- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SAFE-Diff, a segmentation-conditioned and frequency-aware diffusion framework for paired virtual contrast-enhanced medical image synthesis. It follows a two-stage process. In Stage 1, modality-specific VAE encoders are pretrained and a contrastive projection head is used to align source and target representations at the case level, reducing the cross-modal semantic gap. In Stage 2, a latent diffusion model synthesizes the contrast-enhanced target while being conditioned on source semantic features, segmentation masks, and anatomical boundary maps. The key module, Multi-Band Spectral Attention (MBSA), adaptively reweights bottleneck features according to their frequency responses, emphasizing anatomically meaningful high-frequency structures while suppressing noise-like fluctuations. Extensive experiments on a large-scale cardiac CT dataset and the BraTS dataset demonstrate that SAFE-Diff outperforms representative UNet-, GAN-, and diffusion-based baselines in both image fidelity metrics and downstream anatomical segmentation tasks.
Critical strengths
The overall method is coherent and aligned with the goal of anatomy-preserving virtual contrast enhancement. The experiments are comprehensive, including an evaluation of the model's robustness to imperfect anatomical priors.
Critical weaknesses
- The compared baselines are relatively limited for supporting a state-of-the-art claim. The methods listed in Table 1 are general-purpose and relatively older image-to-image translation methods. It is advisable to include comparisons with recent works focused on anatomy preservation or contrast synthesis, such as APT and VASTSD.
- The downstream segmentation-based anatomical evaluation and the structural priors used by SAFE-Diff are not entirely independent, as the processes for prior generation and evaluation may rely on the same segmentation software framework.
- Minor issues. There are some formatting and layout issues in the paper. For instance, the subplot label "(a)" appears repeatedly in Fig. 2; additionally, the same paper by Konz et al. (2024) is listed twice in the references as 2024a and 2024b. While these issues do not affect the technical content, they detract from the paper's overall professionalism and polish.
Questions for authors
Table 2 states that anatomical evaluation is conducted on 55 expert-labelled CTA cases, whereas Supplementary Section S2.4 refers to 20 expert-annotated CTA subjects. Do these numbers correspond to different subsets or annotation protocols? If so, could the authors specify the number of cases used for each metric in Table 2?