- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MOFR, a feature reconstruction method for multi-class unsupervised anomaly detection built on the Dinomaly/Dinomaly2 framework. Instead of initializing the decoder state with input-derived features, the decoder starts from a learnable positional.
Critical strengths
The paper is clearly written, and the authors honestly acknowledge that the differences from the baseline are small.
Critical weaknesses
-
Unaligned training settings. The method is built on the Dinomaly framework, but the training schedule differs. Since the baseline numbers are copied from the literature, the comparison is not controlled. The authors should compare with Dinomaly-based baselines under identical training settings.
-
Missing comparison with Dinomaly2. The method adopts the CLS re-centering of Dinomaly2, and the ablation (Table 3) shows that it is one of the main sources of the improvement over Dinomaly, yet Dinomaly2 is not compared. The Dinomaly2 baseline reports 99.8%, 99.2%, and 91.6% I-AUROC on MVTec-AD, VisA, and Real-IAD, which appear similar or even higher than MOFR's results (99.8%, 99.0%, 91.1%).
-
Limited novelty. Using a learnable, image-independent embedding as the decoder's initial state (rather than input-derived features) is not new; similar designs already exist, e.g., the learnable queries in UniAD and INP-former.
-
No meaningful improvement from the proposed design. Table 2 shows that the proposed modulation-only design performs almost identically to the feature-stream baseline (I-AUROC differences of only 0.02–0.07 pp, and AUPRO is even lower on VisA and Real-IAD). With such small differences, results from multiple random seeds (mean and standard deviation) are necessary to establish whether there is any stable improvement.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses