- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies whether a single system prompt can improve accuracy and behavioral stability across languages and tasks. It evaluates each prompt using four metrics: Acc_mean, Acc_var, Consistency, and Len_var; it min–max normalizes them, weights them by 0.5, 0.25, 0.125, and 0.125, and reverses the two variance terms. The authors build 10,000 prompt components from ten categories, randomly compose 1,000 prompts, evaluate them, and train an XLM-RoBERTa reward model to predict a four-dimensional reward vector with a max-margin pairwise loss. They then adapt the component-editing and iterative-selection procedure from SPRIG [1] for a 25-step optimization of English system prompts; the downstream LLM is not updated, and the selected prompt is prepended at inference time. The main experiments use Gemma-3-12B-Instruct, Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct, and Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct on MMLU-Pro, MATH500, and UniMoral, with additional transfer to MGSM and analyses of segmented reasoning units using language identification and reasoning-type classifiers.
[1] Lechen Zhang et al. SPRIG: Improving Large Language Model Performance by System Prompt Optimization. arXiv:2410.14826, 2024.
Critical strengths
-
The evaluation has substantial coverage with a clean item-level split. The main study spans three LLMs, three benchmarks, and five languages. It assigns all language versions of a question to the same split, uses training questions for reward-model labels, and computes optimized-prompt results on held-out test questions. This prevents language variants of the same question from crossing partitions and makes the end-to-end comparison more informative.
-
The extension experiments test transfer beyond the main search setting. The MGSM experiment reuses prompts optimized on the main tasks and evaluates them on an unseen benchmark and seven unseen languages; on Qwen2.5-7B, Acc_mean increases from 0.636 to 0.674, although Acc_var changes little.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper does not establish that the four-metric objective adds value beyond accuracy-only SPRIG [1].
Len_varis affected by tokenization and language-specific expressions, whileConsistencycounts identical wrong answers as consistent. Without an accuracy-only SPRIG run under the same search and evaluation budget, the gains cannot be attributed to the added metrics. Table 9 also contains counterexamples to the claim that all metrics improve by 5–10%: accuracy and other metrics trade off on Llama–MATH500, and Gemma–UniMoral accuracy decreases. A narrower aggregate claim is needed. -
The reasoning-behavior analysis does not establish a mechanism for the gains. It follows the segmentation and classification workflow in Language Matters [2]; the 70B relabeling check gives only κ = 0.528 and does not calibrate errors by language. The higher Hindi
Othersrate may reflect classifier or segmentation bias, and the PCA/regression results are confounded by output length and prompt style. The evidence, therefore, supports correlation, not the claim that reasoning patterns drive robustness; language-wise annotation checks and confound controls are needed.
[2] Zhi Rui Tam et al. Language Matters: How Do Multilingual Input and Reasoning Paths Affect Large Reasoning Models? arXiv:2505.17407, 2025.
Questions for authors
-
Under the same component library, reward-model training data, candidate-evaluation budget, and search rounds, how does the four-metric objective compare with an accuracy-only SPRIG run? Can you report all four raw metrics and the accuracy of the weakest language? This comparison would directly determine the incremental value of the proposed objective.
-
Maybe you can manually audit segmentation and category labels on samples from the five main languages, especially the distinction between
Others,Logical Reasoning, andReframing? After relabeling the key language comparisons with the 70B model and controlling for total length, task, and model, do the main conclusions remain?
4 comments
Official Comment by Authors (2/2)
W2. The reasoning-behavior analysis does not establish a mechanism for the gains. It follows the segmentation and classification workflow in Language Matters [2]; the 70B relabeling check gives only κ = 0.528 and does not calibrate errors by language. The higher Hindi Others rate may reflect classifier or segmentation bias, and the PCA/regression results are confounded by output length and prompt style. The evidence, therefore, supports correlation, not the claim that reasoning patterns drive robustness; language-wise annotation checks and confound controls are needed.
Q2. Maybe you can manually audit segmentation and category labels on samples from the five main languages, especially the distinction between Others, Logical Reasoning, and Reframing? After relabeling the key language comparisons with the 70B model and controlling for total length, task, and model, do the main conclusions remain?
Thank you for these suggestions! We would like to clarify that our reasoning analysis aims to characterize observable changes in reasoning patterns following prompt optimization, without claiming to establish a causal mechanism for performance improvements.
Regarding classification reliability, we had already manually inspected reasoning-category labels across all five languages before conducting our analysis. In particular, we noticed the relatively high proportion of Others in Hindi and specifically examined these cases, finding no substantial systematic categorization errors. We will make this validation process clearer in the revision.
To further strengthen this validation, we conducted an independent, blinded annotation audit using Claude Opus 5.5, covering 100 responses (705 reasoning units, 20 responses per language). The model assigned reasoning categories without access to the original Qwen3-14B or LLaMA-3.1-70B-Instruct labels. The following table reports step-level Cohen's κ:
| Comparison | All | EN | ES | FR | HI | ZH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen vs. LLaMA (15K sample) | 0.55 | 0.58 | 0.58 | 0.55 | 0.53 | 0.29 |
| Qwen vs. Opus | 0.47 | 0.60 | 0.54 | 0.55 | 0.42 | 0.24 |
| LLaMA vs. Opus | 0.60 | 0.71 | 0.50 | 0.51 | 0.57 | 0.69 |
Although agreement varies across languages, particularly for Qwen's Chinese annotations, the independent audit supports our observation regarding Hindi. 96% of the Hindi units classified as Others by Qwen were also identified as such in the audit. Opus assigned 43% of Hindi units to Others, compared with 29% for English, suggesting that the elevated Hindi Others rate is not simply a classification artifact.
Regarding the robustness of our findings, we re-examined the key reasoning comparisons using LLaMA-3.1-70B-Instruct annotations on the 15K sample, including analyses controlling for response length and task × language. Our central findings remain largely consistent:
- Others and accuracy: Others is negatively associated with accuracy under both classifiers, and this relationship remains significant after controlling for response length and task × language (p < 0.001).
- Language-specific patterns: English exhibits the highest Reframing frequency under both classifiers. Hindi also has the highest Others proportion when grouped by task language, although the difference is smaller under LLaMA (31.3% versus 30.9% for French).
- Task-dependent reasoning: Calculation remains positively and significantly associated with accuracy on MATH500 under both classifiers.
Some finer-grained patterns are less stable. For example, the negative association between Reframing and accuracy remains significant at the prompt level under both classifiers, but loses significance under LLaMA after controlling for length and task. We will clarify these nuances and the language-dependent annotation reliability in the revision.
Overall, the central associations between reasoning behaviors and task performance remain robust across classifiers and statistical controls, supporting the descriptive conclusions of our reasoning analysis.
Follow-up on our rebuttal
Dear Reviewer guHf,
Thank you again for your valuable feedback! We hope our responses and additional experiments have adequately addressed your questions. We would be happy to address any further questions or suggestions you may have. If you feel your concerns have been resolved, we would greatly appreciate your consideration in updating your assessment. Thank you again for your time and thoughtful review!
Second Follow-up on the rebuttal
Dear Reviewer gUhf,
As the discussion period is approaching its end, we wanted to check whether you have had a chance to review our rebuttal and whether any concerns remain. We would be happy to provide further clarification if needed, and would appreciate your consideration of an updated rating if our responses have addressed your concerns. Thank you!
Official Comment by Authors (1/2)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thoughtful and constructive feedback. Below, we respond to each point and include several additional results that we hope will clarify your concerns.
Thank you for this valuable suggestion! We agree that our work builds upon SPRIG as the underlying optimizer. However, our main contribution is extending system prompt optimization to the multilingual, multi-objective setting, where a single prompt must achieve both high accuracy and robust behavior across languages. Beyond optimization, we also introduce a four-dimensional evaluation framework and provide systematic analyses of multilingual prompt components and reasoning behaviors, neither of which was explored in the original SPRIG.
To better isolate these contributions, we conducted additional experiments comparing (1) English-only accuracy optimization, (2) multilingual accuracy optimization, and (3) our four-metric optimization, using the same SPRIG optimizer and English prompt search space. For a fair comparison, we re-evaluated all methods on the same held-out questions under the same computational environment, so some numerical results may differ slightly from those reported in the original manuscript. The results are summarized below.
These results provide several important observations. First, our four-metric optimization outperforms both accuracy-only objectives on Gemma, improving overall accuracy (0.703 vs. 0.700), accuracy variance (0.0061 vs. 0.0065), and consistency (0.511 vs. 0.50). The accuracy improvement is primarily driven by non-English languages, while English performance remains comparable. Second, on Llama, the three approaches achieve broadly similar results, with our method attaining the lowest output-length variance. These results suggest that multilingual, multi-objective optimization can provide improvements beyond accuracy-only SPRIG.
Regarding the metric concerns, we agree that consistency can count identical incorrect answers. However, this is intentional, as consistency measures agreement across languages independently of correctness, which is already captured by accuracy (receiving the highest weight of 0.5). Similarly, while tokenization efficiency varies across languages, our length metric measures computational reasoning effort, as each generated token incurs approximately comparable inference cost within the same model. We will clarify these distinctions in the revision.
Finally, we acknowledge that improvements are not uniform across all models and benchmarks, as illustrated by the Llama–MATH500 and Gemma–UniMoral results in Table 9. We will clarify that the reported 5–10% improvements describe aggregate trends, while individual settings may exhibit trade-offs across metrics.
We will incorporate these ablation results and clarifications into the revised manuscript.