- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Partial-Order Likelihood Policy Optimization (POLPO), a method for learning from multiple binary verifiers in RLVR. Rather than aggregating verifier outcomes into a scalar reward, POLPO constructs Pareto dominance relations among sampled responses and maximizes the probability of rankings consistent with these relations under a Plackett–Luce model parameterized by DPO-style implicit rewards.
Critical strengths
1 The paper provides mathematical derivations and evaluates the approach on controlled program synthesis, code generation, and multi-constraint instruction following. The results are generally positive.
2 The paper addresses an important limitation of scalar reward aggregation in multi-verifier RLVR. The distinction between verified Pareto improvements and unspecified trade-offs is clearly motivated. 3 The partial-order likelihood is well defined, recovers pairwise DPO as a special case, and is accompanied by gradient derivations and an exact dynamic programming implementation.
Critical weaknesses
1 The marginalized Plackett–Luce likelihood for general partial orders is established in prior work, while GraphDPO already combines DPO-style scores with structured preference graphs. The main distinction of POLPO relative to GraphDPO is its joint likelihood over the entire partial order, rather than an aggregation of local graph-based choice losses.
2 The controlled synthesis and coding experiments use a single training seed, and the paper does not report multi-seed variability for the main benchmark results. Several improvements over the strongest competing methods are relatively modest, particularly on external coding benchmarks and MathIF.
Questions for authors
-
How frequently does POLPO receive informative joint partial-order supervision? Could the authors report the fraction of response groups containing strict dominance relations and characterize the distribution of partial-order structures across datasets and training stages? In particular, how frequently do the sampled groups induce genuinely different objectives under POLPO and GraphDPO?
-
Can the authors clarify the missing APPS baseline results? Table 7 specifies learning rates for DPO–Pareto and both REINFORCE++ variants on APPS, but Table 2 does not report their performance. Were these experiments completed, and can the results be provided?
-
Does the advantage over structured preference baselines extend to instruction following? Could the authors provide GraphDPO or DPO–Pareto comparisons on representative multi-instruction-following tasks, or clarify why these direct baselines were excluded?
4 comments
Rebuttal by Authors(2/2)
Question 3: Does the advantage over structured baselines extend to instruction following?
We added DPO–Pareto and GraphDPO comparisons on IFM5, MulDimIF, and MathIF.
On IFM5 and MulDimIF, POLPO achieves the highest overall mean over three training seeds:
| Method | IFM5 | MulDimIF |
|---|---|---|
| GRPO–All | 56.4 ± 0.8 | 88.3 ± 0.2 |
| GRPO–Rate | 57.1 ± 1.7 | 89.1 ± 1.0 |
| DPO–Pareto | 61.0 ± 0.6 | 89.0 ± 0.4 |
| GraphDPO | 59.6 ± 2.2 | 89.7 ± 0.8 |
| POLPO | 61.3 ± 0.2 | 90.1 ± 0.7 |
Overall complete-constraint satisfaction (%), mean ± standard deviation over three training seeds (Tables 4 and 5).
The newly added thinking-enabled MathIF results also favor POLPO:
| Method | HAcc | Math Acc | Joint |
|---|---|---|---|
| GRPO–Rate | 70.5 | 38.8 | 30.7 |
| GraphDPO | 56.4 | 30.0 | 24.8 |
| DPO–Pareto | 72.6 | 40.2 | 31.9 |
| POLPO | 78.1 | 40.2 | 33.8 |
MathIF results (%) with thinking enabled (Table 6). HAcc measures complete instruction adherence; Joint requires both mathematical correctness and complete instruction adherence.
POLPO matches DPO–Pareto’s mathematical accuracy while improving HAcc from 72.6% to 78.1% and Joint from 31.9% to 33.8%. It also exceeds GraphDPO on all three metrics. Together, these results support POLPO’s effectiveness against structured baselines across instruction-following tasks, including tasks that require mathematical correctness.
Follow-up on Our Response to Reviewer B7ej
Dear Reviewer B7ej,
Thank you again for your constructive feedback. We have revised the manuscript and responded to your comments, including additional experiments and analyses.
As the discussion period ends on November 18 (AoE), we would greatly appreciate it if you could share your thoughts on whether our response and revisions address your concerns. If any questions remain, we would be happy to provide further clarification.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Follow-up on Our Rebuttal Responses
Dear Reviewer B7eJ,
Thank you very much for your time and effort in reviewing our paper and for your constructive feedback.
We would like to kindly follow up on our previous message. We have provided responses to the concerns raised in your review in our rebuttal.
As the author-reviewer discussion period ends on November 18 (AoE), we would greatly appreciate it if you could review our responses and let us know if any concerns remain. We would be happy to provide further clarification if needed.
Thank you again for your valuable time and consideration.
Rebuttal by Authors(1/2)
Thank you for your constructive feedback. Please see the Overall Response for an overview of the revisions.
Weakness: What does POLPO contribute beyond existing partial-order likelihoods and GraphDPO?
We agree that the partial-order Plackett–Luce likelihood is established and that GraphDPO combines structured preference graphs with DPO-style scores. POLPO’s contribution combines verifier-derived Pareto supervision with joint likelihood optimization for policy learning.
First, GraphDPO’s reported APPS experiments construct ordered preference layers from scalar test pass rates (Liu et al., 2026, Appendix A.3). POLPO instead constructs a Pareto partial order directly from individual verifier outcomes. Thus, responses with conflicting outcomes remain incomparable even when their pass rates differ.
Second, GraphDPO’s objective is defined for general preference DAGs. We therefore adapt it to the same verifier-derived Pareto graph in our experiments. Under this shared comparison relation, POLPO optimizes the exact joint likelihood of the entire partial order, whereas GraphDPO aggregates local neighborhood losses.
To examine the contribution of the joint objective, we compare POLPO with GraphDPO and DPO–Pareto using the same Pareto relation. On APPS, POLPO improves All-pass / average pass to 25.90% / 42.67%, compared with 21.80% / 37.38% for GraphDPO and 21.70% / 37.57% for DPO–Pareto (Table 2). After AceCode training, POLPO exceeds both baselines on HumanEval, HumanEval+, MBPP, and MBPP+:
External pass@1 (%) after AceCode training (Table 3).
POLPO also has the highest mean on both MBPP model sizes over three training seeds, exceeding both GRPO variants and the structured baselines shown in the Overall Response (Table 1). These comparisons support the value of modeling Pareto comparisons jointly.
To examine the contribution of Pareto supervision, we added POLPO–Rate and POLPO–All, which retain the partial-order likelihood but use pass-rate and all-pass comparisons. POLPO has a higher mean than both on MBPP. In controlled synthesis at M=60, POLPO reaches 0.9 complete-success probability for all three targets in all five seeds, using approximately 96,000–100,000 programs on average. POLPO–Rate requires approximately 136,000 and 151,000 programs for the first two targets and reaches the threshold in three of five seeds for the third; POLPO–All does not reach the threshold within the budget for any of the three targets (Table 1, Figure 3, and Table 17).
Together, these comparisons support the combination of verifier-derived Pareto ordering and joint likelihood optimization.
Weakness: Are the gains stable across training seeds?
We added three-seed MBPP, IFM5, and MulDimIF results and five-seed controlled-synthesis results. As shown in the Overall Response, POLPO has the highest mean on both MBPP model sizes and the highest overall mean on IFM5 and MulDimIF, including comparisons with GRPO–All and GRPO–Rate (Figure 3 and Tables 1, 4, and 5).
Question: How often is supervision informative in coding and instruction following, and when do the objectives differ? We added signal-availability and objective-structure analyses for both task families (Figures 7–10 and Tables 18–20). For the same group, every all-pass reward difference implies a Pareto comparison, so POLPO can provide a signal whenever GRPO–All does.
In coding, POLPO’s signal shares among unsolved groups at the end of the plotted period are approximately 73% on APPS and 62% on AceCode, versus at most about 52% for GRPO–All in the reported runs (Figure 8). On shared initial IFM5 and MulDimIF rollouts, POLPO matches GRPO–Rate’s signal fractions of 47.7% and 74.8%, and exceeds GRPO–All’s 17.7% and 43.0% (Table 18). Later comparisons use each method’s own rollouts; GRPO–Rate can signal on additional groups with conflicting outcomes.
Among groups containing dominance, POLPO and GraphDPO define different objective functions, beyond a constant factor, on approximately 80–90% of coding groups and 92.8–97.8% of the IFM5 and MulDimIF snapshots (Figure 10 and Table 20). Many differences arise from tied verifier outcomes. The joint-versus-local distinction therefore occurs frequently in sampled groups in both task families.
Question: What are the missing APPS baseline results?
We added the omitted results:
APPS Introductory test results (%) after two training epochs (Table 2).