acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Beyond Constraint Counts: A Difficulty-Aware View of Instruction Following in Language Models

Abstract

Large language models increasingly operate under complex user instructions, where violating explicit requirements can undermine otherwise useful outputs. Many instruction-following evaluations summarise compliance at the task level or by constraint count, potentially obscuring substantial variation among individual requirements. We study whether model-conditioned properties of constrained satisfaction provide a more informative characterisation of this variation. Across structurally graded tasks, we estimate individual difficulty using boundary slack, concentration among sampled successful outputs, and conditional perplexity. Compliance is consistently associated with all three properties, with a mean absolute correlation of \(|\rho|\approx0.55\), while prompt interventions designed to shift these properties improve compliance by approximately 6.5 percentage points on average. In multi-constraint settings, the same properties characterise interaction difficulty, where coupling can reduce constituent compliance by up to points, while at fixed constraint counts, mean follow rates differ by points across sets stratified by measured constituent difficulty. We further test controlled extensions beyond feasible sharp constraints, showing that across low to high difficulty settings, infeasibility recognition and fuzzified properties increase by approximately \(70.7%\) and change with a mean , respectively. Together, these results provide evidence that difficulty-aware measurements capture variation in instruction following that raw constraint counts miss, motivating broader evaluation of difficulty-aware diagnostics and mitigation.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Instruction Following, Large Language Models, Constraint Satisfaction, Instruction Difficulty, Compliance Evaluation, Boundary Slack, Solution Concentration, Conditional Perplexity, Multi-Constraint Interactions, Difficulty-Aware Evaluation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_FHhSOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper argues that counting constraints is not enough to explain instruction following failures. It models each instruction as a numeric constraint, and measures three properties of the model's own successful outputs: slack, solution concentration and conditional perplexity. It shows compliance correlates with all three, and that constraint sets with the same count can differ by more than 50 points once difficulty is accounted for. It also extends the analysis to multi-constraint, infeasible and fuzzy instructions, and shows prompt interventions guided by these measurements improve compliance.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper takes shared-sample bias seriously: difficulty is estimated on Stream A and compliance is measured on a disjoint Stream B, with leave-one-model-out transfer on top.
  2. The main finding is clean and non-trivial. At a fixed constraint count, follow rate drops from 85% to 37% to 12% across difficulty terciles, which is a direct problem for count-based evaluation.
  3. The intervention study reports a generic control and random assignment alongside the targeted condition, so the gain is not just "more prompting".
Critical weaknesses

Slack requires a scalar output statistic and a numeric boundary, so the framework is undefined for constraints like tone, persona, or "do not mention X", which are much of real prompts. The fuzzy section does not help: it states it still focuses only on countable output properties. Only three models are tested, all 26B or smaller. Since difficulty is defined as model-conditioned, it is unclear whether the conclusions hold for frontier models.

Questions for authors

Is there any evidence that the difficulty account transfers to non-numeric constraints such as tone or style, where no scalar statistic or boundary exists? How many generations are needed to estimate the difficulty of one constraint in practice, and can the measurements be approximated with fewer samples?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FHhS W1

W1: Slack requires a scalar output statistic and a numeric boundary, so the framework is undefined for constraints like tone, persona, or "do not mention X", which are much of real prompts. The fuzzy section does not help: it states it still focuses only on countable output properties. Only three models are tested, all 26B or smaller. Since difficulty is defined as model-conditioned, it is unclear whether the conclusions hold for frontier models.

Held-Out Frontier-Model Transfer

Yes, our difficulty measurements generalise beyond the original 8B–26B models to four evaluated frontier models. We perform a new held-out evaluation on four frontier models: Qwen 3.7 Plus, DeepSeek V4 Pro, GPT-6.1 Terra, and Claude Haiku 5.5. Crucially, all difficulty measurements and predictive models are derived exclusively from the original three 8B–26B models, without using any frontier-model data for estimation, training, or calibration. This directly tests whether the proposed properties capture difficulty information transferable beyond the original model suite. The results show consistent positive transfer. Adding our three difficulty properties to source-model IFR improves prediction of frontier-model constraint compliance across all four models, increasing macro-averaged Spearman correlation from 0.574 to 0.602 ((\Delta\rho=+0.028)), with improvements of (+0.019) to (+0.041) across individual models. These findings show that although difficulty is model-conditioned, the proposed properties capture aspects of instruction-following difficulty that are shared across the evaluated model families, providing predictive information beyond empirical source-model IFR. While the gains are modest and do not establish universal transferability, they demonstrate that the framework's utility is not confined to the original smaller models.

We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details in Apx E.2.1 to complement the main text (LINE 1739-1763).

Generalization to Non-Numeric Semantic Constraints

[Addressed below in “Response to Reviewer FHhS Q1”]

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FHhS Q1

Q1: Is there any evidence that the difficulty account transfers to non-numeric constraints such as tone or style, where no scalar statistic or boundary exists? How many generations are needed to estimate the difficulty of one constraint in practice, and can the measurements be approximated with fewer samples?

1 Generalization to Non-Numeric Semantic Constraints

Yes it transfers. Our additional experiments show that all three difficulty properties remain predictive of semantic instruction-following, even when constraints lack explicit numerical boundaries.

We evaluate 12 semantic constraints across four families—tone, persona, writing style, and semantic exclusion—on the OpenEnded task. Because these instructions lack intrinsic scalar boundaries, we operationalize semantic slack as a calibrated satisfaction margin, rather than a geometric distance. Satisfaction is assessed using a human-calibrated semantic judge, with an independent judge evaluating held-out compliance.

Importantly, all three measurements retain their expected relationships with independently measured instruction-following rates: semantic slack ((\rho=+0.57)), solution concentration ((\rho=-0.38)), and conditional perplexity ((\rho=-0.46)). Beyond empirical IFR alone, adding the three measurements improves held-out AUROC from 0.704 to 0.748 and reduces Brier score from 0.194 to 0.177. Semantic slack independently contributes an additional 0.021 AUROC beyond concentration and perplexity.

These findings provide evidence that the difficulty framework captures properties of instruction following beyond mechanically measurable constraints. While semantic slack requires a calibrated satisfaction criterion, the predictive relationships persist without an intrinsic numerical boundary.

We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details in Apx E.6 to complement the main text (LINE 1888-1922).

2 Measurement Efficiency and Practical Feasibility

Yes it can. Our additional sample-efficiency analysis shows that 10–15 successful generations are sufficient to preserve most of the measured relative difficulty and predictive utility, compared with our original 20-sample reference.

We systematically reduce the measurement budget from 20 to 5, 10, and 15 successful generations per instance–constraint condition, evaluating measurement stability and correlations with IFR estimated from independent generations. At 10 successful samples, rank agreement with the 20-sample reference reaches 0.941 for slack, 0.883 for concentration, and 0.916 for perplexity, with 84.4% difficulty-tercile agreement. More importantly, the mean absolute correlation with independent IFR is 0.518, retaining 95.2% of the original predictive strength (0.544). At 15 successful samples, all three rank correlations exceed 0.94, tercile agreement rises to 92.2%, and predictive strength retention reaches 98.0%. These results indicate that 20 successful samples represent a conservative reference rather than a strict practical requirement. In the evaluated settings, 10–15 successful generations offer a reasonable trade-off between efficiency and reliability. The total number of generation attempts still depends on the underlying constraint success rate, and particularly difficult constraints may require additional sampling.

We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details iin Apx F to complement the main text (LINE 2141-2184).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Invitation for Further Discussion

Thank you again for your detailed and constructive feedback. We have carefully addressed your concerns, regarding extensions to frontier models, non-numeric fuzziness and sample efficiency, through new controlled experiments.

We would especially appreciate your thoughts on whether the new evidence helps clarify the methodological contributions and practical value. We would be happy to address any remaining concerns.

Reviewer_EDqWOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper suggests metrics for the difficulty of multi-constraint prompts that go beyond the number of constraints in the prompt. The authors argue that constraint count alone is insufficient to characterize difficulty, as different constraints can vary substantially in how difficult they are for a model to satisfy. They introduce three metrics for characterizing the difficulty of individual constraints: boundary slack, which measures the distance of a valid output from the constraint boundary; solution-space concentration, which measures how concentrated valid outputs are among a small number of distinct solutions; and conditional perplexity, which is based on the probability the model assigns to outputs satisfying the constraint. The authors evaluate these metrics across three tasks, including tasks where outputs can be precisely verified, along with more open-ended settings: mathematical scheduling problems, code-generation tasks, and open-ended question answering. The experiments involve three LLMs, three prompt templates, and repeated generations. The results show correlations between the proposed metrics and instruction-following rates. The authors also introduce prompt-level interventions that improve performance and investigate pairwise constraint interactions, the effect of increasing constraint counts, infeasible constraints, and fuzzy constraints.

Critical strengths

Complementary difficulty metrics beyond constraint count - The paper introduces three metrics for characterizing individual constraint difficulty and shows that all three correlate with instruction-following rates. Furthermore, combining the metrics achieves better predictive performance than using each metric individually, suggesting that they provide complementary information. This offers a richer approach to evaluating difficulty and helps explain variations in model performance that cannot be accounted for by constraint count alone.

Evaluation across environments with different levels of structure - The paper evaluates the proposed metrics across three environments, ranging from formal mathematical problems to code-generation tasks and open-ended question answering. This allows the authors to examine how the metrics behave as the output space becomes less structured and provides evidence that they remain relevant beyond formal settings where outputs can be precisely verified.

Clear presentation and organization - The paper is well organized, clearly written, and easy to follow. The authors first introduce the mathematical framework and difficulty metrics, then systematically evaluate them across different experimental settings. This structure makes the motivation, methodology, and main findings easy to understand.

Critical weaknesses

Higher-Order Interactions: The analysis is limited to constraint pairs, ignoring the difficulty of combining three or more constraints. Testing larger sets where individual or pairwise constraints are easy but the joint set is hard would clarify if a broader joint difficulty metric is necessary.

Intervention Applicability: Providing valid solution examples in the Diversity and Accessibility interventions may inflate performance independently of metric-specific targeting. Additionally, pre-generating valid solutions is often impractical in real-world tasks, making example-free improvements (like the Slack intervention) more relevant to test.

Fuzzy Constraint Compliance: While the paper tracks how metrics shift under restrictive fuzzy constraints, it lacks direct evaluation (e.g., human evaluation) to confirm if these metrics actually predict instruction-following success. Metric changes alone do not guarantee lower compliance rates.

Questions for authors

None

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer EDqW W1

W1 Higher-Order Interactions: The analysis is limited to constraint pairs, ignoring the difficulty of combining three or more constraints. Testing larger sets where individual or pairwise constraints are easy but the joint set is hard would clarify if a broader joint difficulty metric is necessary.

Pairwise interactions explain most of the observed variation in triplet difficulty, supporting their use as the primary diagnostic, while establishing residual higher-order effects.

To investigate this directly, we added a controlled triplet experiment (Appendix E.9). Across OpenEnded, MBPP, and Scheduling, we evaluate eight feasible triplets per task, including four per task whose constituent constraints are individually easy (IFR ≥ 0.75) and whose pairs are also easy (IFR ≥ 0.70).

Our findings show that pairwise interactions explain much, but not all, of triplet difficulty. Incorporating pairwise information reduces triplet IFR prediction MAE from 12.1 to 7.6 percentage points (36.8% improvement), while increasing out-of-sample (R^2) from 0.46 to 0.70. Importantly, 2 of the 12 pairwise-easy triplets become unexpectedly difficult jointly, confirming that pairwise difficulty does not fully determine higher-order difficulty.

To investigate this residual, we additionally fit a pairwise-only model using satisfaction statistics measured under the triplet prompt itself. Its lower MAE (4.5 percentage points) suggests that some prediction error arises from changes in prompting context, rather than necessarily requiring explicit three-way dependence. The resulting conclusion is that pairwise interactions provide an informative primary diagnostic of joint difficulty, but are not exhaustive. We have revised the paper accordingly and added this high-order analysis with full experimental details in Apx E.9 to complement the main text [LINE 2000-2051].

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer EDqW W2

W2: Intervention Applicability: Providing valid solution examples in the Diversity and Accessibility interventions may inflate performance independently of metric-specific targeting. Additionally, pre-generating valid solutions is often impractical in real-world tasks, making example-free improvements (like the Slack intervention) more relevant to test.

Our existing matched-control experiments demonstrate that metric-specific targeting improves instruction following beyond simply providing valid examples, while new demonstration-free experiments establish that difficulty-guided mitigation remains effective without successful examples at inference time.

1 Metric-specific targeting
Our existing matched-control experiments isolate and confirm the additional value of metric-specific targeting, demonstrating that selecting valid examples using our proposed difficulty measurements yields consistent improvements beyond untargeted valid-example provision. This is reported in Section “Targeted Interventions on Difficulty Measures”. Specifically, we construct matched controls that preserve the provision of valid examples while removing metric-specific selection. Our results show that metric-specific targeting provides additional improvements beyond simply supplying valid examples. As reported in Table (\ref{tab}) (Left), the Diversity intervention improves IFR by (+3.07) percentage points over its matched control (95% CI: ([1.28,4.78])), while Accessibility achieves an additional (+3.18) points (95% CI: ([1.76,4.62])). These advantages are consistent across all three evaluated tasks. For Diversity, targeted/control IFR gains are (7.25/3.15) (OpenEnded), (3.75/1.95) (MBPP), and (7.15/3.85) (Scheduling). For Accessibility, the corresponding gains are (7.55/3.70), (6.80/3.25), and (4.10/1.95) percentage points. Therefore, we do not attribute the entirety of the observed IFR improvements to metric-specific targeting. Rather, our matched-control results distinguish the general benefit of providing valid examples from the additional benefit of selecting those examples according to the proposed difficulty measurements. The consistently positive targeted-minus-control differences, with confidence intervals excluding zero, support our claim that the measurements provide actionable information beyond untargeted example provision.

2 Testing example-free improvements
No, difficulty-guided mitigation is not dependent on providing successful examples at inference time. We provide a complementary analysis of the interventions to test whether difficulty-guided mitigation remains effective when no successful demonstrations are provided in the inference prompt. Even under this restriction, metric-guided intervention selection improves held-out IFR by +4.28 percentage points, outperforming both the development-selected best-fixed intervention (+3.15) and frequency-matched permutation (+3.18). The latter comparison is particularly informative: even with the same intervention frequencies, matching interventions to individual constraints using difficulty measurements yields an additional +1.10-point improvement. Although the gain is smaller than with demonstrations (+5.85 points), this result shows that the usefulness of difficulty-guided selection is not limited to demonstration-based prompting. We acknowledge that estimating difficulty profiles still requires offline sampling and verification; our result specifically removes the need to supply successful demonstrations at inference time.

We have revised the paper accordingly and added this demo-free analysis with full experimental details in Apx C.5 to complement the main text [LINE 1471-1499].

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer EDqW W3

W3: Fuzzy Constraint Compliance: While the paper tracks how metrics shift under restrictive fuzzy constraints, it lacks direct evaluation (e.g., human evaluation) to confirm if these metrics actually predict instruction-following success. Metric changes alone do not guarantee lower compliance rates.

Our new human evaluation shows that the proposed difficulty measurements predict actual compliance with fuzzy instructions, rather than merely tracking changes in output properties. Specifically, a human annotator evaluated fuzzy instruction compliance on OpenEnded and MBPP without imposing fixed numerical thresholds, preserving the context-dependent interpretation of fuzzy requirements (inter-annotator agreement: =0.71). The results provide two complementary findings:

  1. Actual compliance decreases with difficulty: Human-rated IFR falls from 80.0% to 50.3% on OpenEnded and from 77.3% to 45.0% on MBPP as fuzzy modifiers strengthen.
  2. Our measurements independently predict compliance: Adding the three difficulty measurements improves held-out AUROC from 0.636 to 0.712 on OpenEnded and 0.645 to 0.719 on MBPP (mean: 0.641 to 0.716), beyond a baseline controlling for constraint family, modifier intensity, model, and prompt template. Each measurement contributes predictive information individually, with slack providing the strongest individual signal.

Importantly, difficulty measurements were estimated from separate calibration generations, while compliance was assessed on independently sampled responses using leave-one-task-instance-out validation, avoiding shared-sample bias. These findings show that our measurements predict independently human-judged instruction-following compliance, rather than merely reflecting changes in output properties.

We have revised the paper accordingly and added this analysis with full experimental details in Apx E.5 to complement the main text (LINE 1854-1884).

I thank the authors for the additional experiments. The human evaluation of fuzzy constraints directly addresses my concern. The triplet experiment is helpful, though it remains unclear whether pairwise interactions would still explain most of the difficulty for larger constraint sets, and this would be worth exploring further. As for the demonstration-free experiment, the 1.10-point gain over the frequency-matched baseline is fairly modest, especially since estimating the metrics still requires generating and verifying valid solutions beforehand. Given these, I maintain my score.

Reviewer_qsunOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper highlights the limitations of evaluating the instruction-following performance of LLMs solely based on constraint count and proposes an analytical framework that considers the difficulty of individual constraints. Specifically, the authors quantify constraint difficulty using three properties: boundary slack, solution concentration, and conditional perplexity. Across three tasks, Scheduling, MBPP, and OpenEnded, they analyze the correlations between these properties and instruction-following rates and examine performance improvements through prompt interventions. Furthermore, the authors investigate interactions among multiple constraints, the relationship between constraint count and difficulty, infeasible constraints, and fuzzy constraints, demonstrating that instruction-following performance cannot be sufficiently explained by constraint count alone.

Critical strengths
  • This paper focuses on the difficulty of individual constraints and constraint interactions, rather than relying solely on conventional constraint-count-based evaluation. In particular, it is interesting that instruction-following performance varies substantially with the difficulty of the constraints, even when the constraint count remains the same.
  • The authors analyze instruction-following difficulty from multiple perspectives, including individual constraints, multiple constraints, infeasible constraints, and fuzzy constraints, across three different tasks: Scheduling, MBPP, and OpenEnded.
  • Beyond demonstrating correlations between the proposed difficulty metrics and instruction-following rates, the authors examine the practical effectiveness of difficulty-aware information through targeted prompt interventions and matched controls.
Critical weaknesses
  • W1: Unclear novelty and necessity of the proposed difficulty metrics.
    • This paper proposes boundary slack, solution concentration, and conditional perplexity as measures of instruction-following difficulty. However, these are relatively common concepts in constraint satisfaction and probabilistic modeling, and it remains unclear what novelty they offer over existing difficulty measures.
    • While I understand the motivation that constraint count alone cannot sufficiently explain instruction-following difficulty, the paper lacks sufficient theoretical justification for why these three properties are appropriate for characterizing instruction-following difficulty. I would like the authors to clarify the rationale behind selecting these measures and their contributions relative to existing research.
    • Furthermore, the discussion of related work is insufficient, making it difficult to identify which aspects of this paper are novel. I recommend providing a more comprehensive discussion of prior studies to better establish the novelty and contributions of this work.
  • W2: Insufficient understanding of the individual contributions of the difficulty measures.
    • This paper demonstrates correlations between the three proposed difficulty measures and instruction-following rates (IFR), and further evaluates their effectiveness through matched controls, held-out evaluation, and additional baselines in Table 2 and Appendix E. However, it remains unclear what distinct failure mechanisms these measures capture.
    • In particular, the three measures may be correlated with one another, making it difficult to understand the independent contribution of each measure and the types of constraints for which each measure is effective. Rather than relying solely on aggregate correlations and performance improvements, I would like the authors to clarify the role of each measure through more detailed constraint-level analyses and qualitative examples.
    • Similarly, I would appreciate further discussion or evaluation to justify the selection of tasks and evaluation settings. Specifically, I would like the authors to elaborate on why these tasks and settings can be considered sufficiently distinct from one another or representative of broader instruction-following scenarios.
  • W3: Writing and presentation.
    • The paper delegates essential methodological details, such as dataset construction, to the Appendix, making it difficult to assess the validity of the experimental settings from the main text alone. I have only briefly reviewed the Appendix rather than a detailed review. Appendix should contain supplementary information rather than serve as additional pages for essential methodological descriptions. The main text should be self-contained. If the page limitations prevent the authors from providing sufficient methodological details, I would recommend considering submission to a journal with more flexible page limits. However, if the authors believe that ICLR is an appropriate venue, I strongly recommend reorganizing the paper so that readers can understand and evaluate the study without referring to the Appendix.
    • Relatedly, the lack of descriptions of the evaluated models and experimental configurations makes the paper difficult to follow. Since these details are primarily provided in Appendix C, readers cannot fully understand the experimental setup from the main text. I would like the authors to follow standard scientific reporting practices by clearly describing, at a minimum, which models were evaluated and under what experimental settings, without requiring readers to consult the Appendix.
Questions for authors

Rather than questions, I would like to offer the following suggestions for the authors to address:

  • Please address the three major weaknesses raised above (W1-W3). I have included specific suggestions for improvement in each bottom item.
  • This paper analyzes various settings, including individual constraint difficulty, constraint interactions, infeasible constraints, and fuzzy constraints. However, it remains unclear what new insights these findings collectively provide for practical instruction-following evaluation and model development. Therefore, I believe that the paper would be strengthened by discussing what should be considered in future instruction-following tasks and evaluations based on these findings.
  • Regarding task selection, there are other types of tasks, such as logical reasoning chains and creative sentence composition involving linguistic phenomena. Further justification is needed to explain why the three selected tasks can be considered representative of instruction-following tasks. I would like the authors to discuss this from the perspective of task types rather than task formats.
  • I am willing to reconsider my evaluation if the authors adequately address the concerns raised above.
8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qsun W1-A

W1-A: This paper proposes boundary slack, solution concentration, and conditional perplexity as measures of instruction-following difficulty. However, these are relatively common concepts in constraint satisfaction and probabilistic modeling, and it remains unclear what novelty they offer over existing difficulty measures.

Our contribution is not the invention of these statistical quantities, but the demonstration that structural properties of successful LLM generations provide predictive and actionable information about instruction-following difficulty beyond conventional empirical success-rate measurements.

We clarify our novelty through three aspects.

First, empirical novelty: difficulty properties provide predictive information beyond observed IFR. A central question is whether these measurements capture meaningful aspects of instruction difficulty, or merely re-express the empirical probability of successfully following an instruction. We address this directly using independent generation samples and controlled predictive comparisons.

In Table 21, after controlling for independently estimated empirical IFR and fixed constraint boundaries, incorporating the three difficulty properties increases mean held-out AUROC from 0.648 to 0.702. This indicates that the measurements contain information about future compliance beyond the observed success rate of the same constraint.

We further evaluate whether this information transfers across models. In Table 23, using matched fitting and calibration procedures, augmenting source-model IFR with difficulty measurements improves cross-model prediction correlation from 0.602 to 0.660, reduces MAE from 9.8 to 8.7 percentage points, and increases out-of-sample R2 from 0.21 to 0.28. These improvements demonstrate that difficulty measurements capture transferable information not fully represented by empirical IFR or explained by additional calibration.

Second, practical novelty: difficulty measurements enable constraint-specific mitigation rather than merely describing failures. A useful characterization of difficulty should inform how instruction-following failures can be addressed. We therefore investigate whether measured difficulty profiles can prospectively select interventions suited to particular constraints.

As shown in Table 25, metric-guided intervention selection improves held-out IFR by 5.85 percentage points, outperforming both the development-selected best-fixed intervention by 1.79 points (95% CI: [1.16, 2.40]) and a frequency-matched intervention policy by 1.99 points (95% CI: [1.36, 2.59]). The latter control preserves the frequency of each intervention type, isolating the additional value of matching interventions to the difficulty profiles of individual constraints. Thus, the measurements support actionable decisions beyond selecting generally effective prompting strategies.

Third, conceptual novelty: a unified, model-conditioned account of instruction difficulty. The CSP perspective provides the rationale for selecting these three measurements. Boundary slack characterizes the robustness margin of successful outputs relative to constraint boundaries; solution concentration characterizes the distribution of successful outputs across distinct solution modes; and conditional perplexity characterizes their model-conditioned likelihood. These properties capture different aspects of the relationship between a model's output distribution and the feasible solution space.

Our contribution goes beyond adapting existing CSP measurements to LLMs: we establish and empirically validate a common difficulty-aware characterization across structurally different generation tasks. We demonstrate that properties of successful generations provide predictive information beyond empirical IFR and guide targeted improvements. Additional analyses of constraint interactions, capacity, infeasibility, and fuzziness examine the framework's scope and limitations. Together, these findings provide actionable information for predicting and improving instruction following.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qsun W1-B

W1-B: While I understand the motivation that constraint count alone cannot sufficiently explain instruction-following difficulty, the paper lacks sufficient theoretical justification for why these three properties are appropriate for characterizing instruction-following difficulty. I would like the authors to clarify the rationale behind selecting these measures and their contributions relative to existing research.

The three properties are theoretically motivated by complementary aspects of constrained generation, rather than selected arbitrarily from existing CSP measures. We have revised Sections 3–4 (Lines 97-112, 185–225) to clarify this selection rationale and its relationship to prior research.

First, our CSP formulation establishes why these properties are relevant. Section 3 represents each instruction as a constraint inducing a feasible output region, with joint satisfaction requiring membership in the intersection F_t(x, C) = ⋂_{c∈C} F_t(x, c). However, unlike classical CSP solvers, LLMs generate outputs probabilistically, Y ∼ p_θ(· | π_t(x, C)). Consequently, difficulty depends not only on the existence of feasible outputs, but also on their characteristics and the probability the model assigns to them. This distinction motivates examining three complementary aspects of successful generation: robustness, solution diversity, and conditional likelihood.

Second, each measurement captures a distinct aspect grounded in existing research:

  • Boundary Proximity (robustness): Classical CSP and optimisation research associates slack with distance from constraint boundaries and robustness to deviations [1-3]. We adapt this principle to LLM outputs, hypothesising that smaller margins indicate more fragile satisfaction.
  • Solution Space Concentration (diversity): CSP research connects solution-space clustering to problem difficulty [4,5]. Because LLM solution spaces cannot be enumerated analytically, we operationalise this perspective through Simpson concentration over sampled successful solution modes.
  • Conditional Accessibility (likelihood): Feasibility alone does not establish whether a probabilistic generator readily produces satisfying outputs. Building on likelihood-based language-generation analyses [6,7], we use response-token-normalised NLL to measure the conditional likelihood of observed successful outputs, complementing the geometric and diversity-based properties.

Third, our contribution is not the invention of these underlying mathematical concepts, but their joint operationalisation and validation as model-conditioned instruction-difficulty diagnostics. All three exhibit consistent directional associations with IFR across our three tasks. Importantly, their combined predictive value persists with independent generation samples and fixed constraint boundaries, while metric-targeted interventions outperform matched controls.

Together, the theoretical motivation and empirical validation support these three measurements as complementary, predictive, and actionable characterisations of instruction difficulty.


[1] S. Boyd and L. Vandenberghe, ‘Convex Optimization’. Cambridge University Press, Mar. 08, 2004. doi: 10.1017/cbo9780511804441.
[2] J. C. Beck, A. J. Davenport, E. D. Davis, and M. S. Fox, ‘The ODO project: toward a unified basis for constraint-directed scheduling’, J. Sched., vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 89–125, Aug. 1998, doi: 10.1002/(sici)1099-1425(199808)1:2<89::aid-jos9>3.0.co;2-h.
[3] A. Ben-Tal and A. Nemirovski, ‘Robust Convex Optimization’, Mathematics of OR, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 769–805, Nov. 1998, doi: 10.1287/moor.23.4.769.
[4] F. Krzakala and J. Kurchan, ‘Landscape analysis of constraint satisfaction problems’, Phys. Rev. E, vol. 76, no. 2, Aug. 2007, doi: 10.1103/physreve.76.021122.
[5] D. Achlioptas and F. Ricci-Tersenghi, ‘On the Solution-Space Geometry of Random Constraint Satisfaction Problems’, 2006, arXiv. doi: 10.48550/ARXIV.CS/0611052.
[6] [1] Z. Xu, F. Jiang, L. Niu, B. Y. Lin, and R. Poovendran, ‘Stronger Models are Not Always Stronger Teachers for Instruction Tuning’, Proceedings of the 2025 Conference of the Nations of the Americas Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers). Association for Computational Linguistics, pp. 4392–4405, 2025. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025.naacl-long.224.
[7] M. Li et al., ‘From Quantity to Quality: Boosting LLM Performance with Self-Guided Data Selection for Instruction Tuning’, Proceedings of the 2024 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers). Association for Computational Linguistics, pp. 7602–7635, 2024. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.naacl-long.421.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qsun W1-C

W1-C: Furthermore, the discussion of related work is insufficient, making it difficult to identify which aspects of this paper are novel. I recommend providing a more comprehensive discussion of prior studies to better establish the novelty and contributions of this work.

Our work advances prior instruction-following research by establishing a unified, model-conditioned framework that quantitatively characterises individual constraint difficulty and compositional interactions and demonstrates predictive and mitigation value.

  1. Beyond domain-specific IF evals. AGENTIF [1], EDIT-Bench [2], and LIFEBench [3] test IF challenges in agentic, code editing, and long-generation workflows, respectively. However, they do not systematically establish whether common, measurable properties of individual constraints explain difficulty across heterogeneous output spaces. We address this gap with a unified constraint-satisfaction formulation, evaluating model-conditioned difficulty across graded tasks (Secs. 3-4). We also validate generalization to unseen constraint families and an external benchmark, where difficulty measurements retain predictive and mitigation value (Apx. E.4).

  2. Beyond constraint count. FollowBench [7], Vasileva [4], and MulDimIF [5] show that IF declines as constraint counts and compositions increase. We instead ask which measurable properties of individual constraints predict difficulty beyond count, category, or baseline success rate. Our difficulty properties improve held-out prediction in a controlled fixed-boundary experiment with identical numerical requirements (Apx E.1). At five constraints, easy and hard sets differ in follow rates by over 50 percentage points (Sec. 5). We thus extend count-based evaluations to quantify individual-constraint difficulty.

  3. Beyond prior compositional IF. COLLIE [9] and ComplexBench [8] evaluate compositional constraints and their logical dependencies; Order Matters [6] examines difficulty and ordering, introducing CDDI. Rather than merely showing that composition matters, we quantify how specific constraint combinations alter individual and joint satisfaction. We introduce constituent marginal shift (CMS) and joint interaction penalty (JIP) to distinguish overlapping, additive, and coupled regimes (Sec. 4.3), then separately test their association with sampled feasible-solution diversity. Their mean log interaction ratios are approximately +0.15, −0.08, and −0.39, respectively. In higher-order analysis, pairwise information reduces triplet IFR prediction error by 36.8% relative to an independence baseline (Apx E.9). Our contribution is quantitative interaction diagnostics, not simply identifying difficult compositions.

  4. From measurement to mitigation. Prior work improves IF through constraint-rich training [5] and reordering [6]. We test whether measured difficulty can guide constraint-specific inference-time interventions. All three intervention families improve IFR, outperforming matched untargeted controls by 3.17 points on average (Sec. 4.2). On held-out data, metric-guided selection improves IFR by 5.85 points, versus 4.06 for the best fixed intervention and 3.86 for frequency-matched permutation (Apx E.3). Thus, difficulty metrics inform which intervention to use, not merely whether prompting helps.

In summary, our novelty and contributions are a unified, model-conditioned characterisation of individual and interaction difficulty, supported by controlled evidence of predictive value and mitigation. We have added a new dedicated section for Related Works in the paper. [LINE 82-94]


[1] Qi, Y., Peng, H, … Li, J. AGENTIF: Benchmarking Large Language Models Instruction Following Ability in Agentic Scenarios. NeurIPS 2025 Datasets and Benchmarks Track. [2] Chi, W., Chen, V., … Donahue, C. EDIT-Bench: Evaluating LLM Abilities to Perform Real-World Instructed Code Edits. ICLR 2026. [3] Zhang, W., Zhou, Z., … Su, S. LIFEBENCH: Evaluating Length Instruction Following in Large Language Models. NeurIPS 2025 Datasets and Benchmarks Track. [4] Vasileva, M. I. Large Language Models Can Follow Instructions, But Not Many at Once: Phase Transitions in Compositional Constraint Satisfaction. CompLearn 2026. [5] Ye, J., Huang, C., … Huang, X. MulDimIF: A Multi-Dimensional Constraint Framework for Evaluating and Improving Instruction Following in Large Language Models. Findings ACL 2026. [6] Zeng, J., He, Q., … Xiao, Y. Order Matters: Investigate the Position Bias in Multi-constraint Instruction Following. Findings ACL 2025 [7] Jiang, Y., Wang, Y., ... Wang, W. FollowBench: A multi-level fine-grained constraints following benchmark for large language models. ACL 2024. [8] Wen, B., Ke, P., ... Huang, M. Benchmarking complex instruction-following with multiple constraints composition. NeurIPS 2024. [9] Yao, S., Chen, H., ... Narasimhan, K. COLLIE: Systematic construction of constrained text generation tasks. ICLR 2024.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Rebuttal Posted

Dear Reviewers,

Thank you for your time and thoughtful feedback. We appreciate your reviews and have provided detailed responses to your comments. We would greatly welcome any further discussion or clarification requests you may have.

Thank you for your consideration.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.