- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes VERSA, a world-model framework for safe tool use under hidden execution rules. It uses conditional flow matching to infer a joint posterior over plausible rule configurations and a rule-conditioned transition model to predict candidate-plan outcomes. Based on these predictions, VERSA performs risk-constrained planning and selectively acquires decision-relevant information. Experiments on retail and airline workflows demonstrate improvements in safe task completion over the selected baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies a practical challenge in tool-using agents: identical observations and tool interfaces may conceal different execution rules, potentially causing irreversible errors. Explicitly modeling these uncertainties is valuable for safe decision-making.
-
VERSA combines rule posterior inference, rule-conditioned outcome prediction, and risk-aware decision-making into a coherent framework. The experiments and ablations demonstrate substantial improvements in safe success rates, particularly from considering multiple rule hypotheses.
Critical weaknesses
- The main baselines primarily consist of conventional LLM agents and earlier world-model planners, while several recent studies have explicitly addressed uncertainty in planning and decision-making. For example, BB-WMs[1] introduce explicit belief representations alongside world-model simulations to support decision-making under partial observability; PlanU[2] incorporates uncertainty-aware planning into MCTS as RAP's optimization; and DreamPhase[3] uses a learned latent world model to simulate multiple future trajectories with uncertainty-aware evaluation. The absence of comparisons with these methods limits the evidence for VERSA's advantages over existing uncertainty-aware planning approaches.
- Insufficiently differentiated methodological contributions. Although the paper addresses an interesting application scenario involving hidden execution rules, its methodological novelty relative to existing uncertainty-aware planning approaches remains unclear. The paper does not sufficiently explain why existing methods cannot be directly applied or adapted to this setting, or what fundamental limitations VERSA specifically overcomes.
[1] Towards a Belief-Based World Model for LLM Agents, arXiv:2609.00455.
[2] PlanU: Large Language Model Reasoning through Planning under Uncertainty, NeurIPS 2025.
[3] DreamPhase: Offline Imagination and Uncertainty-Guided Planning for Large-Language-Model Agents, ICLR 2026.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors provide additional comparisons with recent uncertainty-aware planning methods, such as BB-WMs, PlanU, and DreamPhase, or suitable adaptations of their core mechanisms, to better demonstrate VERSA's advantages?
- What are the essential methodological differences between VERSA and existing Bayesian or uncertainty-aware model-based planning approaches? Why are these approaches insufficient for the proposed hidden-rule setting, and what specific limitations does VERSA address?
5 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. The additional comparisons in Q1 have addressed my concern about the missing relevant baselines.
However, my concern regarding Q2 remains. While the authors clarify VERSA's design choices, I am still unclear about why existing Bayesian or uncertainty-aware planning methods cannot be directly adapted to the proposed hidden-rule setting, and what specific methodological limitations VERSA overcomes. I hope you can list a method feature to more clearly explain this point when creating the table. I believe this distinction is crucial to establishing the paper's core contribution.
If the authors can convincingly clarify this point, I would be willing to raise my rating to 3.
Thank you for the follow-up.
VERSA contributes a decision procedure for tool use when the rule in force has not been identified. Before acting, it predicts the outcome of every candidate plan, and of stopping, under every plausible rule and after pending effects settle, and it selects under a risk constraint on these predictions.
Why existing methods cannot be applied directly. Three of their premises do not hold under hidden rules.
-
A single dynamics model. BB-WM specifies its belief and update for known environment rules, and PlanU and DreamPhase plan within one world model. Here deployments with identical interfaces follow different rules, and the rule in force is itself unknown.
-
Responses that reflect outcomes. All three treat the response to an action as its outcome. Effects may be delayed and failures unreported, so the response does not determine the outcome.
-
Safe exploration. PlanU explores, DreamPhase falls back to real interaction, and BB-WM gathers information by acting. A tool call may be irreversible, and pending effects still take place after the agent stops. VERSA therefore converts rule uncertainty into the risk of an irreversible action and bounds it before acting.
Quantities required by a risk-constrained decision. Such a decision requires, for each plan, the probabilities of a violation and of safe success. Neither is determined by an expected return, by a value penalized by policy uncertainty, or by the LLM's judgment, since a single number merges the two events. VERSA computes both: it infers a joint posterior over rule configurations, reconstructs the current state under each hypothesis by replaying the history, and rolls out every plan with the hypothesis held fixed until pending effects settle.
Method features
| BB-WM | PlanU | DreamPhase | VERSA | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Environment rules | one set, known | one world model | one learned world model | several plausible sets; the one in force is hidden |
| Predicted before acting | validity of the next action | return of action sequences; outcomes sampled per step | imagined branches of fixed length, scored by a value head | success and violation of every plan, and of stopping, under every plausible rule, after effects settle |
| Decision based on | the LLM's judgment | expected return plus an exploration bonus | value penalized by policy uncertainty; confidence gate | violation probability within a threshold, then highest safe success |
| Information acquired by | acting | exploration | real interaction when uncertain | a query, only when the answer can change the decision |
Decisions without identifying the rule. On the main panels, the most probable rule differs from the true rule in 110 of 122 retail and 475 of 574 airline episodes, and VERSA queries in 14 and 6 episodes. The table compares it with a planner using only the most probable rule (Table 2, row 2), given the same posterior and transition model.
| SS ↑ (%) | Retail, estimate incorrect | Retail, estimate correct | Airline, estimate incorrect | Airline, estimate correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planner using the most probable rule | 46.46 | 100.00 | 53.32 | 90.00 |
| VERSA | 97.92 | 100.00 | 87.78 | 92.50 |
The single-rule planner is reliable only when its estimate is correct, whereas the safe success of VERSA is nearly unaffected. The differences for incorrect estimates are statistically significant.
Supplying VERSA's predictions to an existing method. The adapted BB-WM of Q1 receives VERSA's rule posterior and its predictions for every plan and for stopping. A new experiment also imposes VERSA's risk constraint in two steps, leaving the choice to the LLM.
| Adapted BB-WM | Retail SS ↑ / U ↓ (%) | Airline SS ↑ / U ↓ (%) |
|---|---|---|
| with VERSA's posterior and predictions (Q1) | 61.20 / 26.04 | 79.10 / 13.77 |
| + one plan only; told which plans meet the threshold | 60.68 / 14.32 | 75.32 / 9.10 |
| + threshold enforced | 64.32 / 8.33 | 74.94 / 7.76 |
| VERSA | 97.92 / 2.08 | 88.09 / 3.52 |
The constraint lowers its violation rate in both domains. VERSA remains ahead of every version, by 33.6 and 13.2 points of safe success over the last one and by 16.0 points on the new-user panel, all statistically significant.
Relation to Bayesian planning. VERSA shares with Bayesian planning the posterior and the practice of holding a hypothesis fixed within a simulation. It differs in three respects.
-
The posterior over rules is learned. No likelihood model of the rules is available, so it is inferred from interaction histories.
-
The decision is defined on the probabilities of violation and safe success, not on expected return as in the standard formulation. The former is constrained, for stopping as well as for execution, and Prop. 1 bounds the resulting risk.
-
Information is obtained by queries rather than by trial and error, and only when the answer can change the decision. Prop. 2 and Cor. 1 bound the loss from deciding before the rule is identified.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive suggestions. We adapted all three methods to our tasks, keeping the core mechanism of each and using Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct, the backbone of Table 1, and evaluated them on the complete retail, airline and new-user panels (SS: safe success; U: violation rate).
Q1.
VERSA achieves higher safe success, fewer violations and lower tool cost than all three methods on every panel.
VERSA is ahead by 9.0 to 50.4 points in safe success, and all differences in safe success and violation rate are statistically significant.
The advantage is largest on delayed-effect tasks. On airline, the four methods are within 84-92% when effects are immediate. When effects are delayed, VERSA reaches 92.5% safe success with no violation, against 73.9%, 39.2% and 34.3% for the three adapted methods.
Q2.
Existing uncertainty-aware planners model uncertainty in the state, in returns or in imagined trajectories. In the hidden-rule setting the uncertainty lies in the rules: a hidden configuration that is fixed for the whole episode and determines the consequence of every action. VERSA differs in three respects.
The rule posterior alone is not sufficient: the adapted BB-WM and DreamPhase receive VERSA's posterior and still trail by 9.0 to 50.4 points.
We will add these comparisons to Sec. 5 and discuss the three papers in Related Work.