fairer link prediction while retaining predictive utility? Changing message-passing representations is consistent with this goal.
This gives FairShift two complementary benefits: preserving observed node information in feature-conditioned generation, and supporting joint feature–edge generators without redesigning their feature-generation branch. Fixed feature values are therefore specific to the first setting, rather than a requirement for applying FairShift.
5. Connection to node classification
Yes, this connects directly to Point 1. We do not advocate keeping node features unchanged in every fairness-aware generation task. The appropriate intervention depends on the downstream objective, the source of disparity, and which parts of the data may be modified.
Our present motivation is that group-dependent connectivity can provide a biased relational signal to a downstream link predictor. We therefore intervene in edge formation, as described in Sections 1 and 3.1–3.2. Because topology affects message passing, edge interventions can also influence node-classification outcomes. Extending the current controller to this task would require a node-level fairness surrogate, corresponding guidance, and a node-classification utility criterion, while retaining the general principle of controlling a frozen generator during reverse diffusion.
Feature interventions may also be appropriate. For example, node-level SP concerns differences in predicted class rates across sensitive groups. If those disparities are primarily driven by node attributes, and modifying those attributes is permitted, intervening in feature generation may provide a more direct approach while allowing more of the relational structure to be retained. Depending on the dataset, this could be combined with edge interventions. Both features and topology can contribute to disparity in either task, so the choice should be guided by the application.
We therefore view control of feature generation as a plausible extension of the sampling-time intervention principle: it would require a suitable surrogate and guidance acting on the feature-generation outputs. This would involve additional development and validation beyond the edge controller evaluated here. Our current choice to preserve the feature-generation mechanism defines the intervention studied in this paper; it does not imply that feature modification is inappropriate for other fairness objectives.
Thank you for the review. We have clarified the motivation and optimization procedure in Sections 3.1 and 4.3 and added a main-text runtime summary in Section 5.5. All references below are to the revised manuscript.
1. Why intervene in edge logits?
Our objective is to adapt graph topology while preserving the node population, features, and group attributes. In a social graph, for example, nodes describe users, whereas edges represent their interactions. Changing only these interactions lets us examine how downstream outcomes would differ if the relational structure were fairer, without changing the users themselves. Modifying node features would alter the information associated with individuals and address a different intervention target.
Edge-logit correction acts during reverse sampling, so earlier changes can influence subsequent edge decisions. It only requires access to the backbone's edge logits, without modifying the denoiser architecture or retraining its parameters. This makes FairShift a plug-in controller for compatible graph-diffusion backbones; on joint feature–edge diffusion, the feature-generation mechanism remains untouched. We clarified this motivation in Section 3.1.
2. What is optimized in Eq. (11)?
We explicitly clarified the connection between Eqs. (10) and (11) in Section 4.3. The optimization variables are exactly the T scalars ω=(ξ1,…,ξT). Each ξt determines the nonnegative shift strength ηt through the fixed softplus transformation in Eq. (10). The denoiser and update coefficient k remain fixed. Pair memories are recursively updated states, rather than additional optimization variables. Appendix B.3 describes how the calibration gradients propagate through this state.
3. How is utility considered?
The controller objective combines fairness and utility preservation:
Lctrl=wfairLfair+wutilLutil.
The terminal fairness term encourages a smaller group disparity. The KL preservation term in Eq. (12) penalizes deviations of the guided memory-state probabilities from the unshifted provisional probabilities, given the same incoming history. It therefore restrains the intervention while the fairness term changes the group-score relationship. Their weights control the trade-off during calibration.
We expanded this explanation in Section 4.3. Downstream AUC is then measured after graph generation and predictor training. Table 1 shows the resulting trade-offs: the retention-oriented settings reduce SP by 47.1%, 45.7%, and 23.6% on the three datasets with AUC decreases of 1.02, 0.93, and 0.53 percentage points.
4. What does "valid graphs" mean?
We clarified this term immediately after Eq. (11), Section 4.3. It identifies replay graphs for which the group comparison is defined. Both relation subsets must be nonempty for SP. EO additionally requires sufficient soft-positive mass in both subsets. If no graph satisfies these conditions, the fairness term is zero while the preservation term remains active. Appendices A.4 and B.3 give the precise conditions.
5. Extension to node classification
We distinguish the general control mechanism from its task-specific fairness objective. Even within link prediction, SP and score-based EO target different pair populations and require distinct surrogates. Node classification is a different downstream task: fairness concerns node predictions across groups, not pairwise link scores. Thus, Eq. (7) cannot be reused unchanged; a node-level fairness surrogate and corresponding guidance and utility evaluation would be necessary.
Nevertheless, the core framework—a frozen pretrained denoiser with per-step edge-logit control—can remain. This requires adapting the task-dependent component, not completely redesigning FairShift. We leave empirical validation to future work.
6. Running time
We now summarize the runtime analysis from Appendix G in the new Section 5.5. Using an NVIDIA RTX A6000 and the pretrained FairWire-style backbone with T=8, the measured application times are:
Both include graph generation and downstream evaluation. FairShift-T additionally includes 500 controller-calibration epochs, whereas FairShift-F requires no controller fitting. Appendix G, Tables 23-24, provides the timing setup and stage-wise breakdown. The practical benefit is that adapting to a fairness objective does not require repeating the expensive diffusion-backbone training stage.