- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper argues that counting constraints is not enough to explain instruction following failures. It models each instruction as a numeric constraint, and measures three properties of the model's own successful outputs: slack, solution concentration and conditional perplexity. It shows compliance correlates with all three, and that constraint sets with the same count can differ by more than 50 points once difficulty is accounted for. It also extends the analysis to multi-constraint, infeasible and fuzzy instructions, and shows prompt interventions guided by these measurements improve compliance.
Critical strengths
- The paper takes shared-sample bias seriously: difficulty is estimated on Stream A and compliance is measured on a disjoint Stream B, with leave-one-model-out transfer on top.
- The main finding is clean and non-trivial. At a fixed constraint count, follow rate drops from 85% to 37% to 12% across difficulty terciles, which is a direct problem for count-based evaluation.
- The intervention study reports a generic control and random assignment alongside the targeted condition, so the gain is not just "more prompting".
Critical weaknesses
Slack requires a scalar output statistic and a numeric boundary, so the framework is undefined for constraints like tone, persona, or "do not mention X", which are much of real prompts. The fuzzy section does not help: it states it still focuses only on countable output properties. Only three models are tested, all 26B or smaller. Since difficulty is defined as model-conditioned, it is unclear whether the conclusions hold for frontier models.
Questions for authors
Is there any evidence that the difficulty account transfers to non-numeric constraints such as tone or style, where no scalar statistic or boundary exists? How many generations are needed to estimate the difficulty of one constraint in practice, and can the measurements be approximated with fewer samples?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer FHhS Q1
Q1: Is there any evidence that the difficulty account transfers to non-numeric constraints such as tone or style, where no scalar statistic or boundary exists? How many generations are needed to estimate the difficulty of one constraint in practice, and can the measurements be approximated with fewer samples?
1 Generalization to Non-Numeric Semantic Constraints
Yes it transfers. Our additional experiments show that all three difficulty properties remain predictive of semantic instruction-following, even when constraints lack explicit numerical boundaries.
We evaluate 12 semantic constraints across four families—tone, persona, writing style, and semantic exclusion—on the OpenEnded task. Because these instructions lack intrinsic scalar boundaries, we operationalize semantic slack as a calibrated satisfaction margin, rather than a geometric distance. Satisfaction is assessed using a human-calibrated semantic judge, with an independent judge evaluating held-out compliance.
Importantly, all three measurements retain their expected relationships with independently measured instruction-following rates: semantic slack ((\rho=+0.57)), solution concentration ((\rho=-0.38)), and conditional perplexity ((\rho=-0.46)). Beyond empirical IFR alone, adding the three measurements improves held-out AUROC from 0.704 to 0.748 and reduces Brier score from 0.194 to 0.177. Semantic slack independently contributes an additional 0.021 AUROC beyond concentration and perplexity.
These findings provide evidence that the difficulty framework captures properties of instruction following beyond mechanically measurable constraints. While semantic slack requires a calibrated satisfaction criterion, the predictive relationships persist without an intrinsic numerical boundary.
We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details in Apx E.6 to complement the main text (LINE 1888-1922).
2 Measurement Efficiency and Practical Feasibility
Yes it can. Our additional sample-efficiency analysis shows that 10–15 successful generations are sufficient to preserve most of the measured relative difficulty and predictive utility, compared with our original 20-sample reference.
We systematically reduce the measurement budget from 20 to 5, 10, and 15 successful generations per instance–constraint condition, evaluating measurement stability and correlations with IFR estimated from independent generations. At 10 successful samples, rank agreement with the 20-sample reference reaches 0.941 for slack, 0.883 for concentration, and 0.916 for perplexity, with 84.4% difficulty-tercile agreement. More importantly, the mean absolute correlation with independent IFR is 0.518, retaining 95.2% of the original predictive strength (0.544). At 15 successful samples, all three rank correlations exceed 0.94, tercile agreement rises to 92.2%, and predictive strength retention reaches 98.0%. These results indicate that 20 successful samples represent a conservative reference rather than a strict practical requirement. In the evaluated settings, 10–15 successful generations offer a reasonable trade-off between efficiency and reliability. The total number of generation attempts still depends on the underlying constraint success rate, and particularly difficult constraints may require additional sampling.
We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details iin Apx F to complement the main text (LINE 2141-2184).
Invitation for Further Discussion
Thank you again for your detailed and constructive feedback. We have carefully addressed your concerns, regarding extensions to frontier models, non-numeric fuzziness and sample efficiency, through new controlled experiments.
We would especially appreciate your thoughts on whether the new evidence helps clarify the methodological contributions and practical value. We would be happy to address any remaining concerns.
Response to Reviewer FHhS W1
W1: Slack requires a scalar output statistic and a numeric boundary, so the framework is undefined for constraints like tone, persona, or "do not mention X", which are much of real prompts. The fuzzy section does not help: it states it still focuses only on countable output properties. Only three models are tested, all 26B or smaller. Since difficulty is defined as model-conditioned, it is unclear whether the conclusions hold for frontier models.Held-Out Frontier-Model Transfer
Yes, our difficulty measurements generalise beyond the original 8B–26B models to four evaluated frontier models. We perform a new held-out evaluation on four frontier models: Qwen 3.7 Plus, DeepSeek V4 Pro, GPT-6.1 Terra, and Claude Haiku 5.5. Crucially, all difficulty measurements and predictive models are derived exclusively from the original three 8B–26B models, without using any frontier-model data for estimation, training, or calibration. This directly tests whether the proposed properties capture difficulty information transferable beyond the original model suite. The results show consistent positive transfer. Adding our three difficulty properties to source-model IFR improves prediction of frontier-model constraint compliance across all four models, increasing macro-averaged Spearman correlation from 0.574 to 0.602 ((\Delta\rho=+0.028)), with improvements of (+0.019) to (+0.041) across individual models. These findings show that although difficulty is model-conditioned, the proposed properties capture aspects of instruction-following difficulty that are shared across the evaluated model families, providing predictive information beyond empirical source-model IFR. While the gains are modest and do not establish universal transferability, they demonstrate that the framework's utility is not confined to the original smaller models.
We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details in Apx E.2.1 to complement the main text (LINE 1739-1763).
Generalization to Non-Numeric Semantic Constraints
[Addressed below in “Response to Reviewer FHhS Q1”]