- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors acknowledge that the drafting, writing, and copy-editing of this paper involves the use of AI tools. This is not a problem per se, but, as a reviewer, I find the resulting manuscript extremely hard to read, understand, or interpret.
This is my (very rough, possibly mistaken) understanding:
- In a simulated mobile network scenario of n cells, each cell is associated with 3 parameters. Every 5 minutes, every cell reports some indicators, two of which are relevant for safety (the "drop rate" and the "handovers"). A "plan" is a choice of these three parameters for every cell at every time step, and there's a baseline plan A_0. A plan is useful relative to the improvements of the indicators over A_0, and is unsafe if its worst drop rate or its worst handover are worse than the baseline.
- The goal is to propose a planner that is more useful and more safe than existing models, especially ood.
- The authors claim that a planner that re-plans hourly and abstains when necessary is more useful and safer ood.
Critical strengths
- I do not understand the paper with enough detail to point at strengths.
Critical weaknesses
The manuscript is extremely hard to follow, because the main text does not define most of its objects, including the experimental scenario.
- The intro does not explain what is trained and what is not, nor on what data. It does not say what the seeds vary, it does not mention what the type of models are, what is the baseline. It introduces generic terms without defining or explaining them (e.g., "a model removes", "oracle caution", "demand", "environment model", "feature interface", "first regime", "open-loop planner", ...). The same comments apply to the figures.
- All the main terms ("admission ceiling", "handover margin", "time to trigger", the quality indicators, the safety indicators, J, ...) are introduced without any definition or explanation (what is their type? what are their units? what do they mean? ...). The same applies to the environments and the features.
- The values of the baseline A_0 is not present in the main text.
- The utility and safety test are not defined in the main text.
- It is not clear what the data is.
- ...
Therefore, I opt to flag this for ethics review (unprofessional behavior).
Questions for authors
N/A.