Partial Identification of Network Causal Effects under Structural Support Deficiency
Abstract
Repeated network experiments can leave policy contrasts unidentified even as sampling error vanishes: operational constraints assign zero probability to relevant exposures. We characterize this limitation through a compact completion polytope combining outcome bounds, scientific linear restrictions, and bidirectional transformation distances respecting one-way operational boundaries. Under the finite-population mean-response model, its target image is a sharp identified set: diameter implies worst-case squared-error risk at least for every point estimator under any number of unchanged-design repetitions. Optimal dual faces characterize when these bounds coincide and their local sensitivity to supported means and restrictions. To infer this set, we project a design-based confidence polytope for supported means, obtaining finite-sample full-set coverage; independent stable waves permit affine refinement through exact common-dual vertex certification. Matching upper and block-experiment lower bounds give minimax expected interval length of order for the specified fixed-dimensional classes with uniformly bounded endpoint sensitivity, identification-diameter bound , supported-cell probabilities , and dependency degree . In 600-repetition experiments, widths approach the identification plateau, while projection attains – full-set coverage versus for raw optimization. The predicted dependence scaling appears in a variance log–log slope of against ; across 4,000 end-to-end runs, dependence-calibrated full-set coverage is , versus – with a unit-iid radius. In a six-cell insurance-network audit, descriptive projection spans all held-out empirical means at average width , versus unrestricted width . These results connect the limits of causal learning to experimental design and specify when greater precision requires new identifying information.
Then back it, or bet against it.
Related papers
Open the market on this paper to see 7 more related papers.