- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Peregrine augments a frozen VLA with structured historical dynamics, execution-time latent prediction, and bounded residual action correction. Its central objective is to align the predicted pre-action state with the application time of a specific pending command. The paper presents evaluations across dynamic simulation conditions and Franka tasks.
Critical strengths
- The prediction horizon covers the complete observation-to-correction pipeline, including correction computation and command adoption.
- Compact historical tokens, joint visual–pose forecasting, and bounded correction provide a plausible way to improve responsiveness while preserving the frozen base policy.
Critical weaknesses
- The title shown in the PDF is inconsistent with the title entered in the submission system, and both titles are confusing to the reviewer.
- The motivation in the Introduction and the description of the proposed approach in the Method section are difficult to follow.
- The manuscript lacks sufficient technical novelty and contribution. The proposed approach is simple and intuitive, and appears closer to a training-free engineering refinement than a substantive methodological advance. The presentation of Figs. 1 and 2 also requires further clarification and improvement. For example, it is unclear where the “latest visual observation” and state information originate, and how they are obtained and updated within the framework.
- The simulation experiments are conducted only on Isaac Sim, which provides insufficient evidence to substantiate the effectiveness and generalizability of the proposed method.
- Essential details of the real-world experimental setup and qualitative visualizations of real-world task executions are missing.
Questions for authors
The authors should thoroughly address all concerns raised in the Weaknesses section.