- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Pearl and Tian gave bounds for PN, PS and PNS. But this requires that we have enough information about the population. This submission claims that in the real world, sometimes we can only have information about a subpopulation. Therefore, it raises 2 questions: 1. can we use a subpopulation bound to get a population bound. 2. can we use PoC information about subpopulation 1 to help us infer the PoC of subpopulation 2? Authors discuss these two questions without assuming any cross-subpopulation invariance assumptions.
Critical strengths
This paper shows a worthy concerning problem that in the real world sometimes we can only have the observational/interventional information of a subpopulation, and they give a very realistic example related to adults and teenagers.
Critical weaknesses
Because the authors do not assume any cross-subpopulation invariance assumptions, this means that if we only know the distribution of subpopulation c, the distribution of the other subpopulation c′ still can be arbitrary. Under this setup, most of this paper's theorems (theorems 3-11) are straightforward consequences of existing Tian–Pearl bounds and elementary probability inequalities (Theorems 9-11). They give limited novel theoretical insights. Most of this paper's theorems (theorems 3-11) address two bounding tasks: one is how to use subpopulation data to infer the whole population bound, and the second one is how to use subpopulation 1 to infer subpopulation 2's bound:
- subpopulations infer population: in this part, most of the theoretical results can be summarized into this pattern: Take PNS as example, let the two subpopulations have proportions and , and let their respective Tian–Pearl bounds be and . Then author's theorems mainly tell us: we can take the weighted sum of these two intervals and we can get the whole population bound:
Questions for authors
What is the reason that authors do not assume any cross-subpopulation invariance assumptions?