- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how to predict the result of a digging action before it is executed, including how the pile will change and how much material the bucket will collect, so that a robot can choose better actions. The main difficulty is that the robot sees only part of the pile, and areas that look the same can respond differently because of earlier digging or hidden soil conditions. The paper proposes PileBelief, a model that records where the pile has changed and how it responded to past actions, and uses this record to improve its predictions. PileBelief outperforms a model that uses only the current view, both in simulation and on real excavation data. It has not yet been tested in real-time control of a physical machine.
Critical strengths
Excavation is a strong and well-chosen case for world models in environments that the robot itself reshapes, and the motivation is sound. The proposed method is interesting, separating memory of where the pile changed from how it responded.
Critical weaknesses
- Several key terms are not clearly defined: Newton/MPM is never explained, the belief state is not defined in one place and varies across experiments, and the resampling operator is only named.
- The problem formulation is unclear, since the model's inputs and outputs are not clearly specified and differ across domains.
- The paper does not show the model's value at the task level. It does not define a task-level objective.
- The paper lacks heuristic baselines, such as selecting the candidate with the largest swept volume.
Questions for authors
- What exactly are the model's inputs and outputs in each domain?
- How does PileBelief compare with a heuristic baseline, such as selecting the candidate with the largest swept volume?
Dear authors and reviewers,
The author-reviewer discussion period closes on November 18 (AoE). Please engage/continue to engage during this period so that we have our issues discussed thoroughly.
AC