acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Topological Fairness in Graph Representation Learning Based on Edge Differentiation

Abstract

The fairness is a fundamental problem in graph representation learning (GRL) because it can lead to the failure of downstream tasks for the significant deviations between the results of GRL and the true semantics. However, current research on fairness mainly focuses on the sensitive attributes of node, ignoring the bias caused by the unfairness of the topological structure of the graph. Although some studies usually attribute topological unfairness to homogeneity effects, that is, nodes with the same sensitive attributes are more likely to form connections, the role of topological fairness in graph representation learning still needs to be explored. To address this issue, we first define Topological Fairness Graph (TFG) inspired by the traditional concepts of Statistical Parity and Equal Opportunity. Then, based on TFG, Edge Differential Operator for Topological Fairness (EDO-TF) in Graph representation learning is introduced to measure the variation of topological structure of graph with Probabilistic Distribution Disparit. Finally, we combine the EDO-TF into the loss function in GRL to eliminate the topological unfairness of graph. Our empirical results are tested on eight datasets, indicating that the introduction of TFG can correct many erroneous information orientations, which is a great extension of research on graph fairness solely based on feature information.

Primary area:
learning on graphs and other geometries & topologies
Keywords:
Graph Representation Learning, GNN, Fairness, Edge Differential Operator, Topological Fairness Graph

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_2Q5KOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies group fairness in graph neural networks from the perspective of graph topology. It introduces the notion of a Topological Fairness Graph (TFG), under which the observed neighborhood of each node should maximize its probability of being correctly classified relative to alternative neighborhoods. The paper then proposes the Edge Differential Operator for Topological Fairness (EDO-TF), which estimates how a probabilistic distribution disparity measure changes with respect to individual adjacency-matrix entries. The method is evaluated on eight node-classification datasets using GCN and GIN backbones. The reported results generally show lower group-fairness gaps while maintaining comparable accuracy.

Critical strengths
  • The paper addresses an important source of unfairness in GNNs. Studying how individual graph connections influence group disparities is well motivated because message passing can propagate or amplify bias, and a rule based only on sensitive-attribute homophily may overlook other harmful structural patterns.
  • The edge-level perspective is potentially useful and interpretable. Estimating how individual edges affect a continuous fairness measure could support more targeted interventions than uniformly dropping edges or suppressing all sensitive information. Accounting for the effect of graph changes on the trained parameters could also be valuable if the corresponding total derivative is formulated and validated correctly.
  • The empirical evaluation has reasonable breadth. The paper reports results on eight datasets, two GNN backbones, and both statistical-parity and equal-opportunity metrics.
Critical weaknesses
  • The central optimization objective does not generally minimize unfairness. Equations (8) and (9) minimize a sum of derivatives, ∂Γ/∂Aij\partial\Gamma/\partial A_{ij}, rather than the disparity Γ\Gamma itself. A derivative can indicate a local descent direction, but minimizing the derivative is not equivalent to minimizing the original function. Summing signed edge derivatives can also produce cancellations. The paper does not provide a descent procedure or a result showing that optimizing Eq. (9) decreases Γ\Gamma. This concern directly affects the validity of EDO-TF.
  • The experiments do not validate the claimed edge-influence mechanism and omit directly relevant comparisons. The reported improvements in final fairness metrics do not demonstrate that EDO-TF correctly identifies helpful and harmful edges. A direct validation should compare the estimated influence of an edge with the actual change in fairness after modifying that edge and retraining. The paper also lacks comparisons with FairEdit, which explicitly uses fairness-loss gradients for edge addition and deletion, as well as Graphair and the already discussed FairSIN.
  • The complexity analysis is incomplete and potentially misleading. The paper describes the Hessian inverse computation as O(p)O(p), but Hessian-free methods generally estimate an inverse-Hessian-vector product rather than explicitly computing an inverse matrix. Their cost depends on the number of iterations and the cost of Hessian-vector products. Algorithm 1 also appears to iterate over every AijA_{ij}, which would involve O(n2)O(n^2) candidate entries unless a restricted edge set or sampling scheme is used. The text is internally inconsistent: Algorithm 1 computes the inverse-Hessian estimate outside the edge loop, while Section 4.4 attributes the cost to computing it separately for every AijA_{ij}.
Questions for authors

Please refer to the weaknesses.

Reviewer_WBMjOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies topological fairness in graph learning and proposes an approach intended to balance predictive utility and fairness. However, its evaluation primarily compares against earlier methods, leaving its advantages over recent research unclear.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses

Insufficient comparison with recent work. The claimed contribution of balancing utility and fairness is insufficiently positioned against recent research, including relevant KDD 2025 [1] and WWW 2024 [2] studies. Omitting these comparisons makes it difficult to assess the novelty and effectiveness of the proposed method.

Claims are not fully supported by the results. The experiments do not convincingly establish the claimed utility–fairness balance. In particular, the claim of achieving the best predictive performance among fairness-aware methods is inconsistent with some reported results: on Pokec-z, the proposed method performs worse than FairGNN. The conclusions should more accurately reflect these limitations.

Poor presentation and reference quality. The manuscript contains overstated experimental conclusions and numerous duplicate entries in the reference list. These issues substantially weaken its clarity and overall quality.

[1] Renqiang Luo, Huafei Huang, Shuo Yu, Zhuoyang Han, Estrid He, Xiuzhen Zhang, and Feng Xia. 2024. FUGNN: Harmonizing Fairness and Utility in Graph Neural Networks. In Proceedings of the 30th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining (KDD ’24), 2072–2081.

[2] Yuchang Zhu, Jintang Li, Zibin Zheng, and Liang Chen. 2024. Fair Graph Representation Learning via Sensitive Attribute Disentanglement. In Proceedings of the ACM on Web Conference 2024 (WWW ’24), 1182–1192.

Questions for authors

Utility–fairness trade-off: In most evaluated settings, the proposed method appears to incur a larger loss in predictive utility than competing methods. How do the authors reconcile these results with the claimed utility–fairness balance, and how could this utility degradation be mitigated?

Comparison with recent baselines: How does the proposed method compare with relevant baselines published in 2024–2026, including FUGNN and FairSAD, in terms of both utility and fairness under the same experimental settings? Do the claimed advantages still hold?

Reviewer_LnkAOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates fairness issues arising from graph topology in Graph Representation Learning (GRL). The authors introduce the concept of a Topological Fairness Graph (TFG), aiming to distinguish appropriate and inappropriate neighborhood information during graph message passing. Building upon this formulation, they propose an Edge Differential Operator for Topological Fairness (EDO-TF), which estimates the influence of individual graph edges on fairness-related distribution disparities through implicit differentiation. The resulting edge-level fairness objective is incorporated into GNN training to mitigate topological bias while preserving predictive utility. Experiments are conducted on eight datasets using GCN and GIN backbones. The results demonstrate improvements in Statistical Parity (SP) and Equal Opportunity (EO) compared with several existing fairness-aware methods, while maintaining competitive classification accuracy.

Critical strengths

Meaningful research direction: The paper investigates how graph topology affects fairness during neighborhood aggregation. By examining individual edges rather than focusing solely on sensitive node attributes, it provides a useful perspective on mitigating structural bias in GNNs.

Encouraging empirical results across multiple benchmarks: The proposed EDO-TF is evaluated on eight datasets with GCN and GIN backbones, showing consistent improvements in Statistical Parity and Equal Opportunity while maintaining competitive accuracy. Ablation studies and efficiency analysis further support its effectiveness.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty: The core idea of distinguishing fairness-promoting and bias-inducing edges has been explored in REFEREE [1], while FairDrop [2], EDITS [3], and Graphair [4] investigate fairness-aware graph structure modification. Moreover, EDO-TF builds upon PDD and influence-function-based attribution introduced in BIND [5]. The paper does not sufficiently clarify its methodological novelty beyond extending existing fairness attribution techniques to edge-level sensitivity.

  2. Concerns on formulations: Equation (6) requires clarification regarding the direct influence of graph topology, while Equation (10) appears inconsistent with the standard graph Laplacian regularizer. These issues weaken the theoretical foundations of the proposed framework.

  3. Insufficient experimental validation of the core contributions. Although experiments cover eight datasets and two kinds of GNN backbones, comparisons with closely related fairness methods (e.g., REFEREE [1]) are missing. More importantly, the experiments do not directly verify whether EDO-TF accurately identifies fairness-promoting and bias-inducing edges. Comparisons against direct PDD optimization and evaluations of fairness changes after edge modifications would better substantiate the effectiveness and necessity of the proposed mechanism.

References:

[1] Dong, Y., et al. "On Structural Explanation of Bias in Graph Neural Networks." KDD, 2022.

[2] Spinelli, I., et al. "FairDrop: Biased Edge Dropout for Enhancing Fairness in Graph Representation Learning." IEEE Transactions on Artificial Intelligence, 2022.

[3] Dong, Y., et al. "EDITS: Modeling and Mitigating Data Bias for Graph Neural Networks." WWW, 2022.

[4] Ling, H., et al. "Learning Fair Graph Representations via Automated Data Augmentations." ICLR, 2023.

[5] Dong, Y., et al. "Interpreting Unfairness in Graph Neural Networks via Training Node Attribution." AAAI, 2023.

Questions for authors
  1. REFEREE already identifies edges that contribute to bias or fairness, while BIND estimates how training nodes affect PDD using influence functions. What does EDO-TF add beyond changing the attribution granularity from nodes to edges? A more comprehensive comparison would help establish the methodological contribution.

  2. Definition 1 (Eq. 4) characterizes topological fairness through prediction optimality over alternative neighborhoods. I would appreciate more explanation of how this relates to SP and EO in Eqs. (1) and (2), which measure disparities across sensitive groups. Since prediction optimality does not generally imply group fairness, are additional assumptions needed to establish this connection?

  3. The objective in Eqs. (8) and (9) would benefit from further explanation, particularly how minimizing the edge derivatives of PDD leads to a reduction in PDD itself. In addition, Eq. (6) appears to account only for the effect of adjacency changes through the retrained model parameters. If PDD is evaluated on the modified graph, should the derivative also include its direct dependence on the adjacency matrix?

  4. Do the estimated edge influences agree with the fairness changes observed after actually adding or removing edges and retraining? This would directly test whether EDO-TF identifies helpful and harmful edges. A comparison with directly minimizing PDD would also help explain the benefit of the proposed derivative-based objective.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.