- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ScopeIF is a training framework for precise instruction following with constraints that apply to particular response segments. It represents constraints using Scope, Target, and Range, and uses this schema to construct ScopeInstruct, with 16,968 training and 1,000 test instructions. Seed-2.0-Pro generates and combines constraints, while GPT-OSS-120B performs quality control and serves as the training judge. The judge can design response-specific Python tools and use their outputs to measure constraint violations. These measurements are converted into graded rewards and combined hierarchically with binary constraint satisfaction for GRPO training. Experiments on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B report improvements over DPO, binary-reward RL baselines, and existing instruction-following frameworks across ScopeIF-Test, IFEval, IFBench, and IFHierBench. The paper also evaluates verifier agreement with human annotations, reward aggregation, and general capabilities. The additional verification machinery is used during training rather than deployment inference.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important limitation of instruction following: constraints can apply to specific, repeated, or nested response segments. The Scope/Target/Range organization and the accompanying dataset provide a concrete way to study these cases beyond global response constraints.
The evaluation includes two policy sizes, several external instruction-following benchmarks, matched binary-reward baselines, and a human-annotated verifier evaluation. The reported gains and reward-aggregation ablation provide useful evidence for the proposed components within the chosen RL training setup.
Critical weaknesses
Limited conceptual novelty relative to the complexity of the pipeline. In my assessment, ScopeIF mainly combines a constraint taxonomy, LLM-based data synthesis, response-conditioned tool-assisted verification, and handcrafted reward shaping within standard GRPO. The Scope/Target/Range decomposition and hierarchical aggregation are reasonable engineering choices, but the paper does not sufficiently establish a substantial conceptual advance beyond their combination. In particular, the need for dynamically generated verification tools and the full reward-construction pipeline should be demonstrated against simpler ways of obtaining supervision from the same strong model.
The comparisons do not establish the value of this particular form of teacher supervision. ScopeIF uses GPT-OSS-120B's constraint-compliance judgments as reward feedback for student RL; it is not direct imitation of teacher answers. RL may offer advantages over answer imitation, but whether those advantages justify this framework in the present setting is an empirical question. The reward-design ablations operate within the RL setup, and the DPO comparison does not replace either of two key baselines: (a) standalone SFT on GPT-OSS-120B answers to the same training instructions and constraints; and (b) RL using GPT-OSS-120B scores obtained directly from an explicit constraint-based rubric, without response-specific Python tool generation or the full graded-reward machinery. The auxiliary SFT loss in Appendix E.2 is not baseline (a). Table 4 does compare pure LLM judges with tool-grounded verification, but that verifier-level comparison does not establish the downstream policy performance of baseline (b). The paper therefore shows benefits relative to selected reward designs without adequately testing whether a simpler teacher-supervision route would be comparable. These missing comparisons are central to assessing the necessity and practical value of the added complexity.
Questions for authors
Please compare three supervision routes on the same ScopeInstruct training instructions and the same initial Qwen3-4B/8B models: (a) GPT-OSS-120B generates answers, followed by standalone student SFT; (b) GPT-OSS-120B directly scores student responses using an explicit rubric derived from the instruction constraints, and those scores serve as rewards for RL; and (c) the full ScopeIF framework. For (b), use the same policy-optimization setup as ScopeIF while omitting response-specific tool generation and the full graded-reward construction. Evaluate all resulting policies on the same held-out benchmarks, and explain the teacher-use and training budgets. Is direct SFT comparable in this setting, and how much additional benefit does full ScopeIF provide over simpler rubric-based RL?
Table 4 evaluates pure LLM judging and tool-grounded verification at the verifier level. Does improved verification translate into a sufficiently better trained policy to justify the extra framework complexity? Please connect this result to the end-to-end rubric-based RL comparison above and clarify which part of the method provides the essential contribution.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer UEAP (Part 2/2)
Questions
Please refer to our response to Weakness 2 for the evaluation results. Regarding training budgets, the other RL ablations in Table 1 (excluding ScopeIF w/o TGV) theoretically require the same training budget as ScopeIF. While ScopeIF w/o TGV requires roughly half the judge token consumption of ScopeIF, their actual training times are nearly identical (44.5h vs. 40.6h on Qwen3-4B and 46.9h vs. 48.6h on Qwen3-8B) due to asynchronous rollout optimization. Given that the judge model is locally deployed without costly external API calls, this additional token overhead is a worthwhile trade-off for the substantial performance gains achieved by ScopeIF.
Dear Reviewer UEAP,
Thank you again for your insightful reviews. As the end of the discussion period draws near, we would like to ensure that we have adequately addressed all your concerns. If you have any further feedback, please do not hesitate to let us know.
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. They help clarify the contribution and address several of my concerns. While some concerns remain, I appreciate the additional evidence and will raise my score.
Response to Reviewer UEAP (Part 1/2)
Thanks for your comprehensive and detailed suggestions for our work! We hope our responses could address your concerns.
We appreciate the opportunity to further clarify the conceptual novelty of ScopeIF, which lies in two key aspects:
Thanks for your constructive suggestion. We agree that these baselines are necessary to isolate the contribution of each component of ScopeIF. In response to this concern, we evaluate the following baselines:
The results are as follows:
Across both existing ablations and these newly added baselines, ScopeIF substantially outperforms all counterparts overall, confirming the necessity of each component. We have included these new results in Table 1 of the revised manuscript.
[1] Yuetian Mao, et al. IFHierBench: Hierarchical Instruction Following for Large Language Models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.27912, 2026.
[2] Eran Goldstein, et al. LIFT: Scoped Constraints for Evaluating and Training Instruction Following. arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.28819, 2026.