- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SelfCheckMark, an in-generation video watermarking method that embeds information into the initial diffusion noise. The method combines repeated sign embedding, Hamming error-correction coding, and confidence-weighted extraction to improve watermark recovery after video distortions.
Critical strengths
Using continuous latent values instead of hard bit decisions during extraction is a reasonable idea.
Critical weaknesses
-
Several components are introduced, but their actual contributions are unclear. For example, the authors describe a dual-channel design with a strong-response anchor and redundant elements. However, all four elements undergo the same embedding operation and are simply summed during extraction. I do not understand what makes this a dual-channel design or what the anchor actually adds. At 512 bits, the simple repetition baseline outperforms the proposed Hamming-based approach under all evaluated attacks. This makes me question the choice of Hamming coding. The additional improvement from the weighting is also very small.
-
Only three attacks are evaluated, each at a single strength. Important video transformations such as cropping, resizing, frame dropping, frame reordering, and other temporal edits are missing. The evaluation is also limited to one video generation model.
-
Another concern is the baseline performance. VideoMark and SIGMark perform poorly under several conditions, sometimes close to random guessing, without sufficient explanation. I would like to understand whether these results are consistent with their original implementations. The improvements over VideoShield are also relatively small, with no confidence intervals or repeated-run analysis to establish their significance.
-
The authors only report an aggregate VBench-2.0 score. No qualitative examples compare watermarked and unwatermarked videos. I would expect a more detailed analysis of visual quality and temporal consistency, especially since the method modifies the initial noise. The authors also claim that sign scrambling preserves the noise distribution, but this is not experimentally demonstrated.
-
The method repeats the same watermark information across channels and frames and uses a global key with a fixed nonce. I am concerned about the security of this construction when the same key or watermark information is reused across multiple videos. There is no analysis of possible watermark removal, forgery, or information leakage from repeated patterns.
-
More importantly, the authors only report bit accuracy. There are no detection metrics such as TPR/FPR, wrong-key verification, or exact payload recovery. Recovering watermark bits is not the same as verifying the origin of a video, which is one of the main motivations of the paper.
Questions for authors
-
What does the dual-channel design actually add compared with simple repeated sign embedding?
-
Why is Hamming coding preferred when pure repetition performs better at 512 bits?
-
How is the proposed confidence measure related to actual recovery errors?
-
Can the authors provide broader video robustness experiments, detection metrics, and more convincing video-quality results?
-
How secure is the method when the same key and watermark information are reused across videos?