- The independent contribution of candidate-aligned process forecasts to critic-guided selection is not convincingly established.
The “Process” comparisons in Tables 3–4 change the process-aware model configuration, including action generation, and therefore do not isolate the benefit of supplying candidate-specific process forecasts to the critic. The closer fixed-model comparison in Table A3 gives identical overall success for MPPI with full process inputs and with those inputs masked out: 73.96% in both cases. For one-round selection, the masked variant is slightly higher, at 70.63% versus 70.21%.
The full-input MPPI variant does perform better on unseen garments, at 63.75% versus 53.75%, which is potentially meaningful. However, this subset contains only 80 episodes across two executions, and the overall result remains unchanged. Moreover, masking a fixed critic at inference is not equivalent to training a matched action-only critic, so this experiment neither establishes that process inputs are unnecessary nor demonstrates their independent benefit.
This uncertainty is consequential because the structured, candidate-aligned process representation is the paper’s main distinguishing contribution. A comparison between retrained observation–action and observation–action–process critics, using the same actor, outcome data, search settings, and comparable capacity, is needed. Quantitative evaluation of process forecasts and their effect on within-state candidate ranking would also help establish the claimed mechanism beyond successful-rollout visualizations.
- The robustness and breadth of the incremental gains over strong actor and selection baselines remain insufficiently established.
Appendix C.2 states that the epoch-2 controller used in the fixed-model LeHome-Fold study was selected after inspecting five checkpoint evaluations. Its original two executions achieve 73.96%, while two additional executions achieve 71.25%, producing a pooled result of 72.60%. The additional executions do not include synchronized Process Actor or IID8 controls. The original equal-budget comparison is useful, but an independent confirmation is needed to establish how reliably its reported advantage persists after checkpoint selection.
On LIBERO-Long, Table 4 reports 96.20% for the full controller versus 95.80% for the Process Actor configuration. The separate four-execution, same-weights comparison with the (16\times2) controller is consistently positive, but its mean improvement is 0.95 percentage points. Figure A1 shows that task 09 alone contributes this net average gain, with improvements and regressions across the other nine tasks cancelling out. These results provide evidence of benefits on some tasks, but weaker support for broadly reliable improvements.
The practical tradeoff is also unresolved. Appendix C.5 reports LeHome-Fold median request durations of 743.0 ms for the controller and 86.9 ms for the actor, while explicitly noting unmatched server loads. A controlled success–latency comparison would help determine whether the additional computation is justified by the incremental gains.