acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Underused Verifier Signals? Refine and Replay for Multi-Constraint Instruction Following

Abstract

Multi-constraint instruction following requires a model to satisfy content, format, length, and lexical requirements jointly within one response. Group-relative reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards offers scalable supervision, but it typically compresses each verifier vector into a scalar reward. This compression obscures which constraints fail and whether equally rewarded responses require different corrections. We find that the discarded verifier structure can refine response-level credit, while successful on-policy siblings provide useful but potentially unsafe token-level supervision. Building on these observations, we introduce Verifier-Informed Refinement and Replay Optimization (VIRRO), which retains the scalar group-relative advantage as a carrier and adds two controlled learning paths.Reliability-calibrated alias refinement uses past-only constraint-family histories to differentiate responses with identical scalar credit while preserving carrier-resolved order and sign under a relative norm cap. Termination-safe peer replay reinforces a verified successful sibling only when termination, length, advantage, and same-group failure conditions admit the route. Across five instruction-tuned backbones and four programmatically checked benchmarks, VIRRO improves the corresponding base checkpoint on all 40 strict metrics and attains the highest local mean in 37 of 40 comparisons. Code is available at this anonymous repository.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
instruction following, RLVR, GRPO, verifier feedback, credit assignment, peer replay

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_pTF4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work presents Verifier-Informed Refinement and Replay Optimization for multi-constraint instruction following. It augments group-relative reinforcement learning with two components: Alias refinement, which uses historical constraint-family difficulty to distinguish responses receiving the same scalar credit, and Peer replay, which adds likelihood supervision on verified successful responses from the same rollout group. Experiments cover five instruction-tuned backbones, four programmatically verified benchmarks, and four semantically judged benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation is reasonable. Responses with the same aggregate reward can fail different constraints, and successful responses within a rollout group provide potentially useful supervision.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The motivation identifies a meaningful problem, but the proposed solutions do not address it as directly as the framing suggests. In Section 3.4, the verifier vector is converted into a difficulty-weighted score and ultimately a scalar advantage for each response. This does recover some distinctions lost by uniform averaging, but it remains unclear whether the benefit reflects learning which constraints need correction or simply changing the relative weights of responses. Section 3.5 similarly adds likelihood supervision on successful samples. Positive-example weighting has precedent in alignment methods such as KTO, which allows separate weights for desirable and undesirable outputs, although its objective differs from Peer replay.

  2. The connection between the two components, and their specific relevance to instruction following, is not sufficiently established. Alias refinement could apply to any task whose reward aggregates multiple rubric scores, while reinforcing verified successes is even more general. The existing ablations are useful, yet the shared-pipeline control in Table 3 shows a relatively modest joint gain on Qwen2.5-3B. More diagnostic evidence is needed to identify which instruction-following bottleneck these components jointly resolve. Alternatively, evaluation on another task with multiple rubrics would help substantiate their broader applicability.

  3. Most evaluated backbones are from older model families, and the experiments do not establish applicability to long chain-of-thought generation. Appendix B.5 does include Qwen3-4B, but new Qwen and recent models have much higher baseline scores on IFbench and other instruction following benchmarks. Moreover, Table 2 and Appendix B.1 specify a response limit of 1,280 tokens, with length penalties beginning above 1,024 tokens. This setting leaves open how the method behaves when training long-cot models.

Questions for authors

see weakness

Reviewer_7Fn2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards for instructions with multiple checkable constraints. It argues that compressing per-constraint check results into a single pass-rate score loses two signals: which constraints fail among equally scored responses, and the fully correct responses within the same sampled group. The proposed method, VIRRO, adds two modules on top of a DAPO-style pipeline: one uses historical pass rates of each constraint type to break ties among equally scored responses, and the other adds an imitation loss on a fully correct response from the same group. Experiments on five models and eight instruction-following benchmarks report improvements over GRPO, GDPO, and MDP-GRPO on most metrics.

Critical strengths
  • The paper targets a practical setting where a response is only useful if all constraints are satisfied.
  • The evaluation covers five models, programmatically checked and LLM-judged benchmarks, and general-capability retention.
Critical weaknesses
  • The novelty of the two modules seems limited. The tie-breaking module essentially gives slightly more credit to responses that satisfy harder constraint types, which is close in spirit to difficulty-weighted rewards and the per-dimension normalization in GDPO [1]. The imitation module trains on the model's own successful samples, which is similar to self-imitation and rejection-sampling fine-tuning [2, 3]. A clearer discussion of what is new relative to these methods would help.
  • The main comparison does not seem to be under matched conditions. VIRRO samples about three times as many responses per step and filters them before updating, and it also builds on DAPO-style [4] techniques such as asymmetric clipping, token-level loss averaging, and overlong penalties. It is not clear whether the baselines use the same budget, filtering, or these techniques. In the appendix, GDPO with the same generation budget, as well as VIRRO with both modules disabled, already comes close to the full method, which suggests much of the gain may come from the training setup.

[1] Liu, S.-Y., et al. GDPO: Group reward-decoupled normalization policy optimization for multi-reward RL optimization. arXiv:2601.05242, 2026.

[2] Oh, J., Guo, Y., Singh, S., and Lee, H. Self-imitation learning. ICML 2018.

[3] Dong, H., et al. RAFT: Reward rAnked FineTuning for generative foundation model alignment. TMLR 2023.

[4] Yu, Q., et al. DAPO: An open-source LLM reinforcement learning system at scale. NeurIPS 2025.

Questions for authors
  • The method involves many hand-designed rules and close to twenty hyperparameters, such as clipping of pass rates, bucketing tolerances, scaling caps, the rule for choosing which correct response to imitate, and a safety switch with warm-up and cooldown. It would help to clarify which of these are essential, since this affects reproducibility and transfer to other tasks. Ablations on all four hard-constraint benchmarks would help.
  • The paper is not easy to follow, as it introduces many new terms and leaves several important details to the appendix. The link to on-policy distillation [5, 6] is also not very clear to me, since the imitation module has no teacher distribution and the failed response only decides whether the loss is applied. In addition, HiR [7], a closely related method, is cited only for its evaluation protocol and is not included as a baseline. It is better to clarify these points and reorganize the paper.

[5] Agarwal, R., et al. On-policy distillation of language models: Learning from self-generated mistakes. ICLR 2024.

[6] Zhao, S., et al. Self-Distilled Reasoner: On-policy self-distillation for large language models. arXiv:2601.18734, 2026.

[7] Zhang, K., et al. Replay failures as successes: Sample-efficient reinforcement learning for instruction following. arXiv:2512.23457, 2025.

Reviewer_T4iiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Most RLVR methods consolidate feedback from multiple constraints to a single scalar. The paper shows that responses satisfying different subsets of constraints can receive the same reward, even though some constraint types are consistently harder for the model to satisfy. The paper proposes VIRRO, which uses historical pass rates to give more credit to tied responses that satisfy harder constraints.

Critical strengths

Fine-grained credit assignment is a real challenge in multi-constraint RLVR, and the paper offers a practical way to address it by using information the verifier already provides about which constraints each response satisfies. Unfortunately, merits of the paper are not clear due to substantial writing issues (see Weaknesses).

Critical weaknesses

I believe that the paper requires a lot of rewriting for it to be parseable. Right now, it seems like AI was heavily used in writing, but as AI writing often does, it cannot explain well. A lot of the paper is very dense and ends up diluting information. Some example of writing issues:

  • Terminology introduced before explaining it. For example, in the abstract "discarded verifier structure can refine response-level credit, while successful on-policy siblings provide useful but potentially unsafe token-level supervision." Terms like "discarded verifier structure" and "on-policy siblings" are introduced even before the reader would get a chance to absorb it. "past-only constraint-family histories to differentiate responses with identical scalar credit while preserving carrier resolved order and sign under a relative norm cap." What is meant by "past-only", "carrier", "relative norm cap" in the abstract?
  • Dense sentence structure: For examples, almost all lines in the introduction's 3rd paragraph (e.g. L70 "...revealing same-group correction routes for validity-screened token-level reuse...") are really really dense and hard to follow. Even after a lot of attempts to try to understand the paper, the writing makes it really hard (e.g. What is a "carrier objective"? L222).

Unfortunately, the writing does speak a lot like AI-written, therefore in its current shape and form, I am not able to judge the technical merits of this paper due to this and would not recommend acceptance. I would encourage the authors to conduct a deeper rewrite of the paper, as that would help centre the reader more towards the actual contributions of the work.

Questions for authors
  • How would you justify the computational efficiency of VIRRO? From the appendix, it seems that for models like Qwen2.5-3B, its average prompt-level success rate leads GDPO by 3.49 percentage points at equal optimizer steps, but 0.56 points at equal rollout counts, and GDPO leads by 0.42 points at equal wall-clock time.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.