- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The overarching goal of this paper is to forecast dissolved oxygen of water column from environmental variables. The authors developed this algorithm using observations from a local region (Chesapeake Bay). The major technical contribution of this work is the incorporation of physical regularization in the final loss function.
Critical strengths
The major technical contribution of this work is the incorporation of physical regularization in the final loss function.
Critical weaknesses
My major comments are listed below. First, the first physical regularization (i.e., the oxygen is forced undersatulation) will be violated in the surface ocean in the summer due to biology. This component should be large when the biological oxygen is large. Second, the second physical regularization will be the same. The source-sink term should be important in some months and depths. Third, the amount of training data compared to the number of parameters (~650K) is very small. I am not sure whether overfitting is problem. Fourth, the forcing variables are not clear. I can only find river discharge,nutrient loading,air temperature,wind,and solarradiation. Apparently, other important variables for dissolved oxygen are not included here. The water temperature, rather than air temperature, will dominate dissolved oxygen. Salinity also influences dissolved oxygen. Another variable will be the biological parameter (e.g., phytoplankton).
Questions for authors
No
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation and constructive feedback. We appreciate the recognition of the value of physics-guided regularization for coastal DO forecasting. We address the four concerns below.
1. Oxygen saturation constraint and biological supersaturation. We agree that biological activity, particularly photosynthesis, can cause oxygen supersaturation in surface waters during summer. Importantly, our approach employs a soft physical constraint rather than strictly enforcing DO concentrations below saturation. Specifically, when temperature and salinity data are available, we calculate the oxygen saturation concentration using �0�; otherwise, we adopt a relaxed fixed upper bound of 14.0 mg/L. Since this constraint is incorporated as a soft regularizer, the model can still predict DO concentrations exceeding the saturation threshold when supported by observations. Its purpose is to discourage physically implausible predictions rather than assume universally undersaturated conditions. We will clarify this implementation and discuss its limitations under intense biological activity.
2. Spatial smoothness and biogeochemical source–sink processes. We acknowledge that localized biological production and consumption can generate substantial spatial DO gradients. However, our smoothness penalty does not enforce spatially uniform DO fields. Instead, it serves as a weak regularizer that suppresses unsupported spatial oscillations while allowing the data-fitting objective to preserve meaningful spatial heterogeneity. Our hyperparameter sensitivity analysis further shows that excessive smoothing degrades prediction accuracy, whereas moderate regularization improves spatial generalization. Thus, our approach balances observational fidelity and spatial regularity rather than assuming negligible source–sink effects. We will further clarify the physical interpretation and applicability of this constraint.
3. Training data size and overfitting. We clarify that our training data cover 288 months across 800 spatial locations, yielding approximately 230,400 spatiotemporal supervised observations, rather than only 288 monthly samples. Although these observations are not statistically independent, PhysiOcean learns shared spatiotemporal representations through its Branch–Trunk architecture instead of fitting separate models at individual locations. We also employ weight decay, early stopping, and physics-guided regularization to mitigate overfitting. More importantly, PhysiOcean achieves R² = 0.881 on the independent 2009–2016 test period and demonstrates generalization to stations and depth layers excluded from training. These results provide empirical evidence of generalization beyond the training observations. We will additionally provide training and validation loss curves to further assess overfitting.
4. Selection of environmental forcing variables. We agree that water temperature, salinity, and biological variables such as phytoplankton are important drivers of DO dynamics. However, our study focuses on forecasting continuous DO fields from regionally aggregated external environmental forcings, rather than relying on local water-quality observations at individual monitoring locations. Our 39 forcing variables include air temperature, river discharge, nutrient loading, wind, precipitation, and solar radiation, which indirectly characterize thermal, transport, and biogeochemical processes. Importantly, temperature and salinity data, when available, are used to calculate oxygen saturation for physical regularization and should not be confused with the environmental forcing inputs to the Branch Network. We acknowledge that external forcings cannot fully replace local water temperature, salinity, and biological observations. We will provide the complete list of forcing variables, clarify the distinction between forecasting inputs and auxiliary variables used for physical constraints, and discuss incorporating local environmental and biological observations in future work.